Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that God doesn't exist and is a manmade concept

569 replies

Perimama · 07/12/2023 01:42

As it is taboo to talk religion politics with people socially, I often wonder whether many people think like me. As a species we have dismissed all the other "Gods" ie Greek gods etc. What makes the Christian God any different? I wasn't born into a religious household although I was baptized Christian. The whole concept seems so unbelievable to me.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 07/12/2023 13:48

Yahweh was originally a warrior deity, which should come as no surprise to anybody. There’s a brilliant man on YT, a Dr Justin Sledge, a practicing Jew, who looks at what we know of the cult of this deity through archeology as well as other topics, such as the origins of Lilith. It’s all fascinating.

Echobelly · 07/12/2023 13:44

@jersydress - I'm practicing, but not Orthodox.

But I think an important thing to understand about Judaism is that unlike Christianity, it is not necessarily a 'faith'. My family and other Jews like us practice Judaism as a spiritual and cultural tradition, and yes that may include keeping kosher, attending synagogue regularly, even not driving on the Sabbath, but it doesn't really necessitate God for the meaning it can have in people's lives.

An orthodox person would probably disagree, but it takes all sorts!

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 07/12/2023 13:44

Perimama · 07/12/2023 01:42

As it is taboo to talk religion politics with people socially, I often wonder whether many people think like me. As a species we have dismissed all the other "Gods" ie Greek gods etc. What makes the Christian God any different? I wasn't born into a religious household although I was baptized Christian. The whole concept seems so unbelievable to me.

We haven't all dismissed all the other gods. I'm pagan and polytheist, quite a few of us about.

What the gods actually are though - that's another question. Made up, literally exist, collective unconscious... lots of people have lots of different thoughts on that.

Abouttimemum · 07/12/2023 13:36

I think all religion is a man made concept, much like land borders and many other nonsensical things we made up for nonsensical reasons, but people can believe what they want.

I suppose we’ll find out when we die, or maybe not, either way I’m happy to wait!

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 07/12/2023 13:32

cheezncrackers · 07/12/2023 11:11

They do say that the best way to raise an atheist is to send them to a Catholic school Grin

I went to a Catholic school and am agnostic (don’t know what the fuck is going on). I must admit that I found Catholicism and the madness of Nuns in general to be utterly craycray, but each to their own.

CampsieGlamper · 07/12/2023 13:32

Reading the more nuanced posts rather than "course there's no god cos I say so" is very interesting.
The concept of a supreme deity or deities has been common throughout time. Adherence globally to a main religion is growing - only in the west is it declining.
If there was no Great Architect of the universe - was the solar solar system just an accident, planets just coincidence, the fact that earth was just in the right orbit around the sun, the atmosphere developed into breathable gas luckily, and animals just happened to evolve and we just happened to happen, along with large numbers of the animals we evolved from still happily running around?
Also, if we came from chimpanzees how any why did we develop to have so many more qualities that they do not have, or appear to display?

jersydress · 07/12/2023 13:24

@Echobelly I was surprised by your post, as practising orthodox Judaism is very demanding with all sorts of inconveniencing, very strict rules. Hard to imagine one going along with it when in fact not practising the main part I.e. faith, while subjecting themselves to all the god worshipping in a shul every week.

Mumof2teens79 · 07/12/2023 13:22

Evidence that events in the bible happened is not evidence of God.
Something happened and people attributed it to god, and stories evolved.

Was Jesus real? Yes
Was Mary a virgin, no. Did Jesus want people think she was, yes
Jesus was the same as anyone since claiming to be the son of God, Making up ways to explain things that happened. Accounts written contemporaneous will include real events but the explanation for those events, and the things that had fewer witnesses will be made up or exaggerated.

ManchesterLu · 07/12/2023 13:19

Of course it's a manmade concept. It's a concept that was created when Man didn't have any other way to explain things that happen in the world. Thunderstorm? God's angry. Illness? You've done something bad and you're being punished for it. Now, we can explain the vast majority of things that happen, yet for some reason people still cling to the idea of 'God'.

We can't yet explain everything, but it will come in time.

mamabear715 · 07/12/2023 13:18

I do believe & have a strong faith. But people please themselves. I'm not gonna fall out with anyone over it.

Blueeyes13 · 07/12/2023 13:15

ErrolTheDragon · 07/12/2023 12:55

There is strong historical evidence for events in the bible

Really? Which ones?

Otoh, there's an awful lot in the Bible for which there's no historical evidence whatever. For instance, that very historical sounding start to Luke 2. Odd - frankly incredible - that the Romans don't seem to have kept any record of Caesar decreeing all the world should be taxed, nor of the peculiarly impractical methodology of requiring people to go to their own city for this purpose.

https://crossexamined.org/really-census-time-caesar-augustus/

https://www.amazon.co.uk/Evidence-Bible-Clive-Anderson/dp/1846254167?ref=d6k_applink_bb_dls&dplnkId=4c5db026-8a74-488d-a343-b1a3e2f03166

Was There Really A Census During the Time of Caesar Augustus?

Archaeology Illuminates & Affirms a Key Fact in the Christmas Story By all counts, Luke’s gospel is a wealth of historical information. He opens it this way: Inasmuch as many have taken in hand to set in order a narrative of those things which have bee...

https://crossexamined.org/really-census-time-caesar-augustus

Echobelly · 07/12/2023 13:03

@jersydress - yes, I reckon most people at our synagogue don't believe in God in the 'Bloke in the Sky' mode, I'm pretty sure I have had those discussions with people.

ErrolTheDragon · 07/12/2023 13:02

I'm almost 100% sure that when people say God they don't mean an actual being but more a general higher power like nature or physics but with some human judgement thrown in. Certainly anyone with a theology degree or who trained as a minister. God is omnipotent omnipresent and transcendent. And not a person but a force.

Some, perhaps. But this really isn't how most Christians seem to describe god. They talk about having a 'personal relationship with Jesus'. The doctrine of the Trinity (which tbh I suspect not many actually think about or consider how it evolved) describes 'god in three persons'.

ErrolTheDragon · 07/12/2023 12:55

There is strong historical evidence for events in the bible

Really? Which ones?

Otoh, there's an awful lot in the Bible for which there's no historical evidence whatever. For instance, that very historical sounding start to Luke 2. Odd - frankly incredible - that the Romans don't seem to have kept any record of Caesar decreeing all the world should be taxed, nor of the peculiarly impractical methodology of requiring people to go to their own city for this purpose.

Boomboom22 · 07/12/2023 12:54

I'm almost 100% sure that when people say God they don't mean an actual being but more a general higher power like nature or physics but with some human judgement thrown in. Certainly anyone with a theology degree or who trained as a minister. God is omnipotent omnipresent and transcendent. And not a person but a force.

The dumb kind of religion for the masses is a different concept of an old man on a cloud watching you which is like a child, I doubt most truly believe that.

I don't believe any of it as a psychologist I think the reasons people believe are easily explained by brain chemistry, sentience and evolution. These explain the human need for faith in a higher power and the 'reason' we exist.

jersydress · 07/12/2023 12:53

@Echobelly are you able to freely talk about not believing in God with others you meet at synagogue?

Echobelly · 07/12/2023 12:47

I'm Jewish, practicing and an atheist.

I guess people needed God/s when they couldn't explain much about the world, so the 'Beardy guy in the sky' idea isn't really necessary any more. I think some people do relate to God/direct prayers to the idea now of 'The better part that exists in everyone' as a focus instead.

I still find synagogue a meaningful spiritual experience, coming together with other people. But no, not a 'God' person.

ErrolTheDragon · 07/12/2023 12:47

I wouldn't expect it to ever vanish completely, but I don't think it's coincidence either that decline in religiosity tends to go hand-in-hand with rising education levels and economic prosperity.

One of the other factors which seems correlated with declining religiosity of a country is having a functioning judicial and policing system.

NonPlayerCharacter · 07/12/2023 12:45

As it is taboo to talk religion politics with people socially, I often wonder whether many people think like me.

You wonder whether many people are atheists? You're all about proof and science and what can be actually demonstrated, and you can't figure out whether there are many atheists?

Blueeyes13 · 07/12/2023 12:41

Brexile · 07/12/2023 06:04

You don't owe anyone an explanation, of course - but I think it would be interesting on a psychological level. The only people who tend to talk about their "beliefs" are clergy/RE teacher/ DUP types who tend to be thick and full of humbug, or predatory cults like the Jehovah's Witnesses who berate the vulnerable into compliance. It would be good to hear an intelligent person with no agenda simply talk frankly about their religious belief.

https://youtube.com/@AylesburyVYFC?si=A3jahHQ8YxAe_6m0. Scientists etc talking about why they believe. Series is ongoing until next year. Of course they'll have an agenda though. That's why you have to weigh up the evidence for yourself. There is strong historical evidence for events in the bible, and many people claim they experience god's presence.

Before you continue to YouTube

https://youtube.com/@AylesburyVYFC?si=A3jahHQ8YxAe_6m0

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/12/2023 12:30

Maybe this partly explains why faith just will not go away even though we are so much more sophisticated and clever now

I wouldn't expect it to ever vanish completely, but I don't think it's coincidence either that decline in religiosity tends to go hand-in-hand with rising education levels and economic prosperity. There are obvious outliers like the USA where declaring agnosticism or atheism can cause social and career death, or perhaps Japan where religion is more of a cultural identity rather than a personal choice, but nonetheless, religion is prospering in the 3rd world while it declines in northern and central Europe at the same time.

You can argue about the reasons for this, but I don't think it's particularly difficult to understand that people who are stressed by penury, disease, wars etc, might be a bit more inclined to "faith" that supernatural elements might intercede and make their lives a bit better.

The former DDR is an interesting case. At one point the least religious place on the planet, again, it's open to conjecture exactly why, but religion isn't showing any sign of making a comeback despite the DDR having been consigned to the dustbin of history 30+ years ago. I think that's curious from the perspective that once people dispense with the notion of divinity, the sky doesn't fall in, and it doesn't appear to be particularly missed.

yoteyak · 07/12/2023 12:22

Mumof2teens79 · 07/12/2023 11:38

But where did the creator come from?
Did they just spring into existence from nothingness? Or do they have a creator?

The creator, of course, created itself; it made itself be; caused itself to exist.

This unusual capacity, of being the cause of itself, is something I have recently been interested to hear is now also to be found on railways in Britain: "This [last-minute change in the timetable]," announces the woman on the station tannoy, "Is due to a last-minute change in the timetable."

It's not possible for the universe itself to be self-causing, as any priest or vicar (or imam or mufti or granthi, whatever ... have to be inclusive these days!) will tell you: being the cause of itself is an attribute restricted just to certain gods and train delays. Some people think that's obvious. (Though not me.)

Abracadabra12345 · 07/12/2023 12:10

gnarlynarwhal · 07/12/2023 05:18

I think a lot of people who call themselves believers wish it were true and are holding onto their ‘belief’ because they are in fear of it not being true. The idea that we are alone and that there is no afterlife is simply too terrifying for some people to come to terms with. The few times I have attended church I have always noticed that the vast majority of people there were old and I think that’s why.

This is exactly what I thought. I thought religion was for children as a nice fairytale and for the old as a crutch. So when I went to church because my dh wanted our kids to be christened and this was part of the deal, I was gobsmacked that all around me sang with such conviction and the highly intelligent, educated ministers clearly believed this nonsense too. It didn't make sense to me, at all

I'm now a Christian of many years. There's plenty of academics and scholars who have questioned the life and resurrection of Jesus Christ, it's not like it's never been examined and scrutinised, and have come to believe. Scientists who see no conflict between science and the notion of God: the opposite really as the move closer to the mind of God.

But that was only partly why I became a Christian. Once I said a grudging and reluctant "yes" to the existence of God, I had a powerful encounter and that's not something you explain away. Once it happens, it's life-changing.

Maybe this partly explains why faith just will not go away even though we are so much more sophisticated and clever now.

Lampzade · 07/12/2023 12:04

gnarlynarwhal · 07/12/2023 11:57

I agree. I also think some people think going to church or worshiping god means they can behave however they like towards other people. I have a relative who has been unpleasant to me over the years and broke up 2 marriages. They follow the Christian faith and have helped out in the local community on certain projects but they have behaved awfully towards various people over the years. I don’t understand it at all.

Not everyone who attends church is a good person. You can get the best and the worst of humans in church .

Swipe left for the next trending thread