Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend asking for loan. Knows I can 'afford it'. Went about it all wrong.

535 replies

edelweissnights · 08/12/2023 23:20

A friend called me up and asked me for a loan... after about an hour of chit-chat (which was largely regarding my grief as I have recently lost someone). It wasn't so much a loan, but a desperate plea to pay his mortgage and kids' school fees. He is starting his own business (after jacking in a £120k + London city job) and basically said he needed the money.... yesterday. Since someone very close to me (family) passed, I've been getting a few of these calls from 'friends', albeit not people who were my friends - but my relative's friend. He knows I'm 'good for it' as it is somewhat obvious/is 'public' (if you search for it). I wish he hadn't spent an hour asking about 'the estate' (which is now the name instead of my relative's actual name) as it seems he was just fishing for intel. Also, to call someone up and put them on the spot is just mad.

I have a long term partner, but no children and he kept saying how 'lucky' I was to not have the life he does as children are expensive etc... but to be honest, I do not feel lucky after the year I've had and the things I have been through. Of course children are expensive. I understand that - and respect that.

I am not even sure I would get the money back but he assured me I would within a few weeks. It's not a number to smirk at either. The way he went about it was so so wrong though. He said: "If only I knew someone who would lend me the money... oh wait..! You're childfree! Lucky you! You must have lots of disposable income!!" (Even inheritance aside, I wouldn't have 'loads' of disposable income and the number still remains slightly eye-watering). It was the fact that he kept repeating: "If only I had a way to get the money...." He sounded desperate, but I hate how horrible he made me feel and how badly he went about everything. AIBU to say no - even without giving a reason?

OP posts:
Borth · 09/12/2023 11:37

Absolutely don’t give any of these spongers anything. They are preying on your grief.

littlehorsesthatrun · 09/12/2023 11:27

This person is not your friend because a true friend would never take advantage of someone who is grieving. I would not lend him the money and would be cutting ties. Sadly money brings out the worst in people when there is a big inheritance. I’m really sorry this happened to you.

Yalta · 09/12/2023 11:23

I wouldn’t lend him money just based on his business and financial acumen

What budget did he make when he left his job to set up his own business knowing that he wouldn’t be getting in any salary or bonus

What was the forecast for the company starting to make a profit.

If both himself and his wife have no income then he needs to do what everyone else does in these situations and get himself to the nearest Uni Cred office and sign on.

A lot of these issues could have been averted if he had made a realistic business forecast and budget

We Buy Any House, We Buy Any Car and the local Primary Schools are the way to go if having no income and bills needing paying

The hard decisions of what needed to go to fund this business venture needed to be made when he decided to give up his job and start this business

Either his bonuses were incredible or his wife out earned him because those school fees would have virtually taken up his monthly salary

I suspect his wife has given up her job because she doesn’t want to end up in the scenario where she is working f/t and paying him maintenance to stay in the family home and look after dc and she only sees dc EOW.
Why should she get punished for being the sensible parent one

She probably gave up her job to establish hers of as the primary parent and will then issue divorce proceedings as she sees equity and savings disappearing and wants to grab what she can before it gets sucked up by bankruptcy proceedings

I suspect divorce proceedings are on the horizon

Londongent · 09/12/2023 11:21

If he replies, he will lay on the emotional guilt as thick as he can.
It is pure manipulation. I guarantee he won't pay it back either. He believes he is entitled to your money.

Panama2 · 09/12/2023 11:16

A friend of mine asked to borrow some money and I glad got it for her I didn't say to her but I regarded it as a gift. She did come back again and again I got her the money. I did it without any expectation of getting back she was in a dire situation and I was pleased to help her unlike your so called friend who seems to be looking for someone else to fund his lifestyle

Arniesleftleg · 09/12/2023 11:14

Please do not give him the money. And please do not feel guilty about not giving it to him.
I have an old friend, over 20 years, and hadn't heard from him in a long time. I knew he'd got into drugs and lost everything, wife and kids etc. He was always very good at rebuilding his life, but one day out of the blue he contacted me through FB messenger and started talking about how there was this 'great' business he wanted to invest in. All the chat for an hour and then the 'if only I knew someone with some money who could help me out!' Crux, I don't have money but have more than he ended up with in the way of my family. I just waited him well and hoped he would be successful and cut the call short.

