Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend asking for loan. Knows I can 'afford it'. Went about it all wrong.

535 replies

edelweissnights · 08/12/2023 23:20

A friend called me up and asked me for a loan... after about an hour of chit-chat (which was largely regarding my grief as I have recently lost someone). It wasn't so much a loan, but a desperate plea to pay his mortgage and kids' school fees. He is starting his own business (after jacking in a £120k + London city job) and basically said he needed the money.... yesterday. Since someone very close to me (family) passed, I've been getting a few of these calls from 'friends', albeit not people who were my friends - but my relative's friend. He knows I'm 'good for it' as it is somewhat obvious/is 'public' (if you search for it). I wish he hadn't spent an hour asking about 'the estate' (which is now the name instead of my relative's actual name) as it seems he was just fishing for intel. Also, to call someone up and put them on the spot is just mad.

I have a long term partner, but no children and he kept saying how 'lucky' I was to not have the life he does as children are expensive etc... but to be honest, I do not feel lucky after the year I've had and the things I have been through. Of course children are expensive. I understand that - and respect that.

I am not even sure I would get the money back but he assured me I would within a few weeks. It's not a number to smirk at either. The way he went about it was so so wrong though. He said: "If only I knew someone who would lend me the money... oh wait..! You're childfree! Lucky you! You must have lots of disposable income!!" (Even inheritance aside, I wouldn't have 'loads' of disposable income and the number still remains slightly eye-watering). It was the fact that he kept repeating: "If only I had a way to get the money...." He sounded desperate, but I hate how horrible he made me feel and how badly he went about everything. AIBU to say no - even without giving a reason?

OP posts:
Coyoacan · 09/12/2023 02:45

I prefer to lend to women as, in general, they are better at paying back. But it is also better to lend someone a small amount of money you can afford to lose and see if they pay it back

edelweissnights · 09/12/2023 02:42

Winter2020 · 09/12/2023 02:31

Hi OP,

Sorry for your loss.

I'm reading your posts with horror at the thought that you would give money to this man who has behaved like a predator. As if your position having children or not means you don't deserve to keep money that is rightfully yours - that sentiment alone would make my blood boil.

A mortgage and school fees are a bottomless pit as far as lending money. So if you pay say 24k for 2 kids to stay in school for the spring term and perhaps 6K(?) of mortgage over this time - that's 30K. What would you say then when he comes back and says he needs another 40K for the summer holidays and the following terms fees... and if you don't lend it then it will have been a waste that you paid the first 30K as he will lose it all anyway - so you will end up deeper and deeper into the hole of his financial problems with no relief from your burden of taking on his problems.

If he is going to need to pull his kids out of private school and sell or re-mortgage his house he might as well just get on with it rather than wait until he owes you 30k, 70k or100k.

When his kids are in state school and he has downsized his home but he owes you 100K he won't be thanking you. No good deed goes unpunished. He will tell you that he wishes you hadn't leant him the money and he wishes that you had let him sell up/pull the kids out because now he is in an even worse position.

Don't try to solve his problem for him. He is obviously bright and also ruthless. If there is help to be had from a school hardship fund he will sniff it out. That is between him and the school. If he has no reason to think he will be able to afford the following terms fees either the school might also think that they will be throwing good money after bad and that it is inevitable that the kids will have to leave.

As often repeated on mumsnet: don't set yourself on fire to keep someone else warm.

Take care of yourself.

"A mortgage and school fees are a bottomless pit as far as lending money."

Spot on. This is also why once you start 'lending' you keep 'lending' - and it becomes never-ending.

I suspect you're 100% right about all that's to come. I also think anger/resentment sets in both for the lender and the person asking for money.

If the receiver ends up in more financial trouble, the lender is expected to bail them out again - as they did it once before. Also, the lender has no hope of getting the original sum back if they don't help out the receiver again... it is just a vicious cycle. Also, all too often the lender goes to the bottom of the priority lists in terms of paying back what's owed - as mortgages are obviously priority bills.

