Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is racist?

194 replies

RomaniWoman · 07/12/2023 09:52

Hey everyone, I'd love some opinions on this situation.

I have recently started a new job in France. My colleague asked me where I was originally from, I told her that I was a Romani, born in England. Hence the accent.

But then it escalated when she went " But you are white" , I insisted that I wasn't white." My mum is a Romani from Ireland and my father a Romani from Romania.

The next day, the same colleague approached me and said " You need to stop saying you're a Gypsy, you don't look like one, why describe yourself as someone who steals and begs?"

She said that sh*t front of 5 other people, and nobody seemed surprised
. I just hesitantly responded " That's pretty racist".

Omg, then the " you are white" blablabla started. My partner then agreed, when I told her, that I should just say I am English because we aren't perceived as a "good" community.

I already know how we are perceived and treated and refuse to deny my identity.

Am I crazy, or is it highly inappropriate, regardless of my skin colour?

OP posts:
curtaintwitcher78 · 07/12/2023 14:08

Why should you have to lie about your ethnicity just cos racist pieces of shit think you 'pass' as white. Good on you OP.

housethatbuiltme · 07/12/2023 14:07

User17w72882 · 07/12/2023 14:00

Wow! Almost as if this post is some sort of rant at Black people...on a thread that has nothing to do with Black people. What a surprise.

And Black people are no longer discriminated against. How ironic.

~ a half Black woman.

Edited

Where on earth did she say anything 'anti black' or even aimed AT black people in her post?

FreshWinterMorning · 07/12/2023 14:06

Rude and nasty! And yeah @RomaniWoman racist too. YANBU. I am so sorry you were spoken to like this.

VanityDiesHard · 07/12/2023 14:04

User17w72882 · 07/12/2023 14:00

Wow! Almost as if this post is some sort of rant at Black people...on a thread that has nothing to do with Black people. What a surprise.

And Black people are no longer discriminated against. How ironic.

~ a half Black woman.

Edited

If you read my post, I am also half Black, and I stand by what I said. I wasn't 'ranting about Black people' I was expressing a negative opinion on the sort of SJW who fetishises the opression of 'POC', usually Black people, in order to make themselves look good. Most of the performative people are white, anyway.

MarkWithaC · 07/12/2023 14:01

YANBU. Report to HR.

User17w72882 · 07/12/2023 14:00

VanityDiesHard · 07/12/2023 13:53

I am a half black woman and I hate this sort of attitude. It seems that a lot of social justice activists play a kind of Top Trumps of racism with a hierachy whereby Black people are supposed to be the most oppressed, and are thereby incapable of racism, white people are never ever victims of racism, and everyone else is scrabbling for their place in the oppression league tables. I got absolutely roasted on my Facebook a few weeks ago for expressing support for Israel, by some moron who thinks that all Black people should support Palestine. It is all so toxic and stupid.

Wow! Almost as if this post is some sort of rant at Black people...on a thread that has nothing to do with Black people. What a surprise.

And Black people are no longer discriminated against. How ironic.

~ a half Black woman.

elkiedee · 07/12/2023 14:00

I'm sorry that you're getting such racist and rude comments at work, @RomaniWoman. And that some other Romani people including your own French-Romani wife, don't feel able say openly who you both are and be proud of it.

I can't give you advice on how best to deal with it - I only know about your posts here that I've so far read, and I know even less about your workplace and the culture of the organisation that you work for. I hope you can find a way forward that doesn't amount to suppressing and hiding yourself.

Terrribletwos · 07/12/2023 13:55

RomaniWoman · 07/12/2023 11:13

Ok, I understand it might be a bit bizarre but it's basically there are Romanis and Non-Romani European/White people.

The Romani dialect I speak is closer to punjabi than English.

I find this fascinating and am rather interested in this. Could you extrapolate? It would be interesting to know about your culture and language.

VanityDiesHard · 07/12/2023 13:53

wudubelieveit · 07/12/2023 12:41

My yr 7 came home from her latest PSHE lesson convinced that racism only affects black people…perhaps a lot of adults are still under this impression

I am a half black woman and I hate this sort of attitude. It seems that a lot of social justice activists play a kind of Top Trumps of racism with a hierachy whereby Black people are supposed to be the most oppressed, and are thereby incapable of racism, white people are never ever victims of racism, and everyone else is scrabbling for their place in the oppression league tables. I got absolutely roasted on my Facebook a few weeks ago for expressing support for Israel, by some moron who thinks that all Black people should support Palestine. It is all so toxic and stupid.

