Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's no wonder people use cars so much?

158 replies

Parapapampam · 07/12/2023 18:53

I work in a large city, always try and commute by train, this week, no strikes past 4 days on this line, my train home has been cancelled every single day, tomorrow there are strikes.

Different excuse every time, driver's seat broken, bad weather, staff shortage, or no reason given at all, the train just disappears off the board as if it never existed.

Tonight, my train, and the three after all cancelled, I imagine the later ones will be too (flooded tracks aren't suddenly going to clear whilst still pissing it down with rain).

So, I'm going to have to fork out £35 on an Uber.

This is not abnormal, happens at least twice a week, and the government wonder why people drive rather than use public transport.

So

YABU - keep using the shit trains, it's better for the environment and you can do work, read a book whilst on the train and don't have to worry about parking

YANBU - Start driving to work clogging up the roads (electric car) but get home before 8pm every night and save the £35 uber fee which is clogging up the roads anyway

OP posts:
FindingMeno · 08/12/2023 08:25

I don't drive and don't like cars.
I use public transport a lot and since I have no alternative I just get on with it.

2023forme · 08/12/2023 08:19

I’m in Scotland and would prefer to use public transport (hate driving) but the service is rubbish.

Scottish government gives young people free bus travel - great - but the local bus companies are slashing many bus routes owing to the costs of making the buses green.So I can no longer get the bus to work as there is no feasible route from my home to my work. Same for students living in my area - no bus to take them to 2 of the biggest colleges/universities we have.

But for some strange reason, there is a subsidised bus which passes very close to my house from the local area to the local hospital -again, you might think that’s great, but it runs at times when no one wants or needs to go there - from about 8pm to 11pm. Night shift starts at 715pm at said hospital so it’s too late for staff and for visiting patients - I see the bus driving around every night with no-one on it! but the bus that did suit staff has been cancelled! Its nuts.

so money is “going into” public transport but not necessarily in the most useful ways.

SquashPenguin · 08/12/2023 08:16

Wales is becoming increasingly anti- car, but at the same time builds new housing estates miles from public transport connections.

keye · 08/12/2023 08:12

@Badbadbunny

The thing is even diesels get stuck when power lines are faulty because there are often stranded electric trains in front of them blocking the tracks. Especially when diversionary routes aren't electrified and the diesels can't "overtake" to get to them.

Of course, but in the post I was responding to the older trains had been running. I was just explaining why that can happen.

falanka · 08/12/2023 08:11

I support striking workers. They are trying to make the service better, or at least not even worse. They are on our side in this, truly.

greyhairnomore · 08/12/2023 08:05

cerisepanther73 · 07/12/2023 19:02

@Parapapampam

I would do both start to learn to drive in the meantime carry on the trains 🚆 service with the hazzle inconvenience of that,

On Google Internet there are warning alerts that in the run up to Christmas time on specific dates expert to see train strikes for more pay happening ect.

She can drive. She's got a car , she was asking whether she should use it or not.

Badbadbunny · 08/12/2023 08:05

keye · 08/12/2023 07:46

Apparently a problem with overhead wires meant only the older trains were working that day!

That's true and often happens on the East coast main line with electric issues as the older trains are diiesl locos - a handful of the new azuma a bi mode so can also switch to diesel when overhead wires have an outage, but these are carefully diagrammed as they serve the part of Scotland north of Edinburgh where there are no overhead wires.

Edited

The thing is even diesels get stuck when power lines are faulty because there are often stranded electric trains in front of them blocking the tracks. Especially when diversionary routes aren't electrified and the diesels can't "overtake" to get to them.

There are only a tiny number of reserve diesel locos which can be mobilised to drag electric trains out of the way and they usually a couple of hours to get there.

RayonSunrise · 08/12/2023 08:05

The cost of learning to drive is also going up, and booking a test when you're actually ready for it nearly impossible. My son recently passed his driving test (on the first go, thank God) but he has to book it six months in advance. If he'd failed he'd have waiting for months to go again. There used to be a system of people booking ahead and looking for cancellations if they wanted something earlier, but even that workaround has been broken since the pandemic. It's a shambles.

Meanwhile, we have a government that's obsessed with getting everyone to stop working from home (unless they're disabled, in which case WFH is suddenly a great reason to cut their benefits), but won't sort out public transport or make driving more accessible. It's like the "pro having cake and pro-eating it" quip has become actual policy.

spottedinthewilds · 08/12/2023 08:04

YANBU. I live in the South West and the 4 of us are going to London for a few days after Christmas. If we all go on train it will cost over £500.

If we drive and park it will cost us just over £100.

Ridiculous!! I would happily use the trains if they were affordable. They manage it in other countries.

daffodilandtulip · 08/12/2023 08:03

I wfh but DC have the choice of an hour plus walk to school/college, a 1.5hr bus journey which needs two buses and costs £4 a day or a lift from me which takes less than ten minutes.

roarrfeckingroar · 08/12/2023 08:03

It's shockingly bad these days and I have no sympathy with striking ASLEF

theemmadilemma · 08/12/2023 08:02

Badbadbunny · 08/12/2023 07:59

@InefficientProcess

I dread to think what it’s like rurally.

People learn to drive when they're 17 - it's the norm in smaller towns and rural areas.

And you see a lot of much older drivers on the roads rurally.

theemmadilemma · 08/12/2023 08:01

settlethisone · 07/12/2023 19:01

YANBU they don’t fund or set up public transport properly and then complain we drive too much. We can’t win

This.

When it costs 50% more to travel by public transport which is throughly unreliable, why would you?

socks1107 · 08/12/2023 07:59

I live in a village, I drive but I use the train to London for work. Every single week there's some delay, some issue. The trains are often dirty with broken seats and overcrowded.
Our bus service is awful, non existent so you have no choice but to drive to our local town for shopping or take a train to one further away (no trains go to our local town!) teenagers and the elderly are totally cut off.
The whole system is run for such little money put back into it and if I could drive into London and park I probably would

Badbadbunny · 08/12/2023 07:59

@InefficientProcess

I dread to think what it’s like rurally.

People learn to drive when they're 17 - it's the norm in smaller towns and rural areas.

Badbadbunny · 08/12/2023 07:57

WrongSwanson · 08/12/2023 07:49

I absolutely wanted not to depend on a car but our trains round here are so unreliable that it forced me to learn to drive. It's so frustrating as we are a really built up area so it doesn't make sense that public transport is so bad

My son is the same though he learned to drive in sixth form,he didn't have a car at uni and thought he'd be fine when he moved to a northern city for his first proper job as flat was on a bus route straight into town. He's been there 3 months and had just bought a car. He was constantly late for work despite leaving his flat at 7.30 and work is only 2 miles away! Bus should be every 20 minutes but they just don't turn up. If one goes awol he can wait for the next and still make it on time but if the next doesn't turn up either then he's late. Happens 2 or 3 times a week. (And no, because of a medical condition he can't cycle or walk it, hence getting a flat on a regular bus route, or so he thought).

InefficientProcess · 08/12/2023 07:52

i don’t have a car and mostly have a within walking distance existence. I need to get public transport to take DS swimming each week though. The bus drivers have been on strike for months so I keep having to get Ubers.

Even before the strike, I had to get an Uber at least once a month because the bus simply didn’t turn up as timetabled.

i live in a city. Public transport here is terrible. Especially if you want to do anything other than going direct to the centre. I dread to think what it’s like rurally.

IsGoodIsDon · 08/12/2023 07:49

We had to get a new car due to Ulez and unfortunately we picked the wrong car and it’s had a ton of problems and we haven’t had it for the last 4 weeks.
we live in outer London and it’s been a nightmare. I have to take 2 buses and a train to work which takes 1.5hrs to get to work. In the car 30mins. To get the kids to clubs 2 buses and about an 50mins a to an hour, usually 20mins in the car. It’s cold it’s smelly and dirty. Never knowing when the bus is coming as the app stops working. I can’t wait to get my car back. If this is what it’s like in outer London I’d hate to see how people manage in rural areas. Public transport is fine here if you’re going into London but going sideways it’s a nightmare. Viva la car 🚗

Lochness1975 · 08/12/2023 07:49

My job role covers a large distance with different areas daily and carrying kit so no chance of using public transport. I was however on a training course many years ago in Birmingham and decided to get the train. Great getting there, but when leaving they’d cancelled all the trains. Had to then attempt along with 30 others to check back into our hotel until the following morning. First and last train ride for commute.

WrongSwanson · 08/12/2023 07:49

I absolutely wanted not to depend on a car but our trains round here are so unreliable that it forced me to learn to drive. It's so frustrating as we are a really built up area so it doesn't make sense that public transport is so bad

ConstantRain · 08/12/2023 07:47

I carry heavy bags, have to drop primary school child to school and start work at 9.30
Journey time in car is 25 minutes, bit longer if traffic is heavier. Train is 1hr 27mins.

myhusbandwantsadog · 08/12/2023 07:47

It takes me an hour and a quarter to drive to work so I'd love to get the train and sit there with a book. But by the time I pay thirty quid for train fare, a tenner on station parking, change twice oh and it takes two hours and there a half hour walk at the end - can't do it. I hate driving though.

keye · 08/12/2023 07:46

Apparently a problem with overhead wires meant only the older trains were working that day!

That's true and often happens on the East coast main line with electric issues as the older trains are diiesl locos - a handful of the new azuma a bi mode so can also switch to diesel when overhead wires have an outage, but these are carefully diagrammed as they serve the part of Scotland north of Edinburgh where there are no overhead wires.

MrsNandortheRelentless · 08/12/2023 07:41

Several cancelled trains last week resulting in packed trains that did turn up.

No seats, people packed into the hallways so impossible to access the toilets.

Then the appalling anti social behaviour with people’s phones on load speaker, awful “music”, full on loud speaker conversations, the shouting and threatening behaviour, the group of kids throwing bottles, McDonald’s wrappers across groups of people… fucking hideous.

Hate everything about it.

Dark freezing platforms late at night because 3 previous trains cancelled. Waiting, hoping that the next one isn’t otherwise it’s another hours wait.

TurquoiseSeasAndSilverSand · 08/12/2023 07:40

I live an hours drive from my Mum's, it's 5.5hrs on public transport. 2 buses and a train, I have to run across town too between stations. Neither of us live in outlandish locations, both locations have a train station.