Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we do girls a massive disservice?

133 replies

Sexnotgender · 07/12/2023 08:52

Just dropped off at primary school, the vast, vast majority of girls are in stupid little Mary Jane type shoes with ankle socks. No jumpers.

The boys are in sensible waterproof looking shoes, long trousers and jumpers.

I stood next to a young girl waiting to go in and she kept saying how cold she was. I felt so sorry for her.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cantbeardarknights · 10/12/2023 21:25

Well that’s a bit stupid for the parents to let their children go to school so inder dresses. Mine was in a private school with no trouser options not a problem, warm tights, vest, shirt, pinafore, cardigan or jumper, blazer and warm coat. She wore Mary Jane’s but they were perfectly robust enough and withstood plenty of football. I actually think it’s warmer than trousers. Never got the hoo-ha over the girls wearing dresses. No colder

Ontheperiphery79 · 10/12/2023 21:09

My twin go to school each day in weather appropriate clothing, as do most of the girls I see in their school. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Bean83ts · 10/12/2023 20:59

It’s not bad parenting it’s a mix between, uniform policy and shop availability. Our school don’t allow boots in their uniform
policy and trying to get normal girls shoes for school that are not May Jane style are hard to find (ankle socks are just silly though, big thick tights needed) but I’ve just ignored the uniform policy and popped her in little ankle boots anyway

RafaFan · 09/12/2023 20:52

I'm glad I live in Canada where this doesn't seem to be a thing. All elementary (primary) age kids are encouraged to wear snow suits and snow boots in the winter, and will wear wellies at any time if it's raining. They go outside for recess year round unless it is really torrential rain, so it's essential they're dressed for the weather, and most get bussed to school so have to wait at a bus stop. They are required to have indoor shoes which must be suitable for gym, so no Mary Janes in sight.
It all changes after elementary though, when they have more autonomy on clothing choices. It seems most teenagers NEVER wear coats, even in -20 C conditions, and I have seen teenage girls wearing slippers year round... sigh. It used to be Birkenstocks and socks, but I think that trend has passed. The more sensible ones wear Blundstones, but they're pretty much useless in snow.

toomuchfaff · 08/12/2023 13:44

hazandduck · 08/12/2023 12:29

Do you have an older child and have already gone through the stubborn toddler/preschool years? Just curious to know as hypothetically I would have said the same before I had kids. The reality of battling a mini dictator everywhere you go every time you try to do anything day in day out is actually very different, I had one sweet compliant child and one…how shall I say…”spirited” child who basically will not be forced in to doing anything. It’s easier said than done, and bloody exhausting, sometimes you pick your battles and actually letting them
feel freezing cold is more likely to get them to put their coat on next time.

Yes my only son is 26 now so has passed the terrible twos a long time ago; i think when i was a young mum, there was a lot more "children should be seen and not heard" type attitude...

My friends child was definitely a happy soul - if not a little chilly! And my friend was a lot less stressed than if she had battled...

hazandduck · 08/12/2023 12:29

toomuchfaff · 07/12/2023 16:25

inclined to agree however; took my friends 3 yr old out the other day; in the cold and frost we went for a walk (in her pram) to the park. Would she put on a coat, no, would she put on her wellies - again no, would she allow her self to be covered in any way - no..... even when she was complaining it was cold on the walk - (friend had taken the coat and wellies) - she still wouldn't dress up to stop the cold, wouldn't allow the shoes to be put on, or the coat, or the blanket...

me; i'd have dressed the child and probably have had a nightmare doing so and a very angry reactive 3 yr old; my friend didn't, let her make her own choices and continued to offer the coat/hat/wellies as a solution but let her continue to refuse to be dressed; all the while the child was happy and interactive on the trip (aside from the odd mumblings about being cold) - different parents have different parenting styles and some kids are weird

Do you have an older child and have already gone through the stubborn toddler/preschool years? Just curious to know as hypothetically I would have said the same before I had kids. The reality of battling a mini dictator everywhere you go every time you try to do anything day in day out is actually very different, I had one sweet compliant child and one…how shall I say…”spirited” child who basically will not be forced in to doing anything. It’s easier said than done, and bloody exhausting, sometimes you pick your battles and actually letting them
feel freezing cold is more likely to get them to put their coat on next time.

lljkk · 07/12/2023 18:31

In primary school, DSs preferred shorts & DD wore boots. Girls are usually allowed to wear trousers if they want.

ByGrabtharsHammarWhatASaving · 07/12/2023 18:18

@Tacotortoise how are parents meant to "demand" stuff that isn't available to buy? Shops may only stock what sells, but people can only buy stuff that's in stock. Typically I will go to the supermarket to get the food shopping and look for new shoes at the same time. If I see that there are only ballet pumps or Mary Jane's available for my dd, and then I have to make a choice between buying her shit shoes or spending hours more of my time trawling shops or searching online for an alternative that is twice as expensive. Many people do not have that kind of time or money, they just get the shoes that are available and that's that. The shops may decide that's an endorsement of their product, but if there is no other choice then what can you actually do? Some people have said that instead they just buy their daughters shoes from the boys section, but surely that just shows up in the marketing stats as boys needing more sturdy shoes? If there is a choice of A and B then maybe you can use your purchase power to send a message, but if there is no choice then how are parents realistically meant to influence what is on sale and available to them?

Benibidibici · 07/12/2023 17:59

The little girls i know don't dress like this.

They wear thick tights or trousers. Lots of winter boots (DDs have warm fur on). The boys are worse for wearing shorts well into winter!

The girls all have warm cardigans or jumpers, thick coats etc. The girls are imho more likely to wear warm hats & scarves.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 07/12/2023 16:44

toomuchfaff · 07/12/2023 16:25

inclined to agree however; took my friends 3 yr old out the other day; in the cold and frost we went for a walk (in her pram) to the park. Would she put on a coat, no, would she put on her wellies - again no, would she allow her self to be covered in any way - no..... even when she was complaining it was cold on the walk - (friend had taken the coat and wellies) - she still wouldn't dress up to stop the cold, wouldn't allow the shoes to be put on, or the coat, or the blanket...

me; i'd have dressed the child and probably have had a nightmare doing so and a very angry reactive 3 yr old; my friend didn't, let her make her own choices and continued to offer the coat/hat/wellies as a solution but let her continue to refuse to be dressed; all the while the child was happy and interactive on the trip (aside from the odd mumblings about being cold) - different parents have different parenting styles and some kids are weird

I used to be the parent that fought the coat and boots onto DS2. Then we met another parent like your friend and I basically copied her. I instantly had a much happier child.

He still is in shorts most of the year now in his teens and I buy him a relatively low cost (but still waterproof/warm) coat each year despite the face he never wears it because his school (understandably) would consider it a neglect issue if he didn't have one. It gets donated to the school uniform bank every time he grows. If it's really, really cold he'll wear a hoodie. The coat is scrunched in the bottom of his bag the entire time.

toomuchfaff · 07/12/2023 16:25

inclined to agree however; took my friends 3 yr old out the other day; in the cold and frost we went for a walk (in her pram) to the park. Would she put on a coat, no, would she put on her wellies - again no, would she allow her self to be covered in any way - no..... even when she was complaining it was cold on the walk - (friend had taken the coat and wellies) - she still wouldn't dress up to stop the cold, wouldn't allow the shoes to be put on, or the coat, or the blanket...

me; i'd have dressed the child and probably have had a nightmare doing so and a very angry reactive 3 yr old; my friend didn't, let her make her own choices and continued to offer the coat/hat/wellies as a solution but let her continue to refuse to be dressed; all the while the child was happy and interactive on the trip (aside from the odd mumblings about being cold) - different parents have different parenting styles and some kids are weird

Rummikub · 07/12/2023 15:35

I remember primary school would say wellies and boots had to be changed out of during the day. So you’d have to remember a second pair.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 07/12/2023 15:16

Lots of girls when they get to secondary school don't feel that this is a fair option though as they want to wear skirts and feel like they are being forced to wear the boys uniform.

Completely agree because unisex just means male fit. It often looks frumpy and ill-fitting on growing girls and women. They should be able to wear clothes that suit their bodies without expectation or shame. I’m all for schools having expectations for uniform but they need to take into account that we live in a wet, cold and miserable country and children need practical clothes for break times.

RandomUsernameHere · 07/12/2023 14:52

It's the opposite in our family, DD is wearing tracksuit bottoms and DS is wearing shorts (his choice) today. DD always wears thick tights if she wears a dress or skirt with the winter uniform.

Goldenbear · 07/12/2023 14:44

DD can't stand football or mixed Rugby and very much stands on the sidelines. Her p.e team players that are boys have a go at her about it, i.e "get in position", "stop standing about", which really annoys me as they have played their whole school life and DD hasn't but as the 'girls' football' has been pushed on to every girl in every school in the last 3 or 4 years, it is unacceptable to opt out. It is nothing to do with societal expectations as her older brother and Dad are keen footballers as are my brother and all his DC including his daughter but we play an annual family torment with a cup at the end (my DB's idea)every Christmas and ever since this has begun, DD has hated it and doesn't join in despite seeing that her aunt, Mum and girl cousin are playing. She is arty and a musician and just not in to sport, particularly team sport, nothing to do with shoes, all to do with personal interests/passions.

Goldenbear · 07/12/2023 14:35

user1471523870 · 07/12/2023 09:19

I agree with @CalistoNoSolo and uniforms should be unisex. There is absolutely no reasons why boys and girls should wear different type of clothes.

Lots of girls when they get to secondary school don't feel that this is a fair option though as they want to wear skirts and feel like they are being forced to wear the boys uniform.

My DD is 12 and is pretty alternative with style, she is wearing trousers now because she is pretty small and feels the cold but they are not boys polyester trousers, more black tracksuit material baggy and flared, 90s style but up until two weeks ago she was wearing the school kilt, fairly short with 40 denier tights and DMs, some girls buy laddered tights and the school accept it (they changed their policy on that last year). DD when she was at infant school liked wearing Mary Janes, I'd buy the thick soled ones but she was always in to fairy tales and would dress as a fairy all of the time when not in school, it came with an intense imagination and a dislike of all stuff that was 'for boys', she didn't want to be practical and she didn't want to go to school anyway so for a time we went with it. The compromises I found were very expensive Austrian made boots which she accepted as I showed her a drawing of an elf like fairy with boots on. It is not a disservice IMO to accept who your child is as an individual. I am way more practical with clothes although do share her romanticism, she has a brother and her Dad only has brothers so he had no clue about fairies and clothes that are impractical and flowing!

KatieKat88 · 07/12/2023 14:28

DD doesn't start reception until next year but this thread has inspired me to look at the unform page of the school she'll hopefully end up at - it's a non-gendered list of clothes (shorts, trousers, dresses all together with no mention of boy or girl) and just 'black school shoes'. That's quite refreshing!

ChateauMargaux · 07/12/2023 14:00

TurquoiseSeasAndSilverSand · 07/12/2023 09:26

One of my kids always wore pinafores, she hated skirts, trousers or shorts because they wouldn't stay up. Mainly wore leggings and dresses at home. It never stopped her being active, she was a keen footballer out of school, but didn't play at school because the boys hogged all the space 🙄.

My daughter is also a keen footballer.. but I do think that it is much harder to kick a football in a pair of Mary Janes than it is in a pair of solid shoes, it hurts, the ball doesn't go as far and most likely in the wrong direction.. I think more girls would play football if they wore trainers all the time. I remember a picture of Prince George and Princess Charlotte with a football.. it made me think that we are hampering the chances of girls being interested in sport by dressing them as we do. (we being society on average.. not those exceptional girls who find their way to the football pitch, or other places, despite the barriers in their way)

To think we do girls a massive disservice?
To think we do girls a massive disservice?
mondaytosunday · 07/12/2023 13:53

Aren't they allowed tights? And we always wore boots to school and they could change out of them.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 07/12/2023 13:28

I don’t understand schools saying no to boots. I’ve just checked my DD’s school’s policy and it just says sensible, flat black boots below the knee. I did struggle to find school suitable ones this year that met the criteria of: black, flat, not patterned, mid-calf length… I ended up getting DDs the same pair each from Monsoon as that’s all I could find that met what I wanted. They have flowers on the side but very much appropriate for school.

To think we do girls a massive disservice?
Achildbelongstoitsmother · 07/12/2023 13:21

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 07/12/2023 12:48

But layering when wearing trousers is perfectly possible as well.

Tights (or leggins, long johns etc) under trousers seem fairly normal to me. and warmer than a skirt and tights...

Of course layering is possible under boys' trousers, just as it is possible for girls to wear 'boys' shoes. But in the UK boys don't wear tights etc under trousers so they get teased if they do.
Most boys would prefer to be cold than teased.
Boys are often the victims of sexism but it is rarely noticed on MN.
MNers tend to care about their daughters but quite happily hang their sons out to dry - or to get cold in this example.

problembottom · 07/12/2023 13:15

There is none of that at DD's school thankfully, she's in reception and the girls are dressed as warm as the boys and just as scruffy looking. Many wear trousers.

I did always think this in the park though when DD was a toddler and we went a lot. DD would be in her scruffs with trainers or wellies on her feet, tearing around the playground, as would many girls in there. But there would always be one or two toddlers dressed to the nines with beautiful dresses and patent shoes who were not allowed to run around, jump in puddles, climb up anything in case they got dirty. I always felt so sorry for them... just why?!

honeylulu · 07/12/2023 13:06

My daughter age 9 hates having her legs covered. She has school trousers and warm tights but she always insists on a skirt with modesty shorts underneath and socks. People constantly ask her "aren't you cold? " and she says no and laughs. It's not all "bad parenting".

She wears shorts at the weekend too!

Kayte198999 · 07/12/2023 12:52

I know kids do some running around and the inside of school is heated but many of them also walk home or have to wait at the bus stop. My school uniform was a skirt all year round and socks or tights. I couldn't stand the feeling of tights and in the winter waiting for the bus my legs were practically blue. I thought it was normal to be freezing all the time in winter. Now as an adult I wear thermal leggings under trousers and two pairs of socks and would refuse to force my child to wait bare-legged in ice or snow

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 07/12/2023 12:48

WorkCleanRepeat · 07/12/2023 12:32

Interestingly I thought quite the opposite when I dropped the kids off at school today. The girls were all layered up with boots and tights etc and the boys only really have the option of the same trousers all year round.

But layering when wearing trousers is perfectly possible as well.

Tights (or leggins, long johns etc) under trousers seem fairly normal to me. and warmer than a skirt and tights...

Swipe left for the next trending thread