Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Blazing row about Michael Jackson

644 replies

PLP432 · 07/12/2023 12:44

I know it sounds ridiculous on the face of it but hear me out.

I was in a shop with DP last night and they were playing Michael Jackson music. I commented that I don't like hearing his music as I can't get past everything he did. Yes, I know he wasn't convicted but he openly admitted to sleeping in bed with random children, showering together and whatever else.

DP said "we have different opinions on that, he's a really good artist" to which I replied something about Rolph Harris being a good artist and Jimmy Saville being a good fund raiser.

DP then goes on to say he doesn't think MJ did anything untoward with the children and he thinks it's all innocent and because he had a "childlike mind" due to not having a proper childhood.

I said that was no excuse and plenty of people have bad or unusual childhoods and don't groom children.

He was getting defensive and talking about how he was found not guilty in court, to which I pointed out how few rape and sexual abuse cases even make it to court let alone conviction.

I asked whether he'd listened to anything the men on Leaving Neverland said before he formed his opinion that MJ wasn't guilty of anything. He said no, and refused to look it up.

It descended into a row and I was very hurt by some of the things he said, as I have a history of child sexual abuse and rape - which he knows all about.

I asked him whether he would have gladly left our DS in the company of someone like MJ unsupervised and he took a while to answer before saying "I don't know"

I said how that concerned me from a safeguarding perspective to which he took huge offence, started shouting and told me to return all of the presents i'd bought him as he doesnt want them anymore, the immature dickhead.

Now we're not talking.

Was I being unreasonable here?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
PLP432 · 14/12/2023 14:20

Tourniquet81 · 14/12/2023 13:30

Yet the actual allegations that would make him a paedophile if true have been shown to be physically impossible in time, number and place. And not just that but shown to be out right lies. That is the only reason he was uncancelled in 2019. How many other celebrities have such a passionate defence and have been uncancelled after such horrific things have been claimed??

People are desperately clinging on to the whole sleepover thing because it’s all they have and not only that but changing the events to help fit the narrative. The effort going into that is astonishing and leads ne to question why. Why so much effort from certain people to make square pegs fit round holes just to be nasty about somebody?

Why, in your opinion, did he want 'sleepovers' with young boys?

OP posts:
Tourniquet81 · 14/12/2023 13:30

Yet the actual allegations that would make him a paedophile if true have been shown to be physically impossible in time, number and place. And not just that but shown to be out right lies. That is the only reason he was uncancelled in 2019. How many other celebrities have such a passionate defence and have been uncancelled after such horrific things have been claimed??

People are desperately clinging on to the whole sleepover thing because it’s all they have and not only that but changing the events to help fit the narrative. The effort going into that is astonishing and leads ne to question why. Why so much effort from certain people to make square pegs fit round holes just to be nasty about somebody?

AllWeWantToDo · 12/12/2023 02:13

Firefly1987 · 12/12/2023 02:09

@AllWeWantToDo well he sure kept Macaulay Culkin around for a long time despite apparently having no "use" for him. Personally (and I know I'll get called naive and worse here) I think he wanted to be a father figure to these kids-some of them didn't have the best parents and he wanted to make sure they didn't miss out like he did growing up without a childhood. I also think he was desperate to be a father and that's why he ended up having them by himself in the end.

Well yes I would go with naive. Having kids around that you don't abuse obviously works well to cast doubt , well it has done for MJ

Firefly1987 · 12/12/2023 02:09

@AllWeWantToDo well he sure kept Macaulay Culkin around for a long time despite apparently having no "use" for him. Personally (and I know I'll get called naive and worse here) I think he wanted to be a father figure to these kids-some of them didn't have the best parents and he wanted to make sure they didn't miss out like he did growing up without a childhood. I also think he was desperate to be a father and that's why he ended up having them by himself in the end.

AllWeWantToDo · 12/12/2023 01:31

Firefly1987 · 11/12/2023 03:54

It wasn't until adulthood and having his own child that he started to see the abuse for what it was and even then, he still felt some misguided loyalty to him.

I thought it was after he didn't get the Cirque Du soleil MJ show?

All the posters worried about listening to MJ's music, I wouldn't worry about that-Wade himself was still dancing to him and wanting to participate in MJ shows up until a few years ago.

It's possible for MJ to have been abusing the other boys whilst not abusing MC.

Yes but most people's arguments for his guilt go back to "he had kids stay over, that's soo inappropriate, that's so wrong, open your eyes, he was a paedophile!", so people can't suddenly go "oh well maybe he didn't do anything to Macaulay"-either he had kids stay over to abuse them, or you admit it's possible he innocently enjoyed their company. You can't have it both ways. And yes they were often boys, but not always-I believe Macaulay's sister stayed over, and/or Gavin's sister, and the girl from the moonwalker film. Perhaps parents were more wary of letting girls stay over, or fewer girls wanted to, who knows.

Just because you are attracted to young boys doesn't mean you are attracted to all young boys. It's very usual for a paedophile to be in contact with more children than they will actually abuse

That some children weren't abused by him means nothing

Mirabai · 12/12/2023 00:36

Incorrect. JC launched one case and his father launched another and it was consolidated eventually into one case.

Jordan separated himself legally when he was 14 not later. He has never once commented on the case publicly let alone claiming it never happened - that is simply a lie.

Tourniquet81 · 12/12/2023 00:23

That wasn’t Jordan that was his father Evan. He wanted to be allowed to record an album called EvanStory in reply to Michael’s album HIStory and wanted to sue for $60m. In fact, Jordan had very little to do with any of it. He maintained in later years nothing ever happened and it was his father after money and his mother was only worried about losing custody of him. His father tried to kill him with a dumb-bell bar over a row over the money and Jordan later ‘divorced’ his parents over the whole thing.

I would think be surprised if he came out one day and debunked the whole story.

cosmicfig · 11/12/2023 20:15

PLP432 · 07/12/2023 13:35

I don't actually have any problem with him liking his music, I mean you wouldn't see me playing it at home but if he likes it then whatever. I know as mentioned some can separate the art from the artist so to speak.

What really upset me was how he said with such confidence that he doesn't believe he did anything wrong, he was innocent and childlike, he wasn't convicted therefore it couldn't have been true.

I will admit that my own personal history means I'm quite sensitive about topics like this.

I think, knowing what he knows about my history, he shouldn't have said all he said. He's entitled to enjoy the music but undermining the victims and declaring the man's innocence when he has never bothered to look into the allegations really upset me.

For what it's worth as I think it's relevant there is history of him choosing to see the good in people that he shouldn't. His eldest had social services involvement because DP and his ex were spending time with, and allowing DSD to spend time with, a convicted paedophile as they thought it was all just 'malicious rumours'

I didn't know about this until years later.

So yes, it's a very loaded topic and I feel so hurt and yes alarmed that this is his attitude towards CSA.

This would give me massive red flags and puts a different spin on your original post. I can now see why you were so upset about him defending MJ.

Hoovermehenry · 11/12/2023 19:49

‘exactly did Jimmy Savile do when he wasn’t abusing children? Raise money to rebuild a children’s hospital.’

yup. Better access to vulnerable people, and a nice charity cover story. MJ did exactly the same.

Mirabai · 11/12/2023 14:25

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 11/12/2023 14:13

There are parents who sell their own children.

There are parents who sexually abuse their own children.

There are parents who look away when their landlord, pastor or new partner sexually abuses their child.

I assume that you are aware of that (unfortunate) reality.

so why wouldn’t there be parents that could be paid off? Parents who wouldn’t want to pursue justice?

I appreciate that this is a sensitive subject and I do now want to be disrespectful. The statement that no parent would or could be paid off is simply incorrect.

And the post you’re responding to fails to consider that pursuing ”justice” rather than compensation - would have meant in JC’s case - putting him through a public trial against a global celebrity at the age of 13.

Would @Martinii actually put their child through that? Would she have faced her abuser in court at 13? Does she know that sex offence court cases can destroy adults let alone children, so stressful and damaging is the process?

In that context, a settlement which will pay for treatment and support the victim’s life going forward is arguably the more prudent course of action.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 11/12/2023 14:13

Martinii · 10/12/2023 17:54

I agree.

As a surviver of sexual child abuse myself, no amount of money could pay me off if my child said someone had abused them, unlike the family of the boy who made the accusation in 1993. I'd want justice, not money, and there's no way as a parent I could be paid off.

There are parents who sell their own children.

There are parents who sexually abuse their own children.

There are parents who look away when their landlord, pastor or new partner sexually abuses their child.

I assume that you are aware of that (unfortunate) reality.

so why wouldn’t there be parents that could be paid off? Parents who wouldn’t want to pursue justice?

I appreciate that this is a sensitive subject and I do now want to be disrespectful. The statement that no parent would or could be paid off is simply incorrect.

Mirabai · 11/12/2023 14:10

It should be said that Jordan Chandler never testified against MJ. Although he did file his own lawsuit in 1998 accusing MJ of violating the terms of the 1994 settlement by claiming publicly, in an attempt to restore his reputation, that JC was a “corrupt and immoral person” and that MJ had been “coerced” or “blackmailed” into settling. JC’s accusation of repeated sexual molestation by MJ was confirmed in the lawsuit.

For the record the evidence of the accuracy of identifying features of MJ’s penis was conflicting not definitive either way. Nor does or should a sexual abuse case ever stand and fall on the description of a penis.

Mirabai · 11/12/2023 13:41

VanityDiesHard · 11/12/2023 13:15

Exactly. I don't believe for a minute that MJ would have been acquitted if there had been enough evidence to convict him, and his accusers had tried a similar grift on with other celebrities.

Really? Evidence in historic sexual abuse is one person’s word against another. In this case a child against a rich and powerful celebrity.

The rape conviction rate in this country is under 6%, lower for historic crimes, and you think justice is achieved for every complainant?

Was justice ever achieved for the victims of abuse of the Catholic priests world wide? Some of them received compensation in the long run - do you call them all liars too?

VanityDiesHard · 11/12/2023 13:15

Rosscameasdoody · 09/12/2023 22:33

Not really the same thing though. Saville died before his crimes came to light. Had he been alive when they were revealed I don’t think there’s much doubt but that he would have been convicted. Whereas MJ was tried and acquitted.

Exactly. I don't believe for a minute that MJ would have been acquitted if there had been enough evidence to convict him, and his accusers had tried a similar grift on with other celebrities.

Ohtobetwentytwo · 11/12/2023 10:47

Plenty of people are raped and abused by their own parents and have a relationship with them. Plenty of people are beaten by their partner and stay with them. A woman's husband was recently convicted for attempted murder on her and she tried to defend him. Victims arent always easy to understand. Doesnt mean an abuser can abuse because of a perception of victim agreement.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 11/12/2023 09:27

@Lambiriyani that is a very charitable impulse but what exactly did Jimmy Savile do when he wasn’t abusing children? Raise money to rebuild a children’s hospital.

DonnaBanana · 11/12/2023 09:27

This is about as ridiculous as avoiding Volkswagen cars or thinking the autobahns should be ripped up just because you know who was involved in the creation of both.

Lambiriyani · 11/12/2023 09:23

There are recordings of MJ drugged up on whatever his doctor was giving him saying how he wanted to use the money from his 2009 comeback tour to help children and to build a hospital etc.

Michaeljosephl · 11/12/2023 09:22

This was 1993, 1994 , u do realise they did not even indict him .

These books as well, were proof off nothing, as they kept em for 12 years.

The photos did not match.

They had nowt to indict

Mirabai · 11/12/2023 09:16

Alligator456 · 11/12/2023 08:23

Let's look at the big picture

We have a famous pop star. He surrounds himself with children. He has special friendships with boys that end after puberty. Usually at any one time he has a special friend who goes everywhere with him. These boys repeatedly share a hotel room with him and there are public photos and vidoes of him hugging and kissing him. Several of the boys accuse him of sexual abuse. What is more plausible?

A) he was a paedophile
B) he was an innocent child in a man's body who just wanted to have sleepovers

Hint: he was an adult man in an adults body

Quite. MJ is on record in film and audio footage that we call all see for ourselves - of doing and saying completely inappropriate things with boys, and totally inappropriate relationships with them.

Yet fans tie themselves in knots either to deny the inappropriateness or to accept it but claim it went no further than the surface. Six of the boys are on record saying that the surface inappropriateness was a reflection of deeper abuse. What’s more likely that the surface reflected the reality or that it was divergent?

It’s reflective of the hold a very fucked up, damaged & self-destructive man had over his fans as much as his victims and their families. The abuse has always been staring them in the face.

Mirabai · 11/12/2023 08:42

Willb2024 · 10/12/2023 23:32

Well I’d think it’s not plausible myself, but clearly it is for them as they are doing it, they are hijacking the Metoo movement and frankly are an insult to legitimate victims. Yes that means people who have ACTUALLY suffered abuse.

Let’s be clear: you are the insult to legitimate victims. This line is used against genuine victims of abuse on a daily basis and you are simply perpetuating this.

PLP432 · 11/12/2023 08:33

Michaeljosephl · 11/12/2023 08:23

Well u seem to like you edited to suit agenda

The full clips is available and was used in the 2005 trial which he was exonorated on

Which clearly stated "he sleep on the floor", and u have the bed. I always give the guests the bed. Sleep in it, its yours.

How can him saying he slept on the floor go in his favour at all when he's on record admitting he shares his bed with boys and sleeps in it with them?

OP posts:
readymealeater · 11/12/2023 08:30

There was a thread here very recently about a row between a Mumsnetter and her boyfriend because he put Gary Glitter onto their Xmas playlist. GG was guilty of horrendous crimes and rightfully convicted, but the consensus seemed to be that having his Xmas song on a playlist that he couldn't profit from was okay. The boyfriend certainly never defended GG's behaviour, just liked his song.

As a pp has said, if we really researched the personal histories of many artists there wouldn't be many left to enjoy.

Michaeljosephl · 11/12/2023 08:28

Jackson was hardly at Neverland when they were there.
Wade mother testimonies stated and confirms this.

In 14 years they only saw MJ at neverland only an handful of times.

Alligator456 · 11/12/2023 08:23

Let's look at the big picture

We have a famous pop star. He surrounds himself with children. He has special friendships with boys that end after puberty. Usually at any one time he has a special friend who goes everywhere with him. These boys repeatedly share a hotel room with him and there are public photos and vidoes of him hugging and kissing him. Several of the boys accuse him of sexual abuse. What is more plausible?

A) he was a paedophile
B) he was an innocent child in a man's body who just wanted to have sleepovers

Hint: he was an adult man in an adults body

Swipe left for the next trending thread