VanityDiesHard · 07/12/2023 13:49

What your colleague said was disgusting racism. Make no mistake, anti zyganism is definitely racism, just because you might appear 'white' does not make any difference to that. I have heard similar bad logic used about anti semitism: some bad faith actors claim to believe that it isn't valid because many Jewish people are white. Nonsense all around and you would be more than justified in escalating this.

RomaniWoman · 07/12/2023 13:44

My wife told me how bad it was in her small town, we moved to the capital city, and her, too, quite surprised that it was bad there too.

She is the "typical" Romani looking woman, and thinks I should just keep our culture for home, and pretend. The sad thing is that she wishes she was blonde and pale like me but I wish I was dark skinned and "cliché looking ".

OP posts:
elkiedee · 07/12/2023 13:40

It's racist.

People are racist about the traveller communities (including Romani and Irish travellers) here in England too, more openly than others and with less challenge, but I get the impression it's much worse in some European countries. Here, I've come across it through local traveller sites being targeted as available for redevelopment, through support services being cut, but also in dismissive or prejudiced comments from local politicians or activists.

Terrribletwos · 07/12/2023 13:38

flowerchild2000 · 07/12/2023 10:14

That's horrible. So are all the comments here excusing it. I grew up in the American South where black men are still to this day lynched. It's a cultural thing, and those views are openly expressed- there was even a large sign in our town warning them, "When the sun goes down get your black ass out of town". So it's ok right? Excusing any level of racism in any form is guess what.. racist!

That shocked me! Where do you live where black men are still lynched?

yearsandyearsago · 07/12/2023 13:37

PeppermintMandy · 07/12/2023 13:04

Of course this is racism and unacceptable.

I’ll admit I am a little confused about your heritage though. I am also Romani. I would never in a million years refer to myself and others from our culture as “gypsies” or “travellers” though.

You mention that your mother is 4th or 5th generation Irish traveller, but Irish travellers have absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with Romani people. Racially, culturally just in no way whatsoever the same group as Romani, who originate from Indian but are now associated mainly with Europe & have nothing whatsoever to do with Romania despite the Romani sounding like it has something to do with Romania.

I would never refer to myself as anything other than white. Yes Roma people originate from Indian and therefore aren’t “white white” but our bloodline in a racial sense is so diluted that to call ourselves “not white” in 99% of cases is just not accurate. Just like you get white Latin American and black Latin Americans. If you have a 5th generation Irish mother you are at least 50% “pure” white since Irish travellers are not racially non white and are not related to Romani people.

Interesting

My mum is Romany, family background is mostly traditional english Rom but also some Welsh kale and theres a little bit of a Russian Romani leg of the family.

My family all call themselves gypsies and would scoff at the suggestion they shouldn't. I think this will most definitely vary community to community.

Like you, though, no one in my family would consider themselves anything but white. We are quite a 'dark' family, lots of black hair, dark eyes, etc and no one is exactly pale but still most definitely white.

TonTonMacoute · 07/12/2023 13:34

Yes, it is racist, but your partner has agreed that you should lie about your true heritage to people for the sake of a quiet life.

It is disheartening that you have to this but it’s not just Romani who are faced with this dilemma, it’s been going on for a very long time. You won’t get rid of prejudice and discrimination - you can fight it all the way or you can give in as your partner suggests.

Christmasusernamepending · 07/12/2023 13:33

I have had so many racist comments about being a gypsy, even from teachers at the schools I work at.
Whenever our culture is mentioned online the comments are flooded with racism and hatred.
But no one seems to care.

ButterCupPie · 07/12/2023 13:31

Illbebythesea · 07/12/2023 12:54

Ask her if she eats smelly cheese and has hairy armpits, as that's what French Women are stereotypically meant to be like .......

I think I might be French.

Et moi aussi !

Mikimoto · 07/12/2023 13:30

JoanMacIntosh · 07/12/2023 11:39

Unfortunately this type of rhetoric is very typical in France.

Unfortunately these types of comments making sweeping statements about France are very typical in the UK.

