Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's no wonder people use cars so much?

158 replies

Parapapampam · 07/12/2023 18:53

I work in a large city, always try and commute by train, this week, no strikes past 4 days on this line, my train home has been cancelled every single day, tomorrow there are strikes.

Different excuse every time, driver's seat broken, bad weather, staff shortage, or no reason given at all, the train just disappears off the board as if it never existed.

Tonight, my train, and the three after all cancelled, I imagine the later ones will be too (flooded tracks aren't suddenly going to clear whilst still pissing it down with rain).

So, I'm going to have to fork out £35 on an Uber.

This is not abnormal, happens at least twice a week, and the government wonder why people drive rather than use public transport.

So

YABU - keep using the shit trains, it's better for the environment and you can do work, read a book whilst on the train and don't have to worry about parking

YANBU - Start driving to work clogging up the roads (electric car) but get home before 8pm every night and save the £35 uber fee which is clogging up the roads anyway

OP posts:
Lincslady53 · 11/12/2023 06:01

We always drove to work as we often had to deliver stuff we sold, but since retiring, we bought a tailgate that gives 30% discount to use the train. We have a 30 minute bus journey to our nearest railway station. Our experience this year.
Feb, few days in London. Train back stopped 30 miles short, bus replacement taking an hour longer than scheduled.
June. To and from airport. Our scheduled train to the airport cancelled as we were on the platform meaning we arrived late at the airport.
August. Day trip to London to do a bit of business. The day before, our return train was cancelled. Offered an alternative 2 days later.
Seotember. Another trip to the airport. Going our, 2 trains cancelled meaning we arrived just in time to check in. Returning, dashed from terminal to station, a 15 minute rush, to catch the next train. Signs sustain due in a few minutes. The time came and went. 15 minutes later we were told the train was cancelled, and the next, and the next. 90 minutes later a train finally turned up, standing room only. This was at Manchester, one of the largest cities in the UK.
So far every journey has not run as scheduled. But we have not given up, we have a couple if days in York this week, we shall see if this journey breaks the mould and runs to time.

Stopthatknocking · 11/12/2023 04:04

This thread has prompted me to took into using public transport for my commute.
I live in a city, and work 16 miles away on the edge of the next city.

Takes me less than 25 mins to drive to work

Public transport would mean a walk to the bus stop, bus, train, another bus then 30 min walk.
Total 2.15 hours.

Why would anyone do that?
I need to be in work at 7am. So goole maps tells me to leave home at 4.45am.

Not happening.

FreshWinterMorning · 08/12/2023 13:47

MotherofWhippets81 · 08/12/2023 01:35

YANBU Same here this week.

I only go to the office twice a week and those days are exhausting and stressful due to the commute.

Tuesday luckily a colleague was watching the live updates and came to tell me they had started cancelling trains. We headed out early - which was a good job as they then cancelled the four trains after the one we planned to get. Whilst on the platform we were told anyone for my stop or beyond needed to go and get the replacement bus service. Kind colleague told me to go to her stop and she would give me a lift. The train then announced it was stopping at my stop anyway! All those poor people they're probably still on a bloody bus somewhere!

They then send four carriages. People were being pulled and pushed on so the doors would close. I've had spinal surgery quite recently and I have an autoimmune condition and it was frightening and dangerous.

Wednesday - delayed in the morning and then I had half a day AL. Got on the train and it announced there was a delay and we were stuck basically - after 40 minutes it announced that we were off but it wasn't stopping at the 5 stops before mine so lots of people had to get off to find a train that was. Complete waste of my half a day.

I can't drive in with my car (congestion charges) but I'm thinking of swapping with my husband (electric) but then parking is a problem as I can't get in early enough due to restrictions around school drop offs etc.

It's awful 🤷🏻‍♀️ I've used public transport in many countries and I've never seen issues like this.

Oh and a couple of weeks ago about 10 police officers were waiting for us at the station in the morning to check for ticket dodgers - one man was being wrestled to the ground. I'm sure he was being a dick but I have started to sympathise with people who take their chances not paying to be honest how expensive it is and how crap a service we get.

Thanks for the rant.

I need a rest after reading that! How awful. Sad Hope you're OK now. Flowers

FreshWinterMorning · 08/12/2023 13:46

Madameprof · 08/12/2023 07:18

My daughter has a highly expensive bus pass to get to college and work in the next town 6 miles away. Half the time at least one or more buses don't turn up and she is constantly late as a result. There is no delay repay on the bus and when I complain I just get a standard blah response. In the past week or so I've ended up driving her out of desperation. I would happily use public transport more if it was more efficient but I can't as it's not fit for purpose.

@Madameprof

That is shit obviously. But could she perhaps get a moped, or an electric bike? 6 miles isn't far really. Bit far to walk, but easily doable by electric bike, pushbike, or a moped...

Alternatively, if you're able, you could take her regularly. My DDs college was 7 miles away, and the bus came at 7.15am and took til 8.45am to get there! 3 hours a day of travel. Plus another half an hour added on with walking to the bus stop, and waiting. So 3 and a half hours a DAY wasted.

So I took them in the car. Took 10 minutes. 10 MINUTES there and 10 MINUTES back, compared to 3 and a half hours. Ridiculous! Hmm No wonder people drive a lot more now.

TheCatfordCat · 08/12/2023 13:20

I can happily bounce around the South East region on PT no problem. It's when I get further out that I start tearing my hair out. Nothing flows. You can't wait hours at some stations for connections or you have rush from one platform to another like your life depended on it. Or you get off a train and have to walk ages to a bus station. Or you blindly tap onto some buses and not realise they've charged you a King's Ransom to go from one part of town to another. Or, there's no getting out of it, you have to get a taxi, but you should have booked it a week last Tuesday.

One day I will get my driving licence and get a car to save time and money!

StillWantingADog · 08/12/2023 13:19

Yanbu and imm about as pro-public transport and anti-car as it comes

the train service where I am (outskirts of a major city, not London) is so unreliable I rarely bother anymore. And I HATE driving into town.I’d genuinely prefer to get the train but can’t guarantee if I will be able to get home again!

EdithStourton · 08/12/2023 13:18

Two rail journeys this week for an event arranged months ago.
First day: strike, so the train was packed and I arrived late.
Second day: no strike but two trains cancelled so I took an alternative route so DH had to drive 35 mins to collect or who knows when I would have got home.

The previous time I took the train: rail replacement bus service which doubled my journey time.

Pisses me off. Massive road works on both major arterial roads in the area too so you are basically fucked if you want to travel.

Strawberrypicnic · 08/12/2023 13:11

It's not even just outside of London. I'm in southeast London in an area of relatively poor public transport provision. To get to one of my favourite exercise classes I have to take two buses to cover a total of just over 3 miles. The other week I left the house 1 hour 10 mins before the start time to make sure that I'd arrive on time. The first bus was so late that I eventually had to abandon my journey as I was going to miss half of the class. It's a joke. I do without a car for environmental reasons but it's not even like you get to breathe pure air in some car-free utopia in return for your efforts - the whole environment (including the pavements) is dominated by cars and many are hostile to pedestrians. And when the bus does turn up, you're sat in a bloody queue because of everyone in their warm clean cars going directly to where they need to be. I've started to feel like a mug tbh

ActDottie · 08/12/2023 11:32

I agree. I don’t trust trains. When I commute to work I get the 6:10 the first train of the day as my logic is if they can’t get that train right then what can they get right. Also means I can leave work 3:45 and get the 4:15 train home which then means there’s another 4/5 trains after I can get if the 4:15 is cancelled. If I oversleep and don’t get into work early I get really panicked because I know there are fewer trains for me to rely on to get to and from work.

Im currently pregnant and just got a car as I was having whole afternoons off work just to travel to a maternity appointment because I’d have to get earlier trains in case they were cancelled. Couple of times had to fork out on a taxi too! If trains could be relied on it would be fine and I wouldn’t have got a car but they’re so unreliable I felt like I had no option.

janfebmarchapril · 08/12/2023 11:25

I live in a city and the trains and busses are either always late or cancel last minute.. or just don't turn up. So unreliable so I just don't bother anymore

irritation2345678 · 08/12/2023 11:03

We drove to a gig in east London last night.

