Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's never OK for a teacher to tell a pupil they love them, is it?

61 replies

BippityBopper · 08/12/2023 19:35

I was watching the film, Precious, on ITV X the other day...

Spolier Alert
Precious breaks down in her alternative school class and lashes out at the teacher. She comes from a background of severe sexual abuse, physical assault, and neglect. She birthed two children from her father. She'd opened up that she recently found she has HIV. She cries that nobody cares for her or loves her.

Her teacher tries to reassure a very broken Precious and tells her that her children love her, and then tells her that she (the teacher loves her). I was bawling like a baby watching this scene and I absolutely see the teacher's point of view for saying that. But in the real world, no artistic licence for a powerful film scene, it wouldn't be ok, would it? Especially because Precious is a vulnerable child.

I felt uncomfortable at the thought of any teacher telling either of my children they loved them. But the thing is, they come from a family surrounded by love. People DO love them. Would you have said it if you were Precious' teacher?

OP posts:
Tacotortoise · 09/12/2023 18:47

Exactly. You don't protect vulnerable children from exploitation by withholding appropriate forms of love from them, that makes them more vulnerable not less.

Strawberryjams · 09/12/2023 18:45

2fast2upset · 08/12/2023 19:43

There are many different types of love.

I have worked with vulnerable children, who have said that no one loves them and have done a similar ‘me and all of the teachers at xyz school love you, your friends love you, your mum loves you.’ Is that weird?

I’ve written it on safeguarding reports as a running record of the entire interaction and I was never pulled for being exploitative or dodgy. 🤨

But this is all pointless really. your children hopefully won’t ever be in the position where they are so traumatised and their sense of worth is so low that they won’t need that reassurance that they are loved and they have worth.

This 100%

Sadly in our job sometimes children need to know they are loved and cared for. It may not be by their parents or family but they matter and have a positive impact on other people’s lives. Everyone deserves to be appreciated, respected and loved.
A few of these children have came back to visit me as young adults to chat. One even came to introduce his girlfriend. I may not do much in this world but knowing that I made those children feel loved and like they mattered seems of such high importance to me.

Dawndayda · 09/12/2023 18:36

BippityBopper · 09/12/2023 17:22

But you said you don't love them the same as your own children. I assume you'd do ANYTHING for your own children but not quite as much for your pupils. What would you have done if you did actually become a kinship carer and you found it was very negatively impacting your own children?

I think I'm drifting into pondering loving someone versus caring about them. I think caring has a wide spectrum. You can care about someone a little or a lot. But love is greater than that.

Separately, I see many people have been lucky enough to have had very special but innocent relationships with teachers. However, I feel with vulnerable children, there is a responsibility to teach them about keeping their wits about them. Finding or accepting "love" in dangerous places can be amplified by a teacher they respect and trust, innocently telling them they love them. The student will think this is appropriate and OK and leave them even more vulnerable to being groomed by someone with sinister intentions.

I didn't have children at the time so wouldn't have known the difference then but I think that there is a difference between the biological, instinctual love that I have for my children now, and the love I have for many if the children that I teach. I do think that it is still love though, it's just different.

I think you can still teach children to keep their wits about them whilst making sure they feel and know they are loved. In fact, maybe that's when it's especially important so that they can learn what love in a healthy relationship looks like. I've taught many children who have been abused and mistreated by their parents and so they think that's what love looks like. But I think for it not to be inappropriate, the context of the teacher's relationship with the child is key here. Obviously there would be situations where a teacher saying it would be completely inappropriate but I think in the context it occurs in in Precious (although it was years ago that I last saw it so apologies if I'm wrong) wouldn't necessarily be inappropriate to me.

LetsGoToTheHills · 09/12/2023 18:21

My children go to a CofE school and part of their vision statement is ‘you are loved’. The children at school say ‘the teachers love us here’. As a previous poster said, there are different types of love, not just romantic or sexual. I am a non Christian but think it’s a beautiful thing.

OldChinaJug · 09/12/2023 17:49

I love the children in my class.

Not in the same way as I love my own children of course but I do love them. Of course I do.

Quite a few will tell me they love me. I'd never reply "I love you too" in return but I have said "I love all of you too, all the teachers do".

Because it's true, we do.

But you're right about boundaries, OP. Which is what you're really talking about. Vulnerable children can become very attached to anyone who shows them kindness and that makes them vulnerable to exploitation - especially those who are desperate to be loved. We can address that by telling them what we admire about them - their sense of humour, their resilience, their confidence, their inquisitiveness, their kindness, their reliability and hopefully they will begin to see their worth (beyond what they offer to someone else).

10HailMarys · 09/12/2023 17:46

It’s an American film and it’s a lot more normal in America than it is here to use the word ‘love’ in that kind of context, I think, eg as an expression of kindness and support, rather than romantic love and friendship.

