Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's no wonder people use cars so much?

158 replies

Parapapampam · 07/12/2023 18:53

I work in a large city, always try and commute by train, this week, no strikes past 4 days on this line, my train home has been cancelled every single day, tomorrow there are strikes.

Different excuse every time, driver's seat broken, bad weather, staff shortage, or no reason given at all, the train just disappears off the board as if it never existed.

Tonight, my train, and the three after all cancelled, I imagine the later ones will be too (flooded tracks aren't suddenly going to clear whilst still pissing it down with rain).

So, I'm going to have to fork out £35 on an Uber.

This is not abnormal, happens at least twice a week, and the government wonder why people drive rather than use public transport.

So

YABU - keep using the shit trains, it's better for the environment and you can do work, read a book whilst on the train and don't have to worry about parking

YANBU - Start driving to work clogging up the roads (electric car) but get home before 8pm every night and save the £35 uber fee which is clogging up the roads anyway

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
hermioneee · 11/12/2023 12:20

CranfordScones · 11/12/2023 11:00

Mumsnet is full of threads about people wanting to work from home. That's fine, but there's an accompanying reality. Which is that train companies have taken a big revenue hit. The commuters formerly subsidised a lot of the off-peak and leisure travel that people here are complaining about.

So...who wants to give up working from home (or pay a WFH-tax) to subsidise the rail system? Thought not.

Nonsense. Rail companies made and continue to make record profits year on year. Their shareholders are absolutely rolling in it and all that would happen if more people took the train is they would be rolling in it some more.

The service has been crap for years, not just since people started working from home.

SusanSHelit · 11/12/2023 11:54

It's not just trains (though they are abysmal).

It's a half hour drive from my house to my mums, almost two hours on public transport.

15 minute drive to work. An hour on the bus, no train link.

10 minute drive to my friend, 45 minutes to an hour by bus, if the once an hour bus shows up, again no train link.

Where I live if you want to go into the city centre or out of it, it's not too bad. If you want to go across the city, you may as well walk it takes that long.

If you live near the city train line it's not bad. Our local trains are every 15 minutes, mostly clean, and rarely late or cancelled compared to many other networks (looking at you northern).

They are one of the best train networks in the country (Merseyrail) but they're still not great. They don't serve a great deal of the city and there are very stations with connections to other lines

user1497207191 · 11/12/2023 11:44

SerendipityJane · 11/12/2023 11:41

It's not just the commute that's an issue. It's the religious fanaticism most firms have about a fixed 9-5 that means you get 80% of the traffic compressed into 20% of the day. Something which just hasn't changed one iota since 1980.

It's more the school traffic really. It's very noticeable that the roads are a lot quieter in school holidays.

SerendipityJane · 11/12/2023 11:41

It's not just the commute that's an issue. It's the religious fanaticism most firms have about a fixed 9-5 that means you get 80% of the traffic compressed into 20% of the day. Something which just hasn't changed one iota since 1980.

user1497207191 · 11/12/2023 11:07

CranfordScones · 11/12/2023 11:00

Mumsnet is full of threads about people wanting to work from home. That's fine, but there's an accompanying reality. Which is that train companies have taken a big revenue hit. The commuters formerly subsidised a lot of the off-peak and leisure travel that people here are complaining about.

So...who wants to give up working from home (or pay a WFH-tax) to subsidise the rail system? Thought not.

Thing is, it's rammed at peak times and even then, they just cancel random trains or put on 2 coachers. Cross country trains are rammed full all the time, not just peak times, yet still they're too infrequent and too short. In Northern England, they're pretty full all the time, even at off peak times, and peak times are just horrendous.

The whole thing needs a re-think. Passenger flows have changed since covid, yet the timetables, types/lengths of trains, etc haven't been amended to adapt to the new "normal". Statistics show that whilst commuter numbers are down, leisure etc numbers are up, meaning it's "peak" commuters numbers that have fallen and off-peak have risen, but the formations/timetables etc havn't changed to suit!

Train companies (now mostly controlled by Govt) need to make better provision for the off peak travellers which is the growing market. It's insane that they have 9 coach trains Monday to Friday, mostly carrying around fresh air for most of the day outside peak commuter times, but then only put 3 coachers on at the weekend which are rammed most of the day!

user1497207191 · 11/12/2023 11:01

My son chose his flat to live in at his new work city because it was on a bus route - he checked where the bus stops were and checked the timetable. He discounted other potential flats because they weren't on bus routes.

Made no difference in the end because the buses are so unreliable, turn up when they want, regularly cancelled without notice/warning - just disappear from the tracking app along the route and disappear, never to turn up at the bus stop. Sometimes even just drive past the bus stop pretending not to notice everyone waiting (when it's not full, it's understandable if full, but it's not!) - they seem to just "not bother" stopping when they're running a bit late! Not too bad if it's a regular service, but it's every 30 minutes daytime and only every hour evenings and weekends which means very long waits when one doesn't turn up.

Anyway, he's got his car now, so drives instead!

CranfordScones · 11/12/2023 11:00

Mumsnet is full of threads about people wanting to work from home. That's fine, but there's an accompanying reality. Which is that train companies have taken a big revenue hit. The commuters formerly subsidised a lot of the off-peak and leisure travel that people here are complaining about.

So...who wants to give up working from home (or pay a WFH-tax) to subsidise the rail system? Thought not.

ConsistentlyElectrifiedElves · 11/12/2023 10:38

YANBU. To buy a house I can get to work from by quick, regular, public transport would cost me a fortune, so I had to buy a house I could afford, then drive to work.

It is possible to get to work by public transport, as I had to during the stupid fuel shortages a couple of years ago, but it consisted of:

  • either a bus or a taxi to the train station. Taxi = £5, bus = £3 with a walk, and a very unreliable service where buses break down regularly.
  • train (to get in for 9am I have a 7.30 option that takes an hour (£25), an 8am option that takes 37 mins (£10.50), or a 8.20 option that takes 35 mins (also £10.50). It is quite reliable though.
  • 15 minute walk (free thankfully!)

Then obviously all of this repeated on the return leg.

Total cost for the day = £27, using the cheaper options for each bit.

Total time for the day = minimum of an hour each way.

Compare that to my drive - 17 miles each way, my car does about 50 mpg, so 0.68 gallons = £4.75 in fuel. Obviously I have to pay running costs, repairs, insurance, etc. Free parking at work.

Time taken = 25 mins each way.

I'll do it if we've got a boozy night out after work, or if I have car problems, but it's totally unsustainable otherwise.

Laffinalltheway · 11/12/2023 10:29

tescocreditcard · 07/12/2023 19:03

YANBU I really don't understand why public transport is so poor in the UK (outside London that is)

Trust me... It's absolutely shit in London as well!

There may be more options, but it is crap and getting worse. Even the newest, hi tech, all singing and dancing lines like the Elizabeth are shit!

Seeline · 11/12/2023 10:17

user1497207191 · 11/12/2023 09:59

@Seeline

And if you want to go round the edge of South London it's almost impossible - all routes run like the spokes of a wheel into central London - nothing links the spokes this far out.

Lots of towns and cities are like that. Buses are all concentrated on routes in and out of the town centre in multiple different directions, but nothing going "around" the town/city on the outskirts. So if, say, you live on the edge of the West of Town and want to go to a retail park, cinema, or even work, at the North edge of town, you have to get a bus into the town centre and then change for a bus going from town centre to the North. It makes a journey that's 15 minutes by car into a journey that can take 2 hours! No sane person would take the bus!

Town and city councils are obsessed with their centres, but in reality, most people don't want to be in the centre itself, they want to go through or around the centre. They have an antiquated idea that people work in town centres, but that ship sailed a few decades ago with most workplaces, hospitals, retail parks, industrial estates etc being on the edge of towns/cities these days, often served by poor public transport, or sometimes, none at all!

We need bus routes "around" the town and city outskirts to link the various retail parks, industrial estates, hospitals, etc.

Oh I realise that, and in a way it makes sense - people will always need to get to city centres. Although in London, people on the edges probably have other places that they need to go, or prefer to go - we don't have to get into the city centre for all services and amenities. Greater London is huge compared to other cities in the UK, so the distances involved even around the edge of inner London are big, by the time you get to the edges, it's pretty much the size of the M25. I made the comment because people are always going on about how brilliant London transport is. Trying to get round the touristy parts in central London is pretty easy (on non-strike days, or non-protest march days, or snow days etc). Once you are out of the reach of the Tube network, public transport is much less user friendly.

user1497207191 · 11/12/2023 10:15

Dixiechickonhols · 11/12/2023 10:10

School buses are very expensive and not enough places. There was a moaning thread on local Facebook group about why so many kids are driven to secondary school. Someone linked the council run bus prices. Lots of the moaners assumed school buses were free or cheap!! - 2 children can be over £100 a month even if close by hence parents dropping off. Season ticket is £517 to £897 a child a year.

Yes, makes no sense at all to use buses if you have 2 or more kids at the same school as the costs are extortionate enough with just one! Far cheaper to use the car with 2 or 3 kids, even if it means you have to give up an hour of pay daily to do the school run.

user1497207191 · 11/12/2023 10:13

@Lincslady53

But we have not given up, we have a couple if days in York this week, we shall see if this journey breaks the mould and runs to time.

The trains between Manchester/Leeds/York are an absolute nightmare, so if you travel that way, you're highly unlikely to run to time and unlikely to get a seat. The ECML from London to York is usually OK-ish, but the overhead wires are notorious for failing or damage and when that happens, everything comes to a standstill for several hours, usually takes overnight for them to be repaired!

My son has gone from York to London 3 times for work, over the past couple of months. Twice he ended up stranded in London overnight, once for bad weather causing flooding around Peterborough and the second for overhead wires down near Peterborough. Luckily he found a hotel room both times, but they were running out fast with all the people stranded. Third time he never even got there, set off from York at around 7am but trapped in a train for 4 hours due to wires down (again) around Peterborough, so when they finally got to a station, he just got off and got the next train North again. But, if there's no flooding, no train breakdowns and no power line damage, the East Coast main line works OK most of the time. Just don't use Grand Central Trains as they're notorious for cancellations and breakdowns - use GNER!

Dixiechickonhols · 11/12/2023 10:10

School buses are very expensive and not enough places. There was a moaning thread on local Facebook group about why so many kids are driven to secondary school. Someone linked the council run bus prices. Lots of the moaners assumed school buses were free or cheap!! - 2 children can be over £100 a month even if close by hence parents dropping off. Season ticket is £517 to £897 a child a year.

user1497207191 · 11/12/2023 10:06

Son took the train back to his work city yesterday. First leg to Leeds was actually fine, he got a seat and arrived at Leeds 1 minute early. Then it all went wrong. His connection to York was literally rammed full, he couldn't even get on to stand. So, fair enough, next due in 15 minutes. It was just 2 coaches and again, absolutely rammed, so he couldn't get on that either. Never mind, the next was 15 minutes later, but the departure board time just kept going back a minute or two, so always 10 minutes away. The train scheduled after that was due and came in on time, but again, rammed, no one could get on it, another 2 coacher! It was 90 minutes later when the late train finally arrived, a 3 coacher this time, absolutely rammed, but son had had enough and just barged himself onto it, barely scraping in enough for the door to close! Finally at York 2 hours later, he went to the bus stop and checked the app to find the hourly bus had been cancelled and he had to wait another hour at the bus stop. So he waited, and the next one didn't come either. So he ended up walking 2 miles home from the station. A journey that should have taken just 3 hours ended up taking 6 hours. He's coming home by car next time!! He's not doing that again! Only takes 2 hours door to door by car.

user1497207191 · 11/12/2023 09:59

@Seeline

And if you want to go round the edge of South London it's almost impossible - all routes run like the spokes of a wheel into central London - nothing links the spokes this far out.

Lots of towns and cities are like that. Buses are all concentrated on routes in and out of the town centre in multiple different directions, but nothing going "around" the town/city on the outskirts. So if, say, you live on the edge of the West of Town and want to go to a retail park, cinema, or even work, at the North edge of town, you have to get a bus into the town centre and then change for a bus going from town centre to the North. It makes a journey that's 15 minutes by car into a journey that can take 2 hours! No sane person would take the bus!

Town and city councils are obsessed with their centres, but in reality, most people don't want to be in the centre itself, they want to go through or around the centre. They have an antiquated idea that people work in town centres, but that ship sailed a few decades ago with most workplaces, hospitals, retail parks, industrial estates etc being on the edge of towns/cities these days, often served by poor public transport, or sometimes, none at all!

We need bus routes "around" the town and city outskirts to link the various retail parks, industrial estates, hospitals, etc.

InefficientProcess · 11/12/2023 09:41

Increasing parking charges and issuing loads of fines for falling foul of ever more Byzantine regulations are revenue generators too. Whereas it costs money to build proper transport links.

InefficientProcess · 11/12/2023 09:40

Tulipsroses · 11/12/2023 09:18

I think this the public transport mentality has really got encouraged councils to limit car use in towns. My example is this Saturday. I went with two boys to the Nutcracker in the centre of Birmingham. It took me 40 minutes to find a parking space. I have to say that's the last time I will go there.

In the past couple of years council have demolished 3 or 4 multi storage car parks in the centre of Birmingham as the redevelopment plan. But cars are not included in there new plan for the city centre. Well it's the end of vibrant city centre in my opinion. And you can see it now, shops and restaurants are closing.

Thing is, it’s not a public transport mentality. It’s just a hostile to cars mentality.

It’s as if policy makers think the answer lies in just making it more difficult and expensive to drive - without looking at all the barriers to using public transport or understanding why people elect to drive.

Another issue is that even where the policies are made by people who practice what they preach, they fail to understand the important ways in which their lives are organised around their preference for public transport. They’ve chosen where they live in relation to the public transport possibilities, and the things within walking distance. They may have planned specifically for bike storage etc.

This matters because there are significant differences for all the people they want to switch from largely using their cars to public transport. The barriers to this behaviour change - and empathy for people who, for example, live out on new build estates with driveways and garages but terrible bus links and no amenities - can be challenging for people who think ‘I can live just fine without a car; these people just don’t care enough about the environment’.

The hard bit is making public transport work for everyone. So policy makers concentrate on just making driving more difficult.

Toddlerteaplease · 11/12/2023 09:21

It's cheaper for me to drive and park in town, than get the bus.

Tulipsroses · 11/12/2023 09:18

I think this the public transport mentality has really got encouraged councils to limit car use in towns. My example is this Saturday. I went with two boys to the Nutcracker in the centre of Birmingham. It took me 40 minutes to find a parking space. I have to say that's the last time I will go there.

In the past couple of years council have demolished 3 or 4 multi storage car parks in the centre of Birmingham as the redevelopment plan. But cars are not included in there new plan for the city centre. Well it's the end of vibrant city centre in my opinion. And you can see it now, shops and restaurants are closing.

CocoPlum · 11/12/2023 09:14

So true.

My previous job was about 4.5 miles away, 20-30 mins drive at peak times. I would need to get 2 buses, one into the centre of town, one out again. The service town-workplace was probably the most reliable although it would be so busy eith the amount of people squeezing on and the cars trying to leave at 5pm it often took 15-20 mins just to get offsite. When I was a regular user, buses on the home-town route were often missed and at peak times in the morning they'd send a single decker so by my stop no one could get on and we'd end up waiting 30 mins.

It was so tedious, I have no guilt about using the car.

Seeline · 11/12/2023 09:13

London transport is pretty shit too if you look at outside the City.
Most of South London doesn't have the Tube network.
Our local train station only has one train an hour timetables for most of the day since lockdown, and that frequently gets cancelled.
The bus doesn't run to the big town centre station, so if you have luggage or shopping or children or are elderly/disabled there is a walk through town to get a more frequent train (unless they are in strike). It's not even a nice walk, and I wouldn't want the kids doing it alone at night. - stabbings unfortunately are on the increase here.
And if you want to go round the edge of South London it's almost impossible - all routes run like the spokes of a wheel into central London - nothing links the spokes this far out.

Ginandjuice57884 · 11/12/2023 08:58

That's privatisation for you.

PowerTulle · 11/12/2023 08:56

I have a job that requires extensive regional travel. Employer encourages public transport where possible. One too many times I’ve been forced to hang around dark, neglected, unstaffed stations in the evening feeling unsafe and no idea if or when a delayed train might arrive. No other options to get home. I just refuse to do it now so it’s either car or I don’t go.

Lincslady53 · 11/12/2023 06:29

When we started out business in a Northern town centre in the 80s all the facilities were in the town centre. All shops, banks, solicitors,markets, restaurants, cinemas, supermarkets, and even car dealers and a cattle market. The town was a thriving, busy hub of activity. Workers could go in by train or bus, and walk to whatever they needed to do. Over the following 3 decades, first the supermarkets, then all large shops that could, moved to the 4 out of town retail parks. Then the cinemas and restaurants followed. Then the solicitors and financial services offices moved out. The shops that couldn't move, the long established department stores, the small independents. The cattle market closed killing the trade from the farmers on market day. The market closed and was turned into a contemporary (expensive) food court. All of the movement to out of town has reduced town centre traffic, but spread it to the outskirts. Few of the out of town centres have good public transport connections compared to the town centre which was, and still is a hub for bus and railway connections.

electriclight · 11/12/2023 06:25

My family don't trust the trains any more. I don't remember a journey where the train wasn't delayed or cancelled. When dd comes back from university it's like planning a major operation, with buffer time built in for the inevitable issues. Never travel on the same day as something important. It's a disgrace really yet the fares are comparatively high. And when people don't trust or use the trains, they have even less money to invest.