Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Yr 6 prom and inclusivity

62 replies

Angelik · 08/12/2023 12:25

I'd like to ensure my dd's y6 prom is as inclusive as possible. I'm happy to organise and run stuff. Prom organisers are set on a disco-fine but it's not for everyone. When I asked what we're doing for those with sensory issues or who just don't like loud music was told they could have ear defenders which I think is insufficient. One patent said SEN children shouldn't be forced to come by parents, implying that's the only reason they did come, that I should survey for sensory needs (!) and there are other fun things (a hoodie and a water fight on other day - this has got to be discrimination) for them, that they have joined in happily before (don't know how they would know) and we can't cater for everyone!

My feeling is disabled people shouldn't have to keep flagging their needs. Society should pause and think.

Aibu that the prom attitude is quite shit or am I making an issue out of nothing?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Boardingmama2 · 08/12/2023 18:54

Sorry just saw it was a year 6 prom! Ignore my post.

UncleBryn · 08/12/2023 18:53

A lot of the suggestions whilst in good intentions are too young for a leavers prom, these are 16 year olds so colouring and board games are not going to interest them. Also a lot of proms aren't on school premises and are at a venue. My DS prom was organised by parents at a local club. There was a chill out room which just had comfy seats, they didn't need anything else as they either chatted to each other or were on their phones, although from what I understand hardly anyone used the room. They had a Photo Booth and a free casino which was a huge hit, disco and a band for part of it. You could put the Photo Booth in the chill out room so there is something to 'watch' even when having a bit of space if you felt the need. They are young adults and should be treated as such.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 08/12/2023 18:40

LlynTegid · 08/12/2023 12:29

It's not just sensory issues.

I don't think there should be school proms at any age.

A leavers party/prom at the end of secondary is fine, but they don't need anything before that imho (other than the odd class party/disco).

TwoBlueFish · 08/12/2023 17:42

I used to help run primary school discos when my kids were young (one of whom has SEN and sensory issues), we always had a classroom set up as a quieter area with a movie playing. Lots of kids would take a break in there.

MargaretThursday · 08/12/2023 17:39

I have 3 dc, two have SEN, one physically, with an unusual physical disability.

It is incredibly irritating when someone tells you that they are ensuring that your dc is included without checking what they actually need/want.
It rarely comes across as anything other than the person trying to performance how great they are without actually caring for the dc involved. In those circumstances I've also found that when I've said what would actually be helpful, which is normally far less hassle/noticeable than what they want to do, that they aren't prepared to do that.

And for what it's worth, ds who has ASD thinks that silent discos are far worse than any noise you can put past him, despite him being fairly noise sensitive.
He would tell you that the only reason to go to such an event is to have fun with friends, which if you can't make rude jokes to each other because you've all got headphones on then you might as well not go.
He might go to a quieter room if there was football of some description on offer, but then it probably wouldn't end up being quiet any longer. 🤣

DormantWindow · 08/12/2023 17:35

Ours was called a leavers disco. It was dancing in a hot room so most kids ended up running in the field outside throwing water at each other and having great fun.

Are you talking about an event in July 24? You have plenty of time to plan!

In the summer it’s quite easy to have some outside space for kids to relax in. Failing that, a quiet room is easy to organise.

Don’t make this more complicated than it needs to be.

Namechangedagain20 · 08/12/2023 17:20

DDs school offer a quiet room during school discos with craft activities for the children who don’t want to be in the hall. DD has ASD and it works well, she can put on ear defenders to go into the disco but if she gets overwhelmed she has somewhere to retreat to. It’s not very difficult to set up and only takes a couple more staff/volunteers.

Onionsmadeofglass · 08/12/2023 17:15

@AmyDudley
I think OP is being unreasonable expecting the volunteer parents on the end of year disco-committee to organize things that aren’t a disco. That doesn’t mean they shouldn’t adapt stuff to include students who might need/benefit from adaptations - like setting the light level higher if there are student with vision or mobility issues who would struggle in the dark. Or providing ear defenders and getting a couple of volunteers to staff a break out room. But expecting volunteers to organize a second completely different event (still presumably on a budget of zero) because some students don’t like discos is just going to result in no volunteers next time.

Onionsmadeofglass · 08/12/2023 17:06

AmyDudley · 08/12/2023 15:27

A silent disco requires hiring loads of headphones. A normal disco in the school hall has fairly minimal expenses. I can’t imagine that the PTA has money to burn…

Cost varies some companies let you hire a very small number of headphones and if only a few children ere requiring it, it wouldn't be prohibitive, and you could have a fundraiser to offset the cost. Anyway it might not be suitable, its a just a suggestion that I thought might be helpful. Maybe the PTA wouldn;t consider spending money to help children with SEN enjoy the occasion 'burning money' I don't know the school so don;t know their attitude to inclusivity. But you go ahead and be rude to people trying to be helpful to the OP . Your suggetions all seem to be centred around 'discos are loud, OK give them a room they can go to out of the way but you can't cater to everyone'

In all my memories of PTA organized stuff one factor is basically that there was practically no budget whatsoever. Disco = volunteer parent DJ using existing school sound system. Teachers would act as security or sometimes the local police if it was a community event open to kids from other schools. Most PTA events seemed designed to make money which was then put back into things like subsidizing school trips for struggling families. I was imagining 200 headsets for kids at disco and that that would be prohibitively expensive, especially if you had to pay for any breakages or if there was a good chance some of the headphones would disappear and not be returned… But then maybe my school 20 years ago was just really rough.
You couldn’t just hire 5 headsets for the kids who might want them. They’d still be surrounded by the noise+lights. It would need to be for everyone.
It really wasn’t about suggesting no money should be spent on accessibility, rather me imagining a budget of zero, a door charge of 1 quid and entirely staffed my parent and teacher volunteers.

Newsenmum · 08/12/2023 16:39

I agree you should ask the parents of those children what would work for them. And definitely have a quiet space/area. Good on you for caring.

TeenDivided · 08/12/2023 16:34

My suggestions

  1. Don't call it a prom. The word prom has connotations of expense, fancy clothes etc etc. Call it a disco or a party.
  2. Put the refreshments into the quiet/break out room. That way everyone will naturally go in there some of the time which will seem more natural.
QuietBear · 08/12/2023 16:25

Every school I've worked in, over the last 15 years, has had a quiet room set up for school discos.

Put some colour sheets in there and a film to watch. Easy.

Just offer to organise/ supervise the room OP.

Soontobe60 · 08/12/2023 16:04

LaLaLouella · 08/12/2023 12:34

Why do you think there shouldn't be school proms at any age? It's a celebration of a rite of passage.

Not in the schools I’ve worked in it isnt. The OP wants to be inclusive - how will she ensure those children whose parents cannot afford to buy a hoody / ticket / party outfit are included? Proms are middle class events that really do exclude less well off families.

Everanewbie · 08/12/2023 16:02

I know you're coming from a good and kind place here OP. But jesus, who would want to be a volunteer these days? No wonder stuff is being cancelled left, right and centre.

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 08/12/2023 16:00

Dixiechickonhols · 08/12/2023 15:55

A disco and a quiet room sound fine. You could make some photo props so the children can have some photos taken in the quiet room. If there’s food then that’s another quieter space.
I wouldn’t over think it.

This sounds good!

Dixiechickonhols · 08/12/2023 15:55

A disco and a quiet room sound fine. You could make some photo props so the children can have some photos taken in the quiet room. If there’s food then that’s another quieter space.
I wouldn’t over think it.

AmyDudley · 08/12/2023 15:27

A silent disco requires hiring loads of headphones. A normal disco in the school hall has fairly minimal expenses. I can’t imagine that the PTA has money to burn…

Cost varies some companies let you hire a very small number of headphones and if only a few children ere requiring it, it wouldn't be prohibitive, and you could have a fundraiser to offset the cost. Anyway it might not be suitable, its a just a suggestion that I thought might be helpful. Maybe the PTA wouldn;t consider spending money to help children with SEN enjoy the occasion 'burning money' I don't know the school so don;t know their attitude to inclusivity. But you go ahead and be rude to people trying to be helpful to the OP . Your suggetions all seem to be centred around 'discos are loud, OK give them a room they can go to out of the way but you can't cater to everyone'

Onionsmadeofglass · 08/12/2023 15:11

A silent disco requires hiring loads of headphones. A normal disco in the school hall has fairly minimal expenses. I can’t imagine that the PTA has money to burn…

Ponderingwindow · 08/12/2023 15:08

For that age group, My DD’s school did two areas. One was a disco. The other was sports.

actually think there would have been great appeal to do a board game / chill out room as well, but I was not an active planner for medical reasons so I kept my mouth shut and just appreciated what the organizers accomplished.

for older years, they just have straight up dances. My DD’s social group is entirely made up of ND teens and they attend together. Her group doesn’t tend towards the sensory sensitive obviously or that would be impossible.

ManateeFair · 08/12/2023 15:07

Well, the very definition of a prom is a school event with dancing, so if you didn't have a disco or a band, it wouldn't actually be a prom. You definitely have to provide that.

However, if there are kids who can't handle loud noise or might want to get away then you need another room set up with beanbags/comfy seating and something less noisy to do - maybe some fun board games, table football, Giant Jenga, stuff like that?

AmyDudley · 08/12/2023 15:02

First find out whether there is a need, and poll those parents/children who want something different what they would like. Would a silent disco be feasible, for children who might like to dance but can control the volume of the music and can do it in a room that doesn't have flashing lights or a crowd of others ?

nutsnutspistachionuts · 08/12/2023 14:44

Quiet room / chilled out space is the big one. Also I'm sure you are anyway but avoid "prom queen/king", any weird looks-focused stuff, stuff that makes them feel like they need a partner or an opposite sex date. Maybe do a suggestions box - like "we'd like the prom to be as fun, welcoming and inclusive as possible! If you have a suggestion for how we can make sure the event is inclusive, please write it in here anonymously" (hardly anyone will do this but it's quite nice to ask)

BoohooWoohoo · 08/12/2023 14:20

I agree with a pp that you should talk to the teacher about how you can make the event inclusive as she will know the children and their needs best. Without talking to the teacher, you could be tying yourself in knots about “what ifs” that don’t exist and accidentally leaving people out because you don’t know what they need.

Nowherenew · 08/12/2023 14:14

YABU

I work with SEN students who attend mainstream proms/discos all of the time.
We also have our own.

Percentage-wise more of our SEN students attend these than the mainstream kids do.

We also have water fights and all of the students either join in or have fun watching.

There are always ear defenders and a quite break out room but they’re very rarely used and a quieter area should be available for NT students too, as not everyone likes loud music all of the time.

As long as there is a quieter area/room then they should be fine.

Gazelda · 08/12/2023 14:12

You're not making an issue out of nothing. Of course the event should be as accessible and inclusive as possible.

But maybe they took your question as criticism rather than appreciation of the effort they're making?

And (maybe I'm wrong) you seem to have asked why arrangements they're making rather than suggesting xyz because you know that's what is needed by the children with additional needs to ensure they enjoy the prom.

I'd get feedback from teacher and then talk with the organisers to say you'd like to arrange [whatever] and how can you incorporate this into the overall project plan (budget, timings, risk assessment, staffing etc)