Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that God doesn't exist and is a manmade concept

569 replies

Perimama · 07/12/2023 01:42

As it is taboo to talk religion politics with people socially, I often wonder whether many people think like me. As a species we have dismissed all the other "Gods" ie Greek gods etc. What makes the Christian God any different? I wasn't born into a religious household although I was baptized Christian. The whole concept seems so unbelievable to me.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
x2boys · 07/12/2023 07:47

Perimama · 07/12/2023 01:42

As it is taboo to talk religion politics with people socially, I often wonder whether many people think like me. As a species we have dismissed all the other "Gods" ie Greek gods etc. What makes the Christian God any different? I wasn't born into a religious household although I was baptized Christian. The whole concept seems so unbelievable to me.

Well yes Lots of people think like you ever heard of Atheists?

PixiePirate · 07/12/2023 07:44

Perimama · 07/12/2023 02:37

ok Captain sarky. I don't tend to talk about it with people that is why it is good to chat about it on here. According to polls atheists/agnostics are a small minority, I'm just wondering if these polls really reflect people's beliefs accurately or do people just say they are Christian etc if that is what their family background it without putting much thought into it. Does a large majority of people truly believe 100%. I would've thought most people have doubts, but maybe not..

You’ve mentioned the two keep points that I always come back to when considering religion in your original point about the Greek gods and also how people often seem to align with whatever religion is followed by their own family or community. To me, that points to cultural norms and fitting in rather than true religious beliefs, particularly because on the odd occasion I’ve seen people start to practice a religion that isn’t typically followed by their community, they have been eyed with suspicion and suspected of having been radicalised.

i agree with a pp that religion is an effective method of crowd control at a local level. It unfortunately seems to be hijacked as an excuse for starting lots of wars though, and I believe that virtually all religions are used as a tool to oppress women.

Burntoutbetty · 07/12/2023 07:43

boobot1 · 07/12/2023 07:37

Christianity was started by St Paul. Jesus was Jewish, he wouldn't of recognised what we call Christianity, especially as it has evolved over the centuries. Religion to me, was simply the first control mechanisim we've invented may others since.

Paul was a high ranking Jewish scholar. He was literally a pharisee.

There are plenty of Messianic Jews who see Christ as the ultimate fulfilment of Judaism.

There are also plenty of Christians who celebrate many of the Jewish holidays through the lens of Christ as the Messiah.

JustWhatWeDontNeed · 07/12/2023 07:40

I went to a CofE primary school but am not religious.

I pretty much assumed that god/Jesus/creation story was to be treated with the same level of seriousness as Father Christmas. It's obviously a nonsense story, but the characters did exist at some point. But obviously not living for hundreds of years...

Religion is just a means to control the masses - you keep people in line with the fear of hell and the promise of heaven. Misunderstood phenomena could also be explained away with "God" and punishments.

A lot of people also struggle without a purpose, therefore need to believe in some higher being. A lot of bereaved people also find it comforting to think their loved ones have gone on existing in some other realm and they will be reunited, especially if the loss is a child.

I struggle to get my head around the notion that people actually truly believe in any god. It's a complete failure of logic and to say that God transcends logic is a cop out.

These days religion is responsible for wars and division. Places of worship and religious practice are overwhelmingly infiltrated by paedophiles and other unsavoury characters. It keeps money in the pockets of a select few. I see nothing good come from religion that wouldn't exist without it.

boobot1 · 07/12/2023 07:37

ABCXYZ17 · 07/12/2023 04:01

Of course God doesn’t exist, it’s an absurd concept. Religion was the easiest way to control people who had no other explanations for things and could easily be scared into compliance etc.
Jesus existed and pretended to be the son of ‘god’ and started the biggest con the world has ever seen. I’m certainly not living my life by ‘beliefs’ that some men in a desert thought up over two thousand years ago and started a cult on the back off.

Christianity was started by St Paul. Jesus was Jewish, he wouldn't of recognised what we call Christianity, especially as it has evolved over the centuries. Religion to me, was simply the first control mechanisim we've invented may others since.

Yousay55 · 07/12/2023 07:36

I was raised in a family that had no faith and yet I can’t remember a time when I didn’t believe in God, even as a very young child.

Ambertonix · 07/12/2023 07:35

I would like to believe that there is a reason for all this and somewhere better that we go 'afterwards' and i like the idea of a God to believe in but thinking rationally, it is very unlikely to be true. However i try to live my life as if he is watching over me because i dont want to chance being 'wrong' iyswim!

Noghtsaving · 07/12/2023 07:33

You are being very unreasonable for wondering if there are other people who think like you, when you absolutely know that there are.

If you were from the 1600s this would be a reasonable question, but in 2023, nah.

Malarandras · 07/12/2023 07:33

There is a philosophy and religion board where you could have posted this for a serious discussion. Seems like all you are after is an argument, how tedious.

CurlewKate · 07/12/2023 07:32

This is from the Social Attitudes Survey. It was roughly contemporaneous with the Census, but asked more neutral questions, precluding the "tick the CofEbox" responses.
" • Only 49% of the UK said they believed in god in 2022 – down from 75% in 1981.
• 72% of people in the UK believe that religious authorities should not ultimately interpret the laws in a democracy
• 82% of the UK public say they trust people of a different religion – the second highest of the 24 nations surveyed"

Burntoutbetty · 07/12/2023 07:30

Lampzade · 07/12/2023 06:21

The reason that I don’t go into any detail is because non believers have already made up their minds and will simply dissect anything I say and put a negative spin on it. It is impossible to intellectualise faith.
I respect people’s right not to believe in God and you won’t catch me criticising them and telling them that they will burn in hell. I won’t try to convince non believers that God exists.

Btw, I actually don’t attend church and I am not a religious zealot.
I am simply someone who believes in God and tries to be a decent person.

I'm a Christian and can relate to this. I came to faith in my thirties. It didn't happen in a vacuum, and was absolutely not something I saw coming. If someone had told me I'd become a Born Again Christian I never would have believed them. I don't come from that kind of background and it was as much a shock for me as it was for other people.

But I can't deny that I felt God's hand over my life and there were experiences and circumstances which led me down this path. I've co pletely changed as a person, for the better. I thought I was a moral person before, but something within me changed from the inside out.

This transformation was beautiful and sometimes explaining what happened and how I came to this conclusion feels like I've poured my heart out and invested emotional energy in retelling profound experience. People respond with scoffing comments with the usual 'sky daddy' tropes and honestly sometimes it leaves me feeling like I've shown someone my prize collection of jewels and they laughed at it.

My husband is an atheist and I'm not scared of an intellectual debate or philosophical differences at all. Mumsnet just tends to spout out clichés and generalisations about people of faith which are so sweeping and ill informed, that sometimes I don't have the emotional energy to engage in it. We are seen as one big oppressed, brainwashed, unthinking, uneducated, thick monolith when we are a vast array of personalities, backgrounds, upbringing, cultures, education levels, professions and unique experiences, and we all arrived at the same conclusion.

Sometimes, people often don't want to hear. They don't want to know your story. They only want to put believers through the hoops to make fun of them.

Oldsu · 07/12/2023 07:26

Sux2buthen · 07/12/2023 06:36

That's handy Grin

It's the same as Father Christmas really 🎅🏼

@Sux2buthen Actually there is a lot of evidence that Father Christmas exists, not the one traditionally called Father Christmas he is part of a tradition of Christmas gift bringers who have different names in different countries, Santa Claus however is a different story, the name comes from the Dutch word sinterklaas and is based on St Nicholas Bishop of Myra and patron saint of Children who certainly did exist, legend has it that he punched Arius a Christian Theologian in the face during the first council of Nicaea in 325 but that seems to have been disproved, pity really it would have livened things up bit.

oldcrinkle · 07/12/2023 07:23

Yep. It's a form of control.

I love an old church though, but only from a historical and architectural view point.

Mummyoflittledragon · 07/12/2023 07:22

lollo8 · 07/12/2023 06:57

I think that religion (as a joint belief in something, and all the rules that must be followed as part of it) was a very strong factor in whether groups/tribes/cultures survived or not.

I always find it fascinating that diaspora cultures such as Orthodox Jews seem to have especially rigid belief-driven rules around how to live everyday life, and they serve as the glue that holds these groups together across countries and continents.

I am not religious but I do wonder what will happen to secular cultures. Believing in some vague idea of goodness and equality sounds nice, but it's not especially compelling, and seems to do little to bind communities together. But I think this is something that's hard for us to understand or evaluate in the here and now. I wish I could transport myself 500 years into the future and find out what happened to the secular West.

Edited

I believe in reincarnation and it is possible to see / talk to people’s souls so although I wont see it in my current form, I will be back. 😂

As for the question, God as the Biblical One True God, no. I do think religion has a place in societal cohesion and rule following. Sadly, a large proportion of religions are also misogynistic.

Do I believe there is a higher being? I believe we are in some way everywhere. That there is universal consciousness, source energy, or whatever people wish to call it. Beyond that, idk.

Holly60 · 07/12/2023 07:17

YireosDodeAver · 07/12/2023 06:34

You aren't being 'unreasonable' as such, in fact you are using 'reason' fine. But you have to admit within that structural reasoning that if God exists (very much not provable either way so not a concept that can be addressed via reason) then your belief or lack of belief is totally irrelevant to that fact. You are entirely at liberty to ignore religion and religious teachings of course. There are many unknowable facts in the universe. The existence of God is one of them. Your belief or otherwise has no bearing on reality for any of them.

FWIW if the Divine does exist then I don't think there's a set of "old" gods that don't exist and one specific religion that has it "right". It would be more that there's always been a single divine entity and the Greeks and the Egyptians and the Aztecs had their culturally-specific ways of understanding that, and we have ours, and I am sure that future generations in 3000 years will have a different understanding again but it wouldn't be different gods, or god changing, just human culture evolving.

You've put my thoughts into words so much more articulately and succinctly than I ever could.

Thank you for this.

ElfontheShelfIsWATCHINGYOUTOO · 07/12/2023 07:17

Of course op, it's a man made construct and we understand why as well.

Authorinwaiting · 07/12/2023 07:16

I'm in Northern Ireland and so I do not believe in any man made religion. I can not believe that any god would allow a DUP group to function let alone be law makers.

I believe it's about making people feel like they have a purpose in this life. "Reward in heaven"

But I live my life trying to be good and kind now. I think we only get one life. Let's make it as pleasant for ourselves and all around us. Live and let live.

Religion is devisive and causes too much pain. My mother is a strict catholic and many of the decisions she made during our upbringing were cruel in my opinion. She is judgmental and pious like most religious people I know.

Be kind and do what's right. We would all be better off it people lived like this.

TheBeautifulMoors · 07/12/2023 07:15

Perimama · 07/12/2023 02:37

ok Captain sarky. I don't tend to talk about it with people that is why it is good to chat about it on here. According to polls atheists/agnostics are a small minority, I'm just wondering if these polls really reflect people's beliefs accurately or do people just say they are Christian etc if that is what their family background it without putting much thought into it. Does a large majority of people truly believe 100%. I would've thought most people have doubts, but maybe not..

37% in England and Wales in the last census is far from a small minority, isn’t it?
Muslims can say they’re a small minority (6%) or Sikhs, Hindus, other (2%).

CurlewKate · 07/12/2023 07:09

@Perimama - have you thought of giving this new idea of yours a name? You never know-it might catch on....

jemenfous37 · 07/12/2023 07:08

@tescocreditcard 😀😀

Find us the transcript of the trial where a pauper, charged with attempted murder of a toff, states "I decided not to do it m'lud, because I wanted my reward in 'eaven didn't I?"

Religion, any religion, is written and interprepted by men with the sole aim of subjegating women (cover everything, you are unclean while mentruating, walk 3 paces behind me, etc)

TheBeautifulMoors · 07/12/2023 07:05

That does sum it up nicely.

TheBeautifulMoors · 07/12/2023 07:03

:Ive just googled and 37% of people in England and Wales identified as having no religion.

Over 40% identified as Christian , 6% as Muslim, 2% other.

I find the Christian/Atheist split very surprising and was expecting the number of atheists to be much higher, from what I come across on the internet and irl. However, I know when I used to work on collecting data, people who were christened as babies but have never had anything to do with Christianity, still identify as Christian so that could explain part of it.

You’re nbu to not believe in God. It’s your choice not to.
So is it mine to believe in Him, through my experiences.
My faith is very important to me but mostly private in my day to day life. I only talk about it with people who I know share my faith.
I never get into a debate on why God exists or doesn’t exist. If someone approaches me irl and asks me about my faith or how I came to it, then I’d happily share it.

I came across a video of proof of God linked to proof that there are no barbers, which I found quite funny.

OneMiniMincePieTooFar · 07/12/2023 06:58

As a species we have dismissed all the other "Gods" ie Greek gods etc. What makes the Christian God any different?

I don't know whether God exists ur not, but as a species we absolutely haven't dismissed all other Gods but the Christian one. Multiple Gods are still worshipped around the world today.

Some Gods have been dismissed. Some have endured.

Similarly, while organised religion has been the excuse for untold evils, to dismiss anyone who believes as weak headed or needing someone to lead them - is just rude.

The fact that the concept of God or Gods is so universal and enduring, across cultures and nations, suggests to me there is something else deeper at play. Maybe truth, maybe something about humankind and our stage of development. But I don't think we can dismiss everyone in that who believed/s in a form of God as weak or whatever.

IMO, anyway.

lollo8 · 07/12/2023 06:57

I think that religion (as a joint belief in something, and all the rules that must be followed as part of it) was a very strong factor in whether groups/tribes/cultures survived or not.

I always find it fascinating that diaspora cultures such as Orthodox Jews seem to have especially rigid belief-driven rules around how to live everyday life, and they serve as the glue that holds these groups together across countries and continents.

I am not religious but I do wonder what will happen to secular cultures. Believing in some vague idea of goodness and equality sounds nice, but it's not especially compelling, and seems to do little to bind communities together. But I think this is something that's hard for us to understand or evaluate in the here and now. I wish I could transport myself 500 years into the future and find out what happened to the secular West.

WillowTit · 07/12/2023 06:56

of course,