OP posts:
viques · 09/12/2023 02:32

He is not asking for a loan , because when you get a loan you expect to repay it. And he has no intention of repaying you. He is asking for a gift.

momonpurpose · 09/12/2023 02:32

Do not give him a penny and never speak to him again. With friends like that who needs enemies. I am very sorry for your loss and so sorry someone wished to take advantage of you at this difficult time of grief. Says alot about them

Winter2020 · 09/12/2023 02:31

Hi OP,

Sorry for your loss.

I'm reading your posts with horror at the thought that you would give money to this man who has behaved like a predator. As if your position having children or not means you don't deserve to keep money that is rightfully yours - that sentiment alone would make my blood boil.

A mortgage and school fees are a bottomless pit as far as lending money. So if you pay say 24k for 2 kids to stay in school for the spring term and perhaps 6K(?) of mortgage over this time - that's 30K. What would you say then when he comes back and says he needs another 40K for the summer holidays and the following terms fees... and if you don't lend it then it will have been a waste that you paid the first 30K as he will lose it all anyway - so you will end up deeper and deeper into the hole of his financial problems with no relief from your burden of taking on his problems.

If he is going to need to pull his kids out of private school and sell or re-mortgage his house he might as well just get on with it rather than wait until he owes you 30k, 70k or100k.

When his kids are in state school and he has downsized his home but he owes you 100K he won't be thanking you. No good deed goes unpunished. He will tell you that he wishes you hadn't leant him the money and he wishes that you had let him sell up/pull the kids out because now he is in an even worse position.

Don't try to solve his problem for him. He is obviously bright and also ruthless. If there is help to be had from a school hardship fund he will sniff it out. That is between him and the school. If he has no reason to think he will be able to afford the following terms fees either the school might also think that they will be throwing good money after bad and that it is inevitable that the kids will have to leave.

As often repeated on mumsnet: don't set yourself on fire to keep someone else warm.

Take care of yourself.

edelweissnights · 09/12/2023 02:22

Biscofffans · 09/12/2023 02:20

Yes your replies to him were well worded, to clarify - my comment about not giving advice was more in response to pp saying you should suggest he gets money from X or Y.

That’s awful - it was a very cynical and sly approach from your friend and doesn’t bode well for your friendship.

It’s shocking someone would rather ask their grieving friend for that kind of money, than just keep on working at their well paid job until they can afford to go full time with their business.

Oh indeed! To be clear, my comment wasn't implying you thought I was offering him too many options or anything. Nor was it a 'clap back'. 😀

I agree it was so sly and underhanded. I think the friendship is over and I hope I don't get any push back. I know he will also try to call and not text if he does indeed want to push back. I suspect I'll get some push back, but ultimately he can't force someone to hand over the money, so I shouldn't be so wound up about it.

OP posts:
Biscofffans · 09/12/2023 02:20

edelweissnights · 09/12/2023 02:10

I actually didn't need to suggest other options to him as he obviously came 'prepared'. I just wish he hadn't spent all that time prior asking me about my loss and how I was... only to then ask for a loan.

He launched in himself about how other options weren't available - so I guess he knew how to play it so that I would think there was no wiggle room. I didn't suggest he take out a bank loan for example, he volunteered that up. The whole thing was just gross and I felt horrible all evening.

The school fees for Spring term is £12,180 per child. He has two children. That's not including the mortgage payments he would want covered too. It's not a small sum of money.

Yes your replies to him were well worded, to clarify - my comment about not giving advice was more in response to pp saying you should suggest he gets money from X or Y.

That’s awful - it was a very cynical and sly approach from your friend and doesn’t bode well for your friendship.

It’s shocking someone would rather ask their grieving friend for that kind of money, than just keep on working at their well paid job until they can afford to go full time with their business.

assessedorregreased · 09/12/2023 02:15

Do NOT lend him the money.

If he says he can pay you back within a few weeks then tell him he just needs to ask school to wait a few weeks for their fees.

edelweissnights · 09/12/2023 02:10

Biscofffans · 09/12/2023 01:56

And also I’d advise against suggesting alternative money sources for him, because really that’s for him to think about and decide . He was a high earner and is starting a business. I’m sure he is reasonably financially savvy and knows where to apply for loans etc . Your response to him was good - continue to just stick with a basic and flat NO, irrespective of what he comes back with. Do not get sucked into trying to figure out this problem he created for himself.

If you start suggesting ways for him
to Get the money, it only invites him to tell you all the reasons why getting money from X or Y isn’t possible and basically batting it back to you since he will claim you are the “only option’.

Don’t allow his money issues to be a topic of conversation at all ever again. Steer the conversation away firmly.

Also keep an eye on him, he seems a bit selfish and focused on his own needs to the detriment of your welfare / friendship. It doesn’t reflect well on him that he even asked.

I actually didn't need to suggest other options to him as he obviously came 'prepared'. I just wish he hadn't spent all that time prior asking me about my loss and how I was... only to then ask for a loan.

He launched in himself about how other options weren't available - so I guess he knew how to play it so that I would think there was no wiggle room. I didn't suggest he take out a bank loan for example, he volunteered that up. The whole thing was just gross and I felt horrible all evening.

The school fees for Spring term is £12,180 per child. He has two children. That's not including the mortgage payments he would want covered too. It's not a small sum of money.

OP posts:
Fraaahnces · 09/12/2023 02:08

Bloody vultures!!! It’s bad enough that you’re grieving without being allowed the mental and emotional space to heal by these entitled people. “Help with the will….” That’s so cheap and nasty.

edelweissnights · 09/12/2023 02:02

Fraaahnces · 09/12/2023 01:56

Oooh…. I forgot to mention that at my mother’s funeral, her long-term gardener. (Aka lame duck that charged her an arm and a leg for blowing leaves from one side of her driveway to the other and back again and doing fuck all else) asked me “What time are WE going to the lawyer to have the will read?” As though he was family and we lived in an American soap opera. I told him he was tacky and that if he had been named in the will, he would have known by now. He got shitty and left.

I'm very sorry for your loss. That is utterly shameful. We had people asking about the will/estate/belongings less than 24 hours after my relative passed and people offering 'their contact information' in case we needed to contact them. They were thinking they were in for a nice sum - and they weren't even family. We also had people 'checking in' and 'offering help with the will'.

A few weeks later people would 'check in' and ask if we 'needed them'. Needless to say, they backed off once they realised they weren't getting anything... but it took a long time for all of that to stop.

Agreed! They often think it's like an episode of 'Succession'. No. Real life is nothing like US dramas.

OP posts:
edelweissnights · 09/12/2023 01:59

This reply has been deleted

We're afraid we don't believe that the OP is genuine so we've removed their threads and posts.

True. In the US, you can go to the courthouse yourself (with ID) and get a copy that way. So it's not technically sealed, but not available to all via a quick Google search and £10 fee. If you don't live in the US, you can send a representative for you. This doesn't apply to my situation as my relative lived in the UK, but just an example of how things are done differently in different countries/jurisdictions.

OP posts:
Middleagedmeangirls · 09/12/2023 01:57

I had something similar with a sibling recently. They asked to borrow a near 6 figure sum. My response was a shocked laugh and "I don't have that kind of money to lend'. Which was absolutely the truth. I could have access to that level of cash but it's not for risking or lending. My sibling managed to raise the money in other ways.

Junemoon222 · 09/12/2023 01:56

This reply has been deleted

We're afraid we don't believe that the OP is genuine so we've removed their threads and posts.

Fraaahnces · 09/12/2023 01:56

Oooh…. I forgot to mention that at my mother’s funeral, her long-term gardener. (Aka lame duck that charged her an arm and a leg for blowing leaves from one side of her driveway to the other and back again and doing fuck all else) asked me “What time are WE going to the lawyer to have the will read?” As though he was family and we lived in an American soap opera. I told him he was tacky and that if he had been named in the will, he would have known by now. He got shitty and left.

Biscofffans · 09/12/2023 01:56

And also I’d advise against suggesting alternative money sources for him, because really that’s for him to think about and decide . He was a high earner and is starting a business. I’m sure he is reasonably financially savvy and knows where to apply for loans etc . Your response to him was good - continue to just stick with a basic and flat NO, irrespective of what he comes back with. Do not get sucked into trying to figure out this problem he created for himself.

If you start suggesting ways for him
to Get the money, it only invites him to tell you all the reasons why getting money from X or Y isn’t possible and basically batting it back to you since he will claim you are the “only option’.

Don’t allow his money issues to be a topic of conversation at all ever again. Steer the conversation away firmly.

Also keep an eye on him, he seems a bit selfish and focused on his own needs to the detriment of your welfare / friendship. It doesn’t reflect well on him that he even asked.

edelweissnights · 09/12/2023 01:54

EmmaEmerald · 09/12/2023 01:42

Actually the desperation, and the oddity of this, makes me wonder if there's more to it. Like massive debt or a crypto thing that went wrong. Or he got sacked for a big thing that damages his work record.

If you get pushback, you might have to harden your heart. I really hope this doesn't happen.

@EmmaEmerald I think he had used up all lines of credit - was behind on all debtors. He couldn't borrow against anything and maybe he was already behind on mortgage payments/fees. That, or yes; something else has happened. I know he didn't get sacked or anything, but I think he needed a massive cash injection. That said; these situations are often a vicious cycle. He hated the commute into London (from Surrey) and wanted to pursue something different so he could WFH, but the London/consistent salary would have meant he wouldn't be in this situation.

OP posts:
Junemoon222 · 09/12/2023 01:54

This reply has been deleted

We're afraid we don't believe that the OP is genuine so we've removed their threads and posts.

edelweissnights · 09/12/2023 01:48

EmmaEmerald · 09/12/2023 01:46

Unfortunately wills and probate are public documents. I think you pay a very small fee to get a copy. It's why journos can report so easily. It ought to be stopped.

Ha. Posted at same time! Agreed! It shouldn't be allowed. Wills should be sealed.

OP posts:
edelweissnights · 09/12/2023 01:47

wjpa · 09/12/2023 01:36

Dh granny left him £15k
soon afterwards we had a relative on the phone wanting a “loan” of £15k
people show their true colours in these situations

said no

op you absolutely must say no

this guy buttered you up and was underhand.
id never speak to him again

So sorry to hear this and for your loss. This makes me wonder if they knew the exact amount because of public records. Can't have been a sheer coincidence. As @EmmaEmerald said too, I hate that records like this are open to all.

OP posts:
EmmaEmerald · 09/12/2023 01:46

Tinkerbyebye · 09/12/2023 01:37

Why are they assuming to will get money? Or have money?

just say sorry I don’t have any money so cant lend it to you. He can go back and find a paid job

Unfortunately wills and probate are public documents. I think you pay a very small fee to get a copy. It's why journos can report so easily. It ought to be stopped.

Fraaahnces · 09/12/2023 01:43

My mum and I had a fraught relationship and a) there was a lot less than she had been telling people and b) she put most of it in a trust for my brother (golden child) and it was like lemon juice in my emotional paper cuts. I had flown from the other side of the world to nurse her at the expense of my kids and husband so many times. (And at our financial cost too) I nursed her for her final couple of months and frankly, she didn’t mellow.When my she died, I had relatives circling like vultures. Even calling at 2am so they could be certain that they “didn’t miss me”. All of this was couched as “business opportunities” as though they were offering MEa favour.

EmmaEmerald · 09/12/2023 01:42

edelweissnights · 09/12/2023 00:11

This is what I don't understand. Unless the business is going to 'take off' suddenly before next term, I don't see how this is going to work long-term.

Actually the desperation, and the oddity of this, makes me wonder if there's more to it. Like massive debt or a crypto thing that went wrong. Or he got sacked for a big thing that damages his work record.

If you get pushback, you might have to harden your heart. I really hope this doesn't happen.

user1492757084 · 09/12/2023 01:38

Send text ..
No, sorry the estate is unavailable for years and I am very uncomfortable to lend. Try a bank.

Don't take offence but please don't ask again.

Tinkerbyebye · 09/12/2023 01:37

Why are they assuming to will get money? Or have money?

just say sorry I don’t have any money so cant lend it to you. He can go back and find a paid job

Swipe left for the next trending thread