Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's no wonder people use cars so much?

158 replies

Parapapampam · 07/12/2023 18:53

I work in a large city, always try and commute by train, this week, no strikes past 4 days on this line, my train home has been cancelled every single day, tomorrow there are strikes.

Different excuse every time, driver's seat broken, bad weather, staff shortage, or no reason given at all, the train just disappears off the board as if it never existed.

Tonight, my train, and the three after all cancelled, I imagine the later ones will be too (flooded tracks aren't suddenly going to clear whilst still pissing it down with rain).

So, I'm going to have to fork out £35 on an Uber.

This is not abnormal, happens at least twice a week, and the government wonder why people drive rather than use public transport.

So

YABU - keep using the shit trains, it's better for the environment and you can do work, read a book whilst on the train and don't have to worry about parking

YANBU - Start driving to work clogging up the roads (electric car) but get home before 8pm every night and save the £35 uber fee which is clogging up the roads anyway

OP posts:
Spacecowboys · 08/12/2023 07:40

Yanbu. If I was to rely on public transport I’d have to take three buses or two buses and a train to get to work. Travel time around 1.5 hours - it’s 30-40 minutes by car. Travelling home from some of my shifts, there would be no public transport available at all. Buses don’t run beyond 930pm.

Badbadbunny · 08/12/2023 07:33

Peckahminn11 · 08/12/2023 01:16

Why isn't there electric trams everywhere? Would make life so much easier and environmentally friendlier!

There used to be in many towns and cities, along with there being a World leading train network. Successive governments over many decades scrapped most of it (but they kept the excellent public transport system in London of course!) Now governments blame drivers for driving!

Nepmarthiturn · 08/12/2023 07:30

The trains are also immensely uncomfortable compared to those in most countries. They should not be allowed to sell more tickets than they have seats and you should be able to pre-book seats with your tickets. Newer trains seem to have got worse in this regard rather than better even on routes of several hours: new stock that has fewer seats, crammed together, with the expectation that "capacity increase" means people should pay 3-4 times the amount per mile as they do on the continent and be expected to stand for the entire journey as though it was a ten minute tube ride.

Add to this lack of clean toilets, no catering onboard, freezing cold trains etc, no accessibility or accommodations for those with disabilities. Even if they were reliable they still would not be worth considering over a car.

Badbadbunny · 08/12/2023 07:29

Nepmarthiturn · 08/12/2023 00:56

Didn't see what happened on the Elizabeth Line today then?

There are always cancelled and delayed trains for commuters in and out of London in all directions and endless strikes. And a higher price is generally charged for the same number of miles. It's just as bad.

I agree OP, it is a shambles. I always drive everywhere, even into central London.

Are there many routes in London where it's only a 2 hourly service (not 2 per hour, one every two hours) and the LAST train of the day is 7-15pm??? That's my son's route home from the Northern city where he works. And no buses or alternative train routes either. If it is cancelled (happens far too often) he's stranded there!

falanka · 08/12/2023 07:28

The trains are ridiculously bad. They were deliberately broken by the government to boost the car industry (not a conspiracy theory, actual history) and have been systematically constrained ever since. The whole idea that somehow it's individual choice for us all to buy cars and we can solve it by making individual choices to stop is absolutely crackers and ahistorical.

If the government really wanted us to use trains, it would be possible to get from Leeds to Manchester reliably. It would be possible to get ACROSS Manchester reliably. It isn't. Because the government (successive, all parties) choose that it isn't. How much did they spend on HS2? More than a modern Leeds Manchester line could ever have cost, and it doesn't even go anywhere.

The government is destroying the planet and blaming us the whole time. It's a joke. Like individuals can build an electrified train track by making "better consumer choices". How can you buy something that doesn't exist.

Nottodaty · 08/12/2023 07:25

I live inside the M25 - my work is 25
miles away - for me to use public transport it would take me over 2 hours and 3 trains. Instead I just sit on the M25 - annoying but I have no option.

Badbadbunny · 08/12/2023 07:22

KnittedCardi · 07/12/2023 20:47

Controversial opinion on MN, but our railways have been destroyed by the unions. Train drivers are paid on average, twice as much as any other European country. They along with railway workers have resisted any and all modern flexible work practices, engineering alternatives and digital upgrades.

Yup, they're certainly a stroppy bunch.

Badbadbunny · 08/12/2023 07:21

Dunmuin · 07/12/2023 20:27

All the government initiatives (local and national) to cut down on car journeys seem to be based around making car journeys more difficult and/or expensive. There seems to be no effort to make public transport better, only efforts to make car journeys worse. It's all stick and no carrot.

Nail on the head there!

Beautiful3 · 08/12/2023 07:18

Yes I agree. I used to commute to work, via two trains. But it was embarrassing when I was late twice a week, because of train delays. I think they thought I left late. When I bought a car I was only late once in 2 years. My petrol cost less than my train season ticket.

Madameprof · 08/12/2023 07:18

My daughter has a highly expensive bus pass to get to college and work in the next town 6 miles away. Half the time at least one or more buses don't turn up and she is constantly late as a result. There is no delay repay on the bus and when I complain I just get a standard blah response. In the past week or so I've ended up driving her out of desperation. I would happily use public transport more if it was more efficient but I can't as it's not fit for purpose.

Princessfluffy · 08/12/2023 07:06

I take the bus across town. Takes 20 mins to drive and an hour or more by bus so 40 mins total travel time there and back by car and 2 hours plus by bus. We have screens to say how long the wait is for the next bus which I like, but the buses are always late and often cancelled. I think they don't have enough drivers because they don't pay well enough.

SunnySomer · 08/12/2023 06:47

Regarding lack of trams: there used to be trams in every city and you can still see the evidence in the really wide roads that lead into the city centres. But we ripped them up in the 60s because they were old fashioned. Replacing them is massively expensive and political decisions have meant that return on investment isn’t always great. Eg Sheffield Supertram was first rolled out to areas of higher deprivation (understandably) EXCEPT that they ended up not receiving as much income in fares as they needed to roll out the investment to the wealthier areas where a higher proportion of customers would have needed to pay full fare. So the roll out to the south and west never happened.
But I agree, having trans everywhere would be really good.

athingofbeauty · 08/12/2023 02:40

Dunmuin · 07/12/2023 20:27

All the government initiatives (local and national) to cut down on car journeys seem to be based around making car journeys more difficult and/or expensive. There seems to be no effort to make public transport better, only efforts to make car journeys worse. It's all stick and no carrot.

This pretty much sums up the situation, and despite what many of you understandably feel, it's even the case here in London.

Transport for London runs the only public transport system in the world that depends mainly on passenger ticket sales rather than tax subsidies. So of course they lost billions (at least £6b on their past three years' balance sheets) during the pandemic. Even with Westminster's exceptional, and loudly grudging, £4b of support, TfL has been cutting bus routes and bus frequencies.

At the same time, driving gets harder by the day. As a condition for Westminster's £4b, London's mayor was required by our central government to increase the Congestion Charge and ULEZ. Westminster also gave all the London councils subsidies to put in LTNs, without public consultation.

Even in London: make it harder to drive, make it harder to use public transport. Apparently, we're all supposed to ride bikes. Or use our wings.

MotherofWhippets81 · 08/12/2023 01:35

YANBU Same here this week.

I only go to the office twice a week and those days are exhausting and stressful due to the commute.

Tuesday luckily a colleague was watching the live updates and came to tell me they had started cancelling trains. We headed out early - which was a good job as they then cancelled the four trains after the one we planned to get. Whilst on the platform we were told anyone for my stop or beyond needed to go and get the replacement bus service. Kind colleague told me to go to her stop and she would give me a lift. The train then announced it was stopping at my stop anyway! All those poor people they're probably still on a bloody bus somewhere!

They then send four carriages. People were being pulled and pushed on so the doors would close. I've had spinal surgery quite recently and I have an autoimmune condition and it was frightening and dangerous.

Wednesday - delayed in the morning and then I had half a day AL. Got on the train and it announced there was a delay and we were stuck basically - after 40 minutes it announced that we were off but it wasn't stopping at the 5 stops before mine so lots of people had to get off to find a train that was. Complete waste of my half a day.

I can't drive in with my car (congestion charges) but I'm thinking of swapping with my husband (electric) but then parking is a problem as I can't get in early enough due to restrictions around school drop offs etc.

It's awful 🤷🏻‍♀️ I've used public transport in many countries and I've never seen issues like this.

Oh and a couple of weeks ago about 10 police officers were waiting for us at the station in the morning to check for ticket dodgers - one man was being wrestled to the ground. I'm sure he was being a dick but I have started to sympathise with people who take their chances not paying to be honest how expensive it is and how crap a service we get.

Thanks for the rant.

Fionaville · 08/12/2023 01:21

I drive. My town has no train station. I was driving into the next town and getting the train into the city once a week for a month, so 4 times. One time the trains were cancelled for a technical issue. So 25% of my train rides were unsuccessful. I won't be giving my car up anytime soon!

lavenderlou · 08/12/2023 01:19

I don't use the trains much because of where I live but the bus network is terrible, even without strikes. I work a ten minute drive away but it would take me over an hour to get there by bus.

DD used to use the bus for school. The morning bus was co sta tly late or cancelled so we had to start driving her.

Peckahminn11 · 08/12/2023 01:16

Why isn't there electric trams everywhere? Would make life so much easier and environmentally friendlier!

TempestTost · 08/12/2023 01:14

Bluevelvetsofa · 07/12/2023 19:46

If we are serious about reducing the use of cars and/or increasing the use of electric vehicles, then we need a complete rethink of the transport system and the infrastructure. It’s just ridiculous to expect people to use trains when they are cancelled or broken on a very regular basis. It’s just not acceptable.

If there can be effective systems in other countries, why not here? The British public can not be expected to fork out ever increasing fares for a shit non service. The infrastructure for electric vehicles must be vastly improved and the roads must be maintained far better.

I often wonder about this. I don't believe it's purely a funding issue. Or at least not in a straightforward way.

From an environmental perspective, I think there also needs to be some serious rethinking about how housing stock is related to employment. The fact that so many people are commuting so far to work is foolish on the face of it, but to a large extent it's caused by the way cities are designed, and the way housing costs distribute. But it means that infrastructure to move people around has to be far more extensive than if more people lived relatively close to work.

Also, PO, agree with a pp, electric cars aren't really all that environmentally.

Peckahminn11 · 08/12/2023 01:13

Car driver here. I drive everywhere as I live relatively close to the city and important places I need to go... but every single time I need to get the train whether that's for a night out, to see friends or just travel to work on the rare occasions, there's ALWAYS a cancellation or strikes. It's becoming tedious and i cannot imagine how infuriating it is for people working in cities like London or Manchester for example. It has a huge affect in people's livelihoods and the people striking are complete wankers IMO.

XenoBitch · 08/12/2023 01:13

I used a car to get to uni placement. Took 15 minutes to get there.
If I got the bus, it would take an hour. It was early morning, so not much traffic... but the bus took the scenic route, plus I would have had to get one that was too early as opposed to the later one to get to my placement on time.

AlltheFs · 08/12/2023 01:09

I drive (electric) - it’s 30 miles and takes about 1hr. The traffic to get 5 miles across the city is a bitch (25 miles is rural). It costs me well under £5 in home charging I guess. Parking is £20pm.

The train from our nearest station is only hourly and I’d have a choice of leaving before nursery opens or arriving well after my work start time. The drive to the station is 10 mins, £5 to park and £18 for 25 min train (return) with a 1 mile walk through pollution to the office. So total cost £23 a day and duration is longer than 1hr but I couldn’t arrive until 9.30am and would have to leave before 4pm to get home for nursery.

The train is a joke.

Nepmarthiturn · 08/12/2023 00:56

tescocreditcard · 07/12/2023 19:03

YANBU I really don't understand why public transport is so poor in the UK (outside London that is)

Didn't see what happened on the Elizabeth Line today then?

There are always cancelled and delayed trains for commuters in and out of London in all directions and endless strikes. And a higher price is generally charged for the same number of miles. It's just as bad.

I agree OP, it is a shambles. I always drive everywhere, even into central London.

BorisIsACuntWaffle · 07/12/2023 22:18

Yanbu 10 min train journey.
Can be 20 to 45 mins in the car depending on traffic.
Train is just not reliable enough

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 07/12/2023 22:16

Just drive! If the government genuinely wanted more people to use public transport, they'd make it work properly and ensure the companies running it had appropriate money and resources so if one train was out of action they could put another on the line instead. The fact the government doesn't give a shit about public transport shouldn't be your problem.

Bang on. Public transport is like those irritating retail websites that claim your search and urge you to buy the item you're looking for from them, maybe offering an apparently cheaper price - but they never have it in stock, ever, and apparently never have nor ever will. No thanks, I'd rather pay a slightly higher price to get it from the site that does actually have it available.

I lived in an EU country for a year and the public transport - trains, trams and buses - were impeccable. I used my car about four times in the whole year, when I went to the enormous out-of-town shopping complex. It just was less hassle to jump on a tram or a train, so why wouldn't I?

There was one - ONE - isolated occasion in that year when the trains didn't run to the timetable: when a passenger who used a wheelchair needed assistance with a ramp (pre-booked and right there waiting ready for him, at the closest door to his pre-booked seat) and he was understandably slightly slower getting off the train. It delayed it by just under two minutes, which the driver then made up by the time it got to the next station at the scheduled time!

As for cancellations, they weren't on their radar, as they simply never happened. They would have been puzzled if you'd asked about the possibility of them and would have directed you back to the timetable, assuming you somehow didn't understand that you could be confident of there being a train there when it said there was one coming!

They also offered considerable discounts for groups travelling together, so that you would never be in the position where you wanted to get the train, but driving in one car would otherwise have worked out cheaper for several of you.

Any idiot knows that, if you offer what should be a carrot to encourage people, but then make it worse than a stick would be, people are just not going to trust or bother with you.

maximist · 07/12/2023 21:54

I live 20 minutes drive from my elderly parents, and often have to go over at very short notice if there's a crisis. To go by public transport I'd have to walk ten minutes to the bus station here, get a bus to an intermediate town (guessing about 20 minutes once on the bus, and I don't think they're that frequent), then change to a bus to theirs (takes 15 minutes, buses every half hour).

I won't be giving up my car....