Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed with DM about her Christmas fund?

295 replies

PurpleSky300 · 07/12/2023 16:09

My Mum (60) works part-time and sometimes struggles for money at Christmas.

We have Christmas with extended family and pool together so we’re never short of anything, but she would like to have a bit more personal spending money and stuff to buy nice presents. Anyway, as a result - 3 of my family agreed last year that we would pay monthly amounts into a Christmas fund for her and by the start of December, we’d got about £800. I transferred it over and within a week, she’s spent about £500 and hardly any of that is on presents. It’s all gone on normal things like groceries, petrol, cat food and now she won’t have enough left for Christmas itself and it feels like we’re back at square one.

I know I probably shouldn’t be annoyed. She said, “When you haven’t got much money, the necessities have to come before luxuries” etc and that’s true. And she said she could top up her spending money from her wages in December anyway. To me that’s not really the point, though? This money was ‘ringfenced’ for Xmas, that was the whole point of it. So that she would be able to go out and do more things, go on nights out, buy treats and enjoy the festivities. I feel annoyed that it’s gone on mundane daily stuff and part of me begrudges doing it again next year. Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
pollyglot · 08/12/2023 00:22

PuzzledObserver · Yesterday 22:38

As a 60 year old woman, I think it's a bit of a reach to say that we've known for "decades" that we wouldn't get our state pension at 60. I can't honestly say when I became aware of it, but it isn't "decades" by any means, and at the start of my working life it was certainly the expectation that 60 was when we'd retire

As a woman in her 74th year, I reiterate... for decades, long before I turned 60, we were aware that women would not be collecting their state pension at 60. I distinctly recall that there was an awful lot of heads-in-sand stuff going on, and strident cries of "being cheated out of our rights" and "stolen money". Any woman born in the 50s or later who has grown up since the birth of feminism would have to be stupid not to recognise that they would need to supplement their state pension by one means or another. And to see that the pension as it was was unsustainable. There was plenty of warning about saving/ISAs/private pensions being essential in the future. Spending ludicrous amounts of money on frivolous "stuff" at Christmas just because you are swept up in the frenzy of the herd mentality is plain foolish.

BOOTS52PollyPrissyPants · 07/12/2023 23:13

You know when you are on low wages and then you get some extra cash it is nice to catch up with bills, and stock up on food. She could have spent it on silly xmas presents that no one will even use.
Go easy on her as she must have needed to buy what she did and hard living on your own and surviving as everything so expensive.

TeaKitten · 07/12/2023 22:55

ElfontheShelfIsWATCHINGYOUTOO · 07/12/2023 22:47

Only read first page.
It sounds like she's struggling so much, it's not like she spent it on her hair.

I wonder why not have monthly savings to top her up a little each month anyway? It sounds like even 40 a month would be helpful and set aside less for her than 800 for Xmas...

I think this money has been a huge boost for for her and she's enjoyed it, let her enjoy it

You should atleast reads the OPs posts, save wasted questions.

ElfontheShelfIsWATCHINGYOUTOO · 07/12/2023 22:47

Only read first page.
It sounds like she's struggling so much, it's not like she spent it on her hair.

I wonder why not have monthly savings to top her up a little each month anyway? It sounds like even 40 a month would be helpful and set aside less for her than 800 for Xmas...

I think this money has been a huge boost for for her and she's enjoyed it, let her enjoy it

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 07/12/2023 22:45

When I was working full time years ago and / or being a stay at home mum, my retirement age would have been 60.

Then I believe it increased to 62 ? gradually up to 65 - in line with men.

Now my retirement age is 67, so I have just over 4 years to go and believe me I am counting them down on one hand.

Not every job can you increase your hours in, I can't - I have asked on more than one occasion 5 members of staff left recently and I was told there was no budget to replace them.

Also it is not that easy to get a new job, I have been applying for other jobs since March.

I would have suggested Mum finds out if there are any benefits she could claim, but then I read there is a partner whom I guess she lives with and I believe that would exclude any assistance via benefits.

PuzzledObserver · 07/12/2023 22:38

As a 60 year old woman, I think it's a bit of a reach to say that we've known for "decades" that we wouldn't get our state pension at 60. I can't honestly say when I became aware of it, but it isn't "decades" by any means, and at the start of my working life it was certainly the expectation that 60 was when we'd retire

I turn 60 next year. When I graduated at 22 I joined a firm with a traditional occupational pensions scheme, in which retirement age was 65 for men and 63 for women. A couple of years later, female employees were given the option of accepting an equalised pension age of 65, which I did. State pension age was still 60 for women, but my expectation - more than 30 years ago - was that I would work to 65.

The change to state pension age was being mooted at that time - late 80’s/early 90’s. The act which introduced the change of state pension age for women was passed in 1995 - originally to be phased in between 2010 and 2020, but later accelerated.

But yes, decades. It’s been on the cards for decades.

PurpleSky300 · 07/12/2023 22:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

She didn't. You might want to check some of the later updates to the thread.

OP posts:
Mischance · 07/12/2023 22:00

I really think this emphasis on spend spend spend at Christmas is not great. Why not simply recognise that her contribution to the festivities and presents will be smaller because her budget is smaller and not try and help her to keep up? Various members of my family have been in assorted financial states over the years and when we know one person/family is a bit stretched financially then less is expected of them. We just welcome their company and presence for the Christmas period, even if they cannot afford much (or indeed anything).

WandaWonder · 07/12/2023 21:51

Yeah OK then, I wonder if our children will feel entitled to boss us around when we get older

Quitelikeit · 07/12/2023 21:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

UsingChangeofName · 07/12/2023 21:45

The amount of people who seem to think that I'm leaving my poor Mum starving or something is absolutely absurd. Talk about jumping to conclusions.

Not 'jumping to conclusions', but responding to what you put in your opening post. You implied that she didn't have enough for necessities and you were cross that she spent money you gave her to buy other people present, on sorting out her essentials.
That's what all the first 3 (?) pages of replies were replying to.

I contribute heavily towards my Mum's groceries and petrol costs every week, all year round. Her partner pays the bills, pays her car insurance, pays for holidays, and all other domestic costs. Her DB sorts out repairs and most DIY things if they ever need help in the house. They have no mortgage.

If you had put this ^ information in at the start, then everyone would have replied differently.

I, for one, would be asking you why on earth you are giving a woman who has no mortgage, has all her bills paid, her insurances, her repairs, her groceries and petrol all year round paid, whilst she is still earning herself, £800 for any reason. Confused

Couldyounot · 07/12/2023 21:44

I get it, OP. You were all trying to do something nice and give your Mum something for special treats and instead she's just used it as general bunse. I think I'd find that a bit trying too.

Twiglets1 · 07/12/2023 21:29

Quitelikeit · 07/12/2023 21:23

So the boyfriend pays for the house and bills

She works full time so must earn about 1500 a month?

Would I hell be giving her £800!

She works part time

Meowandthen · 07/12/2023 21:28

You gave money in the expectation you’d be given most of it back in presents?

You really think that’s better than paying essential bills?

So much for the season of giving and goodwill.

allmyliesaretrue · 07/12/2023 21:24

PurpleSky300 · 07/12/2023 21:06

Exactly. And it is very hard to 'challenge' anyone like this or broach the topic of budgeting when it comes to this type of incremental, drip-drip-drip spending because they will immediately say, "Do you want me to starve?! Do you want my hair to look scruffy and grow all down my back?!" - just like a few PPs have in this thread. And I genuinely do think that people deserve a few treats in life, and plenty of people have them - it's just that sometimes you have to cut your cloth as well.

I get you. I am the same age as your mother and I work FT to continue to support my kids - one to save for a deposit for a house, and two in FT education, one with no funding.

It's shocking to me that she expects her children to support her financially! I wouldn't dream of that - well not unless they were hugely rich and successful!!

She's taking the piss!!

Quitelikeit · 07/12/2023 21:23

So the boyfriend pays for the house and bills

She works full time so must earn about 1500 a month?

Would I hell be giving her £800!

JaffavsCookie · 07/12/2023 21:17

I disagree with PP that she is of a generation that didn’t expect to be working, I am the same age and working fulltime. Is there a specific reason she doesn’t work full time OP, if she is short of money then it is the obvious solution ( I actually also have an extra part time role to top up my money and allow me to save more for my retirement)

istolethetalisker · 07/12/2023 21:17

PurpleSky300 · 07/12/2023 21:09

It's the second scenario, yes. I do appreciate I could have explained it better. It might have spared me so much bile! I was trying not to give details that I thought might be outing. Lesson learned 😮

Oh dear. Poor PurpleSky300. I think you've had a really rotten day. Flowers

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 07/12/2023 21:13

PurpleSky300 · 07/12/2023 21:09

It's the second scenario, yes. I do appreciate I could have explained it better. It might have spared me so much bile! I was trying not to give details that I thought might be outing. Lesson learned 😮

I dunno. Quite early on You said she had no mortgage, a partner paying bills and you and her brother helping her out. To be it seemed obvious there was spending beyond absolute necessities.

Sadly some people will always waste whatever money they have. My parents are similar. Any spare is spent. As a child I’d be asking for beans from my aunty for dinner one minutes and watching sky while dad hoovers with the Dyson the next minute.

PurpleSky300 · 07/12/2023 21:09

istolethetalisker · 07/12/2023 21:07

OP, I think you explained it badly and now people are piling on because you've misrepresented things a bit.

From your first post, it sounds like you gave your Mum some money for Xmas, which she immediately spent on essential food and bills because she's broke, cold and hungry, and you're now cross because she didn't go to Harrods to buy a scarf. Which does sound a bit let-them-eat-cake.

But what actually happened was you gave your perfectly warm and well-fed but terrible-at-budgeting Mum some money for specifically Xmas shopping, and she immediately frittered it away doing some slightly-nicer-than-usual regular shopping, and is now going to complain she's broke when she goes to do her Xmas shopping.

Is that right? Because if the first scenario YABU, but if the second scenario YANBU, I'd be cross too. And would only ever give her vouchers in future.

It's the second scenario, yes. I do appreciate I could have explained it better. It might have spared me so much bile! I was trying not to give details that I thought might be outing. Lesson learned 😮

OP posts:
allmyliesaretrue · 07/12/2023 21:08

pollyglot · 07/12/2023 18:16

telestrations · Today 16:27

Unless there is more to this you are annoyed that your mother is poor.

She is of a generation that did not except to be working, let alone working and struggling at 60. That use to be the retirement age for women. She will continue to work and struggle unless her family steps in and tops her income up for her which is what many adult children do. I do and am just happy that I am able to.

Again unless there is more to it perhaps you should consider topping up by a regular amount each month

Quite frankly I can't imagine leaving my parents without food, petrol or pet food Edited

The woman is only 60! In no way is this a generational thing. Woman have been aware for decades that they would need to be working way longer than 60. From the sound of it, she has possibly never worked full-time to enable herself to save and build up a decent pension pot. Is she disabled? Is it not possible to find another part-time job or boost her hours, or be a little more proactive about supporting herself? I think you are perfectly within your rights to wonder about her attitude towards money.

As a 60 year old woman, I think it's a bit of a reach to say that we've known for "decades" that we wouldn't get our state pension at 60. I can't honestly say when I became aware of it, but it isn't "decades" by any means, and at the start of my working life it was certainly the expectation that 60 was when we'd retire, yet the goalposts were moved by a whole 7 years which is a hell of a lot! My mum retired at 60/61 due to health issues and only lived 2 years into retirement. I don't want that to be me. I've got things I want to do. She did too.

Right up until she died, my mother was helping me, not the other way round!! I had three children, a mortgage and massive childcare costs. She knew it wasn't easy and my mum and dad just wanted to help us. They bought me and my kids clothes, nice treats, food, paid my phone bill (tbf it was mostly run up ringing her and my dad!) - all the stuff I couldn't afford! When money ran really tight, a cheque for £100 would land in my letterbox... they bought my kids a beautiful piano when they started piano lessons and paid for a holiday abroad because they thought our kids were missing out because we just couldn't afford it... We had Christmas every single year at my parents' home, and they paid for it all.

The idea that my kids would have to subsidise me is such a mad concept to me!! I must show them!!!!

istolethetalisker · 07/12/2023 21:07

OP, I think you explained it badly and now people are piling on because you've misrepresented things a bit.

From your first post, it sounds like you gave your Mum some money for Xmas, which she immediately spent on essential food and bills because she's broke, cold and hungry, and you're now cross because she didn't go to Harrods to buy a scarf. Which does sound a bit let-them-eat-cake.

But what actually happened was you gave your perfectly warm and well-fed but terrible-at-budgeting Mum some money for specifically Xmas shopping, and she immediately frittered it away doing some slightly-nicer-than-usual regular shopping, and is now going to complain she's broke when she goes to do her Xmas shopping.

Is that right? Because if the first scenario YABU, but if the second scenario YANBU, I'd be cross too. And would only ever give her vouchers in future.

PurpleSky300 · 07/12/2023 21:06

LardyCakeAgain · 07/12/2023 21:00

Now we have the bigger picture, I really feel for you, as one of my parents is the same - even down to the spending free time wandering various supermarkets buying treats. One pension between the two of them doesn't go far when someone doesn't keep track of what they're spending (and "tap to pay" card machines have made it even worse). Sorry that you feel the savings you all made went up in smoke.

Exactly. And it is very hard to 'challenge' anyone like this or broach the topic of budgeting when it comes to this type of incremental, drip-drip-drip spending because they will immediately say, "Do you want me to starve?! Do you want my hair to look scruffy and grow all down my back?!" - just like a few PPs have in this thread. And I genuinely do think that people deserve a few treats in life, and plenty of people have them - it's just that sometimes you have to cut your cloth as well.

OP posts:
Thelaundryfairyhasbeenassassinated · 07/12/2023 21:05

@Haveallthesongsbeenwritten and you need to read the bloody updates before calling someone horrible.

ExcitingRicotta · 07/12/2023 21:04

PurpleSky300 · 07/12/2023 20:52

People are piling on a bit so I want to say something about necessities and budgeting.

Let’s say you get your weekly grocery shop from Tesco with all your usual items – that’s a necessity. But then you find yourself popping into M & S for wine, Percy Pigs, chocolate nuts, pizza on a Friday and then you go to Morrisons for bread and flowers and pretty soon, that ‘necessary’ food shop has cost you twice as much.

Or clothes. Basic clothes are a necessity but what if you buy a top one day, and then you feel that you need the right shoes with it, and then you see a scarf you can’t resist… and on and on.

This is what my Mum is like. They are necessities on some level but she is also impulsive, she doesn’t tally her spends and she has more free time to roam around and spend than someone who works 40 hours a week. She will spend £70 on a haircut and a bunch of flowers and then be aghast when the car is running out of petrol. It is a mixture of bad budgeting and not having the means to cover all the ‘extras’ that other people might take for granted.

When I was growing up, my Mum and I were bailiff-broke, gas-cut-off broke, no-money-for-school-shoes broke and she was out of work for a long time. Then I got a decent job and Mum’s DP entered the picture - things got a hell of a lot better very quickly and she adjusted to a different lifestyle. I help her out because a) I am fortunate to be well paid and I remember those shitty days very well and b) although her DP pays for a lot, he expects personal spends like make-up and hair and whatever to come out of her wage and it genuinely doesn’t leave a lot.

So then you are definitely not unreasonable to be miffed she’s not used the money as intended but maybe you shouldn’t be surprised! I probably wouldn’t do it again if it’s not been used for its intended purpose and you’re already financially supporting her in other ways.