Cherrysoup · 09/12/2023 17:36

Tricky. I have told classes I love teaching them and that they’re my favourite group in that year (if they’re my only group in that year!). Don’t think I would tell an individual child that I love them, it really isn’t appropriate.

MotherofaToad · 09/12/2023 17:32

I'm a teacher and taught reception age for 4 years. Children would often tell me that they loved me and I never knew what to say back to them. I spoke to another teacher about it who said that the children were looking for reassurance from me and to tell them back that I loved them. I never felt comfortable saying that but I did.

Context is so important. Telling a child in private that you love them is very different to returning the statement to a child in public.

I now teach older kids who tell me that they hate me...

BippityBopper · 09/12/2023 17:23

The first two paragraphs above were in response to @Dawndayda

OP posts:
BippityBopper · 09/12/2023 17:22

But you said you don't love them the same as your own children. I assume you'd do ANYTHING for your own children but not quite as much for your pupils. What would you have done if you did actually become a kinship carer and you found it was very negatively impacting your own children?

I think I'm drifting into pondering loving someone versus caring about them. I think caring has a wide spectrum. You can care about someone a little or a lot. But love is greater than that.

Separately, I see many people have been lucky enough to have had very special but innocent relationships with teachers. However, I feel with vulnerable children, there is a responsibility to teach them about keeping their wits about them. Finding or accepting "love" in dangerous places can be amplified by a teacher they respect and trust, innocently telling them they love them. The student will think this is appropriate and OK and leave them even more vulnerable to being groomed by someone with sinister intentions.

OP posts:
Dawndayda · 08/12/2023 21:09

Titicacacandle · 08/12/2023 20:48

That was a lovely and human response. It wasn't setting you up to think that finally someone loves you and you will be loved and looked after properly only to have your heart broken once again. It's not what the OP is talking about.

I get what you're saying but surely depending on the teacher, that may be their own human and truthful response? I'm actually a teacher now and have had children who I can honestly say that I loved. I teach ASN so often taught the same children for a number of years, I even almost became a kinship carer for one pupil and his sister as they were in foster care but were moving and they couldn't find a place for them together and we're potentially going to be separated which I know would have destroyed them. I was discussing this with their social worker as a possibility when a home together was found for them.
It's hard to describe the love I have for my pupils as it's not the same as the love I have for my own children but still comes from the same maternal place. It's definitely not a sinister or inappropriate love. I think if I taught a child who I felt that love for and felt like they needed to know it (as the girl in Precious clearly did), I wouldn't see an issue in telling them.

Titicacacandle · 08/12/2023 20:48

Dawndayda · 08/12/2023 20:43

A teacher once gave me a kiss in primary school when I was 6 years old.

If I said that on it's own then it might seem really bad and inappropriate, but as others have said, context matters. The reason why the teacher kissed me was because I had made a valentine's card for her son who had been in my class and left to go to a different school. She taught in another class and I asked if I could take it to her room and my own teacher let me, when I gave her it to give to him she welled up and gave me the biggest hug and a kiss. I told my mum later who only told me that it must have been a really nice card. Years later my mum told me that the teacher's son had actually been moved to a special school and had quite profound learning difficulties, as a young child I hadn't noticed and had no idea, he was just my friend and I missed him. I don't think there was anything wrong with what that teacher did because in that moment she was just being a mum, not a teacher.

That was a lovely and human response. It wasn't setting you up to think that finally someone loves you and you will be loved and looked after properly only to have your heart broken once again. It's not what the OP is talking about.

Dawndayda · 08/12/2023 20:43

A teacher once gave me a kiss in primary school when I was 6 years old.

If I said that on it's own then it might seem really bad and inappropriate, but as others have said, context matters. The reason why the teacher kissed me was because I had made a valentine's card for her son who had been in my class and left to go to a different school. She taught in another class and I asked if I could take it to her room and my own teacher let me, when I gave her it to give to him she welled up and gave me the biggest hug and a kiss. I told my mum later who only told me that it must have been a really nice card. Years later my mum told me that the teacher's son had actually been moved to a special school and had quite profound learning difficulties, as a young child I hadn't noticed and had no idea, he was just my friend and I missed him. I don't think there was anything wrong with what that teacher did because in that moment she was just being a mum, not a teacher.

BippityBopper · 08/12/2023 20:24

I think Precious is 16. In that scene, her youngest child was just a few months old.

Lots of great point of views. Particularly about it being inappropriate to tell a child they love them to make them feel better. I feel that's the problem. The scene made my heart bleed and it would be so easy to tell a child so desperate for love that you love them. But how many vulnerable children would take that and run with it? They then think that person can be relied upon for anything and go to them with every hardship/problem they face. She was just Precious' teacher (and seemed to do more for her than the social worker). I think boundaries do need to be drawn. Precious' teacher would have come across multiple girls like her and she can't be everything to everyone all the time.

But still, I see how it could easily be said. We are human. We are social beings and have empathy. It's made me think of all those who work with vulnerable children and do genuinely care. The ones who aren't ticking boxes, or worse, abusing their positions.

