Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend asking for loan. Knows I can 'afford it'. Went about it all wrong.

535 replies

edelweissnights · 08/12/2023 23:20

A friend called me up and asked me for a loan... after about an hour of chit-chat (which was largely regarding my grief as I have recently lost someone). It wasn't so much a loan, but a desperate plea to pay his mortgage and kids' school fees. He is starting his own business (after jacking in a £120k + London city job) and basically said he needed the money.... yesterday. Since someone very close to me (family) passed, I've been getting a few of these calls from 'friends', albeit not people who were my friends - but my relative's friend. He knows I'm 'good for it' as it is somewhat obvious/is 'public' (if you search for it). I wish he hadn't spent an hour asking about 'the estate' (which is now the name instead of my relative's actual name) as it seems he was just fishing for intel. Also, to call someone up and put them on the spot is just mad.

I have a long term partner, but no children and he kept saying how 'lucky' I was to not have the life he does as children are expensive etc... but to be honest, I do not feel lucky after the year I've had and the things I have been through. Of course children are expensive. I understand that - and respect that.

I am not even sure I would get the money back but he assured me I would within a few weeks. It's not a number to smirk at either. The way he went about it was so so wrong though. He said: "If only I knew someone who would lend me the money... oh wait..! You're childfree! Lucky you! You must have lots of disposable income!!" (Even inheritance aside, I wouldn't have 'loads' of disposable income and the number still remains slightly eye-watering). It was the fact that he kept repeating: "If only I had a way to get the money...." He sounded desperate, but I hate how horrible he made me feel and how badly he went about everything. AIBU to say no - even without giving a reason?

OP posts:
SkySecret · 10/12/2023 18:18

Urgh! People who play the “you’re rich and I’m so hard done to and skint” card because THEY chose to have children grates on me badly.

An old boss of mine (who I love dearly, he’s a fabulous person and a great manager) had a bad habit of doing this. He obviously earned more than me as he was my manager, two grades higher, but would sometimes comment that I had more disposable income than him…. well yeah, I haven’t chosen to have children and send them to private school…. but the fact that YOU have is in no way my problem!

Duchydutch · 10/12/2023 18:13
  1. this man is not a friend
  2. this man is irresponsible
  3. this man is a rude, obnoxious, entitled narcissist.

the only thing you owe this creature is a “No” followed by “go away little man”. Then out the phone down.

Saucymushroom · 10/12/2023 18:10

Sod that, he made the decisions that have left him in this predicament, nobody else. I'm sorry for your loss and that you have had to put up with this.

pphammer · 10/12/2023 18:10

Stay away from him.
He's not your friend and he will not pay you back

Sensibleandboring · 10/12/2023 18:03

edelweissnights · 08/12/2023 23:20

A friend called me up and asked me for a loan... after about an hour of chit-chat (which was largely regarding my grief as I have recently lost someone). It wasn't so much a loan, but a desperate plea to pay his mortgage and kids' school fees. He is starting his own business (after jacking in a £120k + London city job) and basically said he needed the money.... yesterday. Since someone very close to me (family) passed, I've been getting a few of these calls from 'friends', albeit not people who were my friends - but my relative's friend. He knows I'm 'good for it' as it is somewhat obvious/is 'public' (if you search for it). I wish he hadn't spent an hour asking about 'the estate' (which is now the name instead of my relative's actual name) as it seems he was just fishing for intel. Also, to call someone up and put them on the spot is just mad.

I have a long term partner, but no children and he kept saying how 'lucky' I was to not have the life he does as children are expensive etc... but to be honest, I do not feel lucky after the year I've had and the things I have been through. Of course children are expensive. I understand that - and respect that.

I am not even sure I would get the money back but he assured me I would within a few weeks. It's not a number to smirk at either. The way he went about it was so so wrong though. He said: "If only I knew someone who would lend me the money... oh wait..! You're childfree! Lucky you! You must have lots of disposable income!!" (Even inheritance aside, I wouldn't have 'loads' of disposable income and the number still remains slightly eye-watering). It was the fact that he kept repeating: "If only I had a way to get the money...." He sounded desperate, but I hate how horrible he made me feel and how badly he went about everything. AIBU to say no - even without giving a reason?

Sounds like an absolute cunt playing the victim card. How dare he bring children into it as if that validates him

Shazam2 · 10/12/2023 17:52

No, you are not being unreasonable and by the sound of it, I would say you would be very lucky if you got the money back, don’t give it to him and you don’t have to give a reason

LalaPaloosa · 10/12/2023 17:44

I’m disgusted by his behaviour. This is really poor form. You are not responsible for his mortgage or school fees. These are his responsibilities!

How manipulative. You need to say no. A firm no, and not take calls from this opportunist again. If he does catch you, you should recommend looking at some state school options. Cheeky so-and-so!

Iamgettingolderandgrumpier · 10/12/2023 17:43

Maybe the CF should have thought about who was going to pay mortgage before he jacked in his £120+ job. (DC could always go to a state school). Don’t give him or anyone else ‘inquiring’ about the estate/money.

