Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Blazing row about Michael Jackson

644 replies

PLP432 · 07/12/2023 12:44

I know it sounds ridiculous on the face of it but hear me out.

I was in a shop with DP last night and they were playing Michael Jackson music. I commented that I don't like hearing his music as I can't get past everything he did. Yes, I know he wasn't convicted but he openly admitted to sleeping in bed with random children, showering together and whatever else.

DP said "we have different opinions on that, he's a really good artist" to which I replied something about Rolph Harris being a good artist and Jimmy Saville being a good fund raiser.

DP then goes on to say he doesn't think MJ did anything untoward with the children and he thinks it's all innocent and because he had a "childlike mind" due to not having a proper childhood.

I said that was no excuse and plenty of people have bad or unusual childhoods and don't groom children.

He was getting defensive and talking about how he was found not guilty in court, to which I pointed out how few rape and sexual abuse cases even make it to court let alone conviction.

I asked whether he'd listened to anything the men on Leaving Neverland said before he formed his opinion that MJ wasn't guilty of anything. He said no, and refused to look it up.

It descended into a row and I was very hurt by some of the things he said, as I have a history of child sexual abuse and rape - which he knows all about.

I asked him whether he would have gladly left our DS in the company of someone like MJ unsupervised and he took a while to answer before saying "I don't know"

I said how that concerned me from a safeguarding perspective to which he took huge offence, started shouting and told me to return all of the presents i'd bought him as he doesnt want them anymore, the immature dickhead.

Now we're not talking.

Was I being unreasonable here?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
Scout2016 · 07/12/2023 19:40

You're entitled to have whatever threshold you want as a marker for who you want to be in a relationship with OP. Anything at all.
It sounds like it's important for you to be with someone who is minded to believe those making allegations. On here people have asked if they are being unreasonable to dump someone for far less and they're often told they can leave for any reason at all, or none.

As for separating the art from the artist, I understand the principle but personally I can't. I've got several cds I can't listen to anymore but also haven't thrown away. I know objectively I still like those songs, my tastes haven't changed, but I dislike the baggage around them more.

InTheRainOnATrain · 07/12/2023 19:09

Oh no OP, so sorry it’s come to this- sometimes it’s just the straw that broke the camel’s back isn’t it? Take care of yourself X

Glowygoose · 07/12/2023 19:05

Oh OP I want to give you a big hug.

Im going to out the topic of MJ aside for this post.

I think a major issue here is you and DP are not intellectually equal. This is therefore frustrating for you.
You can’t debate or come to resolution with someone who isn’t on the same intellectual wavelength as yourself. So in the end you either end up having to gloss over it or give up your own convictions because you know arguing/debating will get you nowhere. It sounds like he doesn’t have the IQ to ever understand nuance or reason.

I’ve had these issues before with people and the frustration is enraging e.g:

Them: I bloody hate Jeremy corbyn
me: oh okay, why do you say that?
Them: he’s a prick
me: ok but why?
them: he just is.
-end of discussion -

Theres no reason, debate or anything of substance there. Just a viewpoint of no substance. Then when you try and put your view across that opposes their own they just deflect with insults or really stupid retorts that are on par with a small child. It’s so infuriating and frustrating. They want to have an opinion but don’t want to have any education on said opinion. It’s baffling.

This will grind you down long term and resentment will build.
also your relationship can never really go beyond being somewhat ‘superficial’ because you can’t delve any deeper with them.

I would seriously consider the relationship because it’s not something couples counselling can solve. It’s a fundamental and biological difference unfortunately.

also excuse any typos, I’m on my phone.

PLP432 · 07/12/2023 18:11

Mirabai · 07/12/2023 18:01

OP I understand your issue with what he said.

But I would put it down to low IQ and question whether he’s the right person for you.

I've been thinking about it plenty today and I don't think we are right together at all. We are completely different people. He has hurt me plenty over the years with his lack of thinking before he speaks.

OP posts:
Americano75 · 07/12/2023 18:05

Mirabai · 07/12/2023 17:58

I mean William Mayne was a paedophile, Eric Gill committed sexually abused his DDs - I may have liked their works before I knew but like hell will I have anything to do with them now - they make me feel sick.

Ditto MJ. I was never a major fan as when I was a teen in the 80s he wasn’t cool, just weird, but I liked Billy Jean and the Jackson 5 70s stuff. But now - I won’t listen to him.

You either take a hard line against sexual abuse or you don’t. The fact he was so rich he could pay off his accusers instead of facing them in court may work for some people, but it doesn’t wash with me.

Ditto. I couldn't stand MJ even before the allegations, and could never put my finger on why. Probably connected to the whole 'he's a child in a man's body' absolute bullshit.

OP, I get it. I'm not surprised this has upset you so much.

Mirabai · 07/12/2023 18:01

PLP432 · 07/12/2023 16:54

I've had counselling. I've had EMDR therapy. I've had ACT therapy. I've spent thousands on it.

I don't think any amount of therapy prepares you for your child's father smugly asserting that if somebody isn't found guilty in court then they are innocent of the crimes they are accused of.

Edited to add -

Especially when he knows that none of your abusers ever got as far as court, let alone being convicted.

Edited

OP I understand your issue with what he said.

But I would put it down to low IQ and question whether he’s the right person for you.

Mirabai · 07/12/2023 17:58

I mean William Mayne was a paedophile, Eric Gill committed sexually abused his DDs - I may have liked their works before I knew but like hell will I have anything to do with them now - they make me feel sick.

Ditto MJ. I was never a major fan as when I was a teen in the 80s he wasn’t cool, just weird, but I liked Billy Jean and the Jackson 5 70s stuff. But now - I won’t listen to him.

You either take a hard line against sexual abuse or you don’t. The fact he was so rich he could pay off his accusers instead of facing them in court may work for some people, but it doesn’t wash with me.

QueenBean22 · 07/12/2023 17:54

I haven’t seen Neverland, don’t know whether he was guilty of those crimes. If he was then that sickens me.

But despite that I still love his music

ANightingale · 07/12/2023 17:49

CrapGoat · 07/12/2023 15:16

@ANightingale that looks like HIM!

It does!

Wavyline · 07/12/2023 17:46

ComtesseDeSpair · 07/12/2023 13:18

History is full of artists, musicians, writers and inventors who didn’t behave wonderfully. We’d have very little left to appreciate if we expected all their material to be removed from the public sphere. Most people are capable of separating the creator and their behaviour from the art.

Agreed

RedToothBrush · 07/12/2023 17:45

MaryMcCarthy · 07/12/2023 13:01

There's no reason to re-visit anything Rolf Harris or Jimmy Savile did.

Michael Jackson however was one of the most outstanding and popular artists of the 20th century and that's not going to change. His songs and his voice didn't become bad as a result of his behaviour. They are still good songs. And he's no longer profiting from them, so what's the issue?

c4 did their experiment on destroying art: the show came to the conclusion that the personal lives of artists matter BUT if they were an artist of such outstanding work, the work should still stand because otherwise it would be a loss to society. The art retains its value to society thus we should still value the art but do so whilst acknowledging the actions of that person were not ok. It forms part of the story of the creation of that art, but the art still stands in its own right.

In this sense thats ultimately the difference between Saville and MJ. Saville didn't offer society something unique that no one else could provide.

I think in a sense that means the OP and her husband aren't either necessarily right and aren't necessarily wrong.

I think the OP pushed it too far but her husband should be more aware too. I don't think he's a safeguarding risk.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 07/12/2023 17:34

I wouldn’t have been so forthright about it, but @Universalsnail does have a point. I have several raw nerves and when my DP is at risk of hurting them I warn him very clearly and we do something harmless instead and talk when I’m less upset (he’s also allowed to do this). It doesn’t help anyone to have a huge argument where you get offended.

ChaoticCrumble · 07/12/2023 17:05

Regardless of DH's internal view, he should've been more sensitive because of your history (which IMO many viewers are ignoring, we should believe victims).

Personally I don't trust any adult who chooses to sleep with unrelated children they are not the caregivers for.

PLP432 · 07/12/2023 16:54

Cosywintertime · 07/12/2023 16:47

Op he hasn’t done anything wrong. And neither have posters. It is clear you’re struggling but picking fights and crying isn’t going to help. Please seek some counselling to help you process the trauma.

I've had counselling. I've had EMDR therapy. I've had ACT therapy. I've spent thousands on it.

I don't think any amount of therapy prepares you for your child's father smugly asserting that if somebody isn't found guilty in court then they are innocent of the crimes they are accused of.

Edited to add -

Especially when he knows that none of your abusers ever got as far as court, let alone being convicted.

OP posts:
Nowherenew · 07/12/2023 16:52

PLP432 · 07/12/2023 16:38

Those of you being so hard on me are vile. It's abundantly clear I'm upset and the argument has brought up past trauma. Why would you, knowing that, continue to have a go at me? You don't know what people are dealing with from behind a screen. Pathetic bullying behaviour.

No one is bullying you OP.

You watched a documentary about abuse.
You then had an argument about it with your DP.
You then came onto MN to talk about it even more.

I’m not really sure what you wanted from this thread.

Your DP wasn’t in the wrong.

If you are struggling then perhaps some counselling would help, as it’s very possible the documentary has triggered some buried feelings.

In future I think it would be a good idea to not watch documentaries about child abuse or have discussions about it, especially if the person has been found not guilty.

UnRavellingFast · 07/12/2023 16:51

Emotionalsupportviper · 07/12/2023 13:33

😬😬😬

That is very . . . Harris-y . . .

Yes! It like he’s put his disgusting creepy eyes into her face. Very disturbing.

Statementdress · 07/12/2023 16:49

I was just pondering this issue the other day. There was an advert on the radio for the Michael Jackson musical. Could you imagine the outrage if we had ‘Jimmy Savile - the musical’ ?

I loved MJ’s music ( and still listen to it- I just tell myself it’s Quincy Jones I’m appreciating) but I don’t think it’s appropriate to make a musical celebrating his life.

it’s pretty obvious this man was an abuser who simply paid away the complaints.

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 07/12/2023 16:47

PLP432 · 07/12/2023 16:38

Those of you being so hard on me are vile. It's abundantly clear I'm upset and the argument has brought up past trauma. Why would you, knowing that, continue to have a go at me? You don't know what people are dealing with from behind a screen. Pathetic bullying behaviour.

Perhaps . And I'm sorry about your trauma. But it is worth bearing in mind in future, that starting a thread on MN AIBU is not the best place to bring up a topic that you find so upsetting .

Cosywintertime · 07/12/2023 16:47

Op he hasn’t done anything wrong. And neither have posters. It is clear you’re struggling but picking fights and crying isn’t going to help. Please seek some counselling to help you process the trauma.

PLP432 · 07/12/2023 16:46

zingally · 07/12/2023 16:43

YABU to escalate an issue that you knew you and your DP disagree on.

Like you, I watched the Leaving Neverland doc, and fail to see how ANYONE could finish watching it and NOT believe the boys (now men). But I also know that a lot of people just won't be reasoned with on the topic of MJ.

My mum likes to do similar with stories about transgender people. We have wildly different POVs, and now, whenever she brings it up, I just grey rock her. "I'm not interested in discussing this with you." Repeated however many times it takes until she gets bored and shuts up.

I suggest you take a similar strategy moving forwards.

We have never discussed Michael Jackson before, if we had I'm sure it would have gone the same way then I'd have known not to bother raising that topic with him again.

OP posts:
Universalsnail · 07/12/2023 16:45

PLP432 · 07/12/2023 16:41

I agree, I shouldn't have ever gone there.

I never intended for it to turn into a debate or argument but I obviously can't talk objectively about CSA without getting upset.

I've had to come and sit in the bedroom so my DS doesn't see me crying. I thought I had dealt with all of this. Lesson learned.

I understand. I have some trigger topics I just can't engage a debate in with my partner as they have historically always just caused a huge argument because his opinion just hits a real inner nerve because of my trauma. I think this is one of those topics for you and it's not worth discussing

ShinyAppleDreamingOfTheSea · 07/12/2023 16:44

For what it's worth as I think it's relevant there is history of him choosing to see the good in people that he shouldn't. His eldest had social services involvement because DP and his ex were spending time with, and allowing DSD to spend time with, a convicted paedophile as they thought it was all just 'malicious rumours'

That's quite a massive drip feed there @PLP432 in terms of your DP's ability to safeguard his children . It makes the subsequent discussion around Michael Jackson almost irrelevant. It may well be that he always tries to see the good in people, innocent until proven guilty etc - but continuing to listen to music by a dodgy singer and failing to safeguard your own child are completely different things .

Cosywintertime · 07/12/2023 16:43

PLP432 · 07/12/2023 16:38

Those of you being so hard on me are vile. It's abundantly clear I'm upset and the argument has brought up past trauma. Why would you, knowing that, continue to have a go at me? You don't know what people are dealing with from behind a screen. Pathetic bullying behaviour.

To be polite but honest, no one has been as hard on you as you have your own husband. And I’m really sorry for what you’ve gone through, maybe more counselling would be in order to help you cope.💐

zingally · 07/12/2023 16:43

YABU to escalate an issue that you knew you and your DP disagree on.

Like you, I watched the Leaving Neverland doc, and fail to see how ANYONE could finish watching it and NOT believe the boys (now men). But I also know that a lot of people just won't be reasoned with on the topic of MJ.

My mum likes to do similar with stories about transgender people. We have wildly different POVs, and now, whenever she brings it up, I just grey rock her. "I'm not interested in discussing this with you." Repeated however many times it takes until she gets bored and shuts up.

I suggest you take a similar strategy moving forwards.

PLP432 · 07/12/2023 16:41

Universalsnail · 07/12/2023 16:36

I think you were being unreasonable to get into a conversation about this considering your history. It was bound to be a triggering conversation that was going to go very sour as soon as your husband said he disagrees. The conversation should have swiftly ended there. It's too an emotive subject.

I agree, I shouldn't have ever gone there.

I never intended for it to turn into a debate or argument but I obviously can't talk objectively about CSA without getting upset.

I've had to come and sit in the bedroom so my DS doesn't see me crying. I thought I had dealt with all of this. Lesson learned.

OP posts: