Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that God doesn't exist and is a manmade concept

569 replies

Perimama · 07/12/2023 01:42

As it is taboo to talk religion politics with people socially, I often wonder whether many people think like me. As a species we have dismissed all the other "Gods" ie Greek gods etc. What makes the Christian God any different? I wasn't born into a religious household although I was baptized Christian. The whole concept seems so unbelievable to me.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Cleaningmyself · 09/12/2023 21:58

aint - isn’t , not sure why autocorrect is changing that!

Cleaningmyself · 09/12/2023 21:58

A friend of mine who is very religious said to me that it ain’t about God solving all the problems or stopping suffering that isn’t what she wants or expects from her god but simply to be given the strength to accept the terrible things can happen in life not for the pain to be taken away . That did make me think quite a lot

Cleaningmyself · 09/12/2023 21:53

Pollyannamex · 08/12/2023 18:26

Where was god on October 7th?

Where are they now while thousands of children are pulverised in Gaza?

your loving, miracle working, all forgiving God. Standing by while innocents are raped, multilated and dying from bombs and bullets and starvation.

Why doesn’t he answer their prayers? Work a miracle for them?

There is your proof that god does not exist.

Edited

I think people want their God that they believe in to be an all powerful singular being capable of stopping atrocities - but maybe it’s not like that - maybe God is a concept designed to assist in stoping these things when those who believe act in ways where these awful situations are avoided, but not everyone believes so it can never be.

I feel as well personally there’s so much religion v science but maybe it’s the same thing. Religion and its teachings were just early ways to try and explain things which we now know can be explained scientifically, and maybe things we can explain scientifically were created by some higher force ? So neither is ‘wrong’ but they are one and the same.

Sodie · 09/12/2023 21:47

Atheist here. I was raised with superstitions and a strong belief in spirits living alongside us, but not god or Jesus.

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 09/12/2023 21:43

I've always been fascinated with how religious people explain their god being real but all the other gods as not! I think if there was one universal god across the world it might the cause to b believable! And I certainly didn't get married because of religion. I'm an Atheist and belive in the commitment of marriage nothing about religion. And I'm sure gay people would also not nessasery do it for religion either considering they won't even able to marry untill fairly recently!

Cloudisi · 09/12/2023 21:41

God is love

I love my child and if I had the power to prevent her being sexually and physically abused or dying slowly of cancer, I would. Isn't God supposed to have that power, and all that love? Fuck him

Cloudisi · 09/12/2023 21:39

whar does this mean? 🥴 you do realise that people have diff beliefs?

I think it means "non-modern" religions, I think we'd call them the old pagan religions, such as the ancient Egyptian god, Roman, greek, Norse etc

namechangenanny · 09/12/2023 21:14

Meowandthen · 09/12/2023 20:08

There are an estimated billion plus planets in the universe and people think there is a god who made them all but chose this one to put people on. Then allows small children to suffer from horrible diseases, which presumably he/she/it also created. They allow people to starve.

This deity is horrible.

And why just believing one when there are multiple cults and each thinks that its own god is best. In some cases, there are claims that it’s fine to kill others with different views.

If you have read all, and I mean all, of your chosen religious text and still think it’s true and/or right, I have to question your morality. Most cherry pick the parts they like and conveniently ignore the rest.

I would hazard a guess that you yourself have also not read all of these texts either before forming your opinion. God is love, all the love. To live without love at the heart of what you do is to be without God. It's not as simple as just saying he created all the stuff it's that humans are able to do as we like here on Earth but humans often don't choose to do good things. But if it's easier for you to blame a deity than accept that humans are imperfect that is your right.

Tandora · 09/12/2023 20:12

Perimama · 07/12/2023 01:42

As it is taboo to talk religion politics with people socially, I often wonder whether many people think like me. As a species we have dismissed all the other "Gods" ie Greek gods etc. What makes the Christian God any different? I wasn't born into a religious household although I was baptized Christian. The whole concept seems so unbelievable to me.

As a species we have dismissed all the other "Gods"

whar does this mean? 🥴 you do realise that people have diff beliefs?

Meowandthen · 09/12/2023 20:08

There are an estimated billion plus planets in the universe and people think there is a god who made them all but chose this one to put people on. Then allows small children to suffer from horrible diseases, which presumably he/she/it also created. They allow people to starve.

This deity is horrible.

And why just believing one when there are multiple cults and each thinks that its own god is best. In some cases, there are claims that it’s fine to kill others with different views.

If you have read all, and I mean all, of your chosen religious text and still think it’s true and/or right, I have to question your morality. Most cherry pick the parts they like and conveniently ignore the rest.

namechangenanny · 09/12/2023 15:52

Calamitousness · 09/12/2023 13:28

@namechangenanny no need to apologise. I’m sorry if you thought I was speaking exclusively. I just said that I thought that most, which is not all, people think that way. This is my experience. I completely understand that you are not one of the ‘most’ and respect your choice/belief and realise with the circles you socialise in that you may have a different paradigm. That’s ok. Room for all. I do not think our society should be influenced by religion. It should be for the religious people only to partake and respect.

I really enjoyed our interaction, nice to be able to have different beliefs without ramming them down each other's throats. Hope you have a lovely weekend, sorry for late reply I've been out at a Christmas fair.

SpacePotato · 09/12/2023 15:08

I'd find it far easier to accept alien intervention in our DNA than there being any god.

The issue is with man's utter self righteous delusion that this planet belongs to them and everything is there for them to exploit.

Religion is control.
Mostly men controlling women.

Blind faith must be nice in a way as it clearly brings comfort to some.

Ancient civilisations were in some ways far more advanced than us and go back much further in time than previously thought. They knew about space and maths and engineering. They made things even now cannot be replicated.

We know so little yet think we know everything.
It's sometimes easy to dismiss religion as a concept, but I do believe there is just so much we just don't understand or can comprehend.

That fact that religion is still being used as an excuse for war in such a supposedly 'advanced' era of civilisation tells me it's all about power for men.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 09/12/2023 13:52

@ErrolTheDragon

The notion that marriage is a religious institution seems quite historically and culturally blinkered. Civil marriages have been legal in England and wales since 1836, and (someone correct me if I'm wrong) there never was a requirement for religion to be involved in Scotland

Until fairly recently in Scotland (20 years or so), you could be married in a registry office by a registrar if you did not want a religious ceremony, but if you wanted a ceremony anywhere else, so any recognised public place with an address, a hotel, house, etc, you had no option but to have the ceremony performed by an ordained minister. The only place Registrars were permitted to marry people was in a Registry office. This has changed now, but the change was relatively recent.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 09/12/2023 13:43

TriOptimim · 08/12/2023 17:49

It's no less hateful than saying religions are cults.

It's all a bit "one rule for me".

That statement is in no way hateful, since religions are, by definition, quite literally cults.

The only way it could be perceived as hateful is if you apply your own personal interpretation of the word "cult", but the commonly agreed definition of the word is no more derogatory than calling religions "clubs" or "groups".

Calamitousness · 09/12/2023 13:28

@namechangenanny no need to apologise. I’m sorry if you thought I was speaking exclusively. I just said that I thought that most, which is not all, people think that way. This is my experience. I completely understand that you are not one of the ‘most’ and respect your choice/belief and realise with the circles you socialise in that you may have a different paradigm. That’s ok. Room for all. I do not think our society should be influenced by religion. It should be for the religious people only to partake and respect.

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/12/2023 13:07

Skara Brae is astonishing. Ancient people were highly accomplished. Evidence of indoor plumbing!

turbonerd · 09/12/2023 12:52

NotEvenThought · 08/12/2023 14:56

@eardefender

Ancient people were not uneducated at all. For example, their maritime knowledge was exceptional and advanced. Ancient people also had deep faith as we can see from the monuments they left behind. I think that religious and spiritual connection and experience is innate to us as human beings and its part of our shared subconcious.

I'm not a historian but as far as I understand most religious monuments were built by power hungry men or 'churches' to control their populations. Building such as the Pyramids and St Peter's Basilica were not serving the spiritual needs of the locals but the megalomaniac desires of the leaders of the time.

You may look at much older monuments than that, prehistoric time over 10 000 yrs ago, which certainly required a lot of people.
They were often buildings for charting astronomical events over big timelines.

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/12/2023 12:32

people getting worked up on another thread about parents “lying” about Father Christmas. Lots of them probably believe in “God”. Hilarious.

namechangenanny · 09/12/2023 12:30

@CurlewKate I'm intrigued, what special treatment? I haven't come across anyone asking that as a Christian in workplaces etc. But as a Catholic yes there is history of persecution in the UK of that. It's literally what the UK was built on- bending everyone to switch to Protestantism to follow the Crown. It's why Catholic schooling exists, because it's important to us that our children learn the history of our faith so they can make an informed choice themselves, but initially all religious teaching was erased from education and people were indeed persecuted for teaching it. So we had to set up separate schooling for it and it's heavily funded by the church for that reason. In Scotland at the moment there is a push to teach sex education in a more blunt way from young ages (my view, again not everyone's and that's ok) There was no consideration of Catholic schooling within this and the statement they put out basically suggests that Catholic schools will have to do what the Scottish government says despite it being against all their beliefs.
I think there needs to be a happy medium, which currently there is. But there is definitely still a level of persecution that exists- though in a very nuanced way rather than the ways we might usually expect persecution to look like.
Sorry that was a huge answer and probably went off on a tangent! I also love these discussions though and it's always good to learn too.

CurlewKate · 09/12/2023 12:21

@namechangenanny "However I do not assume everyone else has that same view for themselves, that's the beauty is that we all get to decide for ourselves whether we accept or disregard it."

Obviously that is absolutely fine, and makes for interesting discussions. I love talking about this sort of stuff. My issue is with people who expect/accept special treatment, or particular respect for their beliefs. Or who, in a country like the UK claim persecution. Or who assume a position of moral superiority.

namechangenanny · 09/12/2023 12:15

@Calamitousness sorry I meant to say not all of my comment was directed at you, only the first bit. Typed too hastily as distracted by my dogs, my apologies.

namechangenanny · 09/12/2023 12:13

Calamitousness · 09/12/2023 12:01

I imagine most people don’t believe. It’s an outdated concept thought up to control the masses.
I know there are religious people but honestly I have always assumed they just like the fantasy of it. I never really think they genuinely believe in the story. To do so, they would have to pick and choose which bits to believe and live by as it’s quite the tall tale with some horrific concepts tied into it.

Can't tell if you're being intentionally antagonistic or genuinely believe that everyone must think the same way you do- which surely would be a bit hypocritical. I have complete faith in God and follow my faith in everything I do. It is important to me. However I do not assume everyone else has that same view for themselves, that's the beauty is that we all get to decide for ourselves whether we accept or disregard it. Unfortunately these threads often end up with a lot of defensiveness, sometimes snarkiness, from people who want to let everyone know exactly what they think of religion and suggest anyone who believes must be backward etc. Often they trot out bits of the Bible without any context or understanding but use it to make their point (funny enough rarely any other religious text but people seem to find it acceptable to openly mock Christianity over any other faith)
If that's your belief then that's your choice, but it doesn't mean you speak for all and sundry.

Calamitousness · 09/12/2023 12:01

I imagine most people don’t believe. It’s an outdated concept thought up to control the masses.
I know there are religious people but honestly I have always assumed they just like the fantasy of it. I never really think they genuinely believe in the story. To do so, they would have to pick and choose which bits to believe and live by as it’s quite the tall tale with some horrific concepts tied into it.

yoteyak · 09/12/2023 10:38

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 18:35

@eardefender
How on earth could you know this? seriously? do you have time to scrutinize them all? really"

Of course not. But I have been interested in this subject for a very long time. And I haven't heard of a single miracle or answered prayer that stood more than a moment's scrutiny. Obviously I can't prove a negative but.....

I hope you don't mind me joining your discussion. About miracles ...

(The story so far (times, yesterday 8/12/23) ...)
eardefender (18:03): "There are so many miracles, ... etc etc."

CurlewKate (18:07): "As far as I am aware, none that stand scrutiny. I am obviously ready to be proved wrong."

eardefender (18:10): "How on earth could you know this? seriously? do you have time to scrutinize them all? really ?"

CurlewKate (18:35): "Of course not. ... Obviously I can't prove a negative but....."

(Me, yoteyak, joining in:) This idea - that we can't prove a negative - is a bit of a canard, I think, CurlewKate. (Think of Euclid's proof (Elements Book IX, Proposition 20) that there is no largest prime number, for instance; there are lots of others.) In the case of miracles, the negative was proved, in fact, convincingly, by David Hume in the eighteenth century. (Many people think so, anyway.) ...

Thing is, eardefender, to answer your challenge, we might scrutinise all miracles without taking time to scrutinise each separately, by looking at the general nature of what a miracle is.

As I say, and like so much of this argument (and other arguments about theism and religion), this has already been done:

David Hume An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding (1748) Section X:
... "A miracle is a violation of the laws of nature; and as a firm and unalterable experience has established these laws, the proof against a miracle, from the very nature of the fact, is as entire as any argument from experience can possibly be imagined. ... There must, therefore, be a uniform experience against every miraculous event, otherwise the event would not merit that appellation. And as an uniform experience amounts to a proof, there is here a direct and full proof, from the nature of the fact, against the existence of any miracle ..."

"A wise man," Hume asserts, "... proportions his belief to the evidence."
... And so, as he says, "... The plain consequence is (and it is a general maxim worthy of our attention), "That no testimony is sufficient to establish a miracle, unless the testimony be of such a kind, that its falsehood would be more miraculous, than the fact, which it endeavours to establish" ... "

Do you understand Hume's argument, eardefender? He claims to offer "... a direct and full proof, from the nature of the fact, against the existence of any miracle." (My emphasis added.) Where do you think he goes wrong?

[I recommend all Hume's 'Of Miracles' (Enquiry, Section X), both to those who wish to believe in miracles and to those who don't. Here's an online copy: David Hume, Of Miracles]

Hume Texts Online

A permanent online resource for Hume scholars and students, including reliable texts of almost everything written by David Hume, and links to secondary material on the web.

https://davidhume.org/texts/e/10