These people are risk takers, as well as piss takers. The likelihood of you seeing that money without a battle is poor.

NWQM · 09/12/2023 11:13

I normally don't worry about not commenting on posts that I don't feel I can add anything different but I feel the need send a virtual hug to the OP and all who have shared their stories. People can be so selfish and cruel. I am sorry you have all been through this. Stay strong.

Jackfrostnippingatmynose · 09/12/2023 11:08

Just no! If he's asking for a "loan" from you and not the bank or putting on his credit card he's financially overstretched and up shit creek and should be cutting his cloth to match his income.

Have sadly been in a similar situation and lent a sum which has never been returned (despite numerous promises). It has destroyed our relationship.

Cailleachian · 09/12/2023 11:06

" As if your position having children or not means you don't deserve to keep money that is rightfully yours"

As I've got older, I've noticed a pattern of men circling single women who inherit without children as its assumed they dont "need" the money.

Two friends, sisters who never married, inherited a substantial property portfolio from a relative's death two years ago. Since then their two brothers, cousin and nephew have been trying all kinds of schemes to manipulate them out of these properties, mainly through sabotaging their cashflow then coming up with grand plans to "solve" the problems that they have created.

I'm not even convinced he does need the money, it could just be that he sees an easy mark.

Genevieva · 09/12/2023 11:00

Just seen the update with the info that he is divorced and these are day fees. Divorce is expensive. And they appear to have chosen the most expensive day fees in the country. Time for him and his ex-wife to cut their cloth. Either they return to city jobs or they move their children to the state sector. And if he can’t pay his mortgage then he will have to downsize. He might think he is facing the abyss, but he is just going to have to get used to the lifestyle most middle class professionals work hard to achieve. He might even find his girls make lovely new friends at a school walking distance from home and that it all works out for the best.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 09/12/2023 10:54

This reply has been deleted

We're afraid we don't believe that the OP is genuine so we've removed their threads and posts.

This happened to me as well.

I was told my abusive father removed me from his will because I refused to visit him when he was dying (after years of nc).

Out of curiosity when it became available I looked at the probate and discovered he had left me an equal share to my siblings.

Remarkably after 3.5 years of silence one mention to the family gossip I had a letter asking for bank details a week later and a high five figure sum in the bank shortly after.

id never have been informed of that had it not been public

notlucreziaborgia · 09/12/2023 10:52

I highly doubt he would pay it back tbh - I imagine in his eyes being able to afford to lend it is the same as being able to afford to lose it. You don’t really ‘deserve’ to keep it, after all you don’t even have kids to support! Oh yeah, and unlike his other creditors, he’s betting on you being swayed by sob stories about his kids too.

Hard pass. If you do lose him as a friend as a result of saying no, then that isn’t in fact a loss at all.

CantGetDecentNickname · 09/12/2023 10:48

If he pushes back or tries again, just ask him why he thinks he is entitled to other people’s money? Why he thinks other people are responsible for his children rather than their own parents? Whether he can see what an awful thing it is to prey on other’s grief? After that I wouldn’t engage further.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 09/12/2023 10:48

It depends how much you like him. I have lent money to a friend for work because I could afford to lose it if she didn't pay it back because I liked her. She did pay it back.

FancyFran · 09/12/2023 10:47

I am sorry for your loss and the stress this man is causing. I have been rich and poor. Sadly I did borrow money because i was desperate but it is always held over you. One friend even remarked about a loan repaid with interest and a gift 15 years ago! I am now in a very well paid job but it's not secure. I save for the day I get fired and give small amounts to relatives and friends. I always shout the lunch and breakfasts.
A man that wants to start a business with your money is a cheeky fecker. There are lots of loans and grants around. He can apply for those if he has property to secure it on!

Genevieva · 09/12/2023 10:46

Glad you have made the right choice and said no. He was clearly living beyond his means before he left his job.

£75,000 a year on school fees, plus I imagine at least £25,000 a year on his mortgage, all post-tax, would be every penny he was earning on a salary of £120,000, with no contingency for utility bills, food bills, mobile phone bills… Even if his wife is also earning, this would be a push for most families. And if she is earning well then they have no business asking for money.

