Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Anyone else hyper vigilant that some men may be pedophiles

311 replies

Cantgetwarmbrr · 07/12/2023 16:47

I wasn’t like this before I had my Dd, she’s 5 now and just always in the back of my mind I wonder about people and hate feeling/thinking like this. For example, really nice, married guy neighbour with a son who walks his dogs and chats on to my Dd, which is nice 🤷🏻‍♀️ I even felt on guard when taking her to Santa as one Elf guy kept telling her how beautiful she was. It’s a horrible way to think, it’s just always there at the back of my mind. I can’t ever imagine letting her go to sleepovers etc, but know I’ll have to one day.
Does anyone else have this in the back of their mind sometimes?
I even said to Dh that I’d never leave her with another male, even close friends of ours etc, who I love and have known for years, why am I so paranoid about this? Does anyone feel similar?

OP posts:
ElfontheShelfIsWATCHINGYOUTOO · 07/12/2023 20:18

@LolaSmiles totally agree

ElfontheShelfIsWATCHINGYOUTOO · 07/12/2023 20:17

@IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos

Unfortunately whilst people who work with dc can be a risk, it's actually family members who are the biggest risks.

People the parents trust.

ElfontheShelfIsWATCHINGYOUTOO · 07/12/2023 20:16

?? My closest male friend is doesn't, and we have a fantastic relationship, why should my in laws?

As I said.. I don't ever totally trust anyone except my dh.

Wishitsnows · 07/12/2023 20:14

You are right to be concerned and young children even when the know all the right terminology are not believed or assumed an adult has prompted them to say something. Even some of the Rochdale pedos got acces to their children on the basis they are attracted to 12 year olds not babies. So the teenagers they raped have to hand over their children for access and hope nothing happens.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 07/12/2023 20:14

I trust my instincts. I wouldn't leave my child with anyone I don't implicitly trust with my life. I wouldn't leave my dog with anyone I don't trust. But I get bad vibes from men AND women and so they are people I don't let my child too near. But to assume every man who talks to my child, especially in a setting where they are meant to entertain the children (the elf) is out to harm them is OTT.

LolaSmiles · 07/12/2023 20:10

It can happen to anyone by anyone
Agree with you.
This is the central principle of safeguarding.

There's a healthy awareness and proactive outlook that's needed when it comes to safeguarding. It doesn't mean living your life with intrusive or paranoid thoughts, but it should mean giving consideration to situations rather than taking everything at face value.

Nanny0gg · 07/12/2023 20:07

ElfontheShelfIsWATCHINGYOUTOO · 07/12/2023 20:05

@sprigatito

What a strange response.

Peadophiles are everywhere.

Cubs/gymnastics/ballet /swimming... Football everywhere...

Simply being on guard doesn't mean you destroy anything.
I've got an extremely close older male friend whom has been a rock throughout my life and supported me.
I view him as a father figure and close to friend however that doesn't mean its precludes him from being a Peadophiles or being with my dd at the wrong time something could happen.
I'm a little bit wary of all men around my dd including uncles, cousins and grandparents.
The only man I totally and implicitly trust is my dh their dad.

Imagine.. If more people did this how much child abuse would fall.

Do your parents and in-laws know how you feel about them?

TheYearOfSmallThings · 07/12/2023 20:06

It's natural to have concerns, especially when your children are too young for you to explain the risks and for them to tell you if anyone says or does something inappropriate.

But you have to give them the knowledge they need and gradually loosen the strings. I have a friend who would not let her husband put their 16 and 14 year old sons in an Uber in town, to come straight home. She sees the world as being full of predators, and has raised her children to believe their lives would be at risk on public transport. It is so disturbing but she got quite aggressive when I questioned it - it has been a warning to me tbh not to get like that.

Nanny0gg · 07/12/2023 20:06

AnonnyMouseDave · 07/12/2023 17:17

I have a lot of sympathy with your position, OP.

I would definitely never consider a male baby-sitter. I would not want a kid of mine at a nursery with ANY male staff. Obviously most men who work with kids are not paedophiles, but best case scenario (IMHO) they are weird. I am not saying I am fully rational or "right" but that is my position and I can't see my mind being changed.

I say this as someone who has done some "voluntary work" (it wasn't truly voluntary) at a day nursery and saw first hand how much some of the kids needed a male influence in their lives.

My DGC had a male Reception teacher.

What would you do then?

ElfontheShelfIsWATCHINGYOUTOO · 07/12/2023 20:05

@sprigatito

What a strange response.

Peadophiles are everywhere.

Cubs/gymnastics/ballet /swimming... Football everywhere...

Simply being on guard doesn't mean you destroy anything.
I've got an extremely close older male friend whom has been a rock throughout my life and supported me.
I view him as a father figure and close to friend however that doesn't mean its precludes him from being a Peadophiles or being with my dd at the wrong time something could happen.
I'm a little bit wary of all men around my dd including uncles, cousins and grandparents.
The only man I totally and implicitly trust is my dh their dad.

Imagine.. If more people did this how much child abuse would fall.

Ardith · 07/12/2023 20:05

Yanbu. An elf telling a little girl she’s beautiful is creepy.

An anonymous survery of a random group of men found that something 10% of them were sexually attracted to young children 🤢

The world is full of paedophiles and they absolutely are trying to befriend the mums of pretty girls. Trust your instincts OP.

mantyzer · 07/12/2023 20:03

Personally I let my children go to sleepovers. But even if I could afford it I would have never have sent them to boarding schools.

mantyzer · 07/12/2023 20:01

The six year child sexual abuse enquiry outlined the most frequent sexual abuse that happened to children.

The most common was in the family. Stepfathers are more likely to sexually abuse than biological fathers. Don't if you are dating advertise that you have children and their ages e.g. on a dating site, it may attract paedophiles.
The next most common is children sexually abusing other children. You need to give your children sex education and talk about normal sexual exploration with other children and when it is coercion. People always ignore this as it is quite upsetting to realise your children's friends could sexually abuse them.
Then it is children in some kind of institution from boarding schools, to sports and music schools, to children's homes and penal institutions.
And then religious organisations. As someone says above religions that promote loving each other and being non judgemental whilst it brings positives, can also lead to people ignoring warning signs. And various religions have actively covered up abuse by their clerics.

Generally it is about being critical and not just trusting people. The example someone gave of a friends husband offering to take her children to the toilet is a major red flag. Paedophiles are attracted to situations where it is easier to abuse e.g. children's homes and boarding schools, or to parents who are too trusting, with weak boundaries, or because of their own issues such as mental health can not adequately protect their children.
There is an issue as well with people who are normally critical, but trust other people like themselves e.g. trusting implicitly other home educators if you are one, or trusting other evangelical Christians if you are one.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/12/2023 19:57

WillowCraft · 07/12/2023 19:48

Ok so you don't believe the survey. Fair enough, these things are notoriously biased. And you think the fact that someone may find out would put off many of these men. Again you're probably right. But even so do you really think 1 in 20 is that different to 1 in 100? To the extent that it would change the way you behave? To me 1 in 100 is still a high risk. I mean obviously that 1 in 100 men do not a use every child they come across. But still.

Not so much "I don't believe it", more that I'd be cautious about trying to apply anything it suggests to reality. See the post above.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/12/2023 19:54

WillowCraft · 07/12/2023 19:37

Your point doesn't make much sense. You seem to be saying that in an anarchist society 1 in 20 men would commit paedophilic acts, but not to worry, as we are in a society that has controls it's only 1 in 100.
For a start 1 in 100 is not that different to 1 in 20. Secondly that's the conviction rate. The real rate must be at least double .

But even if it isn't, 1 in 100 men is say a 1 in 20 chance if there are 5 men in your own family who have access to your child. Or if your child has a few sleepovers, a couple of male primary teachers, goes to a couple of sports clubs etc, it could soon get to a much higher chance than that , that they'd be in a position where an adult male they know and trust has malign intentions.

Nothing about that is vanishingly rare.

If I've misunderstood what you meant I think you need to clarify as I've read your post carefully.

No, you pretty much are correct, with the caveat that I certainly wouldn't say "not to worry"

I would take exception with the point that 1 in 100 is not that different to 1 in 20.

That is a significant difference, especially if we are talking about a population of 25 million or so adult males.

