Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that God doesn't exist and is a manmade concept

569 replies

Perimama · 07/12/2023 01:42

As it is taboo to talk religion politics with people socially, I often wonder whether many people think like me. As a species we have dismissed all the other "Gods" ie Greek gods etc. What makes the Christian God any different? I wasn't born into a religious household although I was baptized Christian. The whole concept seems so unbelievable to me.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
eardefender · 08/12/2023 15:57

@XDownwiththissortofthingX

Religion understandably has a vested interest in declaring a monopoly on morality, and maintaining the facade that humanity would collapse without it, because religion also frequently claims that it is the source of human morality even though this is blatantly untrue. If you come to that realisation though, it is yet another quandary that calls into question the need for religion and religiosity at all

I feel that what you have written down is typical of a secular view of religion and religious people. May i be so bold as to suggest that you don't understand that some people have faith. They really believe. If you ban religion tomorrow people will still worship. Not all religious people are part of a power crazed mafia based on control.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 08/12/2023 15:34

eardefender · 08/12/2023 15:17

I don't agree with your view that religion was invented to control the masses. I think this is far too simplistic (and sorry a bit lazy). If this were true then why would every culture have religion at the heart of it and why is religion a very strong and real factor in peoples lives and culture regardless of education levels or wealth. Religion, education and wealth have been around a lot longer than 1880.

I never said that education wasn't around until 1880 in the UK, I said free education of the masses wasn't.

Of course every culture has to have religion to control the masses before they were educated. It carries on today because people were taught to feel guilty or isolated from their families if they dimissed religion.

Religious leaders make sure that their victims cannot think for themselves and are brainwashed in to feeling guilty if they do something that is against the religion.

Abracadabra12345 · 08/12/2023 15:32

@eardefender Just to say that I am really enjoying your posts

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/12/2023 15:31

overwhelmed2023 · 08/12/2023 15:06

Of course atheists have a moral code according to individual values and obeying the law. What might be different is that it varies more and also is more culturally based. Not saying that's bad but just likely to be different from the for eg Christian values

I'd argue that's a bit arse about face, and what is commonly described as "Christian values" are just those which Christianity has co-opted from general humanity and labelled as their own.

Like previous posters, the attempted religious monopolisation of morality, and associated dire prognostications breakdown of natural law and order should we cast aside religion, irk me no end. Humans have an innate sense of right and wrong, decency, and a natural inclination toward helping other human beings because we all share and understand the human condition to one degree or another.

The fact that some transgress, and some choose to be hateful, immoral, or violent, is not in any way an indication of this being untrue, nor is it the case that this occurs because of a deficit in religiosity, because it still occurs even in the most religious of places, and then you have all the examples of violence, territorial dispute, disharmony, and so on which are fundamentally underpinned by difference in religious dogma.

Religion understandably has a vested interest in declaring a monopoly on morality, and maintaining the facade that humanity would collapse without it, because religion also frequently claims that it is the source of human morality even though this is blatantly untrue. If you come to that realisation though, it is yet another quandary that calls into question the need for religion and religiosity at all.

eardefender · 08/12/2023 15:25

NotEvenThought · 08/12/2023 14:56

@eardefender

Ancient people were not uneducated at all. For example, their maritime knowledge was exceptional and advanced. Ancient people also had deep faith as we can see from the monuments they left behind. I think that religious and spiritual connection and experience is innate to us as human beings and its part of our shared subconcious.

I'm not a historian but as far as I understand most religious monuments were built by power hungry men or 'churches' to control their populations. Building such as the Pyramids and St Peter's Basilica were not serving the spiritual needs of the locals but the megalomaniac desires of the leaders of the time.

I respectfully disagree. My local churches are stunning and one is over 1,000 years old. Its quite an experience to be in one. Stonehenge and Newgrange are also incredibly spiritual places built to honour the dead and possibly to connect to some kind of afterlife. Churches were educational centres, community hubs and the local charity rolled into one. They were the best building in the village. I think your view is a bit dismissive.

eardefender · 08/12/2023 15:19

overwhelmed2023 · 08/12/2023 15:06

Of course atheists have a moral code according to individual values and obeying the law. What might be different is that it varies more and also is more culturally based. Not saying that's bad but just likely to be different from the for eg Christian values

You could argue that the law and individual values come directly from religion. There is nothing wrong with being secular but still following Judeo/Christian values. I am not sure we can really separate ourselves from our heritage that easily or that quickly.

eardefender · 08/12/2023 15:17

IMustDoMoreExercise · 08/12/2023 14:50

Well google says that we only had compulsory education for children in 1880 so before that only rich people could be educated.

That is why religion was needed to control the masses before then.

I don't agree with your view that religion was invented to control the masses. I think this is far too simplistic (and sorry a bit lazy). If this were true then why would every culture have religion at the heart of it and why is religion a very strong and real factor in peoples lives and culture regardless of education levels or wealth. Religion, education and wealth have been around a lot longer than 1880.

overwhelmed2023 · 08/12/2023 15:06

Of course atheists have a moral code according to individual values and obeying the law. What might be different is that it varies more and also is more culturally based. Not saying that's bad but just likely to be different from the for eg Christian values

NotEvenThought · 08/12/2023 14:56

@eardefender

Ancient people were not uneducated at all. For example, their maritime knowledge was exceptional and advanced. Ancient people also had deep faith as we can see from the monuments they left behind. I think that religious and spiritual connection and experience is innate to us as human beings and its part of our shared subconcious.

I'm not a historian but as far as I understand most religious monuments were built by power hungry men or 'churches' to control their populations. Building such as the Pyramids and St Peter's Basilica were not serving the spiritual needs of the locals but the megalomaniac desires of the leaders of the time.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 08/12/2023 14:50

eardefender · 08/12/2023 14:35

Which period are you referring to? What do you mean by 'Education' and 'masses'? This is such a blanket statement it doesn't really mean anything.

Well google says that we only had compulsory education for children in 1880 so before that only rich people could be educated.

That is why religion was needed to control the masses before then.

NotEvenThought · 08/12/2023 14:42

The idea that atheists have 'no moral code' is entirely wrong and frankly offensive

I agree. I'm extremely honest and have always (quietly) done lots of charity work and am generally a decent person. I behave like I do because it's the right thing to do and it makes life easy and relaxing for me. I'm not doing it because some all-seeing God is watching me and I'm not doing it to get a pass into heaven or access to virgins or whatever it might be.

Chinhairsoftheworldunite · 08/12/2023 14:40

Disclaimer: I haven’t read this section yet, I’m working my way from the start of his blog but might find this interesting as he is an atheist with a history background

https://historyforatheists.com/the-great-myths/

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 14:35

I do get exasperated with the "atheists have no moral code" line! Of course we do. And there are already non faith based alternatives to church weddings, baptisms and funerals. Sunday ceased to be a day of rest many years ago.

eardefender · 08/12/2023 14:35

IMustDoMoreExercise · 08/12/2023 11:39

A few people were educated but not the masses.

Which period are you referring to? What do you mean by 'Education' and 'masses'? This is such a blanket statement it doesn't really mean anything.

ErrolTheDragon · 08/12/2023 13:45

You have made a very interesting point. There is an idea that we should all be upholding our religious communities churches etc even if we are atheist because we have nothing else and that atheism does not offer anything to those without faith in terms of life markers like baptism and funerals, marriages etc. No structure to the week, no moral code, no marking the seasons. No centre of a community to uphold values and help people. The idea being that until secular society creates a viable alternative to replace faith based practice then we need to continue with the old.

But you simply don't need a religion for most of those things. The idea that atheists have 'no moral code' is entirely wrong and frankly offensive. Our civil society allows for entirely secular marking of births, marriages and deaths. There is obviously structure to our weeks - the 'day of rest' may have been decided by one religion or another but is firmly entrenched in working practices. We have a justice system and social services. They may not work as well as we'd like but as far as I can see these things are better in the secular present than the religious past.

ErrolTheDragon · 08/12/2023 13:38

natural selection is a theory which many feel has not applied to humans at least as a species.

The fact that now we have 'unnatural' selection (of animals even more than humans) in no way negates the many millions of years of natural selection leading to Homo sapiens.
How anyone 'feels' on this subject is somewhat irrelevant as it's a matter of objective evidence not subjective views.

boamorte · 08/12/2023 12:49

Brainwashing from a young age is why people believe in god

It's a load of BS

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 12:17

@Achildbelongstoitsmother I'm sorry to go on, btw. But you did address me by name, several times.

PTSDBarbiegirl · 08/12/2023 12:16

Achildbelongstoitsmother · 08/12/2023 12:02

But are you confident that the people would be richer if the Catholic Church did not exist. And if so, why?
If man created religion did he also create capitalism. Or is Capitalism just a natural occurring system of organising society?
Did the Catholic Church protect the poor against capitalism or vice-versa? Did the Catholic Church create capitalism or vive-versa?
If Capitalism controlled the Church why did the Church preach to help the poor, the sick and the needy? Was this just window-dressing?
So many questions. It is so much easier to just declare religion is crap.

I recommend you read some philosophy books to answer your questions.

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 12:16

@Achildbelongstoitsmother "My point is that more thought is required by us all. We need to listen as well as speak. We need to think rather than argue. We need to learn rather than want to be right."

I'm sorry- I still don't understand.

