Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Employee feels micromanaged if I give her tasks with deadlines

638 replies

calmama · 08/12/2023 09:11

I manage a person who is generally difficult. She objects to… well everything and undermines me at every chance she gets.

When she first started working for me we sat down together and established a work plan to get our job done and keep us on track to meet deadlines. We agreed I would assign daily tasks and we would meet weekly to discuss progress on projects along with anything new we had to take on, along with any business changes, leave, etc.

Weeks down the line she exploded at me for colour coding priorities, saying the urgent (red) tasks were ‘very unfriendly and freaking her out’. I took the red out.

A few weeks later she exploded at me for ‘micromanaging and bullying her’ by sending her daily priorities, despite this being agreed upon from the very start. I asked for an alternative way of progressing projects. She had none.

Today she exploded at me for setting deadlines because they ‘stress her out’. Again, I asked her for an alternative way of doing things and she had none.

I’m at a loss. She’s doing honestly the bare minimum and can’t seem to cope. I’m having to pick up her slack because otherwise my team looks bad, yet I’m still copping the brunt of her rage and there’s no end in sight.

AIBU to throw my hands in the air and take a long vacation?

OP posts:
laclochette · 08/12/2023 12:46

She sounds difficult and I find her behaviour as recounted unacceptable. Nobody should blow up at their manager like that.

That said, you are micromanaging her. As others have said you may need to let her fail by stepping back, but you need to do so in a way that is fair.

To take your example tasks around booking a venue. Have you had a training session where you go through the whole, big picture on certain tasks or projects. For example, "When we have an event, here are all the steps that need to be followed and the timings they need to be done in, along with any internal contacts or resources (like planning templates etc, examples from previous similar projects) that you might need and find useful. You are responsible for xyz tasks on this kind of project. When we are next organizing an event, we will have a kickoff meeting to align on it and then you can pick up your tasks from there."

In other words, delegate based on project not just daily tasks, which always feels like grunt work and which makes it hard for people to show initiative.

I do not honestly think she will change based on this but you can show you are doing things properly so not leave yourself open to any debate as to who is at fault.

TeenLifeMum · 08/12/2023 12:45

Daily tasks in comms? Hell no! (I’m a communications manager).

yes I might have to say to the team “can you pop this urgent message on social asap please” is fine but the quotes etc, nope. Weekly planning meeting where you look at work, event date and work back deadlines and allow team to work with that, managing their work load. Eg.we need quotes for x,y,z in time for planning meeting on 19 December. You have a plan with all the actions, deadlines and the “lead” which is anyone in the team. Make it clear, the lead is responsible for making the request and chain to ensure you have the info in time.

Use a live Action document in teams and all update as and when. For something important like an event you need them to add notes so anyone can pick it up if they were sick.

PGmicstand · 08/12/2023 12:45

Reading all your posts about this employee @calmama , to a degree she sounds like someone I occasionally work with. In my case, I'm not the manager, but I've been working at the place longer and have more experience and knowledge. My colleague is young and ND. Literally the only way to get the colleague to get anything done is to micromanage.
And when I say micromanage I mean literally explain each task broken down into separate sections, with very clear and unambiguous details of what needs to be done. If, for example, I were to say, "Can you take these papers to the office and then do xyz?" they would just stay where they were, fiddling with their cuffs.
I have to say, "Please will you take these papers to X in the office right now, and then come back?"
It's not their fault but I find it extremely tiring and occasionally frustrating working with them.

I don't have any suggestions or solutions but I think as many pps have said, working with HR on management of this individual, and how to deal with expectations on both sides seems to be the safest way forward.

Chickenkeev · 08/12/2023 12:44

Londonrach1 · 08/12/2023 12:20

Does sound very micro managed. Can you do it more long term... Daily is ott. Her not pulling her weight is a different thing and needs to be dealt with via the proper channels...do you have a hr department

Surely the first thing HR will ask is what actions you have taken to support her/improve her performance? That's the manager's job. HR are (or should be at least) a last resort. OP seems to have done everything she can within reason. It sounds like the employee has become another task for OP to sort, rather than a team member who's getting things done bitter experience

LetMeGoogleThat · 08/12/2023 12:44

Deliria · 08/12/2023 12:34

I'd assume @LetMeGoogleThat is responsible for getting the best out of a lot of people and therefore applies science and logic...

Thank you, and I even find time to read flim flam on MN af lunchtime 🤪

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 08/12/2023 12:43

WinterParakeets · 08/12/2023 12:38

That should take an hour.

An hour tops or depending how she’s contacting the venue and how you source caterers at said venue that could take slightly longer, maybe 2 hours at a push.

LetMeGoogleThat · 08/12/2023 12:42

@madmadaboutmad you are reading one version of the truth here and inexperienced Managers always blame the staff. If you treat people as if they are 5yrs old, they act accordingly. I would be fine, but thanks for your concern 🤣

Anisette · 08/12/2023 12:42

mantyzer · 08/12/2023 11:13

You are micro managing her. Being micro managed is incredibly stressful and people rarely [perform well under this kind of pressure.
She is right, you are bullying her.

So how come she gets no work done, and how come nothing improves when OP does what she asks and bins the awful torturing red colour etc?

Bireadwhatiread · 08/12/2023 12:42

I would be climbing the walls if I had that little work to do!

So, what does she actually do all day? Ask the whole team to give a breakdown of their workload.

Also OP why are you entertaining this? You can politely explain that outbursts are not acceptable.

Your job is to manage, take the emotion out and cover your own backside.

WinterParakeets · 08/12/2023 12:38

calmama · 08/12/2023 09:22

@Aprilx She isn’t privy to the information I am so I have no choice but to communicate tasks to her. She can’t get on with her job even with tasks so without them it would be hopeless.

Say I set her three tasks for the day: 1. Do an urgent social media post about x (no research or anything required, just a simple but timely post), 2. Contact a venue re potentially holding an event there next year, and 3. Look into caterers at said venue for a quote. Does this seem like something you could get done in a week?

That should take an hour.

EBearhug · 08/12/2023 12:36

In the first point she “decided we didn’t need to post this”. On the second, she “couldn’t find the number”, then later “I’ve emailed many times and they won’t reply” (I got a reply myself within an hour). On the third, “I don’t know where to start.”

But...
1 - Did she decide it without discussion? Did she tell you, with her reasoning, that she wasn't posting it after having been asked?
2 - if I couldn't find a number, I'd be asking to check the spelling when I looked it up, or if you had the number on file. I'd also raise it if I wasn't getting any response - is there a contact to escalate to, should we try other people?
3 - did she ask for any hints? The reason we ended up with much better documentation in my last department was because I documented the tasks we had to do, so others didn't spend so much time feeling lost when new to the job as I had.

Does she do anything proactively to improve her situation? Does she ever ask for help or anything? Or does she just sit there, not doing anything and not telling anyone either? Because at least you can do something with melted chocolate, so she's not even as much use as a chocolate teapot, by the sound of it.

Does she have any idea about how crap she is?

Deliria · 08/12/2023 12:34

madaboutmad · 08/12/2023 12:15

God, I assume you don’t manage anyone

I'd assume @LetMeGoogleThat is responsible for getting the best out of a lot of people and therefore applies science and logic...

MMMarmite · 08/12/2023 12:33

I think the way to respond to her anger is to decide confidently what you think is right and fair, then be a very calm broken record on repeat, however angry she gets. But ultimately this needs to be in the context of performance management. Currently you're essentially letting her get away with not doing her job, which will eventually start pissing off the other hardworking members of the team.

Couldyounot · 08/12/2023 12:33

So she does fuck all and then gets shirty when challenged on it? Your organisation has to let her go. Quite apart from the unacceptable behaviour she is not in the right role.

CrotchetyQuaver · 08/12/2023 12:32

You need to go to HR and talk to them. What exactly is she doing all day if she can't manage 3 straightforward tasks set by you?

ChocolateCinderToffee · 08/12/2023 12:32

Notsurewhatnext · 08/12/2023 12:12

I think this sounds like a toxic mix of a very difficult employee in combination with a manager with a terrible nag for micromanaging? sending colour coded spread sheets? Seriously.

Edited

Colour coded spreadsheets are used extensively in project management. They show what is important, what is on time, what has been delayed, where there's slippage and so on. Using them is not micromanagement, they're a fairly standard tool.

madaboutmad · 08/12/2023 12:32

LetMeGoogleThat · 08/12/2023 12:18

Sorry to disappoint, but I do and very well. If you can't find the point of reciprocity then you are just poor a manger, not a leader. If you understand people, then you know how to get the best out of them 🤷‍♀️

Have you read how this person behaves? I'd love to see how you get on. She sounds like a temperamental nightmare, but you go ahead and blame OP who appears to want her to do some work.

MMMarmite · 08/12/2023 12:31

OP you really need to be firmer. So many of your answers are "I tried that but she exploded... If I did that she'd go nuclear". You can't let your management and the company's productivity be held to ransom by her angry outbursts. Get HR involved, put in place the measures needed, and if she goes nuclear, let her do it in front of people. They'll soon get the measure of her.

Anisette · 08/12/2023 12:30

calmama · 08/12/2023 09:25

@Hankunamatata She’s never progressing though. We had a meeting today. She’d done nothing.

What was her explanation for that? What did she claim to have been doing with her time?

akkakk · 08/12/2023 12:29

mantyzer · 08/12/2023 11:17

@akkakk I have lots of experience of managing people. I have also been micro managed.
If I was the employee I would have gone to HR about bullying. I have used colour coded project management tools, but having a manager do this for daily tasks is incredible overkill.
I also wonder how much work OP actually has to do if she can spend time micro managing to this ridiculous degree.
Management is a skill. You can't blame staff if your management is incredibly poor.

I would suggest from the evidence we see in front of us that OP is an unusually sensitive and competent manager!

I assume that you were different to the OP's member of staff in that you actually did the work you were paid to do - in which case being micro-managed would of course be inappropriate - however...

The OP using tried and tested and accepted methodologies for task management is not micro-managing by doing that.

Having tasks with deadlines and chasing to find out if they have been done is not micro-managing.

Categorising and prioritising tasks is not micro-managing.

Having critical tasks in red is not triggering or micro-managing

Expecting a member of staff to do the work they are legally contracted to do is not micro-managing

Finding out what the member of staff is doing with their time (based on not delivering any of the simple tasks they have to do) is not micro-managing

All of that is good management - the simple fact here is that there is a lazy entitled member of staff who is bullying her manager by using aggression and 'woke words' to try to avoid having to work.

The OP has shown patience with some of the answers on here where people either don't read what she has put or where they believe that everyone is entitled to do no work and be paid for it... basic economics means that doesn't work - If I needed to I would hire OP like a shot she would appear to have all the criteria I would want in a manager - sensitivity (tries different options) / good work ethic / checks that she is not the issue / etc. - well done to her - the member of staff would be gone by lunch time!

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 08/12/2023 12:27

I’ve been micromanaged before by someone who’d been told how to do this by their manager and who didn’t know any better (I was a temp). They were also a young manager compared to me who was older and an experienced EA/PA. I thought long and hard before tackling her with the fact that she was micromanaging me on a daily basis and this was impacting on my ability to do the job I was employed to do. My fellow EAs/PAs felt sorry for me when I left, so they said as they didn’t have managers like her.

Deornding on the age of this woman it seems like she’s not capable of doing the job correctly and in inexperienced or is either not doing the work or doesn’t want to do the work. Someone emailing a contact 3 times (not getting a response) and then not looking into another way of contacting them (phone) would drive me up the wall! I also can’t see how red can be triggering on certain tasks, she could then say that about any colour replacing it!

She’ll probably be hard to get rid of or claim a protected health condition (I’d be totally sympathetic if she worked with you if this is the case). Too many employees now use “triggering” or other PC language to accuse others of things they either haven’t done in that way or to excuse their own shortcomings.

LaurieFairyCake · 08/12/2023 12:26

She's not producing any work and throws a tantrum when asked to account for her work

FIRE HER !

Panama2 · 08/12/2023 12:26

I along with most people could have completed those tasks in a morning. Is she new to the company it would be interesting to know why she left her previous role. It does come across that she has some issues or just very good at getting out of doing any work.

Eleganz · 08/12/2023 12:24

Really not sure whether this is a performance or micromanaging issue as you seem to have started managing her from the get go with a highly directive style and we don't know the exact details of the job and therefore whether her behaviour is a response to your style or vice versa and whether her role should expect to be more autonomous or not.

Was there a pre-existing performance issue with the employee before you took over managing her?

Is there an ongoing performance issue? I.e. is she missing deadlines, etc.?

You say that daily task setting by you is necessary as she does not have access to information you do. Is there anyway for her to access this information without you needing to relay it on a daily basis?

Is she in a position where it is reasonable for her to be expected to prioritise tasks herself?

I think that clarity on the above is needed before decent advice can be offered as it can range all the way from a performance improvement plan to complete adjusting your management style depending on the answers.

Diyextension · 08/12/2023 12:22

Basicthings · 08/12/2023 09:55

What is she doing in the office then? Can you see her screen? If she's sitting in work for 8hrs a day - you must be able to tell what she is looking at?

Shes on tik tok