I also make no claims about anything being "vanishingly rare".

In essence, I'll just reiterate what I said in the post above, i.e. I think you have to be cautious about drawing any conclusions from a study that posits a situation that does not reflect reality, especially as to how it pertains to risk, because what you would then be doing is spending your time worrying about a hypothetical risk in a hypothetical situation, rather than an actual existent risk in your lived reality.

To borrow the adage again, I'm sure more people would also rob banks if they knew they would never be caught than do in reality. Banks are still robbed regardless, but banks ameliorate risk based on what actually happens, not on what would hypothetically happen in a hypothetically lawless situation.

So just to be absolutely clear, this is a commentary on the study, and my concerns about drawing any firm conclusions from it, and I am in no way suggesting anyone should stop being vigilant, or stop being worried, or stop being wary of men etc etc.

RealBigBarbie · 07/12/2023 19:51

I think everyone’s dodgy and no one can change my mind about that. There is a lot of CSA in my family and I don’t think people actually realise how common it is.

People that say you’ll have to let your child go to a sleepover at some point. Well no, no you don’t actually. I don’t see anything wrong with your thinking at all. It’s better to be weary about everyone then trusting every Tom, Dick & Harry

WillowCraft · 07/12/2023 19:48

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/12/2023 19:37

You have made some very bizarre arguments on this thread

You appear to have misinterpreted my points, so it's not a surprise they appear "bizarre".

I don't understand how anyone can be so complacent about this, and dismiss what these men admit to as "bravado"

Assuming this is, again, a reference to my point, I did not "dismiss this as bravado". I made the point that in blind surveys which have no consequences for the respondents, the data can be skewed by the fact that the freedom from consequence means people are at liberty to lie, embellish, and engage in bravado, partly because they know there is no comeback, but also out of sheer devilment because they know it will produce wonky results.

I have personal experience of this phenomenon in action, but I'm not going to get into specifics because it involves certain unsavoury topics that I don't really want to discuss, and they aren't really appropriate for this topic.

Just so we're absolutely clear here, the comments and arguments I've made in this thread were prompted by, and solely in relation to, another poster bringing up this study.

When I've referred to not seeing the point in wasting time worrying about a hypothetical, the hypothetical in question is a society where all the instruments of state listed have broken down irretrievably, where people do not practice safeguarding and vigilance, and where there is no fear whatsoever of consequence. This is not the society we live in, nor is it ever likely to be, so this is why I see no point in spending time worrying about this particular hypothetical.

What I am emphatically NOT suggesting, and never have, is that people should not concern themselves with CSA, or be vigilant with regard to the welfare of their children, and I certainly have not implied that CSA would only become an issue of concern is society broke down into anarchy.

I am also in no way "complacent", merely highlighting that the study posits a situation that is not comparable to real life, or how society actually functions, so that needs held in mind when we are talking about real life, and real society.

Ok so you don't believe the survey. Fair enough, these things are notoriously biased. And you think the fact that someone may find out would put off many of these men. Again you're probably right. But even so do you really think 1 in 20 is that different to 1 in 100? To the extent that it would change the way you behave? To me 1 in 100 is still a high risk. I mean obviously that 1 in 100 men do not a use every child they come across. But still.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/12/2023 19:37

Begsthequestion · 07/12/2023 19:11

You have made some very bizarre arguments on this thread.

I just looked at the report, and it is sickening. I don't understand how anyone can be so complacent about this, and dismiss what these men admit to as "bravado".

https://childlight.org/searchlight-2023-dashboard

You have made some very bizarre arguments on this thread

You appear to have misinterpreted my points, so it's not a surprise they appear "bizarre".

I don't understand how anyone can be so complacent about this, and dismiss what these men admit to as "bravado"

Assuming this is, again, a reference to my point, I did not "dismiss this as bravado". I made the point that in blind surveys which have no consequences for the respondents, the data can be skewed by the fact that the freedom from consequence means people are at liberty to lie, embellish, and engage in bravado, partly because they know there is no comeback, but also out of sheer devilment because they know it will produce wonky results.

I have personal experience of this phenomenon in action, but I'm not going to get into specifics because it involves certain unsavoury topics that I don't really want to discuss, and they aren't really appropriate for this topic.

Just so we're absolutely clear here, the comments and arguments I've made in this thread were prompted by, and solely in relation to, another poster bringing up this study.

When I've referred to not seeing the point in wasting time worrying about a hypothetical, the hypothetical in question is a society where all the instruments of state listed have broken down irretrievably, where people do not practice safeguarding and vigilance, and where there is no fear whatsoever of consequence. This is not the society we live in, nor is it ever likely to be, so this is why I see no point in spending time worrying about this particular hypothetical.

What I am emphatically NOT suggesting, and never have, is that people should not concern themselves with CSA, or be vigilant with regard to the welfare of their children, and I certainly have not implied that CSA would only become an issue of concern is society broke down into anarchy.

I am also in no way "complacent", merely highlighting that the study posits a situation that is not comparable to real life, or how society actually functions, so that needs held in mind when we are talking about real life, and real society.

WillowCraft · 07/12/2023 19:37

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/12/2023 18:52

Being concerned about CSA is never a "waste of time"

Just as well I wasn't referring to CSA then, isn't it?

Go back and read the post again. It's abundantly clear that's a reference to a situation whereby society has descended into unfettered anarchy.

Your point that it would require a breakdown of society to make child abuse a real concern is painfully wrong

I have never made any such point.

Your point doesn't make much sense. You seem to be saying that in an anarchist society 1 in 20 men would commit paedophilic acts, but not to worry, as we are in a society that has controls it's only 1 in 100.
For a start 1 in 100 is not that different to 1 in 20. Secondly that's the conviction rate. The real rate must be at least double .

But even if it isn't, 1 in 100 men is say a 1 in 20 chance if there are 5 men in your own family who have access to your child. Or if your child has a few sleepovers, a couple of male primary teachers, goes to a couple of sports clubs etc, it could soon get to a much higher chance than that , that they'd be in a position where an adult male they know and trust has malign intentions.

Nothing about that is vanishingly rare.

If I've misunderstood what you meant I think you need to clarify as I've read your post carefully.

Vettrianofan · 07/12/2023 19:33

Peer on peer abuse can happen too. Don't be so fixated on the most obvious types of abuse. It can happen to anyone by anyone.

WillowCraft · 07/12/2023 19:26

GirrlCrush · 07/12/2023 18:47

Also, I'd like to make the point that many many woman facilitate the abuse if not participate

Turn a blind eye....help set it up.... it happens.

Turning a blind eye to avoid trouble in the family is common

Begsthequestion · 07/12/2023 19:11

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/12/2023 18:56

No, I did not.

You have completely misinterpreted my post, which happens from time to time, but I most assuredly have not made any such point, or "argued against" vigilance, or dismissed CSA as not worth worrying about.

You have made some very bizarre arguments on this thread.

I just looked at the report, and it is sickening. I don't understand how anyone can be so complacent about this, and dismiss what these men admit to as "bravado".

https://childlight.org/searchlight-2023-dashboard

Searchlight 2023 Dashboard | Childlight

Childlight's Flagship Report represents the first of its kind in understanding the nature of CSEA globally. It lays the groundwork for us to understand who benefits from CSEA as well as the burden it places on society. Our hope is that by shining a lig...

https://childlight.org/searchlight-2023-dashboard

peachgreen · 07/12/2023 19:02

I was molested by a family member as a child and although I am fairly well-adjusted about it now (I think!) it does make me wary when it comes to DD, even with my own family. It took me a long time to leave her alone with DP. I don’t think I put that fear on to her, although we do talk about privacy and bodies and consent etc.

Arwen7 · 07/12/2023 19:02

My DP works with the police and sadly meets them all the time... usually done for child pornography. It upsets me so much how many cases there are. So, while it is unhealthy to distrust people like this and we shouldn't leave in fear, it would also be naive to think evil is not out there and it can be literally anyone. I have a DD too so I totally empathise with you. I try to stay positive and not become paranoid without a reason, plenty lovely men out there too, but definitely my radar is always switched on. X

GirrlCrush · 07/12/2023 19:00

It's not a type as such more a presentation....normal

They walk amongst us

As for sleepovers.... my DD was filmed in the shower at a sleepover....by the friends older sister and her boyfriend!