Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Blazing row about Michael Jackson

644 replies

PLP432 · 07/12/2023 12:44

I know it sounds ridiculous on the face of it but hear me out.

I was in a shop with DP last night and they were playing Michael Jackson music. I commented that I don't like hearing his music as I can't get past everything he did. Yes, I know he wasn't convicted but he openly admitted to sleeping in bed with random children, showering together and whatever else.

DP said "we have different opinions on that, he's a really good artist" to which I replied something about Rolph Harris being a good artist and Jimmy Saville being a good fund raiser.

DP then goes on to say he doesn't think MJ did anything untoward with the children and he thinks it's all innocent and because he had a "childlike mind" due to not having a proper childhood.

I said that was no excuse and plenty of people have bad or unusual childhoods and don't groom children.

He was getting defensive and talking about how he was found not guilty in court, to which I pointed out how few rape and sexual abuse cases even make it to court let alone conviction.

I asked whether he'd listened to anything the men on Leaving Neverland said before he formed his opinion that MJ wasn't guilty of anything. He said no, and refused to look it up.

It descended into a row and I was very hurt by some of the things he said, as I have a history of child sexual abuse and rape - which he knows all about.

I asked him whether he would have gladly left our DS in the company of someone like MJ unsupervised and he took a while to answer before saying "I don't know"

I said how that concerned me from a safeguarding perspective to which he took huge offence, started shouting and told me to return all of the presents i'd bought him as he doesnt want them anymore, the immature dickhead.

Now we're not talking.

Was I being unreasonable here?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
Begsthequestion · 07/12/2023 13:52

MaryMcCarthy · 07/12/2023 13:01

There's no reason to re-visit anything Rolf Harris or Jimmy Savile did.

Michael Jackson however was one of the most outstanding and popular artists of the 20th century and that's not going to change. His songs and his voice didn't become bad as a result of his behaviour. They are still good songs. And he's no longer profiting from them, so what's the issue?

His victims are still alive, and have to live in a culture where their abuser is still celebrated, defended and promoted.

That alone puts me off.

InTheRainOnATrain · 07/12/2023 13:51

His eldest had social services involvement because DP and his ex were spending time with, and allowing DSD to spend time with, a convicted paedophile as they thought it was all just 'malicious rumours'
OK that explains why you have safeguarding concerns. It’s got everything to do with his lack of prior judgement and has nothing to do with MJ. Don’t make your real world concerns about a long dead celebrity, it makes you sound bonkers when actually this is really concerning.

Jztbrzzsy · 07/12/2023 13:50

It's one thing to like his music/enjoy hearing his songs, it's another to assert that 'oh actually he didn't reeeaaalllyyy abuse kids'.

Like any prolific abuser (thinking of Saville here as well) - his weirdo, in MJs case - childlike persona was likely developed specifically so he could abuse kids and fly under the radar.

MidnightMeltdown · 07/12/2023 13:49

YABU

It sounds like you've picked a fight about something ridiculous. You are free to not like or listen to MJ music, but that doesn't mean that everyone else must feel the same!

Didimum · 07/12/2023 13:48

While I don’t disagree with you on MJ, I think you were both unreasonable to allow it to escalate the way it did – and you’re still not talking? You’re husband is most likely not a safeguarding risk due to an argument on MJ, nor can any case over him be conclusively proven or disproven (in regard to the law), so it’s very stupid to have such a blazing row over it.

Esgaroth · 07/12/2023 13:47

I agree with your perspective but I wouldn't have started an argument about it. When he said 'we have different opinions' I would have left it.

Scruffington · 07/12/2023 13:46

an actual convicted paedophile not just someone there were rumours about.

yikes.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 07/12/2023 13:46

PLP432 · 07/12/2023 13:35

I don't actually have any problem with him liking his music, I mean you wouldn't see me playing it at home but if he likes it then whatever. I know as mentioned some can separate the art from the artist so to speak.

What really upset me was how he said with such confidence that he doesn't believe he did anything wrong, he was innocent and childlike, he wasn't convicted therefore it couldn't have been true.

I will admit that my own personal history means I'm quite sensitive about topics like this.

I think, knowing what he knows about my history, he shouldn't have said all he said. He's entitled to enjoy the music but undermining the victims and declaring the man's innocence when he has never bothered to look into the allegations really upset me.

For what it's worth as I think it's relevant there is history of him choosing to see the good in people that he shouldn't. His eldest had social services involvement because DP and his ex were spending time with, and allowing DSD to spend time with, a convicted paedophile as they thought it was all just 'malicious rumours'

I didn't know about this until years later.

So yes, it's a very loaded topic and I feel so hurt and yes alarmed that this is his attitude towards CSA.

That makes a lot of sense, OP.

I am sorry you´re having such a hard time on this thread.

As I previously wrote:

Separating music (film, fashion etc.) from the creator is one thing. And there are (imo) convincing arguments for that approach.

But defending the creator - which is what your DP did - is a completely different matter.
I would be upset about that as well. Even without the additional information you chose to share.

NonPlayerCharacter · 07/12/2023 13:46

PLP432 · 07/12/2023 13:35

I don't actually have any problem with him liking his music, I mean you wouldn't see me playing it at home but if he likes it then whatever. I know as mentioned some can separate the art from the artist so to speak.

What really upset me was how he said with such confidence that he doesn't believe he did anything wrong, he was innocent and childlike, he wasn't convicted therefore it couldn't have been true.

I will admit that my own personal history means I'm quite sensitive about topics like this.

I think, knowing what he knows about my history, he shouldn't have said all he said. He's entitled to enjoy the music but undermining the victims and declaring the man's innocence when he has never bothered to look into the allegations really upset me.

For what it's worth as I think it's relevant there is history of him choosing to see the good in people that he shouldn't. His eldest had social services involvement because DP and his ex were spending time with, and allowing DSD to spend time with, a convicted paedophile as they thought it was all just 'malicious rumours'

I didn't know about this until years later.

So yes, it's a very loaded topic and I feel so hurt and yes alarmed that this is his attitude towards CSA.

Well that's a separate issue really, and explains why you got so upset. On some level, you feel he isn't taking your history seriously and doesn't safeguard family properly.

Oblomov23 · 07/12/2023 13:46

Dh and I always liked his music. I had my suspicions well before the trials. The neverland documentary I believed both men completely. Makes me cringe now, I actually shudder writing this.

Scruffington · 07/12/2023 13:46

For what it's worth as I think it's relevant there is history of him choosing to see the good in people that he shouldn't. His eldest had social services involvement because DP and his ex were spending time with, and allowing DSD to spend time with, a convicted paedophile as they thought it was all just 'malicious rumours'

yeah, I can see that wouldn't give you much confidence in his judgement.

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 07/12/2023 13:46

DP said "we have different opinions on that, he's a really good artist" to which I replied something about Rolph Harris being a good artist

YABU for this alone. Rolf Harris was a terrible artist.

While we're at it, I think anyone who listens to MJ is being unreasonable, because his music is shite. But that's nothing to do with whether or not he was a paedophile. There are plenty of artists who inhabit a moral vacuum but create works of brilliance.

Nicole1111 · 07/12/2023 13:45

PinkLemons99 · 07/12/2023 13:36

I think it’s very dangerous to decide that someone is guilty of a crime when they haven’t been given a fair trial, let alone convicted, regardless of who they are or their alleged crimes.

On that basis alone, YABU.

You’re completely right. Even if someone has multiple allegations of child sexual abuse against them from unconnected people we shouldn’t consider them guilty. We wouldn’t want to deny these people access to children would we, especially vulnerable ones. There’s also no need to consider that child sexual abuse conviction rates are really low and are very very very unlikely to be representative of how much child sexual abuse has actually occurred.

Cas112 · 07/12/2023 13:45

@PinkLemons99 so people are only guilty if convicted and not guilty if not convicted?

Parky04 · 07/12/2023 13:42

YABU. You picked a fight. I'm surprised he puts up with you!

PinkLemons99 · 07/12/2023 13:42

mantyzer · 07/12/2023 13:40

@PinkLemons99 do not see someone as a risk unless they have been convicted.

I don’t believe in mob hysteria, no.

I do believe in the rule of law.

DGPP · 07/12/2023 13:41

Can somebody link to the FBI files where they found child abuse on MJ’s computers? Everything I’ve read suggests they investigated him several times but had no case (I’m not saying he’s innocent just interested in the evidence)

InTheRainOnATrain · 07/12/2023 13:41

To add OP, I think you went too far by bringing your DS into it. Whilst I get the theoretical point you’re making and I understand that as a survivor of abuse yourself it might feel overly personal, it was overkill as was suggesting safeguarding concerns. And being honest I agree with your DH’s answer of ‘I don’t know’. Obviously I’d like to think that I wouldn’t have let him anywhere near my kids but he was the biggest star in the world, he groomed those families to gain access and they didn’t know back then what we know now.

Hopefully once you’ve both calmed down you can both agree it got out of hand, apologise and move on agreeing to never play his music at home.

EachandEveryone · 07/12/2023 13:41

Woody Allen is strange I agree however, he was never found guilty of anything and was thoroughly investigated twice.

Holidayhell22 · 07/12/2023 13:41

I agree with you op.
That’s after seeing MJ in concert too. I can still admit he was mesmerising but so was Hiltler.
It just goes to show how far grooming can go. All this ‘I’m just a kid at heart, let me play with the kids,’ was quite frankly an act. It worked too.

mantyzer · 07/12/2023 13:40

@PinkLemons99 do not see someone as a risk unless they have been convicted.

NonPlayerCharacter · 07/12/2023 13:39

BMW6 · 07/12/2023 13:35

That's my view as well. There is no right or wrong attitude towards the work the person produced, its entirely up to each individual.

Personally I separate the work from the person, if you don't that's fine of course. Each to their own.

Yes. There's no paedophilia in Jackson's music and there's no antisemitism in Dahl's books.

Savile wasn't an artist, he was a personality. That makes a difference because his product wasn't art, it was himself, and we now know what that self was.

With all that said, there's definitely a degree of selection going on. David Bowie was a great musician but we never seem to talk about how he had sex with underage girls.

Cosywintertime · 07/12/2023 13:39

I think it’s very unfair to decide this is is attitude to csa as he doesn’t believe Michael Jackson to be guilty and can’t be arsed reading up. I find that a bit extreme to be fair.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 07/12/2023 13:39

Jacfrost · 07/12/2023 13:32

I'd be willing to bet OP that you have watched and enjoyed many Weinstein films. Is it just MJ that you have an issue with?

I have (also) watched and enjoyed Woody Allen films.

But I am not defending that man´s actions or trying to claim that he must be innocent. OP´s DP however did.

If somebody asked me whether I would leave an unsupervised child or teenager in his company I wouldn´t hesitate to say NO. Enjoying films doesn´t change that.
OP´s DP however chose to answer with "I don´t know"...

CatamaranViper · 07/12/2023 13:39

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 07/12/2023 13:32

That is an argument I would take much more seriously IF people were honest and didn´t try to defend MJ´s action (not his music/art). But most people somehow aren´t...

"MJ was found not guilty of certain, specific charges in the case that actually went to a criminal trial. He did, however, pay the family of the accuser several million dollars in the subsequent civil case, which doesn't scream innocence to me. The other accusations against him, by multiple other children, didn't go to court. BUT I STILL LIKE HIS MUSIC."
(I am quoting @ManateeFair here. Thank you for summarising the issues, Manatee!)

But that is definitely not what OP´s DP did... Arguing that MJ was innocent is the opposite of trying to seperate the art / music from his personal life...

No you're right, there is a difference between excusing their actions and accepting they're bad people but still enjoy their music/acting/books etc.

I was trying to point out that some people who do condemn MJ and refuse to listen to his music on principle (instead of just disliking it), but don't do the same for other celebrities are quite hypocritical.

But people do make excuses for many celebrities ie Mark Wahlberg is often excused because he was young and impressionable, taken in by a bad crowd etc. He still racially abused people.