Could have got 2 trains (delayed) and stood about in the wind and rain for a bit, but instead got there door to door in 30 mins.

In the past I have always taken public transport as we are always told not to even think about driving anywhere in London.

I will probably drive again in future. Much quicker and nicer.

steppemum · 08/12/2023 10:57

My dd takes the train to school. 30 minutes.
We have had this school run since 2013 when my oldest started.
At the beginning it was a reliable service.
By the time my middle one was taking the train it was delayed by 10 minutes at least once a week.

Now I just have dd in her last year.
The last 18 months have been HORRENDOUS.
This week - morning train cancelled twice.
The afternoon train cancelled every single day. There is a 3:30; 4:30; 5:30 etc train. Monday she came on 5:30. Tuesday 4:30 and Wed 4:30.
Today the 3:30 and 4:30 are already cancelled and the 5:30 delayed.

yesterday was a train strike. It is a 50 minute drive at rush hour, so even with full car and car sharing it means that parents have had to take time off work to get them in to school.

Today the school has had to allow train kids to leave an hour early to get the 2:30 train.

She is in GCSE year, and at exam time, I will need ot make myself availble every day incase the morning trainis cancelled and I have to drive her in for exams.
Did not need to do that for ds or dd1, for GCSE or A level.

I am so glad this is our last year, and I would not recommend this journey any more to any new parent.

UK train system is broken

user1497207191 · 08/12/2023 10:55

It's nothing new, sadly. My first job, 40 years ago was in the next town, just 20 miles away, an easy 30 minute drive door to door.

By train it would take 2.5 hours as both towns are on branch lines off the main line, so it was 3 different trains, none of which "connected" with acceptably short changeover times. Actually "on" the train moving was about 25 minutes, 5 minutes on each branch line and 15 minutes on the main line.

By bus, just as bad as the only bus went via all the outlying villages not on the main road and only went from our town's bus station and was an hourly service, so I had to leave home around 6.30 to get a bus to the station and then the slow bus to the next town for work for 9!

These were both "big" towns, i.e. 40-50k population each, not tiny hamlets! There "could" be direct trains if they wanted to as the tracks would "meet" at the stations, and network rail inspection trains often do the journey directly (there always used to be direct trains until the 60s!). Likewise, more direct buses (and more regular buses) are also possible as both towns are linked by a good, direct "A" road!

Trouble is political, as the two towns are in different counties, so neither county council is remotely interested in "integrated" services between them. They even stop the gritting trucks dead on the boundary line when it's icy! Of course both councils are raging a war against motorists with ever more one way systems, traffic calming, parking charge increases, etc., but don't actually ever bother to find out "why" people use cars. It's definitely all stick and no carrot!

bellac11 · 08/12/2023 10:28

NoCloudsAllowed · 08/12/2023 10:21

Bleinheim palace is in Woodstock, well served by buses and would make sense for many people living fairly close by to get the bus. I get the point but in this case it's not exactly middle of nowhere.

I wasnt referencing Bleinheim specifically, just a myriad of places we have visited in the past, not near any train stations so you would have to get an expensive cab or near regular bus routes.

NoCloudsAllowed · 08/12/2023 10:21

bellac11 · 08/12/2023 10:15

My god this drives me mad when you go to an attraction, usually in the middle of no where and they're bigging up to travel to them by public transport

How is that then, by that bus that runs every other Wednesday?

Bleinheim palace is in Woodstock, well served by buses and would make sense for many people living fairly close by to get the bus. I get the point but in this case it's not exactly middle of nowhere.

bellac11 · 08/12/2023 10:15

Tulipsroses · 08/12/2023 09:00

Why use cars? Is there an alternative?
We went to Bleinhaim Palace few weeks ago, and when purchasing the tickets there is a lot of bullshit about going green. Have you considered using public transport when travelling here?
So I sat down with a pen and computer and did a calculation: it takes us about 45 minutes to get there by car, about £10 of petrol.
Public transport: 3 bus rides plus one train ride, 54 bus stops and 11 train stops, one hour of walking. 2 hours just travelling time plus waiting in between so it wold take close to 4 hours each way. Price for the whole family 2 adults and 3 kids £88 with all discounts.
It's a sad picture!

