Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we do girls a massive disservice?

133 replies

Sexnotgender · 07/12/2023 08:52

Just dropped off at primary school, the vast, vast majority of girls are in stupid little Mary Jane type shoes with ankle socks. No jumpers.

The boys are in sensible waterproof looking shoes, long trousers and jumpers.

I stood next to a young girl waiting to go in and she kept saying how cold she was. I felt so sorry for her.

OP posts:
YetMoreNewBeginnings · 07/12/2023 12:40

Comedycook · 07/12/2023 11:59

It makes me really angry that secondary schools insist on navy or black coats. It gets dark so early... surely it would be safer if they could wear other colours

It enrages me. Especially as we live in an area where lots of children walk a good distance to school.

One of the reasons I felt instantly that DD4’s new HT was going to be a good one was that in her first week (pre covid times) she sent out a note highlighting that children walking to school should be dressed in easy to see colours and made reflective stickers for bags a school manners prize (which coincidentally every child managed to win within two weeks…)

The local secondary HT isn’t half as sensible sadly.

WorkCleanRepeat · 07/12/2023 12:32

Interestingly I thought quite the opposite when I dropped the kids off at school today. The girls were all layered up with boots and tights etc and the boys only really have the option of the same trousers all year round.

maltichi · 07/12/2023 12:31

I agree about the shoes for girls but to be honest I think it's just time we do away with traditional school uniform all together. I only have boys but the school shoes never last the whole year as they're not practical for playing football or running around in the woods. School trousers aren't warm at all, I wouldn't want to wear flimsy, loose trousers in the winter. DS1 wears his PE kit to school two days a week as I'm sure lots of children do now and it seems much more practical and comfortable and I no longer have to replace his school shoes every term.

Longma · 07/12/2023 12:30

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

Lancasterel · 07/12/2023 12:28

My DD (Y3) has black Clark’s school boots this year, and there’s just been a note in the school newsletter saying boots are not part of uniform (for social levelling?!?!). Well she’ll be wearing her boots until Spring because a) they fit and are comfy and b) she has dry feet!! I am normally one to toe the line completely as regards school, but this just seems ridiculous.

TedLasto · 07/12/2023 12:26

Boots are banned at my daughter's primary school, she always wore boots to nursery in winter. It's annoying. She has the clumpiest biggest shoes I could find that were not 'boy' shoes. Cannot get her into tights or trousers without an enormous meltdown so she has long (over the knee) socks on. Went in to school this morning for a music assembly and noticed that she was the only one of the entire school not wearing her cardigan (she was sent in wearing her cardigan). She claims not to feel the cold. (She's also autistic). But I do understand your post OP. It is a feminist issue. Young girls do want to fit in though, and the majority seem to buy into the whole pink/ unicorns/ pretty frilly socks are for girls nonsense. Mine was not interested in any of that until school. At nursery was boots and thick jogging bottoms in winter, and was into dinosaurs. Since school it's skirts and unicorns. I despair.

Nineteendays · 07/12/2023 12:19

There are warm girls clothes available though. My daughter has shiny Velcro shoes that are a cross between a trainer and a shoe, only from Asda but they seem to be holding up and keeping her feet warm and dry. She wears trousers- this week it’s been the fleecy lined leggings from primark although I appreciate some schools won’t allow leggings. She has on a cardi, long warm coat, hat and gloves. If anything she’s warmer than my son used to be in primary because he refused trousers and wore shorts year round. In his high school he has to wear trousers now which took him forever to get used to!

hazandduck · 07/12/2023 12:10

@Theprincessisblanketed yep I’ve had similar, I am very much a feminist and hate gender stereotypes, but my DD struggled when she started reception to make friends and spent a lot of time ‘observing.’ She still is desperate to ‘fit in.’ It’s all well and good using your child to make a political stand, but sometimes you have to take in to account an individual’s feelings and the fact that your child has their own tastes and opinions. She wanted Mary Janes. They are sturdy still and she wears thick tights. I bought her trousers but she hates wearing them because all her girl friends are in skirts. We did then get her a pair of black lace up boots (which she chose) so she wears those on wet or really cold days. And I’ve seen a lot of girls at her school in similar boots on those bad weather days.

OP I do completely understand your point though and hate how objectification of girls starts in infancy, even down to their bloody swimwear. Thank god for full body swimwear!

Orangeandgold · 07/12/2023 12:08

I usually find that my girl does herself a disservice! She is so vocal about not wanting a coat that I have to force on her. She wants socks instead of tights and I have to tell her that she must wear them!

From having conversations with parents they tend to find that their girls want to wear socks and don’t want coats because of some sort of playground trend. Whereas boys go with whatever (usually - this is what I’ve gathered from speaking with parents).

Not mine. She is wearing a coat, jumper l, heat tech and tights in this weather.

PurpleBugz · 07/12/2023 12:06

Yup it really annoys me. Dd school don't allow boots. I cannot find sensible girls school shoes. She won't wear boys shoes as she will get laughed at. Every day it's wet she gets wet feet on the way to school and has damp feet all day.

Theprincessisblanketed · 07/12/2023 12:03

I got my daughter full covering (unisex) shoes her first two years of school but this year she insisted on the t-bar style ones, and to be fair to her has not complained once about the shoes since getting them.

School shoes are too expensive for me to buy proper boots that she'd only wear for a few months, and the school won't let them wear wellies on the school run then change into the school shoes (which would be my preference for her).

She has always had a choice of skirts with tights and trousers in her wardrobe and chooses to wear school trousers (with leggings underneath when it's below zero) in the winter, but she's one of the very few girls who do at her school. I even had a parent comment to me when she started 'oh, are the girls allowed to wear trousers?' - the uniform policy is completely genderless just a list of possible items.

I wish there were full covering 'pretty' shoes to entice her into wearing more than the t-bar shoes, but I imagine they wouldn't sell as well so no one is willing to make them.

Comedycook · 07/12/2023 11:59

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 07/12/2023 11:28

There’s a parental revolt going on at a school near us. The new head banned boots and has insisted on a navy school coat, but also wants the kids walking to school…

Parents are sending notes en-mass basically refusing to allow their child any after school detention for non conforming footwear or a bright coloured coat.

It makes me really angry that secondary schools insist on navy or black coats. It gets dark so early... surely it would be safer if they could wear other colours

nutbrownhare15 · 07/12/2023 11:45

I agree abou the girls shoes but my daughters won't wear anything else. Otherwise they wear trousers, tights or leggings, and jogging bottoms to school. Occasionally the four year old insists on knee high socks in this weather. They always wear a jumper and a coat to school. I'm a bit 🤔at parents not making sure their children is as warm as possible.

Tacotortoise · 07/12/2023 11:32

And yes, girls brogues have become much more common here in recent years (probably because of the crappy weather) so covered shoes for girls do exist.

Tacotortoise · 07/12/2023 11:29

@ByGrabtharsHammarWhatASaving no, the shops stock what sells. When the parents of girls start demanding sensible winter shoes for their daughters you'll find the on the shelves.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 07/12/2023 11:28

verdantverdure · 07/12/2023 10:33

I also love the schools that promote walking to school but don't allow children to wear practical footwear such as boots or trainers.

There’s a parental revolt going on at a school near us. The new head banned boots and has insisted on a navy school coat, but also wants the kids walking to school…

Parents are sending notes en-mass basically refusing to allow their child any after school detention for non conforming footwear or a bright coloured coat.

TurquoiseSeasAndSilverSand · 07/12/2023 11:24

threelittlescones · 07/12/2023 11:17

Any school which attempted to dictate to me that my children couldn't wear weather appropriate, comfortable clothing would be informed otherwise. They'll still be wearing uniform but nobody is going to tell me that my kids can't wear coats (seriously??) thick tights or trousers or boots. Especially on the walk to and from school which is none of their business. Why do people conform to this? That's how schools get away with it.

And they wouldn't be staying for any silly detentions for it either.

How ridiculous. But we're in Scotland and it seems to be different here although I'm sure some schools do try these things.

I'm a bolshy cow and up for making a stand on these things, but my kids aren't/weren't. It's also difficult to fight back, so many conformist parents who think uniform is a good thing, so many posters on MN trot out the line that if you sign up to a school, you sign up to the rules. Overlooking the fact that few people have a realistic choice of schools, few people want to see their kids getting pulled up every time they walk down the school corridor or have numerous isolations and suspensions on their school record.

There's also no storage within school for coats and wellies. Lockers are tiny, anything left hanging around gets stolen.

RudsyFarmer · 07/12/2023 11:23

It’s going to depend if the girls are allowed to pick their outfits. I have a memory of being VERY particular about my shoes at primary. Huge meltdowns over it and wearing ridiculous summer shoes in winter.

Acqua · 07/12/2023 11:23

Daughter likes to look like the average teen. She doesn't like to look all bundled up. However, now that the weather's turned, she's happily wearing the warm coat I bought her (despite her protests) . I also got her a few thermal tops, tights and socks to discreetly layer under her thinner, trendier clothes. Judging how quickly they end back up in the laundry basket means she's appreciating them.

We just need to teach them how to be warm. M&S and Uniqlo are good hunting grounds for thermals. Just wish they were cheaper. Sigh.

CrispsandCheeseSandwich · 07/12/2023 11:21

How weird. Most of the girls at DD's school wear wellies to walk to school if it's raining, and are in jumpers and coats like the boys.

DD wears a pinafore and tights, I hardly see any children at all in skirts and little ankle socks.

megletthesecond · 07/12/2023 11:21

Yanbu.
My DD (and lots of her friends) wore 'boys' shoes in primary school. Always trousers or shorts too.

Boys also need to be able to wear shorts all year round in secondary school.

pastypirate · 07/12/2023 11:21

If anyone is looking for them I bought the dds their school ankle boots in Morrisons every year. They sell quite chic patent ankle boots in primary sizes and they are very reasonable.

pastypirate · 07/12/2023 11:17

Dd ffs not my dad

pastypirate · 07/12/2023 11:17

I think the op has valid points.
My dad's primary has a no boots policy in the uniform long as I can remember. I ignore it every year and send dd2 in parent ankle boots of her choosing when it is cold as well as trousers. Last couple of years she has chosen the genderless Nike school shoes which are at least practical.

That said our primary includes a logo fleece jb its uniform which dd2 requested and wears very happily. It's so much better that a cardigan/jumper and lasts longer and doesn't look scratty after a term. Hardly any kids have been bought the fleeces in the school and it's a very affluent area. Btw I wouldn't push it on dd2 she's very fashion conscious but apparently rhe navy fleece is all good!

We do kids a massive disservice with uniform. It should be warm and practical as a first consideration and non gendered.

threelittlescones · 07/12/2023 11:17

Any school which attempted to dictate to me that my children couldn't wear weather appropriate, comfortable clothing would be informed otherwise. They'll still be wearing uniform but nobody is going to tell me that my kids can't wear coats (seriously??) thick tights or trousers or boots. Especially on the walk to and from school which is none of their business. Why do people conform to this? That's how schools get away with it.

And they wouldn't be staying for any silly detentions for it either.

How ridiculous. But we're in Scotland and it seems to be different here although I'm sure some schools do try these things.