Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I terrible?

117 replies

Shakeylegs · 07/12/2023 21:54

Just seen the thread about the person who accidentally didn’t pay for her big shop. Makes me wonder if my morals are in the bin because I’d not give it a second’s thought other than to chalk it up as a bit of good fortune.

the following three things have genuinely happened to me in the past few years, and I wonder if they make me immoral.

  1. Bought some stuff off Amazon a few weeks ago. About £90 worth actually. Paid as normal. Transaction stayed ‘Pending’ for a week then disappeared and the money was never taken. I haven’t mentioned it.

  2. Bought some petrol from an unstaffed supermarket petrol station. Put my card in as normal. Just as I was getting towards a tank-full, the pump just seized up and shut down. There was nobody around to ask, so I drove away. Was never charged any money for the fuel. Never mentioned it.

  3. Bought some towels from a department store. Went to pay, and as I was doing so, asked if they’d mind storing them for me so that I didn’t have to carry them round all afternoon. They said fine. I didn’t pay at that point. Then when I went to pick them up, I was all ready to pay but the staff member just handed them to me and walked off, mistakenly assuming I’d previously paid. Again, I said nothing.

What do you think? I guess number 3 is the clearest cut bit of awfulness, but even then they literally handed me the stuff!

Weirdly, given what I’ve just admitted, I’d never actually steal something off a shelf. I even balked at ripped CDs back in the day, and wouldn’t touch a fire stick to get free Sky or whatever it is you can do. But those three things I did do. Am I awful?

I think God knows anyway. The amount of times I get ‘quality checked’ at the self service checkout. 24 items they checked today. Obviously all paid for cos I don’t steal except for special circumstances!

OP posts:
Shakeylegs · 08/12/2023 11:56

LylaLee · 08/12/2023 11:41

Everyone knows most self checkouts record you. And shops have CCTV. In fact sometimes they allow thieves to 'build up' a case against themselves by being caught multiple times on CCTV.

In other cases, like where something is unattended, you're not sure whether or not you'll get caught, so you don't risk it. But when you are fairly sure you will get away with it, you steal.

Those are your morals.

So you’ve determined that because of the three examples I gave, my morals are that I will steal when I’m fairly sure I can get away with it?

That’s quite a leap. I’ve never done it other than those three occasions, all of which were freakish occurrences. I am presented with easy theft opportunities every day of my life, but never take them.

OP posts:
Whataretheodds · 08/12/2023 11:44

The fact they were large companies rather than small doesn't make you any less dishonest

LylaLee · 08/12/2023 11:41

Shakeylegs · 08/12/2023 09:09

But that just isn’t true though. I could probably get away with loads if I wanted to. Self-checkouts are a thief’s playground. But I never do.

Everyone knows most self checkouts record you. And shops have CCTV. In fact sometimes they allow thieves to 'build up' a case against themselves by being caught multiple times on CCTV.

In other cases, like where something is unattended, you're not sure whether or not you'll get caught, so you don't risk it. But when you are fairly sure you will get away with it, you steal.

Those are your morals.

LylaLee · 08/12/2023 11:00

scrunch22 · 08/12/2023 10:19

I agree with the majority, number 3 is theft because there was the intent behind it- you knew you hadn't paid when you walked out. 1 and 2 not so much.

The errors were not OP's fault. Doing nothing to rectify them is where OP went wrong.

scrunch22 · 08/12/2023 10:19

I agree with the majority, number 3 is theft because there was the intent behind it- you knew you hadn't paid when you walked out. 1 and 2 not so much.

easylikeasundaymorn · 08/12/2023 10:16

1&2 understandable because at the time you had no way of knowing whether they would/wouldn't charge you. Plus amazon and asda are huge businesses and the fault was due to automated systems - there was no individual around that would have been blamed for the error.

3 is completely different - you knew you were stealing at the time and it's likely if it was picked up the individual handing you the items would get in trouble and potentially lose their job.

3luckystars · 08/12/2023 09:52

Well, if you were overcharged or charged twice for the fuel, you would definitely have found someone to help you there. Not criticising you at all, I’m just saying if it was me I’d worry I’d have to pay it back elsewhere and it would serve me right.

Are you not worried it will get taken off you in other ways?

At the moment I just hope nobody makes any mistakes with me because I don’t have the energy or time to chase it up and try try to put it right, which is often as much hassle as when I have been wronged.

Tiredmum100 · 08/12/2023 09:49

Tiredmum100 · 08/12/2023 09:45

I once got charged for one top in sainsburys, when I bought 2, amoungstbother things. I never went back when I discovered I'd only paid for one. I still feel guilty now. A few years ago, I was off sick from work with anxiety. I went to m&s food shop and bought a pile of things. When I got home, I realised I hadn't paid for one packet of Crisps. The anxiety I felt was horrendous. In my head, I was going to prison and going to struck off the NMC register. So I drove to another close store to pay the £1.50. The cashier looked at me like I was mad.