My god this drives me mad when you go to an attraction, usually in the middle of no where and they're bigging up to travel to them by public transport

How is that then, by that bus that runs every other Wednesday?

Caledoniadreaming · 08/12/2023 10:11

Definitely not being unreasonable.

I work in London, and the last month has been pretty horrific even by London's standards. If there was somewhere I could park easily and even get the tube into work, I would.

To make matters worse, I'm in the public sector where we've just had the 60% time in the office edict handed down - apparently to make us more productive. If the "grown ups" think that commuting (with delays) for 6 hours a day to get 4 hours of work done is productive.....not to mention the increase in costs, which are scheduled to increase in March. Fun times.

NoCloudsAllowed · 08/12/2023 09:17

Yanbu. The system is geared towards cars.

I live in a fairly big city and cycle into the city centre or get the bus if I go alone.

However with kids (4 and 6) it costs more and takes longer to get the bus and other bus passengers are often quite unpleasant (smelly, ranting, saying inappropriate things etc). I know that sounds snobby but to pay £8 for an inconvenient journey with even one oddball doing alarming things when driving costs £4 in parking and is door to door - it's a no brainer.

I'd happily have a cargo bike but there's nowhere to store it as we're in a terrace with no rear access. Of course, you don't usually have to worry about where to store a car!

The icing on the cake with public transport is that lots of them are part owned by foreign nationally owned transport companies. So profits from UK transport goes to improving transport in France and Netherlands etc while we're stuck with a shit service.

RedPony1 · 08/12/2023 09:02

We've booked to see a gig in London in Feb. Train for the time we need is £139 each return, plus a taxi to/from the station ourside (say £20) that's £298 for two people

So we've booked parking for £65 and will drive in, which will be about £35 in fuel so £100, that's £200 cheaper and we get to go at our convenience rather than train times.

My normal day to day life couldnt be done on public transport any way, even if it was a better set up.

Tulipsroses · 08/12/2023 09:00

Why use cars? Is there an alternative?
We went to Bleinhaim Palace few weeks ago, and when purchasing the tickets there is a lot of bullshit about going green. Have you considered using public transport when travelling here?
So I sat down with a pen and computer and did a calculation: it takes us about 45 minutes to get there by car, about £10 of petrol.
Public transport: 3 bus rides plus one train ride, 54 bus stops and 11 train stops, one hour of walking. 2 hours just travelling time plus waiting in between so it wold take close to 4 hours each way. Price for the whole family 2 adults and 3 kids £88 with all discounts.
It's a sad picture!

Artichoke88 · 08/12/2023 08:57

The whole transport system is a mess. We were quoted £1,124 for 6 people for a train journey London to Bristol return. Add to that accommodation, food etc. instead, we've chosen to go to Lisbon, Portugal for £586 teturn. And they wonder why people use their cars - more reliable and costs less.

Gillypie23 · 08/12/2023 08:49

Purchase transport in this country is the pits.

ItsNotOkItsNotTheEnd · 08/12/2023 08:44

YANBU it's quicker and cheaper for me to go most places by car rather than train, they are always delayed or dissappear which is risky if you need a connection, on the only fast ones there are never any seats and buses aren't much better as there are not enough bus lanes where I live

WrongSwanson · 08/12/2023 08:41

FindingMeno · 08/12/2023 08:25

I don't drive and don't like cars.
I use public transport a lot and since I have no alternative I just get on with it.

That's great but bar a massive taxi bill there is no option for me to just get on with it

And I genuinely dislike cars and planned where to live so it was a near a train and bus route!

Unwisebutnotillegal · 08/12/2023 08:32

During the summer I was traveling across the Netherlands I bought a return ticket for a family of 4 for £60. We sat down on our train and there was an extremely tense announcement in English, German and Dutch saying we were two minutes delayed. We made up the time and there also was an announcement for that 😂.
I commute three days a week and last week got all my money back in delay repay. Luckily I can work on the train so I just do nine hours instead of seven in a day.

Swipe left for the next trending thread