Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Employee feels micromanaged if I give her tasks with deadlines

638 replies

calmama · 08/12/2023 09:11

I manage a person who is generally difficult. She objects to… well everything and undermines me at every chance she gets.

When she first started working for me we sat down together and established a work plan to get our job done and keep us on track to meet deadlines. We agreed I would assign daily tasks and we would meet weekly to discuss progress on projects along with anything new we had to take on, along with any business changes, leave, etc.

Weeks down the line she exploded at me for colour coding priorities, saying the urgent (red) tasks were ‘very unfriendly and freaking her out’. I took the red out.

A few weeks later she exploded at me for ‘micromanaging and bullying her’ by sending her daily priorities, despite this being agreed upon from the very start. I asked for an alternative way of progressing projects. She had none.

Today she exploded at me for setting deadlines because they ‘stress her out’. Again, I asked her for an alternative way of doing things and she had none.

I’m at a loss. She’s doing honestly the bare minimum and can’t seem to cope. I’m having to pick up her slack because otherwise my team looks bad, yet I’m still copping the brunt of her rage and there’s no end in sight.

AIBU to throw my hands in the air and take a long vacation?

OP posts:
SovietSpy · 08/12/2023 12:21

Rosscameasdoody · 08/12/2023 12:13

This. But on the issue of a health condition as a reason for her failings, there is no legal obligation for an employee to disclose a health issue to an employer and it’s actually illegal for an employer to ask. So broaching the subject of any barriers or support needed to completing the tasks absolutely should not ask directly if she has any health issues or disabilities

The Equality Act 2010 makes employers responsible for making reasonable adjustment for someone’s health condition, but if she hasn’t disclosed anything the OP and the company can’t be expected to make any such provision until she does.

Tbf I didn’t say ask about health issues directly. It should be a generic question about support the employee needs to do the job or any barriers that are affecting them that the employer may be able to help with e.g flexibility over start times. It’s just giving the opportunity for anything to be disclosed if the employee wants. But if they choose not to, that’s their right but then the employer can’t help.

Londonrach1 · 08/12/2023 12:20

Does sound very micro managed. Can you do it more long term... Daily is ott. Her not pulling her weight is a different thing and needs to be dealt with via the proper channels...do you have a hr department

BeeDavis · 08/12/2023 12:19

I’m baffled as to how she got this job in the first place… if I was like this in my job I’d be straight up SACKED. She isn’t doing any work, how does she think she can get away with it 😩

LetMeGoogleThat · 08/12/2023 12:18

madaboutmad · 08/12/2023 12:15

God, I assume you don’t manage anyone

Sorry to disappoint, but I do and very well. If you can't find the point of reciprocity then you are just poor a manger, not a leader. If you understand people, then you know how to get the best out of them 🤷‍♀️

Codlingmoths · 08/12/2023 12:17

She does sweet fuck all every day at work and people are … suggesting sending her on a leadership course?? What fresh hell is this, to quote another poster out of context 😁 do all the people who feel colour coding is a micro aggression simply refuse to use the many widely used tools such as teams planner and other it project related ones I’ve used that flag overdue items RED? Or do they just cry bullying and open a grievance as just because the 1000 other employees at the firm use it doesn’t mean it’s not personally targeted at them?
Dont try and make any further plans here op, bring in hr, tell them she accomplishes nothing with terrible excuses and ask how to proceed.

madaboutmad · 08/12/2023 12:15

LetMeGoogleThat · 08/12/2023 12:13

You sound like someone I used to work with. They too could never understand why they were disliked either. Basic psychological needs in the workplace are autonomy, belonging and competence.... you are micromanaging her and none of her needs are being met. You do realise that you earn respect, you can't demand it.

God, I assume you don’t manage anyone

Thepeopleversuswork · 08/12/2023 12:15

This is very much a work culture clash issue I think. You're both kind of right. And you can tell from the responses to your posts that this is very divisive.

It does sound as if her productivity is very low and she behaves in an unprofessional way. The way you manage it would be micro management in a senior and productive employee. She clearly isn't very productive so on the face of it you're right do to this.

What's less clear to me is to what extent your micro-management has exacerbated it or whether she basically pretty lazy anyway.

I have to say your style of management would really wind me up as well. Not to the point of saying I was triggered or shouting at you. But I do think treating employees like children is generally very counterproductive. It might be appropriate for someone on a performance review. If you're doing it as a matter of course it's a disaster: babying people creates a culture of resentment and actually disincentives people from taking responsibility for themselves.

