Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's no wonder people use cars so much?

158 replies

Parapapampam · 07/12/2023 18:53

I work in a large city, always try and commute by train, this week, no strikes past 4 days on this line, my train home has been cancelled every single day, tomorrow there are strikes.

Different excuse every time, driver's seat broken, bad weather, staff shortage, or no reason given at all, the train just disappears off the board as if it never existed.

Tonight, my train, and the three after all cancelled, I imagine the later ones will be too (flooded tracks aren't suddenly going to clear whilst still pissing it down with rain).

So, I'm going to have to fork out £35 on an Uber.

This is not abnormal, happens at least twice a week, and the government wonder why people drive rather than use public transport.

So

YABU - keep using the shit trains, it's better for the environment and you can do work, read a book whilst on the train and don't have to worry about parking

YANBU - Start driving to work clogging up the roads (electric car) but get home before 8pm every night and save the £35 uber fee which is clogging up the roads anyway

OP posts:
FreshWinterMorning · 07/12/2023 21:31

100% with you here. My two adult daughters in their mid to late 20s - and their 30 or so friends they've got between them, have been let down by the trains, and STRANDED, late at night, between 10 and 15 times each in the past 3-4 years. Every. Single. One... They've been stranded in Brighton, London, Edinburgh, Birmingham, Norwich, Cambridge, Manchester, Leeds, Bournemouth, and many more places. A few times they have had a replacement bus service, but 80% of the time they haven't.

On countless occasions they have had to get a family member or friend to do (sometimes) a 150-500 mile round trip to go and get them by car. Not gonna get a flipping taxi - it would cost between £125 and £450+! Trains are shit. There's hardly ever a seat. They're always late. And that's when they bother to turn up. For this reason they never go anywhere by train now.

There's always some reason for them to not be running - and they are on bloody strike half the time! I usually drive in my everyday life, but I have always loved travelling by train to places away from my town. Up to about 4 years ago that is... Me and my husband were supposed to go Birmingham to the Christmas markets, and a show in December 2019, and were ready for the trip, stood on the platform waiting for our train, and had actually booked a hotel to stop overnight.

Inexplicably, the trains suddenly stopped to Birmingham, and they couldn't tell us when another one was coming. So we couldn't get there. Bus was not an option. Only 2 a day go from where we live, and you have to book in advance. Our trip was ruined. We lost what we paid for the hotel, and lost out on seeing the show/lost the ticket money.

It wasn't the first time we had been let down by the trains. They had let us down quite a few times in the previous year for short trips/shopping trips we had planned. But this took the biscuit! We gave up on them after they let us down with our Birmingham theatre/Christmas markets trip, and have never gone by train since ... We drive everywhere now. So do my DDs and most people I know. Trains are fucking shit in the UK now. Imagine having to depend on them for work? Fuck that. How do people cope?

In addition to bus services being cut left, right, and centre, I can't fathom why anyone would not do their best to learn to drive. Must close so many doors for people. If I couldn't drive, I'd be scared to get a job I couldn't walk or cycle to.

TizerorFizz · 07/12/2023 21:15

Yes. Just ordered a new one!!!

saythebellsofstclements · 07/12/2023 21:10

. . . and if you try and walk the roads just aren't designed for it unless you are walking within a town. I tried to walk 1.5 miles from a b&b to a place I had a meeting recently and ended up having to walk down the edge of a dual carriageway then along a narrow country road with cars hurtling round bends at 50mph.

This happens to me a lot and the stupid advice of 'walk if its less than n 2 miles' only works if you live in an area with pavements and crossings

Imagine hoards of people suddenly walking down country lanes and dual carriageways.

Cars are here to stay.

AllAroundMyCat · 07/12/2023 21:08

Was in Spain earlier in the year.

Never waited more than a few minutes for a bus.

Trains on time.

Where I live... buses have been cancelled at school times and at peak travelling times into town so that folk that need to get into work now can't.
It's utter madness.
The road traffic in the mornings are standstill.

Trains are hit and Miss in the mornings.

Curlewwoohoo · 07/12/2023 21:08

I've had to go on train twice this month, to different places. Both cancelled. Train to London on Tuesday was +£200 as well. It's an absolute bloody mess and needs to be a government priority to sort! But then same as most things...

Allfur · 07/12/2023 21:05

Atomicblonde, so your car was free then and costs nothing to run?

Primproperpenny · 07/12/2023 21:04

Agree Op, same with buses. Last time I tried to catch one, it was 45 minutes late! It would have taken me 30 mins to drive to my destination but the bus is about twenty because of bus lanes. And no parking to pay then (more than fare). In the end, 45 minute wait plus got stuck in roadworks where the bus lane was closed. Arrived in town about an hour after I would have done, had I just driven. Have used the car since 🤯

bellac11 · 07/12/2023 21:02

As someone who used to be fairly anti car, I am very pro car. Nice and warm, reliable, goes where I want it, can carry things around for me, can drive me off route quickly to find a loo safely.

I have changed my view completely and actually feel that new towns/cities should be built around car use, not trying to deny the inevitable. We need parking, underground parking, proper wide enough roads on new build estates, garages that actually fit cars in them.

wineandmaltesershappyme · 07/12/2023 21:02

Public transport is awful lately, I've been stood at a bus stop for over an hour in the cold and rain because 2 buses never turned up, the one that did the driver was over his shift time but took us all home anyway bless him. Super star.

Greydog · 07/12/2023 21:00

I took my car in for a service this week - 20 min journey - to get home after dropping it off, 2 trains, and a 30 min walk from the station. I got a taxi. DH works in Chester - a reasonable size town, but to get home on the Wirral, the last bus leaves at 5.30. Not much use when your shift ends at 10pm. Not much use for the average shop worker either

KnittedCardi · 07/12/2023 20:47

Controversial opinion on MN, but our railways have been destroyed by the unions. Train drivers are paid on average, twice as much as any other European country. They along with railway workers have resisted any and all modern flexible work practices, engineering alternatives and digital upgrades.

maddening · 07/12/2023 20:38

YouJustDoYou · 07/12/2023 19:08

Having come from a country with literally one of the veyr best, most efficient transport systems in the world, it's mortifying to have to explain to people I know back home what a shit show the UK is.

Which country?

Why is it mortifying?

Tbh while I think public transport is poor here I wouldn't judge a whole country negatively or even positively on the transport alone

Dixiechickonhols · 07/12/2023 20:29

Done lots of uni visits with dd this year, every journey on an avanti north west has been disrupted.
My favourite was announcing in London and on train it was replacement bus from Crewe. Big crowd gets off at Crewe and say which way to the bus…no bus as no one had told Crewe staff. I showed pic of board in London to Crewe station manager as proof, he said they were now denying it. Near riot, after several hours they paid for taxis to Preston. Glasgow last week train was delayed over an hour then a further wait while driver had his break. DH gets refunded on most trips to London.

Dunmuin · 07/12/2023 20:27

All the government initiatives (local and national) to cut down on car journeys seem to be based around making car journeys more difficult and/or expensive. There seems to be no effort to make public transport better, only efforts to make car journeys worse. It's all stick and no carrot.

Ashara · 07/12/2023 20:25

We live 50 miles from London, and 5 miles from the nearest station which is a direct commuter line into Waterloo. If I plan enough in advance to get the cheaper parking, 4 of us can drive into central London, park on the South Bank and pay the congestion charge for cheaper than just over an hours journey on the train. It’s madness. My kids wouldn’t even know how to get a bus here, they barely exist.

ElfontheShelfIsWATCHINGYOUTOO · 07/12/2023 20:21

I was a late driver, about 32 and all those years I was continuing to be let down by trains and busses etc. And I would say put at risk left stranded at stations and bus stops late at night.

And with a small child tying to navigate stairs, broken lifts and loos.

I adore my car....

Sumerian · 07/12/2023 20:19

I live a 30 minute walk into town, fine when its sunny but miserable in cold, wet weather.

So i had the idea of buying a bike, thinking it would stop me using the car to go into town.

There are no cycle paths (actually thats a lie, there is one tiny 20m stretch of road that has a cycle path, it randomly starts then ends). I tried to cycle into town twice and both times felt so unsafe that I've given up. I can either cycle along a busy road where the edges by the pavement are riddled with potholes. Endless potholes hidden in puddles. Like a fun death trap game. Or i can cycle more towards the centre of the road and massively irritate all the drivers. Or i can be someone who cycles on the pavement.

So earlier this week when i needed to go to the bank, i got into my car.

Thankfully i don't need to catch trains, but the last time i looked it was cheaper to pay for flights to canary islands than it was to get the train tickets to the airport.

