Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend asking for loan. Knows I can 'afford it'. Went about it all wrong.

535 replies

edelweissnights · 08/12/2023 23:20

A friend called me up and asked me for a loan... after about an hour of chit-chat (which was largely regarding my grief as I have recently lost someone). It wasn't so much a loan, but a desperate plea to pay his mortgage and kids' school fees. He is starting his own business (after jacking in a £120k + London city job) and basically said he needed the money.... yesterday. Since someone very close to me (family) passed, I've been getting a few of these calls from 'friends', albeit not people who were my friends - but my relative's friend. He knows I'm 'good for it' as it is somewhat obvious/is 'public' (if you search for it). I wish he hadn't spent an hour asking about 'the estate' (which is now the name instead of my relative's actual name) as it seems he was just fishing for intel. Also, to call someone up and put them on the spot is just mad.

I have a long term partner, but no children and he kept saying how 'lucky' I was to not have the life he does as children are expensive etc... but to be honest, I do not feel lucky after the year I've had and the things I have been through. Of course children are expensive. I understand that - and respect that.

I am not even sure I would get the money back but he assured me I would within a few weeks. It's not a number to smirk at either. The way he went about it was so so wrong though. He said: "If only I knew someone who would lend me the money... oh wait..! You're childfree! Lucky you! You must have lots of disposable income!!" (Even inheritance aside, I wouldn't have 'loads' of disposable income and the number still remains slightly eye-watering). It was the fact that he kept repeating: "If only I had a way to get the money...." He sounded desperate, but I hate how horrible he made me feel and how badly he went about everything. AIBU to say no - even without giving a reason?

OP posts:
mouldyfalafel · 12/12/2023 08:17

Well done OP. There is no obligation whatsoever to "hear him out" that's utter BS. He wanted cash from you and you said no. End of. It was cruel and predatory to do that when you are grieving. You aren't obliged to hand over your inheritance due to his poor life choices. His kids are in private school for goodness sakes!

Not only that, but none of us know what the future holds, you may need that money in the future for all you know. I notice when he was flush with cash he never offered to buy you anything did he?

Even IF he was losing his house- why on earth is that YOUR responsibility? He has family and an ex partner to help him out with that- why aren't they stepping up to bridge the gap? By that rationale, no-one should ever be allowed have any savings whatsoever because they should just hand it all over to someone who is struggling due to irresponsible money management. We all have to take responsibility for our lives and he is no different. If I was in a financial hole, I certainly wouldn't expect my friends to constantly bail me out because long term it won't work anyway if he is leaving well paid jobs to start up some Mickey Mouse business.

edelweissnights · 12/12/2023 08:06

P.S. I was so saddened to hear of so many similar stories on this thread. I'm so sorry to those who have felt a similar way/experienced something along the same lines as this.

Some people can be truly awful. It's a tale as old as time when it comes to money and inheritances etc... I'm not the first and I won't be the last (to witness something like this).

Things like this shake your trust in people and makes you look at people/humanity differently. Not everyone is 'bad' of course, but the damage done to friendships, relationships, families and dynamics can be very real and long-lasting.

OP posts:
3luckystars · 12/12/2023 08:02

Good news. Well done shaking him off!!

Zonder · 12/12/2023 07:57

Well done OP. Maybe he found someone else to finance his lifestyle.

edelweissnights · 12/12/2023 07:56

UPDATE (FOR THOSE ASKING & WHO HAVE MESSAGED).

I never heard from him after I blocked him. I only blocked him after I had already told him 'no' the day prior - and after he continued to push and call me 4 times and message twice the next day. For those saying I should have 'heard him out' (in case he was calling to apologise) and not blocked after the push-back, he had other means of contacting me - via email/social media etc... if he wanted to do so. He didn't.

From a worst case scenario perspective, I know (through mutual friends) he is fine/alive and well - and his children are fine too. In fact; it looks like they are staying in private school and he certainly hasn't lost his home - or anything catastrophic like that.

In truth, I don't think I will hear from him (ever) again.

OP posts:
RetirementIsGreat · 12/12/2023 00:06

instrumentofthestate · 10/12/2023 21:27

The sheer desperation of the numerous texts & calls "phone me back ASAP" suggests there's more to this than school tees. What's the desperate rush on a Saturday?

Is there some sort of large scale drug smuggling or crime issue going on here?

Are the mob or some Columbian drug lords after him? 🤣 (Only half joking)

I was wondering if he got it to trouble with gambling and he owes the bookie. He's so desperate seems like more than what he says.

OVienna · 11/12/2023 14:01

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 11/12/2023 12:55

Before her own time came my wealthy elderly (childless) great-aunt had watched quite a few funerals and the property-grabbing (with real fighting sometimes) that followed.

She herself left a very very detailed list (one that included every single item in her house and garden). She left something (to remember her by) to every friend and relation AND the postage costs for each. I suspect she had quite enjoyed planning which item would go to which person (with secret or not so secret reasons for each).

Her money was gone.

Knowing her time was limited, she'd managed to spend almost all - on holidays and good times- in her final two years.

I would love to hear more about your great-aunt. She sounds FABULOUS. I bet she was having a huge chuckle thinking about some of the people who were hoping to get their hands on her cash.

Ihadenough22 · 11/12/2023 13:44

I would not be lending this man money. It was his decision to give up his job and become self employed. I knew a couple where the husband was made unemployed and he set up his own business. They cut their expenses, had no foreign holidays and she stayed working full time to keep the bills paid. Meanwhile he worked long hours and took a small salary to get the business on its feet. In fact they put off having a family until the business was up and running for a while.
If he was setting up his own business why did his wife leave work and let them be down his income and hers? Who did they think was going to support them and their current lifestyle?

I have heard a few things in my time but this gets the gold medal of a CF. Over the years I had 1 friend and at times we might give each other £50 till pay day when we had a hard month of expenses. I was glad to help them because they did the same for me in the past.

I saw a friend of mine win some money a few years ago. She gave another friend money and paid for a cheap holiday for them to go away together. This friend had been through a horrible time and needed a break. Now a few years later this lady makes hardly any effort for my friend.
My friend is aware that she came into some money and was never offered as much £5 of this. Recently the same lady asked for something and my friend told her she had not got this. My friend told me let her ask someone else's because she has made no effort for me recently.

I think when you lose someone it can be hard. Yes your going to get an inheritance but that does not make it easier. How can your friend think it ok to ask you for money now?
You might not have kids but you still have to live, pay the bills and have some life for yourself.
That money could pay for a nice holiday, give you a cushion if something unexpected happens or perhaps boost your retirement fund.

If you give him money he will keep asking for more and you know he is not in a financial position to pay this back. In fact I would block him or just be to busy to chat when he calls.

RaininSummer · 11/12/2023 12:56

I am quite astounded by the sheer cheek of people who would hit up recently bereaved friends for large amounts of money. Not real friends for sure so let them wallow .

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 11/12/2023 12:55

Before her own time came my wealthy elderly (childless) great-aunt had watched quite a few funerals and the property-grabbing (with real fighting sometimes) that followed.

She herself left a very very detailed list (one that included every single item in her house and garden). She left something (to remember her by) to every friend and relation AND the postage costs for each. I suspect she had quite enjoyed planning which item would go to which person (with secret or not so secret reasons for each).

Her money was gone.

Knowing her time was limited, she'd managed to spend almost all - on holidays and good times- in her final two years.

Arniesleftleg · 11/12/2023 12:37

@ButterCupPie it's awful isn't it? You do things because you like to help then they do this. Sad times.

StmMary · 11/12/2023 12:31

Tell him to do one. Your not a bank of friends.. If he doesn't like it.. His problem, not yours.. Helping people who's down and out. Yes. He made himself cashless.. Happy Christmas to him..

furtivetussling · 11/12/2023 12:10

Call me a raging cynic if you will, but what was the timeline between the sad loss of your relative and this so-called friend of yours jacking in his job?

I can't help wondering whether he has been playing a long game and gave up his job shortly after your relative died, thinking that it would be fine because you'll be loaded and he could always milk you for funds should the need arise.

Also loving your typo about his wife stopping work and becoming a 'SHAM'. 😂

Ginnnny · 11/12/2023 11:38

I'm sorry for your loss 😘

Please, please, say no to this person. He's not your friend. He doesn't care about you, just what you can do for him.

Ineke · 11/12/2023 09:28

He could take his kids out of private school if he was that desperate. No, don’t lend him a penny.

TicTacNicNak · 11/12/2023 08:41

How crazy for two people with such well paying jobs to give them up for a business adventure that wasn't even established or successful. Unless they go back to their jobs they've a long way to fall yet, and will come to deeply regret their choices I suspect.

Sorry for your loss OP, and well done for your strength in saying no to this man.

agentcooperinthewhitelodge · 11/12/2023 08:31

Unfortunately OP, when someone dies this always happens and its very revealing regarding people's true character.

When my father died, literally two days later I had three different people give me an offhand "sorry to hear" then proceeded to ask if they could have various belongings of his. "I'd really like the rug in his lounge" and "can I have that piece of electronic radio equipment?- it would be really helpful to me" etc. One even told me he was sure my dad had wanted him to have it, but I had never heard that from him ever and it certainly wasn't in his will.

Bear in mind these were not family members or life long friends who had misty eyed memories of him, they were random people he knew- aquaintances basically, who had not bothered to visit him or contact him in all the 4 years he was in the nursing home as they were too "busy". I said no to all of them and that I was distributing his estate based on his legal will. If they werent in it, they got nothing as those were his express wishes. They came to his funeral and poked around a bit again, asking yet again about the stuff they had earmarked for themselves but I politely told them no. I have never heard from any of them since.

When someone dies people seem to lose their minds thinking its some kind of open season for them to grab what they want- its utterly predatory and well done for saying no.

Zerosleep · 11/12/2023 06:54

It’s a clear no, no and NO from me. For god’s sake don’t lend any money no matter how reliable you think they are, no matter how much of a friend, no matter what. You won’t get it back and that will be the end of the friendship. If he doesn’t have it now then he won’t have it in a week or a month. Sorry OP but please don’t lend anything and you are not being unreasonable to say no. You don’t have to explain but if it makes it easier to say no then it’s a ‘I’m sorry I would love to help but it’s all tied up’.

T1Dmama · 11/12/2023 01:04

tell Him ‘sorry no I’m not lending out any money to anyone, because quite frankly I’ve had way too many cultures circling!!’

and if he says anything in response tell him quite plainly how irresponsible he was to give up his job without paying his kids schools fees and his mortgage etc a year in advance to cover his transition from employee to self employed!!

What kind of an idiot gives up a well paid job without having enough ‘backup’ savings stashed away for these sort of bills??

Dogknowsbest · 10/12/2023 22:39

Well done for not giving him the money. He sounds awful and manipulative.

FWIW, my view on inheriting money goes like this (even if it's a lot).

It's your money regardless of how you earnt it. If the person that died wanted it to go to Jo Bloggs that's who she would have left it too but she left it to you, knowing it wouldn't be abused or squandered. Don't give it to other people who will squander it. If you want to do something good with it, give it to charity.

Galdos · 10/12/2023 22:22

You will never see your money again if you give him anything. All the comments that you should not 'lend' him any money are absolutely right. Sob stories can be hard to listen to, but in 99+% of cases the money will never be repaid, and the friendship/acquaintance be destroyed. It may be destroyed anyway by a refusal, but at least you won't be out of pocket!

Snowconecanfly · 10/12/2023 22:12

He chose to stop working knowing he had to lay his mortgage and school fees.

No, sorry I don’t lend money.

or No, sorry all money is tied up and cannot access it.

and as he can pay an eye watering sum back in a few weeks to you, a bank no doubt can lend it to him!

Mt61 · 10/12/2023 22:01

Well done, hardest part is over, move on & try not to dwell, you have totally made the right decision 😊

OhComeOnFFS · 10/12/2023 21:36

How close were you to this man? Were you his friend or his ex wife's?

elkiedee · 10/12/2023 21:32

If he wanted to leave his job and start a business, he should have planned for it. If he can't get bank loans or investment in the business through normal means (whatever those are), and if he has experience in the city, why should you risk your money? If your loss is very recent, you won't have inheritance through for a while, and even if not, how insensitive to keep pressing about the value of your estate.