It does sound as she needs quite a lot of hand-holding, to put it mildly. What I don't really know is whether she's a basically poor employee who is kicking off because she doesn't want to work, or whether she's someone who finds working for you profoundly demotivating. I think you might want to get to the bottom of that and adjust your strategy. I honestly don't think this level of management is appropriate for everyone.

coffeeaddict77 · 08/12/2023 12:13

Rosscameasdoody · 08/12/2023 12:02

So how would you advise the OP to proceed, given that this employee doesn’t meet deadlines and can’t be left to get on with it ?

I think she should just get rid of her if she isn't doing anything.

SovietSpy · 08/12/2023 12:13

If you can’t get her to tell you what she spends her time doing at work then there is a huge problem. As a manager it’s not unreasonable to have sight of this and you need to be clear with her that there are serious consequences if she doesn’t engage with you.
Most employees don’t want to get sacked or be on improvement plans and would welcome help to get back on track. So the fact she is putting up so many barriers suggests she doesn’t care or is just biding her time getting paid to do nothing and see how long she can get away with it for.
If she’s refusing to engage or ‘going nuclear’ then it’s HR time. I am often too nice a manager but if someone shouted at me at work I would say I was going to end the call or ask them to leave the meeting until they have calmed down. And get every instance documented. The employee could easily be breaking your code of conduct if she behaves this way.

Rosscameasdoody · 08/12/2023 12:13

SovietSpy · 08/12/2023 12:02

Can you go back to her role profile or objectives to check that the tasks line up to these? Working to deadlines is requirement of most jobs so the fact she struggles with this is very concerning.
I think you need to flip things round to push ownership back to her to get away from the micromanaging.
set the objectives and share with her to ensure she is clear of expectations e.g. publish social media posts by required deadlines or as instructed by me/ head of.
Then when that doesn’t happen you can use as proof she is not meeting her role requirements.
Get her to outline all tasks she completes in an average week so you can see what she’s spending her time on. Make her provide weekly update via email on tasks to you and in team meetings (good idea to get her to talk through what she has been doing). Make sure you ask her to disclose any barriers or support she needs to complete tasks so she doesn’t throw you a grenade last minute where she discloses a health issue.
If she fails to do this, then performance management is the route.

This. But on the issue of a health condition as a reason for her failings, there is no legal obligation for an employee to disclose a health issue to an employer and it’s actually illegal for an employer to ask. So broaching the subject of any barriers or support needed to completing the tasks absolutely should not ask directly if she has any health issues or disabilities

The Equality Act 2010 makes employers responsible for making reasonable adjustment for someone’s health condition, but if she hasn’t disclosed anything the OP and the company can’t be expected to make any such provision until she does.

LetMeGoogleThat · 08/12/2023 12:13

You sound like someone I used to work with. They too could never understand why they were disliked either. Basic psychological needs in the workplace are autonomy, belonging and competence.... you are micromanaging her and none of her needs are being met. You do realise that you earn respect, you can't demand it.

FreeRider · 08/12/2023 12:13

I have a friend who sounds a lot like your employee, OP.

Every time his manager even vaguely suggests he needs to improve, he takes offence and goes off 'sick'...for months at a time! He never sees the same doctor twice, always locums...and has managed to convince them he's 'depressed' - and before anyone jumps on me, just yesterday he admitted to me that he's not depressed in the slightest, he just wanted time off work! He's changed jobs 5 times in the last decade, he always finds another job just before he's about to be dismissed.

SuperSange · 08/12/2023 12:12

Notsurewhatnext · 08/12/2023 12:12

I think this sounds like a toxic mix of a very difficult employee in combination with a manager with a terrible nag for micromanaging? sending colour coded spread sheets? Seriously.

Edited

At least RTFT. 🙄

Notsurewhatnext · 08/12/2023 12:12

I think this sounds like a toxic mix of a very difficult employee in combination with a manager with a terrible nag for micromanaging? sending colour coded spread sheets? Seriously.

madaboutmad · 08/12/2023 12:11

I just sack her. Honestly, less than 2 years, it’s not worth the aggro.

madaboutmad · 08/12/2023 12:10

calmama · 08/12/2023 12:05

“Get her to outline all tasks she completes in an average week so you can see what she’s spending her time on. Make her provide weekly update via email on tasks to you and in team meetings (good idea to get her to talk through what she has been doing). Make sure you ask her to disclose any barriers or support she needs to complete tasks so she doesn’t throw you a grenade last minute where she discloses a health issue.“

If I did this she would go nuclear.

She has no right to go nuclear. If she’s not able to deliver, you need to know how she’s spending her time.

You need to get ahead of this and push it up the command chain.

123becauseicouldntthinkofone · 08/12/2023 12:09

Based on your responses to other questions i would be involving HR and looking at a PIP. So if she thinks you are micromanaging now wait until that happens. When i was in this situation i used to make notes for every conversation and every agreement and get the employee to sign that they agreed with the notes and the task agreement. Good luck OP as you can see from a lot of the responses you are going to have your hands full.

LusaBatoosa · 08/12/2023 12:09

calmama · 08/12/2023 12:05

“Get her to outline all tasks she completes in an average week so you can see what she’s spending her time on. Make her provide weekly update via email on tasks to you and in team meetings (good idea to get her to talk through what she has been doing). Make sure you ask her to disclose any barriers or support she needs to complete tasks so she doesn’t throw you a grenade last minute where she discloses a health issue.“

If I did this she would go nuclear.

But, what’s been suggested is actually managing her. Which isn’t what you’re currently doing.

If I did this she would go nuclear.

Are you afraid of this person? Is that what the issue is?

calmama · 08/12/2023 12:09

@SuperSange Sorry. Definitely under two years.

For the other questions in the thread, I don’t know what she’s doing otherwise. Sometimes she does work from home. Others she claims to be busy doing things I haven’t assigned her to do but she sees as important. Other times she “lost track of time talking to Paula”. Other times “Jack asked me to help fix his phone”. “Can’t get through to xx on the phone.” “Emailed a million times and no response.” Yadayadayada.

OP posts:
ConstitutionHill · 08/12/2023 12:09

I don't understand all the flack you are getting about micro managing OP.

I have various tasks, some of which need to be completed on a daily/weekly basis or there would be serious consequences and if I am off then I arrange for someone else to cover.

If I didn't do them then I would not be doing my job and my line manager would be rightfully pissed off.

What does it look like when she "explodes".

Sounds like they are workshy, incompetent and defensive. Best have a word with HR.

Workawayxx · 08/12/2023 12:08

How long has she worked there and did she have a previous manager before you or did she join under you? It sounds like it's the wrong type of work for her - is she doing anything at all? The 3 examples you gave (social media post etc) sounds like they should have barely taken an hour in total let alone a day/week!

We had an assistant and we realised after a while (she was telling each of us that the others had given her loads of work) that she was basically doing nothing all day. I think she just needed more of a sociable, immediate tasks type job rather than a list of work she had to quietly churn through.

LusaBatoosa · 08/12/2023 12:08

calmama · 08/12/2023 11:52

@HereForTheFreeLunch Did exactly this (ask to be CCd) and it caused a blowup.

Asked her to CC me in something and she didn’t. Asked her why she didn’t CC me, she said not to worry because it was done. I asked again why she didn’t CC me as I’d asked, she said I didn’t need to be CCd. I said it was fine but to please forward me the email so I could escalate things with a supplier she claimed was dragging their feet. She refused, I insisted, she exploded and accused me of being a bully and a micromanager.

Turns out, she didn’t email the supplier. She forgot.

So, what did you do? Verbal warning? Written warning? Meeting with HR? Or…nothing. A clean slate and hoping for the best?

You’re doing this to yourself, at this point.

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 08/12/2023 12:07

The OP trying working with her without micromanaging - it didn't work & things weren't getting done.

She then tried micro management to see if it got better results - it didn't work.

In summary-

  1. She doesn't achieve the tasks she is supposed to do
  2. She lies about things she hasn't done
  3. She has verbally abusive interactions with her manager
  4. She objects to all proposed solutions but offers no suggestions of her own
  5. She continually deflects or blames others
  6. She takes sick leave after every blow up (she may genuinely require sick leave but if all interact leads to sick leave she isn't able for the role)
  7. She can't account for her time and confirm what she is doing
  8. A day's worth of work is taking a week

Go to HR and cover yourself as she is a highly volatile employee and will most like take a bullying claim against you.

Get everything documented and agreed with HR, PIP and exit if no improvement.

SuperSange · 08/12/2023 12:05

You've still not said how long she's worked there. It's kind of crucial.

calmama · 08/12/2023 12:05

@Nicole1111 great plan. Thank you!

OP posts: