Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed with DM about her Christmas fund?

295 replies

PurpleSky300 · 07/12/2023 16:09

My Mum (60) works part-time and sometimes struggles for money at Christmas.

We have Christmas with extended family and pool together so we’re never short of anything, but she would like to have a bit more personal spending money and stuff to buy nice presents. Anyway, as a result - 3 of my family agreed last year that we would pay monthly amounts into a Christmas fund for her and by the start of December, we’d got about £800. I transferred it over and within a week, she’s spent about £500 and hardly any of that is on presents. It’s all gone on normal things like groceries, petrol, cat food and now she won’t have enough left for Christmas itself and it feels like we’re back at square one.

I know I probably shouldn’t be annoyed. She said, “When you haven’t got much money, the necessities have to come before luxuries” etc and that’s true. And she said she could top up her spending money from her wages in December anyway. To me that’s not really the point, though? This money was ‘ringfenced’ for Xmas, that was the whole point of it. So that she would be able to go out and do more things, go on nights out, buy treats and enjoy the festivities. I feel annoyed that it’s gone on mundane daily stuff and part of me begrudges doing it again next year. Am I being unreasonable?

OP posts:
laraitopbanana · 08/12/2023 20:02

Sorry not heat, rather food or groceries

« It’s all gone on normal things like groceries, petrol, cat food and now she won’t have enough left for Christmas itself »

what will you do if she calls without groceries money...?

Greatdomestic · 08/12/2023 19:53

Hi op

I sometimes read things on here and wonder what planet some people are on.

I am only a couple of years younger than your mum. I work full time and expect to do so until I am 65. I see no reason why an able bodied person who needs to work full time should not do so.

I am shocked at your mums approach. She spends her cash on her, and everyone else including you her child, pays for her essentials. Awful. If I were you I would stop her gravy train right now. No amount of £ will ever be enough. She will keep tapping you for cash. Tell her to get a full time job, cos you are done funding her. I'll bet your husband isn't enthused by this either. The old adage 'bleed Rockafeller dry' applies here.

As has already been noted, it has been common knowledge since the 80s that government would not fund retirements if they could help it. Raising retirement age is part of that.

OldPerson · 08/12/2023 19:32

You're not thinking about DM's needs. I'm sure DM would rather the cat was fed than go out for a night on the town. So what does she need for a great Christmas and what do you need? And why did they transfer all the money to her? Were they expecting her to think up all the presents and fun for everyone? Or did they just not want her to be stressed at Christmas? The 3 cash contributors need to sit down and agree what the money should be spent on and if they're happy or not. You sound a little entitled and immature if you think the money raised was centrally for your benefit and fun. And I also suspect you didn't contribute.

PuzzledObserver · 08/12/2023 18:52

@pollyglot the bit you quoted wasn’t from me. I quoted it from someone else and then explained why I didn’t agree with it.

Yes, we have known for decades. There was loads of publicity about it.

JS06 · 08/12/2023 18:48

I don’t consider you’re unreasonable. You sound like the kind of family that are willing to support and help. Your DM has possibly been relieved at a source of income to help. I sense you would have appreciated a heads up that the intention for ‘Christmas’ had been somewhat railroaded. It would defo inform my choices about next year.

itsmylife7 · 08/12/2023 18:42

So you had a terrible childhood due to your Mothers "spending"

She obviously hasn't changed OP.

She's got everyone running around and bailing her out.... clever woman.

DeedlessIndeed · 08/12/2023 18:33

laraitopbanana · 08/12/2023 18:05

It sounds a bit harsh for you to decide that she should go without before Xmas...
if it really bothering you, next year, send the money right before Xmas or pay the outings yourself from the fund...but then what will you do if she calls and tell you she hasn’t got heat...would you not do exactly what she did?

How will she go without heat?

RTFT - her partner pays all bills. She has no mortgage. OP pays fuel and personal spends every month...

Mum is a spendthrift that cannot budget and has blown a nice gesture.

laraitopbanana · 08/12/2023 18:05

It sounds a bit harsh for you to decide that she should go without before Xmas...
if it really bothering you, next year, send the money right before Xmas or pay the outings yourself from the fund...but then what will you do if she calls and tell you she hasn’t got heat...would you not do exactly what she did?

MMAS · 08/12/2023 17:57

Have any of you actually bothered to find out how much money your mother has to live on - there is no mention of a Dad in your post. Sounds like she is really struggling and all you are bothered about is Xmas presents and the like. Time to grow up, have some compassion, be less selfish and, most of all take care of what may be the only parent you have as parents only come around once in a life time.

Bakingbread · 08/12/2023 17:46

YABVVVU

AlwaysFreezing · 08/12/2023 16:24

I definitely the think the worst gifts are ones with conditions.

Give freely, with joy. Your life will be simpler.

LookItsMeAgain · 08/12/2023 15:02

If I were you @PurpleSky300 , I'd start putting money aside for when she is really is dire straits and needs money to cover either medical expenses or care or something else that would be really expensive.

I've read all of your posts and your mum is an impulse shopper and doesn't stick to a budget. She never has. She overspent when you were young and she never had to learn how to budget then. When her DP came on the scene it was the opposite, there was a steady stream of money if she needed it so it never dawned on her that she should budget and spend wisely then either.

Stop funding her lifestyle.

That's my updated take on the situation.

LookItsMeAgain · 08/12/2023 14:58

Does she not budget? She would have had to get the stuff she spent the Christmas Fund money on anyway surely??

Sounds like she really needs to work and stick to a budget for the daily essentials if you're planning on doing another Christmas Fund for Christmas 2024.

I don't think you are being unreasonable in that.

However if she was really struggling and she absolutely couldn't get by without dipping into the fund to cover the essentials, then I think a little latitude wouldn't go amiss there.

LimeCheesecake · 08/12/2023 14:28

Oh OP - when you were young you took in the parenting role, accepting your mother couldn’t be expected to look after herself, and between you, siblings and her boyfriend, managed to avoid your mum having to learn to budget. So even though she was once “bailiff broke” levels, she’s never learned.

Its time to stop. If her mortgage and bills are paid, and even if she only works 2 days a week on minimum wage- she doesn’t need you to save through the year for her Christmas treats. She needs to budget her own money. (Particularly if you are also subsidising her through the year with food shopping).

and her boyfriend might need to be serious with her about their finances. (And if she can true it afford to work part time.)

next year buy her things, buy her tickets, but don’t give this woman cash.

your mum won’t change. It’s not your job to look after her.

hydriotaphia · 08/12/2023 14:20

YABU and from spending £500 I'm guessing she paid off debt rather then just spent it.

Houseplantmad · 08/12/2023 14:14

Perhaps next time it might be better for you to order a big grocery shop for her with all the Christmassy bits in it, so she doesn’t spend the money on other things. And she could do an Amazon wish list or similar for presents and one of you could fund that?
It sounds as if you’re doing an awful lot for her, which is a very kind thing to do.

toomuchfaff · 08/12/2023 14:01

YABVU

If your mum is struggling so much that this Xmas money had to be spent on essentials; why are you annoyed? That she bought groceries? Its not like she bought a 16ft inflatable santa or spent the money at the casino? She didnt squander it; she bought groceries... Maybe you should be wondering whether the family should be giving her money routinely...

BoredofBlonde · 08/12/2023 12:23

billyt · 08/12/2023 11:54

I can never understand justifying things by saying this. The mother chose to have a baby. So carrying a baby in a womb for nine months was the mothers choice, not the baby's.

And how do you know what the mother gave during the chid's life? Not every parent puts their child first or cares for them.

Totally agree! Well said. It is the laziest kind of justification for a parent behaving badly/ selfishly

BoredofBlonde · 08/12/2023 12:21

Meowandthen · 07/12/2023 21:28

You gave money in the expectation you’d be given most of it back in presents?

You really think that’s better than paying essential bills?

So much for the season of giving and goodwill.

And the award for not seeing the real problem goes to you! Though many are in competition with you for the prize 🙄

billyt · 08/12/2023 11:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I can never understand justifying things by saying this. The mother chose to have a baby. So carrying a baby in a womb for nine months was the mothers choice, not the baby's.

And how do you know what the mother gave during the chid's life? Not every parent puts their child first or cares for them.

housethatbuiltme · 08/12/2023 10:26

OP I don't want to sound mean but your mam is a scrounger.

I have no issue with her working part time or anything like that but you have to live in your means. If you do not have money you cannot have luxury hair cuts, flowers, a parliament of cats and treat.

STOP FUNDING HER.

If she wastes all her spending money on luxuries the day she gets it and has nothing for the rest of the month then tough shit she is not OWED luxury. Given she is fortunate to have the actual necessarily paid for by her partner you do not need to give her anything. Its not actually 'helping' her its like buying heroin for a junkie.

TorroFerney · 08/12/2023 09:57

Meowandthen · 07/12/2023 21:28

You gave money in the expectation you’d be given most of it back in presents?

You really think that’s better than paying essential bills?

So much for the season of giving and goodwill.

I think you've not read it properly.

Op, I get being annoyed but part of this is perhaps you are cross at yourself for expecting her to be different this time and she isn't? Perhaps next time she moans about money to get presents (if she does) then don't jump in with a solution ie giving her money, just sympathise and say that sounds hard what are you going to do. And remember the oldadage, no good deed goes unpunished.

Tempnamechng · 08/12/2023 09:38

I'm picturing your mother, in fact, are you my sister's SIL? 🤣 My sister's mother in law matches your description of your mother perfectly. She flits from one part time job to another - usually gets sacked for overstepping or talking too much and heavily relies on her dc, whether they can afford to help or not. She isn't really broke, just bad with money and frivolous. She lives in a big house that she refuses to sell but can't upkeep, and relies heavily on her dc for food and bills, when they have their own dc and much more modest homes to support.

Ffsnotaconference · 08/12/2023 03:43

BOOTS52PollyPrissyPants · 07/12/2023 23:13

You know when you are on low wages and then you get some extra cash it is nice to catch up with bills, and stock up on food. She could have spent it on silly xmas presents that no one will even use.
Go easy on her as she must have needed to buy what she did and hard living on your own and surviving as everything so expensive.

She isn’t on her own. She has a dp who pays all her bills and op also helps her out with petrol and food.

Ffsnotaconference · 08/12/2023 03:42

PurpleSky300 · 07/12/2023 20:52

People are piling on a bit so I want to say something about necessities and budgeting.

Let’s say you get your weekly grocery shop from Tesco with all your usual items – that’s a necessity. But then you find yourself popping into M & S for wine, Percy Pigs, chocolate nuts, pizza on a Friday and then you go to Morrisons for bread and flowers and pretty soon, that ‘necessary’ food shop has cost you twice as much.

Or clothes. Basic clothes are a necessity but what if you buy a top one day, and then you feel that you need the right shoes with it, and then you see a scarf you can’t resist… and on and on.

This is what my Mum is like. They are necessities on some level but she is also impulsive, she doesn’t tally her spends and she has more free time to roam around and spend than someone who works 40 hours a week. She will spend £70 on a haircut and a bunch of flowers and then be aghast when the car is running out of petrol. It is a mixture of bad budgeting and not having the means to cover all the ‘extras’ that other people might take for granted.

When I was growing up, my Mum and I were bailiff-broke, gas-cut-off broke, no-money-for-school-shoes broke and she was out of work for a long time. Then I got a decent job and Mum’s DP entered the picture - things got a hell of a lot better very quickly and she adjusted to a different lifestyle. I help her out because a) I am fortunate to be well paid and I remember those shitty days very well and b) although her DP pays for a lot, he expects personal spends like make-up and hair and whatever to come out of her wage and it genuinely doesn’t leave a lot.

Genuinely doesn’t leave a lot?

He expects her personal spends to come out of her own money? Of course he does. He pays all the bills. You post as though he has an obligation to cover all her bills. I earned 3 times what my ex dp did, I covered the majority of the bills. Damn right I expected him to cover his own personal spends.

The only reason I could think he would need to cover her personal spends is if she was a sahp.

The fact is that she is bad with money. You also contribute and have been conditioned to feel sorry for her. You described them as necessities. But they aren’t. She has treated herself. Not in the way you wanted. But she has been treating herself. By ‘popping into m&s for pizza and wine’, because she wouldn’t normally, she has treated herself.

But she has somehow managed to spend the money treating herself and convinced you the spending is proof that she is poor. The whole ‘when you are poor necessities come first’ line is absolute rubbish. Bad with money and poor can be 2 different things.

The things you gave her the money to do, she isn’t interested in doing. Or she would do them. She would have spent money on them before whether she could afford it or not.

I have been skint. Like, after bills and food I had no spare money, skint. Then I was getting more in debt every month type skint. Then I started earning a bit more and slowly I have spare money after sorting the debt. In the middle stages, if I got a new top but needed new shoes to go with it and I couldn’t afford the new shoes I just didn’t get them the shoes until next month. If I needed a hair cut and I didn’t have the money. It waited.

Your mum isn’t ’just bad with money’ she just knows that everyone else will see her right so she doesn’t have to be better with money.

I think your gesture came from the right place and you sound like you really want to help her. But it’s also sounds like you are waking up from her manipulation around money. She might be a lovely mum in all other ways, but she has you convinced that she is poor when she isn’t really. She is making choices that leave her without money. And she has you convinced it’s everyone else’s responsibility to help her because she is poor. She isn’t really poor. She is spent.

She needs to earn more money if she wants to be able to get the new shoes and a scarf and a top all at the same time. But even if she earned more money, she would still be in the same situation. She would spend everything she has and still come asking for money.

Swipe left for the next trending thread