Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off

134 replies

anonqrtb · 07/12/2023 09:17

I imagine I will be told i am being unreasonable and that is fine, i just need to rant somewhere as i can't irl.

Me and my partner have worked our asses off for the last 4 years to scrape together enough money to purchase (shared ownership so 40%) our home. We both worked full time in stressful jobs, whilst paying private rent and the cost of living rising and rising. My partner was made redundant in this time due to Covid, so when i say its been a struggle to get here i really mean it.

However, a family member has just been given the EXACT same house a few streets away on our estate through social housing. She never had a job as got pregnant young and had multiple kids afterwards, and she has ended up in the same position as we have. Obviously, both working we do have slightly more spare cash at the end of the month but due to paying mortgage and rent we actually pay more to live in the same house then she does. We worked it out and we basically only have an extra £150 per month than her.

It now turns out that shes really annoyed because her friend has been given a house ont he same estate but hers is larger, detached and with a garage - a house we could have no afforded for another maybe 10 years of saving.

AIBU to think just what is the point in working so hard when it doesnt see to get us any further forward?

I want to point out i have nothing against SH, they provide homes for those who need them. Just feels really deflating

OP posts:
berksandbeyond · 07/12/2023 18:27

I understand your annoyance.
I remember saying to my dad, when I was 18 and annoyed because someone I went to school with had been given a council flat, that it felt unfair.
He said ‘yeah but that’s as good as it’ll ever get for them. That’s all they’ll have’
and he was right. We worked hard to buy our first flat, and then we moved on and now have a beautiful home. That persons still in the same council flat, 15 years on.

congratulations on your purchase, onwards and upwards!

WhamBamThankU · 07/12/2023 18:24

Why are you even 'working it out'? You can't know what her exact income is unless you're incredibly nosey. You own, she doesn't. You sound judgemental.

Babyroobs · 07/12/2023 18:21

MaryMcCarthy · 07/12/2023 11:03

Isn't the point that you'll own your house and they won't own theirs?

It's a pretty significant difference.

Op will own 40% unless she can manage to raise a mortgage to buy the rest.

MissBuffyAnneSummers · 07/12/2023 18:18

You are making an investment in shared ownership.

She is renting.

In the long run you will always be better off than her.

Babyroobs · 07/12/2023 18:18

YANBU. so many people just go through life getting it all handed to them. I'm not talking about those too ill to work or the disabled. It's fine people saying you will own an asset, an asset that will likely be sold to pay care home fees if you need to wheras others get it all paid for. You will likely also be paying into a private pension due to working and that will likely just rule you out of any top ups at pension age whilst those who have barely worked get a similar amount. Again I am not talking about those too ill to work. The whole system sucks. I hope that when her kids are grown up and flown the nest that she will need to downsize.

Spatchcooked · 07/12/2023 18:16

The proposal upthread to bring back the ghettos Grin as if someone wrote that down and pressed post.
I don't think the OP is real, I think it's a Tory Party employee fishing for public opinion sock puppeting with the ghetto suggestion.

On the slim chance you are real, stop moaning, quit your job, have another baby and apply for social housing. Bag yourself one of those detached with a garage. You can sleep on your piles of benefit money.

Flamingogirl08 · 07/12/2023 18:09

I think some people need to ask themselves why they think poor/disabled people/single parents/low earners etc don't deserve to live in nice homes?

Are those people only deserving of shit holes?

Why can't you just be happy with what you've achieved OP? You have an asset which many people living in HA properties will never have. You will potentially make money off it, leave an inheritance to your kids and hopefully later in life if you're able to buy outright not have to worry about mortgage or rent payments.

I assume you and DH pay into a private pension through your jobs and will probably progress in your careers and be so much better off in the long run.

So it is so weird that you're jealous somebody is RENTING (not been given) a home you deem to be what? Too nice for them?

Crishell · 07/12/2023 18:08

MrsElsa · 07/12/2023 09:23

Longer term you will be better off as building up equity.

Short to medium term yes it does feel like being shafted.

Try to plan some nice days for yourself, seeing friends, baking a cake. The simple things that you can really enjoy, that don't cost much.

I agree.

You're far better off long term, trust me.

IClaudine · 07/12/2023 18:07

Oh, look, it is the bi-monthly HA tenants bashing thread with a smattering of ableism thrown in for extra froth.

You lot would be annoyed at a homeless couple with a baby on the way being "given" a stable.

Spatchcooked · 07/12/2023 18:03

You actually sat and calculated how much money she has left over at the end of the month?

Give your head a shake. That isn't normal.

cadburyegg · 07/12/2023 18:00

Personally I think social homes should be high rise flats, large enough for large families. Obviously lifts would make it accessible for all

You think just adding lifts makes tower blocks accessible to disabled people? What planet do you live on?

stepintochristmas1 · 07/12/2023 17:38

You need to punch out a couple of kids ( doesn't sound like you have any) so that you have actual stuff to stress about than a woman with kids living in a house ('tis the season of goodwill 🎄).

Flamingogirl08 · 07/12/2023 17:33

Beautiful3 · 07/12/2023 14:51

Honestly I don't think it's very fair at all. But the houses do not belong to them, at all. Personally I think social homes should be high rise flats, large enough for large families. Obviously lifts would make it accessible for all.

Er why exactly?

Tinkerbyebye · 07/12/2023 17:33

Ghentsummer · 07/12/2023 17:29

And she'll continue receiving benefits to pay the rent and won't have the costs of maintaining a house.

@Ghentsummer

neither will she have an asset worth money that could potentially be sold to downsize and you live off the difference as well as your pension(s) so she may not have to maintain a house but she is in for a very poor old age

Tinkerbyebye · 07/12/2023 17:32

If a few years however you will have the benefit of that 40% increasing in value, she won’t. You have done this on your own, she hasn’t

Ghentsummer · 07/12/2023 17:29

CornishPorsche · 07/12/2023 09:25

When you pay off your house (assuming you staircase it), she'll still have to pay the rent forever, even after retirement age. So the gains you'll have will be very different from hers.

Don't compare apples and oranges.

And she'll continue receiving benefits to pay the rent and won't have the costs of maintaining a house.

incywincyspiders · 07/12/2023 17:23

This whole thread is what is wrong with the world today. Stop worrying about what others have or haven't got. You both have houses - what's the big deal? People constantly resenting others when there is honestly no need!

SWSO · 07/12/2023 17:14

Surely though as her children grow up and leave home she will have to downsize. ?

PurpleBugz · 07/12/2023 17:12

The problem is with society. Workers are not paid enough leading to this resentment.

I do kind of get your point. I worked 70 hour weeks to save the deposit for my home. Moved in with partner had kids then split because I have a challenging disabled child I can't leave to go to work. I'm back in my house that too small for the number of kids I have. Not entitled to social housing because I own. Seriously struggling financially but not as much help for me as those who rent. My house is one of the few owned in a mostly social housing street. They have been getting new kitchens and bathrooms recently. When they have too many kids for the house they move on to bigger properties.

It's shit. My life is shit.

BUT you have to remember you have an asset in the house. You actually are paying your off and can move on in future. I'm stuck paying interest only because I can't afford to pay more. I hold onto the fact when I die my kids will get the equity I built before I stopped paying it off. They won't need to work as hard to get their deposits for their houses. (I've got degenerative health stuff myself I'm not gonna love into their Middle Ages- another thing I struggle with as my house isn't appropriate for my needs but I own it so stuck in it).

But honestly. If I hadn't bought before my life fell to shit and I did get social housing I would need to be housed, my kids need to be housed. Life is utterly shit with no money and kids. I can't blame the most disadvantaged people because our society doesn't pay well enough for full time hard work for so many people

GladioliandSweetPeas · 07/12/2023 16:30

Beautiful3 · 07/12/2023 14:51

Honestly I don't think it's very fair at all. But the houses do not belong to them, at all. Personally I think social homes should be high rise flats, large enough for large families. Obviously lifts would make it accessible for all.

So me being a disabled mother means I have to be shoved into a high rise and don't 'deserve' a garden? My child doesn't deserve a garden?

Wow. Tell me you vote Tory without telling me you vote Tory....

GladioliandSweetPeas · 07/12/2023 16:26

cadburyegg · 07/12/2023 11:57

So you are a couple with no kids and a dual income, and no disabilities / reasons why you can't work full time, so there's no reason why you won't be able to climb the career ladder, your income will only increase. You own an asset which will likely only increase in value over the years, you may have options to sell and climb the property ladder in the future.

She is a single mum on UC and possibly child maintenance that can't be relied upon. Her career options are extremely limited because she has no work experience and has to be around to look after the kids after school and during the holidays. She will never own the house she lives in.

And you're jealous of her situation because?

This

GladioliandSweetPeas · 07/12/2023 16:24

Dotjones · 07/12/2023 10:16

Social housing should be segregated from private housing - there should be specific estates for social housing so that situations like the OP's are less likely to occur. Also social housing should be means-tested on a regular basis, if people's income rises they should no longer qualify for social housing. Not necessarily be kicked out of their homes but rents should be increased to market levels.

It IS means tested! I had a very, very in depth means test where I had to provide everything. Bank statements etc. Proof of income. Character references and yes, social housing. It is done every 5 years.

GladioliandSweetPeas · 07/12/2023 16:21

@anonqrtb Given? I have a new build social housing property and I most certainly was not 'given' it ffs. I pay rent every month probably more than you pay out in total. This house will never be mine. I'm here because I lost my DH and lost our house we'd just purchased and had zero equity in. Leaving me and our child homeless.

How dare you?

CasaAmarela · 07/12/2023 15:04

@Timewentfast Completely agree with you. They've just built a load of council houses next to my street and I'm moving. It's unbearable. Litter, screaming kids, fireworks every Sunday in the middle of the night. I don't know why MN is so unwilling to acknowledge that whilst not everyone in council houses is scummy, they do attract a certain type of people ie career scroungers with multiple children they can't be arsed to look after. A PP said that when this happened previously (putting them in one area) it lead to neighbourhoods rife with crime - well what does that show you about the people living there?

Timewentfast · 07/12/2023 14:59

Just to cheer you up OP - when you are finished paying for your house and get old, you'll probably need to sell it to pay for care whilst your neighbour could end up in the same care home as you paid for by council.
It is flippin galling - I don't care what you say. YANBU

Lots of people jumping on the poster who said social housing should be segregated from private housing. I understand they wanted to mix houses to try to stop these really bad areas forming where crime was rife etc. However where I live each new estate has a percentage now of social houses on it and you can always tell where they are without knowing. You walk round the estate and the owned ones are generally (not always) tidy and cared for looking. You get to the social houses and there is rubbish, dog shit bags, broken things lying in front garden. Now I know not everyone in social houses behaves like this but there definately seems to be a pattern. So it's like 'mini ghettos' surrounded by newbuilds. Is this better? Who knows. I'd rather not live beside them and I'm sure most of us feel that way but it's unpopular to say it. I KNOW there are good, honest, decent people, working hard or on benefits temporarily due to life changes and these people might be in social housing and keep their garden nice (and I feel sorry for these people trying their best but having to live next to / in the mini ghetto). However from my observations a large number of the social houses do appear to be littered with rubbish / unkempt. As far as I can see putting the 'scroungers' in the newbuild estates is not making them change their behaviour. They continue as they were before just pulling down the other houses on the estate.