£12K a term indicates boarding fees. Maybe he should have been sending his kids to an independence day school on £8K a term.

My suspicion is that their lifestyle verses earnings profile has been leaving a monthly deficit for some time and the issue is greater than a sudden risk of default on the school fees and mortgage. Mortgage providers are usually willing to discuss reduced payments to tide people over. Ditto, independent schools have hardship funds and the bursar will sit down with parents, look at their finances and reach a sensible decision with them. This might involve a short-term bursary while a house is sold to release capital. If he has done all that already then he knows he is never going to pay you back. This means he was never a friend and you are just a disposable means to an end. He has got some serious restructuring of his life to do and the sooner he faces up to that the better.

OVienna · 09/12/2023 10:42

Who is in the 1% that thinks the OP is being unreasonable?!

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 09/12/2023 10:41

I’ve had various inheritances over the years which I’ve either spent wisely or spent some of it.

Most normal moralistic people don’t even dream of asking for a share of it, but I have had some people try to advise me to be careful with it. Either way it’s none of their business! I have had people not so much as ask for a loan (they knew I’d say no) but have asked for other things and I either say yes or no but with no/few conditions.

CantHaveTooMuchChocolate · 09/12/2023 10:41

madeinmanc · 09/12/2023 08:17

I wouldn't go that far. It sounds like he's got himself in a fix through poor judgement and bad decisions and he's trying to do something for his children, it's not like he's trying to fund a crack habit. He's just out of options.

I don’t agree, he’s not out of options at all. He can downsize his home, put his kids into state school like most people do, sell his car, go back to his old job, etc. He’s just too entitled to make any changes. And the way he went about it is absolutely despicable too, so no, he’s not a friend.

GreigeO · 09/12/2023 10:39

Thank god you said no!

Womencanlift · 09/12/2023 10:38

Would absolutely not bail someone out for school fees. Paying for private school is a privileged choice and if you are not in that position anymore then you do what the majority of the population do and use the state system - you don’t leech off friends

madaboutmad · 09/12/2023 10:36

JollyHostess101 · 09/12/2023 10:34

Thank you for this…… I’m in the process of inheriting from my Dad and kind of don’t want to earmark it for anything except meaning I might not have to go back to work after maternity leave…… I just want to use it wisely!

OP not quite the same but someone at my dads wake asked if I’d sell her one of dads cars cheaply for their daughter 🤣

😮

JollyHostess101 · 09/12/2023 10:34

MrsClatterbuck · 09/12/2023 00:04

I know you said he went about it the wrong way but tbh there was no right way for him to do this. I can't believe that someone would have the actual bare faced cheek to do this. He would have no idea how you would be feeling and probably still grieving. I have just inherited money well I will when the solicitor gets their ass into gear but that's another thread. Not one person has said anything about the money except my dh and the person I am inheriting with.I also have no kids no mortgage dh and I retired with pensions and tbh I keep thinking that this money is my parents hard earned money and I want to use it wisely.

It sounds like they are looking a significant amount and no guarantee it will be paid back even if you do have a proper loan agreement drawn up. If he reneged on this are you prepared to take him to court to get your money back.
Take your time with regards to this inheritance. It's no one else's business and even if considering a financial advisor take your time about who to see and do your research.
If he can get the money within a few weeks why is he asking you for it I smell a rat

Thank you for this…… I’m in the process of inheriting from my Dad and kind of don’t want to earmark it for anything except meaning I might not have to go back to work after maternity leave…… I just want to use it wisely!

OP not quite the same but someone at my dads wake asked if I’d sell her one of dads cars cheaply for their daughter 🤣

ChampagneLassie · 09/12/2023 10:33

Honestly he sounds cretinous and you on no way owe anyone anything. I’d not just say no I’d tell him what you told us, he came across as a callous gold digger and his choice to jack in his job and pursue something he’s hardly a charity. Furthermore describing your childlessness as “lucky” is very insensitive.

RedHotAirBalloon · 09/12/2023 10:32

Well done OP.

It's strange how some people view other people's money as their own. My brother is like this about our parent's money. He just feels entitled to it.