I should add, there is no sainsburys near where I live. I visiting another town.

Tiredmum100 · 08/12/2023 09:45

I once got charged for one top in sainsburys, when I bought 2, amoungstbother things. I never went back when I discovered I'd only paid for one. I still feel guilty now. A few years ago, I was off sick from work with anxiety. I went to m&s food shop and bought a pile of things. When I got home, I realised I hadn't paid for one packet of Crisps. The anxiety I felt was horrendous. In my head, I was going to prison and going to struck off the NMC register. So I drove to another close store to pay the £1.50. The cashier looked at me like I was mad.

readingismycardio · 08/12/2023 09:37

1 & 2 moderately fine, but 3 is plain stealing

yumyum33 · 08/12/2023 09:17

I must be too honest - is there such a thing? - as I'd have had to follow up the first two unpaid items and then spoken out to say I'd not paid for the towels yet.

1AngelicFruitCake · 08/12/2023 09:15

LylaLee · 07/12/2023 21:55

Character is what you are when no one is watching.

Completely agree. The third one will mean you’ve caused another person stress and upset when the the mistake is found out. I don’t know how you can do that. Hopefully they’ve got you on cttv for next time you go in.

I imagine you’re the first person to complain if this happened to you!

Mazuslongtoenail · 08/12/2023 09:13

I think you’re normal.

Outrage at accidental undercharging / finding money and forward facing car seats seem to the be the two areas where mumsnet is a very alien world to what I see in real life.

Shakeylegs · 08/12/2023 09:10

lkwhjis · 08/12/2023 08:26

OP actually thinks she’s a comedian for thieving. She’s not looking for re assurances she’s basically bragging that she’s get away with stealing.

Seems a bit weird and unhinged to come online and get your kicks while bragging that you’re stealing.

Some would argue that it’s weird and unhinged to incorrectly assign motive to the behaviours of others.

OP posts:
Shakeylegs · 08/12/2023 09:09

LylaLee · 08/12/2023 08:26

But that’s the thing. My ‘character’ hasn’t become my permanent way of being. I don’t regularly go around committing crimes.

That's literally what character is. Your permanent way of being. Your outlook on the world. And of course you're not going to be blatant. You know everywhere has CCTV. You don't want to lose your job, get arrested etc. But you will do as much as you think you can get away with without consequences. Just as in the examples you have given.

But that just isn’t true though. I could probably get away with loads if I wanted to. Self-checkouts are a thief’s playground. But I never do.

OP posts:
Shakeylegs · 08/12/2023 09:07

SiousieSoo · 08/12/2023 08:18

Why are you posting for opinions and then mocking those that give them? You literally walked away without paying for those towels = common thief in my opinion. Happy to help.

Wasn’t mocking anyone. Sorry if it came across that way.

OP posts:
lkwhjis · 08/12/2023 08:26

OP actually thinks she’s a comedian for thieving. She’s not looking for re assurances she’s basically bragging that she’s get away with stealing.

Seems a bit weird and unhinged to come online and get your kicks while bragging that you’re stealing.

LylaLee · 08/12/2023 08:26

But that’s the thing. My ‘character’ hasn’t become my permanent way of being. I don’t regularly go around committing crimes.

That's literally what character is. Your permanent way of being. Your outlook on the world. And of course you're not going to be blatant. You know everywhere has CCTV. You don't want to lose your job, get arrested etc. But you will do as much as you think you can get away with without consequences. Just as in the examples you have given.

lkwhjis · 08/12/2023 08:25

The amount of times you seem to have ‘good fortune’ seems to suggests it’s not good fortune. Strange how people dress things up to make themselves feel better.

Dressing up theft as good fortune doesn’t make you virtuous.

While everyone else pays for the theft.

SiousieSoo · 08/12/2023 08:18

Shakeylegs · 07/12/2023 22:24

It was Amazon, Asda, Debenhams.

I mean, Debenhams went bust soon afterwards but I don’t think it was due to widespread towel thievery.

Why are you posting for opinions and then mocking those that give them? You literally walked away without paying for those towels = common thief in my opinion. Happy to help.

Ducksinthebath · 08/12/2023 08:15

Rosiiee · 08/12/2023 06:58

When we go grocery shopping I always stop in the baby aisle before anything else to give DS a pouch so he’ll stay settled in his pram. The number of times I forget to take the pouch from him to scan it at the end is awful 🙈 but sometimes I do remember!

Why not bring your own and feed him before you go in? Because then it wouldn’t be free.

kookykalki · 08/12/2023 08:05

I am similar to you OP but am prevented being too "immoral" by having been raised with Islamic morals.

I really easily find myself accidentally not paying for plastic bags etc and then remember God is watching so I better do it. I found myself thinking about this stuff a lot lately as I had a little baby several months ago and often think"I won't be able to do X soon as she will learn/copy me" and am finding I do quite a lot of little not OK things eg. drinking straight out the carton.

The other day I bought a playpen online. It was too small when it arrived so I went online to buy another so we could double it up with more panels and I saw that it was now discounted by 30%. I bought two with the intention of returning the original one. Except the original one was already set up and I had no intention of putting it back together. I filled out the paperwork and returned the unopened newly delivered one as the original because I couldn't be bothered to package up the original one.

Also while DH was putting together the extra panels, he was missing some fixtures so I said to take it out the box we would return. He didn't listen to me and instead found them sold separately online..

Basically I find I would be even worse if I didn't have religion in my life. I know the thinking that a long long time ago religion came about because society didn't have these basic morals but now as a society we do and so you could argue we don't really need religion anymore. Except there is nothing to enforce these culturally/socially determined morals. For me, it's religion that forces me to try and be a bit better.

Edit to add that I THINK I would have sorted out all your three points, OP, but only after a little convincing in my head that God is watching and the right thing to do would be to pay etc

Shakeylegs · 08/12/2023 07:57

LylaLee · 08/12/2023 07:50

It wasn't your money lost, though, was it?

Obviously very different

Yes, there's a difference between a pre-meditated crime and a spur-of-the-moment crime, and a crime of omission.

However you've still committed a crime.

There's no one 100% good, or 100% bad. Violent cartel people are sweethearts to their dear old mums. People who have dedicated their lives to orphans can have grumpy days and be snappy with a child.

By stealing, you take a step to the 'bad' side. And with character, before you know it, your occasional actions become your permanent way of being.

The culmination (which most don't get) is having your moral choices publicly on display. Ending up in The Daily Mail after walking out of a restaurant without paying, for example. Or facing public, criminal prosecution when a fed up shopkeeper decides to make an example of you.

But that’s the thing. My ‘character’ hasn’t become my permanent way of being. I don’t regularly go around committing crimes.

OP posts:
LylaLee · 08/12/2023 07:50

Shakeylegs · 08/12/2023 07:21

i get this. And I suppose the point of the post wasn’t to ask ‘Are these things stealing and is it OK?’ because I think the answers are ‘Yes’ and ‘No’.

I think what I was trying to get at was whether there is any nuance to that. Is it really so bad (is the world really a less nice place) to do what I did when the circumstances are obviously very different to pre-planned thefts, shelf-to-pocket shoplifting, taking from small businesses etc?

I remember years ago I worked in a shop, in the days when you had to manually put the amount in for a card purchase. I sold a £240 camera for £24 by mistake. The bloke I sold it to never came back. I got a minor bollocking for it but it was understood that these things happen. I wonder if that has clouded my view somewhat as well.

Maybe there is no nuance. Just interesting to me as to whether people see it the same way as I do.

It wasn't your money lost, though, was it?

Obviously very different

Yes, there's a difference between a pre-meditated crime and a spur-of-the-moment crime, and a crime of omission.

However you've still committed a crime.

There's no one 100% good, or 100% bad. Violent cartel people are sweethearts to their dear old mums. People who have dedicated their lives to orphans can have grumpy days and be snappy with a child.

By stealing, you take a step to the 'bad' side. And with character, before you know it, your occasional actions become your permanent way of being.

The culmination (which most don't get) is having your moral choices publicly on display. Ending up in The Daily Mail after walking out of a restaurant without paying, for example. Or facing public, criminal prosecution when a fed up shopkeeper decides to make an example of you.

ANightingale · 08/12/2023 07:31

For me:

Amazon - the difficulty of actually getting through to speak to someone about the issue would put me off raising it, plus potential hassle if money then gets taken twice. They have the mandate to take the money which is valid for a year, so I would rely on it being picked up sooner or later and corrected.

Petrol: I'd try to contact them, maybe go into the actual supermarket and explain what happened. I'd want something on record in case the police came calling.

Towels: I would mention I hadn't paid.

I don't feel comfortable 'getting away with things' - I've always pointed it out if I have been given too much change in a shop; once got sent two cheques from a solicitor and sent one back (got a nice letter of thanks); got sent two items from an eBay seller, emailed them and they said to keep the extra one so my conscience was clear.

Swipe left for the next trending thread