Lulu123450 · 10/12/2023 17:42

Sounds like an absolute loser with no morals what so ever, do not lend him any money EVER. You will never see it again. This person is using you and you would be crazy to even consider lending them a penny. You honestly do not need a reason, but if you feel like you need to, just say that the estate was in arrears and you are unable to help.

laraitopbanana · 10/12/2023 17:31

Please say no, he will never reimburse and use the same reasons he asked you the loan….
if he has the money in a few weeks, he will be fine.

Fraaahnces · 10/12/2023 01:29

I’m glad he’s blocked @edelweissnights. FOUR messages??? AFTER you’d said no!!! I wonder what he would have hit you with? Guilt trips? Aggression? Offers of legally-enforceable contracts??? (Ha! That would work only if he had income). He needs to change his lifestyle and sort his shit out!!!

Italiangreyhound · 09/12/2023 23:01

@Tellmesomethingidontknow I am so sorry to hear what happened to you.

edelweissnights · 09/12/2023 21:52

Biscofffans · 09/12/2023 20:16

Bear in mind, I had already said no last night! So it's not like I went MIA and left him hanging today. Any pushback after someone has already said 'no' is just not on.

Sorry to hear these updates. It’s very disappointing. I had really hoped your friend would have at least some shame and pride left, and not try and talk you out of your decision. The fact he isn’t accepting a NO is further evidence of how entitled he thinks he is to your money. Absolutely disgusting behaviour, he put himself in this situation by quitting his job and he’s trying to make you pay for his lifestyle choices & business dreams.

I’d probably be really petty and send a text with something like “ I know you probably feel terrible about asking me for money while I’m grieving - we all do stupid things sometimes. Let’s just forget about it .”

This is not advisable btw but I’m petty like that 😄 seriously though, blocking him is the best thing. He has shown no respect for your boundaries and his behaviour could escalate. As you say, he can always email if he wants to apologise.

Ha! I did contemplate being petty! I left it and blocked him though so as to not engage. Since he will apparently be back on track in a mere few weeks (according to him) I trust he will be ok.

OP posts:
edelweissnights · 09/12/2023 21:50

GladioliandSweetPeas · 09/12/2023 21:21

@edelweissnights We had people offering 'their contact information' in case we needed to contact them. They were thinking they were in for a nice sum - and they weren't even family. We also had people 'checking in' and 'offering help with the will'. A few weeks later people would 'check in' and ask if we 'needed them'.

To be fair, the people you're referring to in this particular quote ⬆️ could've been genuinely saying "let us know if you need anything" and honestly offering you support. I think it's unfair and quite odd for you to immediately jump to them ALL being after money or hoping to be named in the will.

The people I am referring to sadly all were indeed after the money/hoping they'd be named as a beneficiary.

Of course; many others genuinely wanted to help/brought food/asked about how we were doing etc... but the ones who specifically were wanting to pass on their information (funnily enough only to the executors) were indeed looking for a payday as their correspondence was only regarding to the will/estate and in the context of needing them in that regard. Once they knew they weren't named, we never heard from them again, whereas the people who truly cared stuck around.

I wanted to be wrong about those I'm referring to, but I wasn't sadly.

OP posts:
GladioliandSweetPeas · 09/12/2023 21:23

@edelweissnights The school fees for Spring term is £12,180 per child.

Jesus Christ £12,180 is more than my yearly income as a single (widowed) mother 🙁

GladioliandSweetPeas · 09/12/2023 21:21

@edelweissnights We had people offering 'their contact information' in case we needed to contact them. They were thinking they were in for a nice sum - and they weren't even family. We also had people 'checking in' and 'offering help with the will'. A few weeks later people would 'check in' and ask if we 'needed them'.

To be fair, the people you're referring to in this particular quote ⬆️ could've been genuinely saying "let us know if you need anything" and honestly offering you support. I think it's unfair and quite odd for you to immediately jump to them ALL being after money or hoping to be named in the will.

Biscofffans · 09/12/2023 20:16

Bear in mind, I had already said no last night! So it's not like I went MIA and left him hanging today. Any pushback after someone has already said 'no' is just not on.

Sorry to hear these updates. It’s very disappointing. I had really hoped your friend would have at least some shame and pride left, and not try and talk you out of your decision. The fact he isn’t accepting a NO is further evidence of how entitled he thinks he is to your money. Absolutely disgusting behaviour, he put himself in this situation by quitting his job and he’s trying to make you pay for his lifestyle choices & business dreams.

I’d probably be really petty and send a text with something like “ I know you probably feel terrible about asking me for money while I’m grieving - we all do stupid things sometimes. Let’s just forget about it .”

This is not advisable btw but I’m petty like that 😄 seriously though, blocking him is the best thing. He has shown no respect for your boundaries and his behaviour could escalate. As you say, he can always email if he wants to apologise.

WhiteRabbitBlackCat · 09/12/2023 19:47

I was feeling smug reading this thread, because a few years after uni I borrowed thousands of pounds from a friend to live overseas for a year, and at the end of that year I turned down the chance to stay (which would have meant incurring more debt, though not from my friend), and instead I went back home and worked boring jobs and paid him back every penny before going off gallivanting in foreign parts again. I am clearly an honourable person!

But then, I occasionally take advantage of errors at the self-scan machines, so according to that other thread I am a common thief and the lowest of the low.

Anyway, I'm glad OP will not be lending any money to this guy. The horror stories on this thread seem to indicate that if you are going to lend, it's essential to have an agreement in writing, even informal (though formal would be better for larger sums - payback terms in particular). Anyone who legitimately needs a loan and intends to pay it back won't object to having everything set out in writing and agreed to by both parties, if not their solicitors.

OVienna · 09/12/2023 19:14

captainmarvella · 09/12/2023 18:08

This is a good message to send, esp the bit about how others have been asking OP money too. Tells the CF that he has been made.

Gets it in writing what he was up to as well - I'd mention loan specifically, on reflection though. Who could possibly argue with it? Might prevent any bad mouthing going round too if that is a concern.

lto2019 · 09/12/2023 19:14

Aside from the crass way he went about it - and not considering your grief - it would be a no from me anyway. He left a high salaried job and he knew when he did that he still had his mortgage and school fees to pay. Setting up a business - he should have factored these things in - if he didn't how does he think he will pay the following months fees. There are other options he could explore.

I would say - I am not to willing to pay your mortgage or school fees. I found it very upsetting that you have contacted me when I am grieving and I find your approach completely crass and unwelcome.

Bigcat25 · 09/12/2023 18:51

Merryoldgoat · 09/12/2023 18:34

@edelweissnights

It’s tricky and a balance needs to be achieved but there is often a lack of recognition that private education is a choice.

There are lots of families for whom it is stretch to afford the fees, but the reality is that minus school fees they’d have zero financial issues. So when they do stretch themselves there’s no room for the £2k cricket tour, or football in Holland, or PGL in Spain. And they feel like they should have help because they’re finding it hard, but it’s all of their own making.

A parent approached me because they had less coming in because she had dropped to part-time. They had a 6 bed family home (2 children) and three investment properties. That they could even consider asking was beyond me.

Selling ONE of the properties would’ve paid ALL the school fees for both children through to A-Level.

How ridiculous of her, as if going part time wasn't her choice. I'm in Canada, and while there's multiple private schools in my city, they aren't so common, and never would be seen as mandatory unless under very special circumstances.

Bigcat25 · 09/12/2023 18:47

Tellmesomethingidontknow · 09/12/2023 14:50

This thread has struck a chord . I lost my husband and very young child in an accident . My only brother tried to get a very large amount of money from me when he thought the estate was finalised ( it wasn't). I said no and surprise , I never heard from him again . Its been years now but yes , money brings out the absolute worst in people .

So extremely sorry for your loss, and your brother's behavior. So very heartbreaking.

PomsRun · 09/12/2023 18:44

I hope you don’t feel too upset - just just so awful to think a friend would do this. I guess he wasn’t really a good friend.

Merryoldgoat · 09/12/2023 18:34

@edelweissnights

It’s tricky and a balance needs to be achieved but there is often a lack of recognition that private education is a choice.

There are lots of families for whom it is stretch to afford the fees, but the reality is that minus school fees they’d have zero financial issues. So when they do stretch themselves there’s no room for the £2k cricket tour, or football in Holland, or PGL in Spain. And they feel like they should have help because they’re finding it hard, but it’s all of their own making.

A parent approached me because they had less coming in because she had dropped to part-time. They had a 6 bed family home (2 children) and three investment properties. That they could even consider asking was beyond me.

Selling ONE of the properties would’ve paid ALL the school fees for both children through to A-Level.

edelweissnights · 09/12/2023 18:21

Merryoldgoat · 09/12/2023 18:12

@edelweissnights

I’ve only read your posts OP so not sure if your hardship fund question has been answered.

I assess these applications as part of my job.

First port of call is a monthly instalment plan which assists if paying from income.

We use a third party to do a full financial assessment and the following would exclude eligibility:

Savings beyond a £5k rainy day fund
Second property
A stay at home parent without significant caring responsibilities
Significant equity in the home that could be called on.

The number of people with significant assets that approach me is shocking.

Additionally the support would not be open ended. Either until the end of the school year or sooner if finances picked up.

The other factor would be the stage the children are at. More flexibility if child is about to take GCSEs or A-Level. Am assuming senior given the cost of those fees.

Oh wow. Thank you so much for your post. I was curious as to what it was/how it worked - not because I was trying to help him with that/offer endless suggestions - but more because I had never heard such a thing. (I do not have children).

Regardless, he would not qualify!

Is it that people think they are 'poor' but actually aren't (in the eyes of most)? Is it quite difficult to filter out who qualifies based on the variables? I can imagine most applicants would think they qualify, but actually don't.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread