Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I terrible?

117 replies

Shakeylegs · 07/12/2023 21:54

Just seen the thread about the person who accidentally didn’t pay for her big shop. Makes me wonder if my morals are in the bin because I’d not give it a second’s thought other than to chalk it up as a bit of good fortune.

the following three things have genuinely happened to me in the past few years, and I wonder if they make me immoral.

  1. Bought some stuff off Amazon a few weeks ago. About £90 worth actually. Paid as normal. Transaction stayed ‘Pending’ for a week then disappeared and the money was never taken. I haven’t mentioned it.

  2. Bought some petrol from an unstaffed supermarket petrol station. Put my card in as normal. Just as I was getting towards a tank-full, the pump just seized up and shut down. There was nobody around to ask, so I drove away. Was never charged any money for the fuel. Never mentioned it.

  3. Bought some towels from a department store. Went to pay, and as I was doing so, asked if they’d mind storing them for me so that I didn’t have to carry them round all afternoon. They said fine. I didn’t pay at that point. Then when I went to pick them up, I was all ready to pay but the staff member just handed them to me and walked off, mistakenly assuming I’d previously paid. Again, I said nothing.

What do you think? I guess number 3 is the clearest cut bit of awfulness, but even then they literally handed me the stuff!

Weirdly, given what I’ve just admitted, I’d never actually steal something off a shelf. I even balked at ripped CDs back in the day, and wouldn’t touch a fire stick to get free Sky or whatever it is you can do. But those three things I did do. Am I awful?

I think God knows anyway. The amount of times I get ‘quality checked’ at the self service checkout. 24 items they checked today. Obviously all paid for cos I don’t steal except for special circumstances!

OP posts:
Shakeylegs · 08/12/2023 07:21

IfYouDontAsk · 08/12/2023 07:01

I agree with this. OP there are lots of people who have and would do what you’ve done but (and I realise this sounds really Pollyanna-ish) the world is a less nice place for it. It’s wrong to knowingly take things you haven’t paid for.

i get this. And I suppose the point of the post wasn’t to ask ‘Are these things stealing and is it OK?’ because I think the answers are ‘Yes’ and ‘No’.

I think what I was trying to get at was whether there is any nuance to that. Is it really so bad (is the world really a less nice place) to do what I did when the circumstances are obviously very different to pre-planned thefts, shelf-to-pocket shoplifting, taking from small businesses etc?

I remember years ago I worked in a shop, in the days when you had to manually put the amount in for a card purchase. I sold a £240 camera for £24 by mistake. The bloke I sold it to never came back. I got a minor bollocking for it but it was understood that these things happen. I wonder if that has clouded my view somewhat as well.

Maybe there is no nuance. Just interesting to me as to whether people see it the same way as I do.

OP posts:
thedukeofbuckinghamshire · 08/12/2023 07:13

I was in a local cafe last week and ordered a bacon and egg roll to take away, sat down when they made it and my coffee and they brought it over to me and were like thanks, bye. I had to remind them I hadn't paid yet and she was laughing and said I could have got away with it. But I didn't try because I'm a decent person and they're trying to make a living...

IfYouDontAsk · 08/12/2023 07:01

LylaLee · 07/12/2023 21:55

Character is what you are when no one is watching.

I agree with this. OP there are lots of people who have and would do what you’ve done but (and I realise this sounds really Pollyanna-ish) the world is a less nice place for it. It’s wrong to knowingly take things you haven’t paid for.

Rosiiee · 08/12/2023 06:58

When we go grocery shopping I always stop in the baby aisle before anything else to give DS a pouch so he’ll stay settled in his pram. The number of times I forget to take the pouch from him to scan it at the end is awful 🙈 but sometimes I do remember!

CRG01 · 08/12/2023 06:55

Why would you ask for some towels to be stored behind a till so you can go off for the afternoon and go back for them when you fancy it, before actually evening paying. Of course the person presumed you would have paid for them, as surely you don't put non paid items behind a till.

Andthereyougo · 08/12/2023 05:55

I’m the opposite, I’d have to pay.
Fir the towels you could have used your voice , “ thanks, but I’ve not paid yet”
A few weeks ago in Aldi I used the self checkout and miscounted my bananas, paid for 9 instead of 10 so the following week I added one on to even it out. Just seemed the right thing to do 😃

HelpMeGetThrough · 08/12/2023 05:45

Number 3 you took the piss and know it. That was just blatant stealing.

1 and 2 I wouldn't lose sleep over.

hby9628 · 08/12/2023 01:38

I ordered some clothes from next. About £300 worth on my account. Kept half & sent half back but they credited the full amount in my account 🤷‍♀️

Whatwereyouthinking · 08/12/2023 01:36

From a “does it really matter to them” point of view I understand why people think differently about big business vs small business but it would still matter to me and I’d feel guilty.

I always check my bill at restaurants and have let them know on many occasions when I’ve been undercharged and once took a small item from a supermarket by mistake (was in bottom of trolley and not scanned and didn’t realise until later) and so asked for it to added when I went again (I’m aware I’m a bit crazy - the till woman def thought I was!)

Palindrone · 08/12/2023 01:23

LylaLee · 07/12/2023 23:53

I certainly don't consider myself a bad person

Few people do. Even actual murderers and nonces are reported to see themselves as good people.

Your self-perception is just that. It's your own opinion about yourself. It might not match up with ours.

Your first John Lewis example, you did the right thing. The second time you choose to do the wrong thing, because there was a chance you might not get free stuff again.

Evidently, my perception that I'm not a bad person doesn't match up with your perception of me based on this thread.

I've sacrificed my career and income to care for my disabled daughter and be the sole carer for my parents who both have advanced dementia yet the max I can claim is £76pw regardless of how many people I care for...so yes, I didn't pursue an oversight with John Lewis that was no fault of my own and I sleep soundly knowing I'm a good person regardless of judgment.

SnowyPetals · 08/12/2023 01:14

I am all about avoiding hassle with these things, as my main criterion for what I do. 1 and 2 would almost certainly involve an extra trip, phone calls, form filling or similar, and I wouldn't bother, but number 3 was easily fixable at the time and I would have paid.

LylaLee · 08/12/2023 01:13

Capitalism is a flawed system, but the solution is not stealing, and fucking over other people.

Thieves lack empathy. They lack the ability to think ahead a couple of steps.

The branch with too many thefts gets shut down. The shift manager with too many thefts gets sacked. The shop with too many thefts lays Sandra off.

The shop which sold a rocking horse through Amazon then didn't get paid is going to have to eat the costs. It's just some guy who took out a second mortgage to sell rocking horses using Amazon as a platform.

And. And.

LoreleiG · 08/12/2023 01:11

I would have owned up and paid in all those situations. I blame my catholic upbringing.

Amybelle88 · 08/12/2023 01:11

Couldn't give a shiny shite when it's big massive companies - do you think the big wigs are losing sleep because they're putting their prices up and people can't afford them?! Nope.

When it's a small business then I'd have to be honest, totally different kettle of fish.

Amazon, Asda and Debenhams? They'll be fine - hope you enjoyed your freebies and take no notice of people calling you a thief - hysterical 😂😂😂😂😂

Fionaville · 08/12/2023 01:06

LylaLee · 07/12/2023 23:24

Pretty sure you won't be so casual when YOU are the one being defrauded.

It's actually sickening to read all this.

Jeff Bezos, is that you? Or are you a major shareholder in BP?

FatFatMary · 08/12/2023 00:54

LylaLee · 08/12/2023 00:34

I'm not sickened by OP's instances of dishonesty. What sickens me is the widespread attitude of entitlement so many seem to have.

It makes the world worse for everyone and the world is bad enough as it is.

I see. May be it’s to do with resentment. We’ve had our right to exist freely, to have food and shelter without paying a disproportionate price taken from us unnaturally because of greed

ConstantRain · 08/12/2023 00:53

I would've sorted all those out. I'm a bit extreme and I can't even keep money I find! I saw £40 in a cashpoint once and I took it and handed it in. I found £5 in a park, no one was around so I took it and donated it to a charity.
But then I also complain when I have to and get given vouchers and gift cards.

MadamVastra · 08/12/2023 00:52

I get excited with my food shop arrival in case I get items I didn't order!

nothing has quite lived up to the dizzying heights of 3 litre bottles of gin I got but I live in hope every week

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 08/12/2023 00:45

Number 1 & 2 are pretty bad, but Number 3 is out and out theft, you knew you hadn't paid and you took the goods anyway. Given number 3 I expect the only thing keeping you from stealing again is the fear of getting caught.

It's not good enough to justify it because they're big business. Poorly paid staff work at these companies and might get in trouble because of your behaviour, and Amazon is full of small businesses. So your actions may well have impacted a small business and a retail worker. As an early PP said our morales are how we behave when no one is watching. Yours are lacking.

Sconehenge · 08/12/2023 00:44

@LylaLee totally agree. Also people showing an alarming lack of knowledge about how Amazon works, “Amazon” isn’t selling you the products, they are a platform and you are purchasing from a third party, which is often a small business.

LylaLee · 08/12/2023 00:34

FatFatMary · 08/12/2023 00:27

Why are you so emotionally affected by it though ? Sickening, come on

I'm not sickened by OP's instances of dishonesty. What sickens me is the widespread attitude of entitlement so many seem to have.

It makes the world worse for everyone and the world is bad enough as it is.

Nelliemellie · 08/12/2023 00:32

I found a gift card with about 150 pounds on it in M and S. I tried to hand it in at customer service, they were indifferent. I kept it unused for about 2 months in case someone claimed it or cancelled it. In the end I gave it to a hard up relative.

FatFatMary · 08/12/2023 00:27

LylaLee · 07/12/2023 23:24

Pretty sure you won't be so casual when YOU are the one being defrauded.

It's actually sickening to read all this.

Why are you so emotionally affected by it though ? Sickening, come on

theduchessofspork · 07/12/2023 23:56

I think there are bigger things to worry about

LylaLee · 07/12/2023 23:53

I certainly don't consider myself a bad person

Few people do. Even actual murderers and nonces are reported to see themselves as good people.

Your self-perception is just that. It's your own opinion about yourself. It might not match up with ours.

Your first John Lewis example, you did the right thing. The second time you choose to do the wrong thing, because there was a chance you might not get free stuff again.

Swipe left for the next trending thread