Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are things becoming just a little bit shit?

563 replies

Bloomsburygirl · 08/12/2023 09:38

I was wondering if anyone else has started to notice the deteriorating standards in public services and private businesses. I went to London over the weekend, and I was shocked by the filth and litter. I moved to the UK in 2011, and I visited many times before I moved. I do not remember rubbish strewn across streets like it is now. And every place I seem to go gives off a feeling that there simply are not enough staff anymore. Restaurant toilets and public toilets are filthy, it takes an age to be served, and don't get me started on public transport (I read the recent thread on this and agree with every word). It seems to me like the consequences of Brexit/pandemic are really starting to bite, and to be honest, I miss the way it was pre-2016. AIBU, or do others feel the same? And is this the new normal? Disclaimer - I still adore the UK and would never want to live anywhere else!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Lifesd · 08/12/2023 12:11

YANBU there is a noticeable decline across public services and the state of some
of our cities is awful. The NHS, Roads, rail, water - dreadful. Public services will continue to decline due to bankrupt councils. The mood in the country is terrible, we desperately need an election and for something to change but I am not holding out much hope.

Flyhigher · 08/12/2023 12:11

How will this be studied in history gsce in the future?

Ozgirl75 · 08/12/2023 12:10

I was always a fan of privatisation - it made economic sense that companies would run things efficiently. I’ve totally changed my mind about this as I now see that private companies just run things for the benefit of shareholders. That’s fine for some things, but when it comes of utilities and services, you can’t successfully concentrate just on profit. Some things have to be unprofitable for the good of the service (like not very busy bus routes that are still vital for small villages etc)
When I see what big companies have done to things like the water companies I just can hardly believe it. How is it possible in a western nation in 2023 that rivers are regularly flooded with sewage? How do we accept this?
And trains - my god! We were promised an efficient system, and hey, maybe it would cost a little more but that’s ok if it’s better? And yet what we actually have is a system that is astoundingly expensive, and terrible. I’ve been up to London about 8 times in the past year and only on one of these journeys was my train actually on time - and on two occasions it was absolute chaos with trains cancelled or re routed.

readymealeater · 08/12/2023 12:10

Below the poverty line: slum Britain in the 1960s – in pictures | Art and design | The Guardian

Mr and Mrs Gallagher lived with their four children in a ground floor tenement flat. Their bedroom was covered in pools of rainwater. At night they sleep with the light on to keep the rats away. One night they counted 16 rats in the room. Glasgow Maryhill, October 1970.

Mr and Mrs M and their four children lived in a council-owned house with no bathroom, no hot water, outside lavatory, inside walls running with damp. The children slept on sodden seat cushions covered by a couple of old ‘macs’, there was no heating in the room, the snow lay thick outside and the windows were broken. Birmingham, January 1969.

Mrs T and her family of five lived in a decaying terraced house owned by a steelworks. She had no gas, no electricity, no hot water, no bathroom. Her cooking was done on the fire in the living room. Sheffield, May 1969.

Flyhigher · 08/12/2023 12:10

Tories, Brexit, Covid. Even crazier Tories. Completely insane shameless Tories.

anniegun · 08/12/2023 12:09

We have declined as a country whilst the ruling classes have robbed our wealth in a way that was only slightly stealthier than Russian kleptocrats. Tory donors get yachts and private jets whist ordinary people cant get a doctors appointment or stay warm

readymealeater · 08/12/2023 12:08

user1497207191 · 08/12/2023 10:22

YABU because none of this is just recent. The decline in services/standards etc started decades ago. I'm old enough to remember the 70s and 80s and generally things were better across the board. Yes, a small number of things were crap, such as power cuts, council worker strikes etc but they were short term and resolved within a pretty short period of time. What we're seeing now is culmination of several decades of "creeping" of poor public services, poor staff service, etc. People in cities, especially London, didn't see it at first, but now they're starting to suffer, they think it's something new. It's not. Lots of northern industrial towns, lots of seaside towns, etc., have suffered terribly in the 90s and noughties but London centric people didn't notice and didn't care!

Yep, totally agree.

Pics of some of Birmingham and Glasgow 1969-1971:

Below the poverty line: slum Britain in the 1960s – in pictures | Art and design | The Guardian

Ortila · 08/12/2023 12:08

Crushed23 · 08/12/2023 10:02

It’s probably a sign that the developing world has got richer and demand for goods and services has increased globally.

I don’t see the redistribution of wealth on a global level to be a bad thing, but it does mean we in the West have to accept a lower standard of living than what we had when more of the world’s population was poor.

I agree with this. The global south is getting smarter and richer and has a younger population than Europe/USA/Australia. There will necessarily be a distributive shift and it's started happening already.

However there are some things we've done that have made it worse for the UK - Brexit obviously, and quantitative easing means money is literally worth less. The only thing worth having are assets and successive governments have restricted supply one of our key assets (housing) while enabling it to be traded globally alongside key industry drivers like fuel and transport. So we aren't part of a trading bloc and the things we rely on day to day are expensive and difficult to get hold of.

JamSandle · 08/12/2023 12:07

user1497207191 · 08/12/2023 11:03

@XDownwiththissortofthingX

but the truth is the UK has been broke and in decline since the 1950's, people in the UK were afforded an entirely unrealistic and unsustainable standard of living for decades thanks to profligate borrowing, and now we are finally being hit with the bill.

I agree with all this. We've been sold a lie for several decades. It's all coming home to roost now. We're paying more in interest on the national debt than we spend on education! Developing countries are getting richer at our expense and we've just sleep walked into it. At the end of the day, Britain was just "lucky" for a couple of centuries with natural resources, the empire, etc. Tables have turned and we're in managed (or MIS managed) decline. It's not going to get any better folks!

I dont think we sleep walked into anything. People have been warning about this for a long time - it's just that people didn't listen.

Blueblell · 08/12/2023 12:06

Since brexit and Covid everything has declined. The only good thing has been the Elizabeth line which is actually pretty good

TheThingIsYeah · 08/12/2023 12:06

@Crushed23 @Ozgirl75 @EasternStandard

I can only assume that many people are just not really affected by inflation. It might too be a shift in demographics that spend in pubs/restaurants though. When I was at school 40 years ago we used to celebrate harvest festival and bring in tins of food for the old folk, nowadays they seem to be the ones with the spare cash to spend.

Pooracoustics · 08/12/2023 12:04

WrappersDelight · 08/12/2023 11:54

This 100%

Or… rather than blame our plight on immigrants who we need to run public services .. how about we look at inflation rising without attendant wage rises. Unions weaker. Private companies asset stripping public services. Manufacturing industries shut or unsupported. Rail links to open up the north cancelled. Public transport costly and inefficient. Childcare prohibitively expensive. Health care on its knees. Poor investment in school infrastructure. Two parents working ft having to shop at food banks. Homelessness. Terrible social care. Wage gaps between those paid the lowest and those paid the highest getting increasongly wider. A scandalous number of children living below the poverty line.

I agree with you about corrupt governance though!

IheartNiles · 08/12/2023 12:02

We’ve had a massive surge in population with no planning for how we will accommodate it (infrastructure, housing, services).
At the same time public services have been out into the hands of private businesses and individuals, who have asset stripped them. The money sits in the hands of a small number of individuals who control the media and governments and influence how we think and vote in order to maintain the status quo.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/12/2023 12:01

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 08/12/2023 11:55

in the guardian yesterday there was an article saying that a European Commission had decided that public services and infrastructure in the uk was worse than in East Germany.
wether that’s factually correct I don’t know, but since covid/lockdown everting seems to have deteriorated from public services to individual behaviour.

Really wouldn't be a surprise.

There is little value in any argument along the lines of "we should be more like DDR and less like ourselves", because the DDR is not an example anyone should be striving to emulate, but still, it's amusing purely from an anecdotal perspective.

100% employment and basically being free to chose your career path, education, and vocation within reason? Great. Not sure I want a Totalitarian government and all the apparatus of state that comes along with that though.

Curious that there are still some older former citizens who opine the demise of the DDR, but I suspect those weren't the ones on the receiving end of the Stasi's hospitality.

MidgeFragnets · 08/12/2023 11:57

It's been shit for 13 years at least. The difference now is that the corruption is in plain sight. What isn't different is that some people still can't see it and blame each other over trivial things rather than the huge failures of our government and their strategic incompetence and greed.

The lot of them and their buddies need to be ejected into space. I despise them. I'm glad they look like utter narcisstic freaks and thick as shit to most people now because they truly are.

Ace56 · 08/12/2023 11:57

Yes, I’ve been thinking for years that the standard of living in the UK is now below most other western countries, and definitely below most of the EU.

Things rarely run properly or on time, you have to wait ages for any kind of service, there is a lack of efficiency.

On my way to work there’s a smashed up car on the side of the road that I see every day that’s obviously been involved in an accident. There’s police tape around it. It’s been there for about 2 months, I guess they haven’t got round to clearing it away yet. In the European country where I used to live, this would have been removed within a couple of days, if not on the day. Just an example of a lack of efficiency and underfunded/understaffed services.

Crushed23 · 08/12/2023 11:56

mantyzer · 08/12/2023 11:44

@Crushed23 I am worried that things are going to get worse. So we are very much living for today.

Me too!

My longterm goals have been shot to shit so I’m living for the moment much more.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 08/12/2023 11:55

in the guardian yesterday there was an article saying that a European Commission had decided that public services and infrastructure in the uk was worse than in East Germany.
wether that’s factually correct I don’t know, but since covid/lockdown everting seems to have deteriorated from public services to individual behaviour.

WrappersDelight · 08/12/2023 11:54

lkwhjis · 08/12/2023 10:32

Two decades of low skilled mass migration, low productivity, 5 million economically inactive being funded by others, record low 47% net contributors in the economy. And then Covid happened with rampant borrowing, money printing and government corruption. Too many people not contributing enough. Too few holding those people up. This is what you get.

This 100%

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/12/2023 11:53

user1497207191 · 08/12/2023 11:43

Unfortunately, massive investment was needed in a lot of public services due to new legislation, H&S etc., which would have had to be paid for by government borrowings had those industries not been privatised.

Take trains. We used to have pretty cheap "rolling stock", i.e. carriages - cheap and simple, look at the pacers which were basically buses on train wheels! They were all non compliant with modern safety standards, modern H&S requirements, disability access requirements, etc. Hence the privatised railway companies (now mostly back in govt control) and a whole new industry in the leasing of "new" trains that cost millions per carriage! Over the past 20/30 literally every single carriage has been replaced and the average age of trains is now much lower and they're all no compliant. That's a massive improvement in the quality of the rolling stock, at least in terms of meeting the new laws and standards (we all know a lot of them are faulty, uncomfortable etc but that's another story).

Of course, it's not all roses. But the taxpayer couldn't have financed such a massive changeover of the old stock into new. It's basically PFI for trains rather than hospitals! All to keep the debt off the government's balance sheet!

This is all true enough, but the point remains that privatisation simply has not delivered on the promises which were originally pitched, namely, a massive increase in quality of provision and choice, with no detriment to level of service.

We were sold a turkey, and we've now left ourselves wide open to the nonsense of out of control profiteering for providing basic, life-essential services like utilities, and almost essential services like public transport, while the government shows little interest in regulating these industries to suit public interest, and the initial financial boons to public funds are long since gone.

EasternStandard · 08/12/2023 11:53

Crushed23 · 08/12/2023 11:42

This is one of the strangest phenomena I’ve noticed as well.

Even in a COL crisis, every single attraction and bar/restaurant I go to is the busiest it has ever been seemingly. Tickets to concerts and festivals costing several hundred pounds each sell out in minutes. Theatre tickets if you want a view of the stage are now £100+ as standard but shows still sell out.

Are people just saving less than they used to? Have our priorities changed (experiences over material things)?

Why is everywhere so goddamn busy?!

Everything we’ve gone to has been packed, theatre etc at really high prices

Pooracoustics · 08/12/2023 11:51

peppermintcrisp · 08/12/2023 11:36

The train strikes/no overtime rule is awful atm trains are cancelled constantly. My young DC stranded late at night at stations also they haven't managed to get to work on time for days. I have never before seen train transport to be so abysmal.

Yes agree with this and train fares have never been so extortionate!

Ragruggers · 08/12/2023 11:47

cornishsqueezy · 08/12/2023 10:21

It's always been like this in Cornwall. We've had the same graffiti in Falmouth for about 15 years now - It'll be Grade II listed by the time they get around to painting over it.

Dog shit and litter everywhere. Weeds. Potholes. Buses catching on fire.

I live in a beautiful small town in Cornwall.Very clean road sweeper every day,leaves cleared from paths.Great pride in planting,decorating always going on.Depends where you live and the community.Sure there are plenty of towns like this in the UK.But pot holes galore as the rest of the country.Residents are very vocal re issues in the town which is one of the reasons why it is like this.

Ozgirl75 · 08/12/2023 11:46

Crushed23 · 08/12/2023 11:42

This is one of the strangest phenomena I’ve noticed as well.

Even in a COL crisis, every single attraction and bar/restaurant I go to is the busiest it has ever been seemingly. Tickets to concerts and festivals costing several hundred pounds each sell out in minutes. Theatre tickets if you want a view of the stage are now £100+ as standard but shows still sell out.

Are people just saving less than they used to? Have our priorities changed (experiences over material things)?

Why is everywhere so goddamn busy?!

Totally agree! Everywhere you go it’s rammed! Even when we go out for dinner and gasp at the price, the places are full.
I was at a national trust recently and the shop was chockas with £300 throws and £30 candles which I assume someone is buying.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/12/2023 11:45

Neelsplace · 08/12/2023 11:35

It’s a nice point about volunteers but frankly I think it’s terrifying how much charities have to pick up the government slack. Litter picking is one thing but relying on (struggling , underfunded) charities to tackle addiction, homelessness, domestic violence, rehabilitation, mental health etc etc seems to be a key strategy of this government.

It has always been this way, it's not just a facet of this particular government.

I think it's partly because putting money into things which the public might not perceive as "high value" activities is a hard-sell electorally, but also because if you acknowledge the full extent of some of these problems, you are simultaneously highlighting and drawing attention to your own failings as a government and a society.

I work for a tiny Mental Health charity, and I can remember killing myself laughing at Theresa May making a big fanfare about "an extra 1.5 million pounds for mental health". That is a drop in the ocean, but it highlights just how pitifully this sort of thing is resourced in the first place if politicians genuinely believe an extra 1.5million is a big song and dance.