ButterCupPie · 07/12/2023 13:30

wudubelieveit · 07/12/2023 12:41

My yr 7 came home from her latest PSHE lesson convinced that racism only affects black people…perhaps a lot of adults are still under this impression

I have met quite a few.

HidingUnderARock · 07/12/2023 13:22

Yes of course it's racism.
So just to be clear, you went from England (or Ireland) with your French Romani partner to live and work in France, and there was never any discussion of how things might be different, like before you made the decision to move there?

This is France that maybe as much as 3 or 4 years ago made international headlines for sending 3 policemen with automatic weapons to make a muslim woman remove her long sleeves and trousers because they offended public decency by being worn on a beach.

Honestly I was with you most of the way till you suggested women visiting "anti-women countries" could transition out of their oppression. No. In some of those countries some gay men can transition out of their oppression, but women never can. That is the nature of of oppressing women.

It seems you are being told you could pass as "not a descriminated against minority", but you choose to be out and proud. Fine. That's your choice. The racism is wrong. But you walked in with all the information available, so all this surprise and self righteous identity pride seems a bit played for.

Verv · 07/12/2023 13:12

ButterCupPie · 07/12/2023 12:02

How do you know that? Don't tell me, you've met three French people?

I can confirm what @fulawitt has stated.
I know that because I lived there for a decade in the south west.
When travellers came word went round the nearby villages that residents should ensure that their homes and garages were locked.

Personally, yes I think it was racist.
The first blurt may have been unguarded bewilderment if you appear to be white but state that you are not.
The follow-up was overt racism.

RomaniWoman · 07/12/2023 13:11

@TizerorFizz

Okey, I will address you one final time, because I have the impression that you don't get my point.

I am a Romani, and I am not ashamed of it. If you think I deserved to be hated on, or should hide my identity. That's your opinion.

If my only option is hiding who I am to be treated decently , then it's very disheartening.

OP posts:
PeppermintMandy · 07/12/2023 13:11

housethatbuiltme · 07/12/2023 13:04

I'm of Irish heritage born in England too (family fled here due to the genocide) and I find a lot of people have an attitude of 'you can't be racist to white people'. I have had that straight up said to me while they laughed in my face before after making jokes about the famine.

It is of course Racist though. Ironically the same people would be deeply offended if people made jokes about Auschwitz or WW2 even though the Jewish would class as 'white' to them too. There like a weird blind spot where some of us are seen as 'acceptable' targets to bully.

Nope. Being discriminated against because you are Irish is not racist. It is discrimination, but not based on race. Irish isn’t a race.

Anti-semitism is racist because Jewish is race. People can convert to Judaism but people can also be ethnically Jewish.

To be Irish you just have to be born in Ireland. That’s why you can be black and Irish, because it isn’t a race.

LadyBevvy · 07/12/2023 13:08

MelsMoneyTree · 07/12/2023 12:59

Finding racism entertaining is disgusting. Ask MN to delete your post and stop minimising.

I didn't minimise racism. I think it's terrible what happened to OP. As someone who's often read as a different ethnicity to what I am, and have to endure some pretty ignorant follow up questions, I concur with OP that it's racist, rude and ignorant.

But that doesn't change the fact that this thread is a binfire. We've got one poster saying that it's racist to call out racism. Someone else claiming that English people shit on the streets like it's 961 AD. Well I've travelled extensively in UK and never seen that happen, in fact the only time I've seen a human shitting in the street was two young kids in Sylhet.

Another poster who seems to think that sundown towns complete with regular lynchings still exist in US.

And someone else who seems to think that there are 'cultures' which are 'anti-Israeli' but still somehow not 'antisemitic'.

And then there's you who think they can tell other people what to do. Why do people come onto mumsnet if not partly to be entertained? Why else would you be here? It's not like it's an economically productive activity, unless you're one of MN's advertisers of course.

I mean, this thread is all over the place - and that part IS entertaining.

housethatbuiltme · 07/12/2023 13:07

Illbebythesea · 07/12/2023 12:54

Ask her if she eats smelly cheese and has hairy armpits, as that's what French Women are stereotypically meant to be like .......

I think I might be French.

I don't like cheese much (unless its cake form) but damn sure I'm growing out my 'winter coat' right now.