Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that God doesn't exist and is a manmade concept

569 replies

Perimama · 07/12/2023 01:42

As it is taboo to talk religion politics with people socially, I often wonder whether many people think like me. As a species we have dismissed all the other "Gods" ie Greek gods etc. What makes the Christian God any different? I wasn't born into a religious household although I was baptized Christian. The whole concept seems so unbelievable to me.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
ErrolTheDragon · 08/12/2023 22:49

( I'm a chemist not a physicist, @Boomboom22 ... should I be flattered or insulted?Grin)

The notion that marriage is a religious institution seems quite historically and culturally blinkered. Civil marriages have been legal in England and wales since 1836, and (someone correct me if I'm wrong) there never was a requirement for religion to be involved in Scotland.

Laurendelaney1987 · 08/12/2023 22:13

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 03:12

@Laurendelaney1987 "This wil probably sicken non believers, but my faith makes my life complete , gives me inexplicable inner peace and meaning."

Why would anyone be "sickened" by this?
What I am sickened by is Christians claiming and getting special privileges. And also having the unmitigated gall to claim persecution. In the UK. If you do neither of these things, then it's obviously none of my business what you believe.

Hi: I think you’ve tagged the wrong person here, as I didn’t say that.

Boomboom22 · 08/12/2023 20:33

It's been explained why, it's how our brains work and a feature of consciousness. We collaborate, that was selected for in evolution.
The ridiculous misunderstandings of evolution as if being the strongest is the only trait, read some Darwin! Every single behaviour over thousands of years interplays, we now can read dna and make predictions using this. We even fix genetic disorders in unborn children using virus with new programmed dna / rna in the splice method. There is no way anyone can say evolution doesn't apply to humans.
Then arguing with Erroll, an actual physicist, about matter as if their position has any weight.

MassageForLife · 08/12/2023 20:21

eardefender · 08/12/2023 17:19

There is a compelling argument for the existence of God. The Easter Bunny isn't the same as God. Not in reality or in spirituality, history etc You are equating all make believe with God.

Just because you think the argument for the existence of god is compelling, doesn't make not believing in god extraordinary.

It's much less extraordinary than believing that one specific god is the one true god and that all the others are fake.

Banderwassnatched · 08/12/2023 19:58

God can exist despite all that stuff- they're not necessarily particularly nice.

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 19:54

@JimJonesLivesInMyHead "I'm an agnostic. I cannot prove God exists. Equally I cannot prove he doesn't."

Well, technically, one can't be an atheist, only an agnostic. Even RichardDawkins says he is agnostic. Personally, I am agnostic about God in the same way I am agnostic about the sun rising in the east tomorrow. It may not. But it's going to.

NotEvenThought · 08/12/2023 19:38

@eardefender
You can 'get' marriage because of the church, not 'in spite of it'. (Interesting use of words there). Marriage is a religious institution and a good example of how even secular people are still living in a religious way

Thankfully marriage in the U.K. is NOT a religious institution anymore. People may choose to have a religious marriage ceremony but they may also choose a civil ceremony. I got married purely for legal reasons. It had nothing to do with religion whatsoever.

The link between morals and religion is interesting but I'm not sure that morals evolved due to the belief of the presence of the God/Gods or more because of the necessity of societies to have some moral framework in order to function.

Also the 'morals' of many religion are still painfully backward.

Church of England does not allow same sex marriage
The Catholic Church still bans the use of birth control
Other religions around the world still believe in things such as corporal punishment (sometimes including the death penalty) for 'moral crimes' such as being gay or sex outside of marriage, leaving your religion, or even just wearing the wrong clothes. Then we have practices such as female (and male) genital mutilation of children, child 'marriage' and religious and racial persecution.

Previous posters suggest we all get our morals from religion but I'm not sure I'd want to.

Meowandthen · 08/12/2023 19:31

WandaWonder · 07/12/2023 01:56

It cant be proven either way

The onus is on those who claim there is a god, or gods, to provide evidence.

JimJonesLivesInMyHead · 08/12/2023 19:13

I'm an agnostic. I cannot prove God exists. Equally I cannot prove he doesn't.

If he does exist I suspect he got bored of his little project and binned us all off to do something more interesting. It's the only way I can fathom the existence of such appalling suffering in the world. Either that or he's an evil God masquerading (badly) as the 'loving' father.

I have seen things no compassionate God would permit. And if he does, that's not a God I ever want to worship

Pollyannamex · 08/12/2023 18:43

DC1888 · 08/12/2023 18:40

If there is a God (and tbh I'd like to think there is), there most certainly is no divine intervention.

Anyone who believes in a God cannot think there is given the appalling things that happen. No decent, loving entity would stand idly by.

If all of the terrible, awful things happening in the world right now are ‘God’s plan’ then that’s not something I want any involvement in.

DC1888 · 08/12/2023 18:40

Pollyannamex · 08/12/2023 18:26

Where was god on October 7th?

Where are they now while thousands of children are pulverised in Gaza?

your loving, miracle working, all forgiving God. Standing by while innocents are raped, multilated and dying from bombs and bullets and starvation.

Why doesn’t he answer their prayers? Work a miracle for them?

There is your proof that god does not exist.

Edited

If there is a God (and tbh I'd like to think there is), there most certainly is no divine intervention.

Anyone who believes in a God cannot think there is given the appalling things that happen. No decent, loving entity would stand idly by.

DC1888 · 08/12/2023 18:36

Hoovermehenry · 08/12/2023 17:59

If there is a god, he/she/they have apparently sat on a big cloud and watched every single sexual assault - on children, women, everyone else …
and don’t give me that free will bullshit.

And apparently its "God's plan".

One thing is certain, prayer is nonsense. Two decent, loving couples, each with a sick child, both pray, one child dies and the other lives. If the (desperate) response to the child who dies is "its God's plan" (thus ignoring the unconscionable thought of God preferring one child over the other), that would make prayer pointless as it's going to happen anyway. On the other hand, if prayer was actually effective it would mean God picks and chooses who gets help, so preferential treatment, the very antithesis of God's teaching.

So it's either ineffective and pointless, or its effective and biased...or, there's just no divine intervention at all and it's all just the luck of the draw (ie. one child's illness was easier to treat than the other, hence one survived).

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 18:35

@eardefender
How on earth could you know this? seriously? do you have time to scrutinize them all? really"

Of course not. But I have been interested in this subject for a very long time. And I haven't heard of a single miracle or answered prayer that stood more than a moment's scrutiny. Obviously I can't prove a negative but.....

BrainInAJar · 08/12/2023 18:29

I used, due to my mother's teaching, that I was special and one of God's chosen people. Now I know that I'm just one of 6 billion folk and when I die, I will rot in the ground just like everyone else.

ginasevern · 08/12/2023 18:29

@Guesswho88

"why does almost everyone (whether they believe in God or not) think that God should automatically be good?"

The whole concept of God as an all knowing, all powerful entity would be little comfort to human kind if it was evil. The point of faith is to take away confusion, fear and to an extent decision making. Humans find comfort in "God" and evil doesn't give much comfort. That's my take on it anyway.

Pollyannamex · 08/12/2023 18:26

Where was god on October 7th?

Where are they now while thousands of children are pulverised in Gaza?

your loving, miracle working, all forgiving God. Standing by while innocents are raped, multilated and dying from bombs and bullets and starvation.

Why doesn’t he answer their prayers? Work a miracle for them?

There is your proof that god does not exist.

BrainInAJar · 08/12/2023 18:26

I wish I still believed! I used to think I'd see my cats again when I die and that various evil people eg Jimmy Savile would finally face punishment.

But I have become disillusioned with the whole thing now I'm in my 40s. I highly doubt that I would have been religious if it hadn't been for my mother teaching me all of this stuff at a young age.

overwhelmed2023 · 08/12/2023 18:24

Have just bought this - my liberal views are at odds with my ( previous) church

To think that God doesn't exist and is a manmade concept
helpfulperson · 08/12/2023 18:20

Living with gods by neil macgregor is an interesting read and talks about a lot of this. The Bible by Karen Armstrong is another good one examining the history of what we know as the Bible.

eardefender · 08/12/2023 18:10

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 18:07

@eardefender "There are so many miracles, payers answered etc etc." As far as I am aware, none that stand scrutiny. I am obviously ready to be proved wrong.

How on earth could you know this? seriously? do you have time to scrutinize them all? really ?

eardefender · 08/12/2023 18:09

Guesswho88 · 08/12/2023 17:27

Exactly, well sort of. I do believe in God but I can't make sense of everything. I just feel it's interesting that there is definitely a man made preconceived notion that God HAS to be good. Where does this come from and more importantly why does almost everyone (whether they believe in God or not) think that God should automatically be good? - What is good and why do we have a need for it? Where does THAT come from? If you see what I mean.

if were going to start discussing good and evil then were 'gonna need a bigger boat'.

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 18:07

@eardefender "There are so many miracles, payers answered etc etc." As far as I am aware, none that stand scrutiny. I am obviously ready to be proved wrong.

eardefender · 08/12/2023 18:04

Hoovermehenry · 08/12/2023 17:59

If there is a god, he/she/they have apparently sat on a big cloud and watched every single sexual assault - on children, women, everyone else …
and don’t give me that free will bullshit.

I think this is the main argument against religion and the reason a lot of people lose their faith and cannot understand God and faith etc. So much is said and written about this point it s big part of theology.

eardefender · 08/12/2023 18:03

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 17:55

@eardefender " You misunderstand, i mean in terms of religion, which is very different from every day activities, which are not religion."

Ah. I think it was you saying "basically anything very interesting" that confused me. Also "very dull and a sort of nothingness."

As far as proof goes-obviously I can't prove that God doesn't exist any more than you can prove he does. But on a purely empirical basis, you would have thought that for the type of interventionist, prayer answering, miracle working God Christians tend to believe, there would have been some evidence of him intervening, answering prayers or working miracles at some point. And there just isn't.

This isn't true. That's why there are saints and holy sites, There are so many miracles, payers answered etc etc. There is huge evidence in terms of people reporting and believing in such things so evidence yes, proof, that's a matter of opinion, belief, faith i suppose.

Hoovermehenry · 08/12/2023 17:59

If there is a god, he/she/they have apparently sat on a big cloud and watched every single sexual assault - on children, women, everyone else …
and don’t give me that free will bullshit.

Swipe left for the next trending thread