Achildbelongstoitsmother · 08/12/2023 12:02

PTSDBarbiegirl · 08/12/2023 11:46

31% of the world's population are religious and half of them Christians. In times before universal education the core tenets of the Bible were what educated people, the basic principles of all religions are very similar.
People add to them or make new versions and use religious teachings to control the vulnerable and get them to do what they want. Look at the wealth of the Catholic Church and the poverty round the world. The themes of good over evil are the same themes in all the big cultural phenomenon too, even Harry Potter! 'God' is whatever you want it to be.

But are you confident that the people would be richer if the Catholic Church did not exist. And if so, why?
If man created religion did he also create capitalism. Or is Capitalism just a natural occurring system of organising society?
Did the Catholic Church protect the poor against capitalism or vice-versa? Did the Catholic Church create capitalism or vive-versa?
If Capitalism controlled the Church why did the Church preach to help the poor, the sick and the needy? Was this just window-dressing?
So many questions. It is so much easier to just declare religion is crap.

yoteyak · 08/12/2023 11:47

crikeymikeydoyoulikey · 08/12/2023 08:45

It is a fascinating thought. Here's an excerpt from GotQuestions which I find a helpful site when my mind is wrangling with these thoughts:

Next comes the big question: does God exist? Atheists and naturalists (who do not accept anything beyond this physical world and universe) say “no.” While volumes have been written and debates have raged throughout history on this question, it is actually not difficult to answer. To give it proper attention, you must first ask this question: Why do we have something rather than nothing at all? In other words, how did you and everything around you get here? The argument for God can be presented very simply:

Something exists.
You do not get something from nothing.
Therefore, a necessary and eternal Being exists.

You cannot deny you exist because you have to exist in order to deny your own existence (which is self-defeating), so the first premise above is true. No one has ever demonstrated that something can come from nothing unless they redefine what ‘nothing’ is, so the second premise rings true. Therefore, the conclusion naturally follows—an eternal Being is responsible for everything that exists.

This is a position no thinking atheist denies; they just claim that the universe is that eternal being. However, the problem with that stance is that all scientific evidence points to the fact that the universe had a beginning (the ‘big bang’). And everything that has a beginning must have a cause; therefore, the universe had a cause and is not eternal. Because the only two sources of eternality are an eternal universe (denied by all current empirical evidence) or an eternal Creator, the only logical conclusion is that God exists. Answering the question of God’s existence in the affirmative rules out atheism as a valid belief system.

gotquestions bible - Search (bing.com)

@crikeymikeydoyoulikey : "everything that has a beginning must have a cause"

Interestingly, this is challenged by certain interpretations of quantum mechanics (QM).

When Albert Einstein famously refused to believe that "God plays dice", he was referring to QM's implications of essential randomness, with further implications of non-causal happenings (including 'beginnings', such as for instance the start of a particular caesium-137 atom's decay ... or, indeed, what has become known as the Big Bang).

And, well, Einstein's reservations turned out to be misplaced. As far as we can tell (and perhaps modulo more outré interpretations such as 'many worlds' which anyway wouldn't rescue that premise in the argument for theism), events at the quantum level do have uncaused beginnings.

There are many fallacies in that argument for theism, @crikeymikeydoyoulikey; far too many to list, and some of them fairly gross. But I thought you might be interested in a particular way scientific advances falsify one of its major premises.

[Of course QM is the most successful physical theory ever. It just works - predicts and explains - better than any other theory.]

PTSDBarbiegirl · 08/12/2023 11:46

31% of the world's population are religious and half of them Christians. In times before universal education the core tenets of the Bible were what educated people, the basic principles of all religions are very similar.
People add to them or make new versions and use religious teachings to control the vulnerable and get them to do what they want. Look at the wealth of the Catholic Church and the poverty round the world. The themes of good over evil are the same themes in all the big cultural phenomenon too, even Harry Potter! 'God' is whatever you want it to be.

Achildbelongstoitsmother · 08/12/2023 11:45

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 11:39

@Achildbelongstoitsmother

Am I somehow missing a joke? I don't understand your post.

Sadly I'm not funny, so you are not missing a joke.

My point is that more thought is required by us all. We need to listen as well as speak. We need to think rather than argue. We need to learn rather than want to be right.

I'm impressed with eardefender's post above. I found that very thought provoking.

Blueeyes13 · 08/12/2023 11:45

crikeymikeydoyoulikey · 08/12/2023 10:16

I know of some already (including myself). I will dig them up and post them here, if that's okay with everyone. I should be working, after having lost all day to a powercut yesterday, but I'll be back...

The most obvious one I can think of is C S Lewis who rejected Christianity as a teenager and became an atheist, especially after his experience in World War 1. He became a Christian and was one of the most influential theologians in the world. When he came to believe in god he described himself as the most dejected and reluctant convert in the whole of England.

Swipe left for the next trending thread