I appreciate It's very different to telling a run of the mill child that you love them. One that wouldn't need your love.

The film has really moved me as I know this is reality for many. The ending, although meant to be somewhat positive, was very sombre.

OP posts:
ManyATrueWord · 08/12/2023 20:10

In a C of E school you are meant to love everyone so I think there is something wrong with insisting all love,.all personal relationship feelings are sexual or inappropriate.

Okaaaay · 08/12/2023 20:08

Does it feel weird because, as adults, we equate love with intimacy and therefore it starts to feel seedy?

Agree that there are loads of types of love and context is absolutely everything here.

Titicacacandle · 08/12/2023 19:57

sprigatito · 08/12/2023 19:51

What if you genuinely do love them - in a parental, non-sinister way - and you don't intend to drop them once they leave school? I have several of those long-term friendships with my school teachers. They're great people and they mean a lot to me. No harm has been done to anyone.

They cannot guarantee that they will be able to stay in that persons life. Even if they wanted to foster them (it does happen, people care about a vulnerable child who gets taken into care and they step up to foster them) then it would still be inappropriate until they've got a secure long term foster placement. It's an easy way out to make a child feel better when that person doesn't t have the tools to help them regulate their emotions.

Imagine being told you're loved by a trusted adult who you've attached to and then never being able to see that one person who told you they loved you. That child would have already created a fairy tale ending about the teacher being their family in their head once they heard that!

sprigatito · 08/12/2023 19:51

Titicacacandle · 08/12/2023 19:48

It is inappropriate to set a vulnerable young person up to be 'rejected' again by someone who has told them they love them. It's not about bending the rules of professionalism, it's about managing someones attachment to you if you've told them you love them. It's easy to say you love someone to make them feel better, it's not helpful to the person in the long run and can make that person feel worse.

What if you genuinely do love them - in a parental, non-sinister way - and you don't intend to drop them once they leave school? I have several of those long-term friendships with my school teachers. They're great people and they mean a lot to me. No harm has been done to anyone.

Whattodo112222 · 08/12/2023 19:51

Its a true story.
In that situation, she needed to be told someone loved her.

CaptainMyCaptain · 08/12/2023 19:50

As a completely irrelevant aside, Mariah Carey plays the part of a social worker in that film.

violetcuriosity · 08/12/2023 19:49

I work with children who have experienced trauma, I'm their assistant head teacher. I've been in this situation countless times with children who truthfully probably don't have anyone that loves them, at least not in a whole, healthy way. I would never tell them I love them, even though the care and affection I have for them may border that feeling, it isn't actual love. I wouldn't tell them that for the obvious safeguarding reasons but also because it would just be more evidence that love is something people can give and take, that is transient and something I would be able to withdraw when they are no longer in my care. I would then be someone else who has let them down. I do, however, tell them how special they are, how much I care about them and that they can trust me to do the right things for them, I tell them they can put their problems on me and I will carry those problems and make decisions for them- I will do all of the things that someone who loves them would do- but I will always make sure they know there is a professional boundary there.

Titicacacandle · 08/12/2023 19:48

It is inappropriate to set a vulnerable young person up to be 'rejected' again by someone who has told them they love them. It's not about bending the rules of professionalism, it's about managing someones attachment to you if you've told them you love them. It's easy to say you love someone to make them feel better, it's not helpful to the person in the long run and can make that person feel worse.

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 08/12/2023 19:47

CityCommuter · 08/12/2023 19:41

@BippityBopper how old is Precious being as she's given birth to two children?

I think she’s 15 if I remember rightly.

Honestly in that setting (I think it’s a true story?) I don’t think it was inappropriate. The teacher ended up housing her and obviously cared deeply for her.
it was also 40 years ago with slightly different attitudes to safeguarding

sprigatito · 08/12/2023 19:47

Titicacacandle · 08/12/2023 19:44

You're right OP. You shouldn't tell people in that position that you love them. It sets a really unfair hope off in that person that you would then have to manage to have an appropriate work boundary with them.

You can say things like - I'm really happy to know you, you're a strong person, your children love you and others will too, it's rubbish right now but, etc. Then you work on supporting them to integrate into a community and have supportive and loving networks of people. It's really unfair to try to be that person as a professional as it's completely not fair on them to have that expectation that you will always be there for them when you won't.

It's not always true that you won't be there, though. I am 46 and still friends with a couple of my teachers. Though I do accept that my school was a bit unusual.

CaptainMyCaptain · 08/12/2023 19:47

CityCommuter · 08/12/2023 19:41

@BippityBopper how old is Precious being as she's given birth to two children?

I can't remember exactly but she was very, very young.

I think the love being referred to is an all encompassing love and not sexual. Loving her as a valued human being. I was an Early Years teacher and sometimes children told me they loved me. My response was always 'and I love ALL of you'.