Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that God doesn't exist and is a manmade concept

569 replies

Perimama · 07/12/2023 01:42

As it is taboo to talk religion politics with people socially, I often wonder whether many people think like me. As a species we have dismissed all the other "Gods" ie Greek gods etc. What makes the Christian God any different? I wasn't born into a religious household although I was baptized Christian. The whole concept seems so unbelievable to me.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
MassageForLife · 08/12/2023 17:06

If someone needs religion in order to have a set of morals to live by, then surely that doesn't say much for them as an individual?

I think that people that use that as a pro-religious argument haven't really thought it through. People are perfectly capable of having a strong moral code without relying on religion. Do the people saying that think that without religion they would be a murderous adulterer that eats too much and moves too little?

overwhelmed2023 · 08/12/2023 17:04

xdown
I take your point. Everyone can be good, patient, kind etc
Maybe what I meant was that speaking now about what Christians specifically believe or experience is that if you are following Jesus you become better than you could be alone - through example but also through faith and the Holy Spirit.
We are flawed and fail but that is the aim / path.
It probably means more spiritual than earthly priorities. In general.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/12/2023 17:03

eardefender · 08/12/2023 17:02

I think it is a faith because you cant prove God doesn't exist.

There is no need for atheists to prove anything.

It's not atheists making the extraordinary claims.

eardefender · 08/12/2023 17:02

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/12/2023 16:58

@eardefender

I won't take exception with Atheism being described as a "belief". It's a term I'll use myself.

It is in no way a "faith" though, because it is not dependent upon the existence of something absent of proof.

My criticism of atheism is that it offers not much at all and is very dull and a sort of nothingness which doesn't cater for our need for ritual and spirituality, shared memory and basically anything very interesting

You are, of course, entitled to your own opinion of atheism, but I will just say that the fact it might appear "dull" or a nothingness, is of no concern whatsoever to atheists, and some people have absolutely no need for ritual and spirituality.

I am one of them. I do not have a spiritual bone in my body, I don't even really recognise the concept of "spirituality" because I find the notion absurd and alien. It is utterly superfluous to my needs, which is why I have no issues with accepting atheism.

Edited

I think it is a faith because you cant prove God doesn't exist.

eardefender · 08/12/2023 16:59

TriOptimim · 08/12/2023 16:44

Interesting you list marriage. I can get marriage in spite of the Church, not because of it.

You can 'get' marriage because of the church, not 'in spite of it'. (Interesting use of words there). Marriage is a religious institution and a good example of how even secular people are still living in a religious way.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/12/2023 16:58

@eardefender

I won't take exception with Atheism being described as a "belief". It's a term I'll use myself.

It is in no way a "faith" though, because it is not dependent upon the existence of something absent of proof.

My criticism of atheism is that it offers not much at all and is very dull and a sort of nothingness which doesn't cater for our need for ritual and spirituality, shared memory and basically anything very interesting

You are, of course, entitled to your own opinion of atheism, but I will just say that the fact it might appear "dull" or a nothingness, is of no concern whatsoever to atheists, and some people have absolutely no need for ritual and spirituality.

I am one of them. I do not have a spiritual bone in my body, I don't even really recognise the concept of "spirituality" because I find the notion absurd and alien. It is utterly superfluous to my needs, which is why I have no issues with accepting atheism.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 08/12/2023 16:58

eardefender · 08/12/2023 16:57

'all religions are cults', 'who brainwash their victims'?.......

Saying this doesn't make you sound like you have a tin foil hat on at all. Definitely not....

Of course they are. What are they if they are not cults?

eardefender · 08/12/2023 16:57

IMustDoMoreExercise · 08/12/2023 16:48

What exactly have I said that is hateful?

'all religions are cults', 'who brainwash their victims'?.......

Saying this doesn't make you sound like you have a tin foil hat on at all. Definitely not....

eardefender · 08/12/2023 16:55

this is a brilliant thread, i am really trying to write Christmas cards and also manage my unruly children but will try and read and reply to so many comments. thanks all who are contributing.

ReadtheReviews · 08/12/2023 16:51

Nrft but the title sounds like something you discuss with uni friends convinced you are the first person ever to have this revelation.

OP, nothing is provable one way or the other. Believe what you like as long as it doesn't infringe on others. I'm not.religious but I do find the existence of the universe pretty odd and don't for one second think some bald, slightly smart (but not so smart they don't keep having wars and fucking up their planet) apes can possibly understand it.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 08/12/2023 16:48

eardefender · 08/12/2023 16:17

this is hateful, you are not here to debate or discuss at all. Sad.

What exactly have I said that is hateful?

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/12/2023 16:46

@Rockofages3

Atheism is a rare niche belief. Are the majority of humanity dumb and wrong?

I wouldn't suggest they are "dumb", but it is entirely possible they are, indeed, wrong.

To say you know what’s going on enough to firmly class oneself as atheist is the height of arrogance and narcissism at worst, or simple ignorance at best

Well this is total nonsense.

Atheism, simply put, is the denial of the existence of the divine. There is no evidence whatsoever that divinity is a real thing, therefore, it is perfectly reasonable and sensible to conclude that it does not exist.

What else do you, if you believe in the existence of the divine, also believe in despite there being no evidence whatsoever to suggest it actually exists? Russell's teapot?

A belief in a higher power would mean you have everything to gain after our short lives, and disbelief could be loosing everything

So the afterlife is conditional upon belief? Ok, I'd like some sort of explanation for how the mechanics of this function precisely, because if you can be making claims about entry conditions, then you surely must be familiar with how, precisely it all works, so please spill the beans.

Betting on another life, instead of non existence, is a no brainer, only positives can come from it. Whilst the pessimism of non existence is very negative and invites corruption without consequence to those with low ethics

You are just lowering yourself to arrant nonsense now. There is nothing "negative" about non-belief, otherwise you wouldn't have so many people happy to testify that their journey away from belief and toward atheism liberated them and made them far happier than they were previously. It would also be impossible for atheists to describe the peace and contentment that freedom from religion provides. Corruption and low ethics you say? Care to comment on the unending series of revelations and abuse scandals associated with the priesthood, religious schools, churches and so on?

Belief makes us psychologically and physically safer

Evidence for this extraordinary claim please.

eardefender · 08/12/2023 16:45

@XDownwiththissortofthingX

when religion is completely absent.
But it has never been completely absent. Can we really separate from it? I am not so sure. Judaism is the religion from which christianity and parts of Islam flow and it is at least 4,000 years old. It is the cornerstone of our laws and cultural norms in so many ways. Even if you consider your self secular i don't think you can say you have no influence from religion. Also atheism is a belief system like any other. Atheism is a faith and i don't think it is better or worse or more proven than any other faith. My criticism of atheism is that it offers not much at all and is very dull and a sort of nothingness which doesn't cater for our need for ritual and spirituality, shared memory and basically anything very interesting.

TriOptimim · 08/12/2023 16:44

Rockofages3 · 08/12/2023 16:33

If we look beyond our small island (which is difficult to find without a magnifying glass in a to scale world map), the vast majority of the world’s population believes in a higher power.

Atheism is a rare niche belief. Are the majority of humanity dumb and wrong?
I dare say the majority who do not live in technology based cities have a much wider knowledge of nature and the natural forces at play as yet unexplained by science.

We are still in our infancy when it comes to deciphering our little corner of the galaxy, let alone the universe, 90% of which is unseen and we don’t know what it’s made of or what it does. And we haven’t even touched on multiverses or multiple dimensions.

To say you know what’s going on enough to firmly class oneself as atheist is the height of arrogance and narcissism at worst, or simple ignorance at best.

A belief in a higher power would mean you have everything to gain after our short lives, and disbelief could be loosing everything.

Betting on another life, instead of non existence, is a no brainer, only positives can come from it. Whilst the pessimism of non existence is very negative and invites corruption without consequence to those with low ethics.

Belief makes us collectively psychologically and physically safer.

Knowing there is supreme love, as well as ultimate justice, even if it not found in this world, can make all the difference.

Edited

Calling atheists ignorant, arrogant and narcissistic is also quite offensive.

TriOptimim · 08/12/2023 16:44

eardefender · 08/12/2023 11:36

You have made a very interesting point. There is an idea that we should all be upholding our religious communities churches etc even if we are atheist because we have nothing else and that atheism does not offer anything to those without faith in terms of life markers like baptism and funerals, marriages etc. No structure to the week, no moral code, no marking the seasons. No centre of a community to uphold values and help people. The idea being that until secular society creates a viable alternative to replace faith based practice then we need to continue with the old.

Interesting you list marriage. I can get marriage in spite of the Church, not because of it.

TriOptimim · 08/12/2023 16:43

eardefender · 08/12/2023 16:01

Actually the church has been providing free education to the masses long before 1880. I think your generalisations about all religion are quite frankly bonkers and also just bigoted religious discrimination. I really think you need to think about having some tolerance and understanding of others beliefs and faiths. I hope you can see that many will find what you have written quite offensive.

Not as offensive as saying atheists don't have a moral code.

Rockofages3 · 08/12/2023 16:33

If we look beyond our small island (which is difficult to find without a magnifying glass in a to scale world map), the vast majority of the world’s population believes in a higher power.

Atheism is a rare niche belief. Are the majority of humanity dumb and wrong?
I dare say the majority who do not live in technology based cities have a much wider knowledge of nature and the natural forces at play as yet unexplained by science.

We are still in our infancy when it comes to deciphering our little corner of the galaxy, let alone the universe, 90% of which is unseen and we don’t know what it’s made of or what it does. And we haven’t even touched on multiverses or multiple dimensions.

To say you know what’s going on enough to firmly class oneself as atheist is the height of arrogance and narcissism at worst, or simple ignorance at best.

A belief in a higher power would mean you have everything to gain after our short lives, and disbelief could be loosing everything.

Betting on another life, instead of non existence, is a no brainer, only positives can come from it. Whilst the pessimism of non existence is very negative and invites corruption without consequence to those with low ethics.

Belief makes us collectively psychologically and physically safer.

Knowing there is supreme love, as well as ultimate justice, even if it not found in this world, can make all the difference.

Cloudisi · 08/12/2023 16:27

Ultimately, humans are scared or intimidated by "the unknown". A religion helps comfort people.

Cloudisi · 08/12/2023 16:25

I agree. We fill in what we don't know with religion and faith.

Once upon a time, we had rain gods because we didn't know how rain worked. I don't see how modern religions are any different. My Catholic ex used to say that evolution wasn't real and that there were some pieces of evidence that were missing etс and it's just a theory... But got mightily offended when I replied that his "theory" of the universe had no evidence and was just a story.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/12/2023 16:23

overwhelmed2023 · 08/12/2023 16:13

Xdown:
Not really because Christian's take their way of behaving from the Bible and Jesus' example. For eg if I was acting as a secular person I might think it's ok to be fall out with someone if they were annoying/ unreliable etc but as a Christian I might think harder to empathise with them and cut them slack.

Or conversely, you as a Christian, might still reach the limit of your patience with them, whereas someone who is more patient than even you, despite being an atheist, may still persist with them.

Patience may well be a "Chrisitian value", but it is also a human value, and unless you want to go making wild claims about all Christians, without exception, being more patient that atheists, then I think your point is nonsense, quite frankly.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/12/2023 16:20

eardefender · 08/12/2023 15:57

@XDownwiththissortofthingX

Religion understandably has a vested interest in declaring a monopoly on morality, and maintaining the facade that humanity would collapse without it, because religion also frequently claims that it is the source of human morality even though this is blatantly untrue. If you come to that realisation though, it is yet another quandary that calls into question the need for religion and religiosity at all

I feel that what you have written down is typical of a secular view of religion and religious people. May i be so bold as to suggest that you don't understand that some people have faith. They really believe. If you ban religion tomorrow people will still worship. Not all religious people are part of a power crazed mafia based on control.

I have never doubted that people have "faith", and I'm also well aware that religion and faith are two wholly separate things.

I also have no desire to "ban religion", and nor do I doubt that even were it to be banned, people would still practice. There is, after all, historical precedent for this even in the UK.

I'll just reiterate, it is clear, to me at least, why religion frequently attempts to monopolise morality, and declare itself the origin and source of morality, as if it is something that humans required to be "taught" instead of something that is innate. If you take this as read, it follows that if you remove this moral authority, humans will regress back to an animalistic state, whereupon they are incapable of behaving with any sort of human decency whatsoever, therefore, it is imperative that humans retain their religiosity and religion persists.

The problem is though, that simply isn't true, because there are plenty of examples of non-religious or atheistic humans still behaving with perfect human decency when religion is completely absent. So it's clear that human decency and morality is not dependant on religion and religiosity at all, and therefore any argument that posits this as a reason as to why religion must be preserved is nonsense.

I'm not saying "we need to do away with religion", I'm merely demonstrating how "we need religion to stop society falling apart" is baseless nonsense.

eardefender · 08/12/2023 16:17

IMustDoMoreExercise · 08/12/2023 16:04

Of course the church provided free education. How else could they brainwash their victims?

All religions are cults.

I am sorry if some people find the truth offensive but it is the truth.

this is hateful, you are not here to debate or discuss at all. Sad.

overwhelmed2023 · 08/12/2023 16:13

Xdown:
Not really because Christian's take their way of behaving from the Bible and Jesus' example. For eg if I was acting as a secular person I might think it's ok to be fall out with someone if they were annoying/ unreliable etc but as a Christian I might think harder to empathise with them and cut them slack.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 08/12/2023 16:04

eardefender · 08/12/2023 16:01

Actually the church has been providing free education to the masses long before 1880. I think your generalisations about all religion are quite frankly bonkers and also just bigoted religious discrimination. I really think you need to think about having some tolerance and understanding of others beliefs and faiths. I hope you can see that many will find what you have written quite offensive.

Of course the church provided free education. How else could they brainwash their victims?

All religions are cults.

I am sorry if some people find the truth offensive but it is the truth.

eardefender · 08/12/2023 16:01

IMustDoMoreExercise · 08/12/2023 15:34

I never said that education wasn't around until 1880 in the UK, I said free education of the masses wasn't.

Of course every culture has to have religion to control the masses before they were educated. It carries on today because people were taught to feel guilty or isolated from their families if they dimissed religion.

Religious leaders make sure that their victims cannot think for themselves and are brainwashed in to feeling guilty if they do something that is against the religion.

Actually the church has been providing free education to the masses long before 1880. I think your generalisations about all religion are quite frankly bonkers and also just bigoted religious discrimination. I really think you need to think about having some tolerance and understanding of others beliefs and faiths. I hope you can see that many will find what you have written quite offensive.

Swipe left for the next trending thread