Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we do girls a massive disservice?

133 replies

Sexnotgender · 07/12/2023 08:52

Just dropped off at primary school, the vast, vast majority of girls are in stupid little Mary Jane type shoes with ankle socks. No jumpers.

The boys are in sensible waterproof looking shoes, long trousers and jumpers.

I stood next to a young girl waiting to go in and she kept saying how cold she was. I felt so sorry for her.

OP posts:
MrsSkylerWhite · 07/12/2023 09:58

Ours wore woolly tights (and chose her shoes, within reason) 🤷‍♀️

goodkidsmaadhouse · 07/12/2023 09:58

OP YANBU and actually the boots piss me off as well - I work in a primary and though there are some girls in cosy wellies or snow boots, most of the boots are fancy ones that are a) not waterproof b) not warm and c) a nightmare to get on and off. None of the boys have this issue.

I get why parents buy this sort of thing, I really do, but I wish they’d think beyond the look and about the practicality!

TeenDivided · 07/12/2023 09:57

re boots for girls in winter. I suspect the arguments are:

They aren't needed (boys don't need them, they just wear more sensible shoes all year round)

They produce yet another extra expense for parents of girls, as they still need school shoes for out of winter. Peer pressure to have them.

Parents aren't sensible. The school says plain black ankle boots, no tassles. Before you know it Abby has black tassles, then Beyonce has silver ones, Clara has mid height, Dora has patent knee height. They sit on the carpet and play with the add ons (see also toys in shoes). etc etc. Then Elsa's go missing after PE and they cost £80 (because Fifi fancied them and stuck them in her bag and her parent aren't honest enough to return them).

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 07/12/2023 09:56

Also it kind of goes with the child too. When my DD1 went to preschool, I sent her in 'boys' trousers and 'boys' shoes, and a jumper and thick coat. She was fine with it, until she noticed all the girls were wearing skirts and dresses and Mary Janes. So that's then what she wanted. And I went with it, because (a) I don't want her hating on femininity and (b) I do want her to feel she has control over her own body and have choices to an extent how she presents herself to the world.

So for reception it was patent MJs from Clarks and pinny dresses. When time came to buy her new shoes, she agreed with me MJs are rubbish at keeping you warm and dry and went for patent ankle boots. I am actually well in favour of the patent as it seems more waterproof and I don't have to polish it ever :P And now (just after I bought a bunch more pinny dresses) she's turned off them and only wants to wear trousers!

So I think societal expectations do play a part, as do parental expectations... but I also think girls aren't by and large stupid, and if given choice, and all the choices treated as morally neutral, rather than us feminist mums shitting on 'girly' things, in the end they make the compromises they're happiest and most comfortable in.

verdantverdure · 07/12/2023 09:53

A nearby school to is absolutely unreasonable about their uniform which involves above the knee plaid kilt like skirts for girls bought from a single specialist supplier. Well above the knee for the taller girls.

They also object to the wearing of coats

terraced · 07/12/2023 09:52

I work outside and buy men's clothes and workwear as standard now. It's so much better.

NoCloudsAllowed · 07/12/2023 09:51

I love a pair of Mary Janes!

DD wears a sensible cosy pinafore, polo shirt, thick woolly tights and a pair of black boots. I'd happily wear that myself and it's cosier than DS's trousers. I wish he could wear jersey dungarees!

At our school there's a unisex uniform, plenty of girls wear trousers, a handful of boys wear dresses or skirts when the mood takes them.

mollyfolk · 07/12/2023 09:49

Our school has no uniform for shoes so mine all wear waterproof runners. I agree school shoes for girls are ridiculous. My daughter begged me for a pair of Mary Janes one year and they were wrecked after weeks of scooters and running around in puddles and wet grass.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 07/12/2023 09:49

We have the choice to opt out of the daft expectations for girls. My DD1(9) went to school today in a pinafore, polo, thick tights, cardigan and waterproof black boots. On PE days, she wears joggers instead of shorts or leggings when it’s cold. My DD2(3) will be going to pre-school in her school top, fleece and joggers. She’ll likely be in trainers today as they’re more practical for her and boots won’t go over her joggers.

It is harder to find practical clothes for girls but they are available.

mummymeister · 07/12/2023 09:49

this was never my girls. they dressed up warmly and appropriately and still do. we arent doing girls a disservice. some parents are. they arent instilling confidence in their daughters to be who they want to be or who they are.

HousePlantNeglect · 07/12/2023 09:47

YANBU! I have two boys and a girl and it's completely bonkers.

Our school uniform can be completely unisex, they all wear a school sweater and have the option of any dark plain leggings, joggers, trousers, or skirts. Any shoes are allowed. So it's really relaxed.

The boys generally wear sweatshirt, leggings/joggers and trainers, perfect for playing. Some of the girls wear the same but most wear little Mary Jane patent shoes, knee socks/tights, and a skirt.

SleepingStandingUp · 07/12/2023 09:46

Sexnotgender · 07/12/2023 09:01

Because all the boys were running around having a whale of a time splashing in puddles in their sensible shoes while the girls stood freezing.

So their parents bad parenting is doing them a disservice, not US or SOCIETY. My son's female friends are in trousers or tights and dresses. Both sexes are in shoes they can run around in. They're in jumpers and coats. Sorry your kid goes to school in an area with such useless parents.

Mazuslongtoenail · 07/12/2023 09:45

terrywynne · 07/12/2023 09:09

It's not just daft parenting though is it? It's decades of messaging about what girls"should" wear which has been internalised by parents and passed on to their children. Compounded by companies (especially at the cheaper end) who offer impractical options so they get bought. And the girls don't want the boys options because internalised messaging. And the companies say that they are making what there is demand for but again the demand is there because that is what society tells us should be bought and it takes time to break that and create demand.

Sure, there are plenty of people on MN who think it's daft and who are doing their best to break down gendered notions of clothing but it is not necessarily reflective of people in the UK as a whole

And yes, OP, it is a massive disservice! And hopefully it will change but it is likely to take a while...

I think this is really balanced and sums up how I see it.

My DD is the only girl that wears trousers for non-religious reasons and I buy a lot of her clothes in the boys department.

ThreeTescoBags · 07/12/2023 09:44

DD's class seems to have the opposite problem, the girls are sensibly dressed for the weather but a few of the boys are still in shorts 🥶

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 07/12/2023 09:44

Ploctopus · 07/12/2023 08:59

YANBU. I could rant for days about the ways in which so much clothing made for girls is flimsy, impractical, unsuitable for our climate and inappropriate for play, particularly when compared to clothing made for boys. It’s at every level - right down to pants for little girls having itchy lace round the waistband and legs because some weirdo had decided it’s more important for their pants to be pretty than comfortable.

I don’t have a daughter but if I did I would be much more likely to buy clothes made for boys. That isn’t the solution though - ideally we should move away from the whole concept of gendered children’s clothing and just have all of it be practical and comfortable.

Some brands do a good job of this already (Frugi, Little Green Radicals, Polarn O. Pyret) but they’re bloody expensive. If anyone has recommendations for any high street brands offering similar I’d love to hear them!

I find Tu (Sainsbury's) actually do a lot of good quality, hard-wearing clothes that manage to be attractive to both boys and girls. You have to ignore a lot of the silly stuff but it is there to be had. I dress my DDs largely in these and if Frugi sale items 😆

Dunmuin · 07/12/2023 09:43

I'm not a big fan of Clarks in general, but was pleased to see recently that when I searched for girls' school shoes on their website then a number of good solid options (chunky loafers and lace-ups) came up as well as the pathetic Mary Jane flimsies. A number of their styles show up in both the "Girls' Shoes" and the "Boys' Shoes" sections.

I think they had a bit of a come-to-Jesus moment a few years back when people started pointing out how rubbish their Girls Shoes section was compared with their boys' ones. Also they were naming the girls' styles things like "Dolly Babe" and their boys' styles things like "Leader". It even made the newspapers and Clarks have clearly realised that that was bad publicity...

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 07/12/2023 09:42

Surely there's a winter version of the uniform - tights instead of socks, thicker skirt or even trousers, proper lace up shoes or ankle boots, a nice thick cardigan/jumper?

DazedandConfused1234 · 07/12/2023 09:41

VickyEadieofThigh · 07/12/2023 09:22

YANBU. Gendered clothing (and hair and toys and...)for children has got worse over the past 20 years. I really thought we'd got past this shit by the 90s but if anything, it's even worse than when I was at primary in the 60s. Most girls had short hair back then, too.

100%. I wore lace up shoes, from the girls' section of Startrite in the 70s.and 80s. Lace ups for girls no longer seem to exist.

Also what is the reason for the ban on boots? DD's secondary is obsessed with this rule, but no explanation. As DD's ankles roll easily, I have written her a note to give her permission to wear ankle height walking-style black boots. She has to show that note every day practically, but honestly, I can't see what's wrong with them, and at least her feet are warm and dry.

TeenDivided · 07/12/2023 09:39

My DD wore trousers and jumpers and decent coats.
She had traditional 'girls' shoes, but relatively robust ones. In bad weather she wore wellies to school and changed when she got there.

LakeTiticaca · 07/12/2023 09:37

Its down to the parents to dress them appropriately. It's not like there isn't shops with racks of girls trousers, woollen tights and sturdy winter shoes/boots??

Howmuchtohireahitman · 07/12/2023 09:33

I've sent my DSD to school with wooley tights, knee high black boots, a warm coats, hat and gloves. Nothing to do with doing girls a disservice, just stupid parenting. I've also seen boys in school shorts and ankle socks.

Bloodyhellmate · 07/12/2023 09:32

I'm school support staff and there has been quite a few kids with no gloves, bare legs, thin coats etc in these freezing cold temperatures and they then say to me their hands are cold 😥. I usually give them mine. I do get that parents forget, I'm a parent too but it tends to be the same kids and they never seem to have gloves.

Mulhollandmagoo · 07/12/2023 09:31

DontBeAPrickDarren · 07/12/2023 08:55

How is that doing girls a disservice? It just sounds like daft parenting. Two girls here, both wear trousers and boots to school with a cardigan or jumper 🤷‍♀️

Same here, my daughter wears trousers and ankle boots in this weather, with a school cardigan and her coat!

DappledThings · 07/12/2023 09:27

DD wears tights and a pinafore in the cold and the gingham summer dresses. In the summer. She's warm when she needs to be and hates trousers. Never stopped her hanging off the monkey bars, running around or climbing trees.

At our school it's mostly the boys looking freezing because they insist on still wearing shorts when there's snow on the ground.

CoffeeWithCheese · 07/12/2023 09:27

One of mine has gone in in her Mary-Jane style shoes, the other is wearing ankle boots - both have the choice available (and allowed by school) for them. Both have trousers available - but one will adamantly refuse to wear them at all, the other will do so reluctantly on rare occasions. One will have gone in looking like the Michelin man with a huge thick coat, hat, scarf, gloves (she hates the cold) and the other is trying to tough it out in a blazer because she doesn't get cold like her sister.

Kids vary - round here there are lots of boys who are in shorts through choice still.