Paddington98 · 07/12/2023 20:18

YANBU. Public transport is getting worse and worse, even the smart new Elizabeth line is down or delayed almost every day. In my hometown, the buses used to run from the town to the suburbs until 10.30pm. The last bus is now at 5.30pm.

mamahg · 07/12/2023 20:16

YANBU! I bursted out crying not too long ago due to the awful train services. I live in Greater Manchester and travel into the city Center for work and with the train it should take around 10 minutes but it has taken me over an hour to get there and an hour or more to get back home due to delays and cancellations. There are times I couldn't fit on the train because they used a smaller train (during rush hour!) and that meant I had to RUN to the station on the other side of town to get a train home and of course it was delayed.

I was always late picking DS up from nursery and have had to ask mum very last minute to start picking him up and it's sometimes not convenient for her. But I kept getting told off by the nursery... I have also had a day where I was waiting over an hour for 2 cancelled trains until I said fuck it, and paid £25 for an Uber to get me home in 40 minutes. I was cold, soaking wet and already experiencing the start of hyperemesis so it was a nightmare!

During train strikes there are no rail replacement services and it would take me 2 buses (so about 2 hours each way). 4 hour commute per day! Or I'd have to park the car at a park and ride and get the tram which is also totalling about 1 hour or more each way due to rush hour to get to the park and ride and how slow the trams are. Not to mention how disgustingly close together people are due to all wanting to squash in 🤢🤮.

Only my manager and supervisor is allowed a free parking spot at the hotel i work at which is quite frustrating as most people get public transport to the hotel as it's in the city Center, and the time I finish that's when the vast majority of people check-in, so technically they could allow more staff to park.

It's so stressful and an absolute waste of £110 per month for shit quality /non existent services.

I'm currently off due to severe hyperemesis and I am dreading going back due to the commute! 😢😢😢😢😢😢
Unfortunately where I live there aren't a lot of jobs and we can't afford to move closer to the city either, and I have mum living across the road to help with childcare.

Dixiechickonhols · 07/12/2023 20:14

I used to get train to work (2 trains each way), regularly it was cancelled or terminated half way. They changed timetable making it totally impractical to get to nearby city as it’s now a 35 min wait for second train not 5 mins. Just checking new timetable hoping it has changed back but still 35 mins wait.
So I drive the 16 miles instead and sit in bumper to bumper traffic.

LadyChilli · 07/12/2023 20:10

casuarinatree · 07/12/2023 19:42

We've had a new LTN brought in locally which has caused chaos on the main roads - the roads that all the buses use. I've actually started driving more since the LTN was brought in - go figure.

I dread this happening here because I live on a main road and it's bad enough with traffic already. Rat runs exist for a reason, and I say that as someone who is very anti car and walks anything under about 3 miles. If it was attractive enough, people would give up their cars.

YANBU OP. Public transport in my city is awful too. I live 2 minutes walk from a train station and bus stop but if I commute to my nearest office it's a 40 min drive one way or a 2 hour train journey. To visit my parents it's a 35 minute drive or again over 2 hours by train door to door. Either train fare for one adult would be more than the fuel cost. My boyfriend lives on the other side of the city but on the same bus route and the quickest door to door journey is over an hour IF the bus shows up, or 20 mins in a taxi. If both of us are in the taxi it's less than a tenner more than the bus, a fraction of the time and guaranteed to get you there.

ANightingale · 07/12/2023 20:09

tescocreditcard · 07/12/2023 19:03

YANBU I really don't understand why public transport is so poor in the UK (outside London that is)

'Outside London' is key. Where do all the decision-makers work? London.

Diamonde · 07/12/2023 20:07

balmysummerevening · 07/12/2023 19:18

Just drive! If the government genuinely wanted more people to use public transport, they'd make it work properly and ensure the companies running it had appropriate money and resources so if one train was out of action they could put another on the line instead. The fact the government doesn't give a shit about public transport shouldn't be your problem

Absolutely this. Zero guilt about using my car at all. I'd be happy to use public transport if it was reliable, but it isn't. So I drive.

Re trains this makes sense but more cars on the road makes it shit for buses 😬

ChilledToTheBone · 07/12/2023 20:06

I used to drive £5 all day parking. 10 min drive ( via school drop-off)
Or £4.50 return bus.. If it turned up. Which took 30 min and often made me late.
.only time I get a bus now is if dc ask. Thankfully only about 3x a year

ANightingale · 07/12/2023 20:03

driver's seat broken

😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread