Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that God doesn't exist and is a manmade concept

569 replies

Perimama · 07/12/2023 01:42

As it is taboo to talk religion politics with people socially, I often wonder whether many people think like me. As a species we have dismissed all the other "Gods" ie Greek gods etc. What makes the Christian God any different? I wasn't born into a religious household although I was baptized Christian. The whole concept seems so unbelievable to me.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
NonPlayerCharacter · 07/12/2023 17:26

girlfriend44 · 07/12/2023 16:15

There is no imaginary man in the sky. It hasnt been scientifically proved. Its all ancient hearsay.

Just like there is no tooth fairy or Santa Claus.

there is no tooth fairy or Santa Claus.

Wait...what?

girlfriend44 · 07/12/2023 16:15

There is no imaginary man in the sky. It hasnt been scientifically proved. Its all ancient hearsay.

Just like there is no tooth fairy or Santa Claus.

Moonmelodies · 07/12/2023 16:08

blowfishh · 07/12/2023 15:34

@Moonmelodies
"No bad thing? Depends what your guidelines say?
What if they say be mean to women and gay people?"

My religion says love the neighbour as thyself. I've never been to church and been encouraged to be mean to women and gay people.

You're very lucky.
Many people's religions do tell them to be mean to women, to gay people, to cut bits off babies, etc.

NotObligedToArgueWithStrangers · 07/12/2023 16:01

I think that god and religion is all just a metaphor for all the stuff that's too big for humans to get their head around. We work better if we can press things into a shape and pattern that we recognise and understand.

IncompleteSenten · 07/12/2023 15:46

CampsieGlamper · 07/12/2023 13:32

Reading the more nuanced posts rather than "course there's no god cos I say so" is very interesting.
The concept of a supreme deity or deities has been common throughout time. Adherence globally to a main religion is growing - only in the west is it declining.
If there was no Great Architect of the universe - was the solar solar system just an accident, planets just coincidence, the fact that earth was just in the right orbit around the sun, the atmosphere developed into breathable gas luckily, and animals just happened to evolve and we just happened to happen, along with large numbers of the animals we evolved from still happily running around?
Also, if we came from chimpanzees how any why did we develop to have so many more qualities that they do not have, or appear to display?

We didn't come from chimps.
We share a common ancestor.
Quite different.

Hoovermehenry · 07/12/2023 15:35

Am an atheist now. As are most of my old school
mates. 🥸😜

Hoovermehenry · 07/12/2023 15:34

Even as a child in a Catholic school I thought it made more sense for people to worship the sun, which they could see, or things from nature over our beliefs!
Making us all do GCSE religion backfired, the more we learned about other religions and paganism the less sense following one path ( Catholicism) made to us!

blowfishh · 07/12/2023 15:34

@Moonmelodies
"No bad thing? Depends what your guidelines say?
What if they say be mean to women and gay people?"

My religion says love the neighbour as thyself. I've never been to church and been encouraged to be mean to women and gay people.

LittleMissSunshiner · 07/12/2023 15:32

ErrolTheDragon · 07/12/2023 15:15

But as long as I accept that there is a power higher than me, outside of me, that means the sun will rise and the sun will set with no influence over what I think, feel, believe, do, or don't do, then I know that I am powerless and there is a power higher than me, outside of me, beyond me.

The laws of physics suffice for the sun rising and setting etc. As for being 'powerless' though - while what we can do is limited, we have agency and ability to do or not do some things. Scientists can't stop all disease just like that, but we can work to find preventions and cures. We can't stop tsunamis but we can develop early warning systems to mitigate loss of life. Humanly weak, sure - but it's a cop out to say we're 'powerless', isn't it?

Not in my book it's not a cop out.

It's a life saving spiritual belief system in which I trust in the power of nature and that which is true over and above science and man made theories - religion being a man made theory in which I don't believe.

I accept other peoples religions and belief systems and I accept total atheism and agnosticism because I only care about what I think and what gets me through the day.

Before I developed and acknowledged some form of spiritual belief system I was suicidally depressed (and acting on it) and killing myself with substance addiction. I once thought science, maths, and medicine, etc could explain everything in existence and the more you knew and researched the more agency you had. Now I know that's garbage. I don't really care what anyone else has to say about my personal belief system.

What other people believe is none of my business. (< Good AA saying there)

Moonmelodies · 07/12/2023 15:19

blowfishh · 07/12/2023 14:14

Religion is an idea of a higher power.

Regardless of what you believe, to have faith and to live by the guidelines of your religion is no bad thing.

In the old world, the good fearing man didn't rely on the government or laws to tell him what he needed to, he knew.

No bad thing? Depends what your guidelines say?
What if they say be mean to women and gay people?

ErrolTheDragon · 07/12/2023 15:15

But as long as I accept that there is a power higher than me, outside of me, that means the sun will rise and the sun will set with no influence over what I think, feel, believe, do, or don't do, then I know that I am powerless and there is a power higher than me, outside of me, beyond me.

The laws of physics suffice for the sun rising and setting etc. As for being 'powerless' though - while what we can do is limited, we have agency and ability to do or not do some things. Scientists can't stop all disease just like that, but we can work to find preventions and cures. We can't stop tsunamis but we can develop early warning systems to mitigate loss of life. Humanly weak, sure - but it's a cop out to say we're 'powerless', isn't it?

LittleMissSunshiner · 07/12/2023 14:39

blowfishh · 07/12/2023 14:14

Religion is an idea of a higher power.

Regardless of what you believe, to have faith and to live by the guidelines of your religion is no bad thing.

In the old world, the good fearing man didn't rely on the government or laws to tell him what he needed to, he knew.

I have no religious faith as per organised religion but I found faith in a higher power.

To my mind there is a universal higher order from which all of life and matter has sprung and I have no idea how that possibly works.

But as long as I accept that there is a power higher than me, outside of me, that means the sun will rise and the sun will set with no influence over what I think, feel, believe, do, or don't do, then I know that I am powerless and there is a power higher than me, outside of me, beyond me.

TheCatfordCat · 07/12/2023 14:25

No God.

I discuss my utter lack of faith with friends and family, partly because they also have an absence of faith. Or they do have faith, and want to challenge me on my conviction. I ask them why there is a God. There has been some very interesting discussions.

NonPlayerCharacter · 07/12/2023 14:15

yoteyak · 07/12/2023 13:56

For those (and there are some) who think we have no proof either way, here is a sketch of a proof that God does not exist:

God, if existent, is omnipotent, omniscient, and morally perfect.

Omnipotent: God has the power to eliminate all evil.
Omniscient: God knows when evil exists.
Morally perfect: God has the desire to eliminate all evil.

Evil exists. (Earthquakes, war, famine, ... lots of bad things in the world)

So either God doesn’t have the power to eliminate all evil, or doesn’t know when evil exists, or doesn’t have the desire to eliminate all evil.

That is, God doesn’t exist.

This argument is certainly valid (the conclusion follows from the premises).

Is it sound? (Given its validity, are the premises all true)? ... Well, perhaps God is not all three of (all powerful), (all knowing) and (morally perfect). Perhaps there's an ignorant creator, an impotent Demiurge, or a big baddie. But otherwise, yes this is a sound argument (pace Leibniz and that best-of-all-possible schtick). So its conclusion is true.

There is no god.

You're starting from the premise that any existing God must be omnipotent, omniscient, and morally perfect. It doesn't. In fact, many cultures have gods that are fucking awful. Greek mythology is full of them.

This isn't a proof of anything except that a particular type of God doesn't exist - and even then, we could argue that he's so far above us, we just can't understand his workings.

blowfishh · 07/12/2023 14:14

Religion is an idea of a higher power.

Regardless of what you believe, to have faith and to live by the guidelines of your religion is no bad thing.

In the old world, the good fearing man didn't rely on the government or laws to tell him what he needed to, he knew.

Flyhigher · 07/12/2023 14:12

It's is unbelievable. But if some get comfort from it then I'm ok with it.

AchillesHeel23 · 07/12/2023 14:12

Reading the background to the rise of Christianity and the way the books of the bible were put together destroyed forever any credibility that religion might have had for me
Me too @Elphame delving into it from a historical viewpoint doesn’t take much for it to fall apart

YireosDodeAver · 07/12/2023 14:10

yoteyak · 07/12/2023 13:56

For those (and there are some) who think we have no proof either way, here is a sketch of a proof that God does not exist:

God, if existent, is omnipotent, omniscient, and morally perfect.

Omnipotent: God has the power to eliminate all evil.
Omniscient: God knows when evil exists.
Morally perfect: God has the desire to eliminate all evil.

Evil exists. (Earthquakes, war, famine, ... lots of bad things in the world)

So either God doesn’t have the power to eliminate all evil, or doesn’t know when evil exists, or doesn’t have the desire to eliminate all evil.

That is, God doesn’t exist.

This argument is certainly valid (the conclusion follows from the premises).

Is it sound? (Given its validity, are the premises all true)? ... Well, perhaps God is not all three of (all powerful), (all knowing) and (morally perfect). Perhaps there's an ignorant creator, an impotent Demiurge, or a big baddie. But otherwise, yes this is a sound argument (pace Leibniz and that best-of-all-possible schtick). So its conclusion is true.

There is no god.

Nope. The assumption that being morally perfect requires a deity to want to eliminate all evil is not at all proven, not at all obvioius and is a very human and limited idea. You can say that if you were God you would want to eliminate all evil. We can certainly agree that a god who wants to eliminate all evil and has the power and knowledge to do so doesn't exist. That doesn't prove that God doesn't exist, only that specific idea of one.

Elphame · 07/12/2023 14:08

Perimama · 07/12/2023 01:42

As it is taboo to talk religion politics with people socially, I often wonder whether many people think like me. As a species we have dismissed all the other "Gods" ie Greek gods etc. What makes the Christian God any different? I wasn't born into a religious household although I was baptized Christian. The whole concept seems so unbelievable to me.

Basically politics.

He had a great PR man in Paul and sadly Constantine was afraid of his army so plumped for Christianity rather than Mithraism as the Roman state religion. Had he gone the other way, we'd probably all be sacrificing white bulls on the 25th December.

Reading the background to the rise of Christianity and the way the books of the bible were put together destroyed forever any credibility that religion might have had for me.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 07/12/2023 14:08

@CampsieGlamper

Humans did not evolve from Chimpanzees.

We have a common ancestor, but Chimps evolved separately from humans.

There are obvious discrepancies between the species, but at the same time we are so similar as to be almost indistinguishable. Chimps use tools, can solve complex problems, form strong family and interpersonal bonds, have their own languages, can be taught to communicate with us, they even have a rudimentary sense of humour which you can see by the fact they mock and tease each other about personal characteristics.

We're more successful in terms of proliferation and clearly more able to adapt to different circumstances, but in terms of functionality Chimps are so close to us that it makes a mockery of this idea that humans are somehow a "chosen" or "special" species.

SkySecret · 07/12/2023 14:06

Absolutely. I’ve always thought this.

Some of the bible is true and some of the people did exist…. but picture it now…. Moses is trying to coordinate all these people, who likely had no laws or regulations. He disappears for 40 days while he chips out some basic rules and tells them they came from “god” to help instil fear in people. Make them behave themselves….

It was a way for people who knew no better, with no scientific advancement, to explain the unexplained - how did the world come to be?

I also think, in modern times, it’s a way for people to either seek community and inclusion (a group of people all signing the same things, the group responses to the priest, the community that creates) and also a way for people who can’t deal with reality to be able to cope - pray to god, believe “god has a plan” etc.

SwordToFlamethrower · 07/12/2023 14:01

Yep deffo. I'm a witch and work with the "goddess" so to speak. She is the creator that exists in every woman. She manifests herself in all new life, inspiration and new beginnings. It makes sense to me to work with powerful female energies. Energy that can be seen and felt. The Great Maiden- Mother- Matriarch. Wonderful, empowering stuff.

I never understood why anyone, especially women would want to grovel at the feet of a jealous, cruel and vindictive, manchild desert god.

Absolutely baffling.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 07/12/2023 13:58

yoteyak · 07/12/2023 13:56

For those (and there are some) who think we have no proof either way, here is a sketch of a proof that God does not exist:

God, if existent, is omnipotent, omniscient, and morally perfect.

Omnipotent: God has the power to eliminate all evil.
Omniscient: God knows when evil exists.
Morally perfect: God has the desire to eliminate all evil.

Evil exists. (Earthquakes, war, famine, ... lots of bad things in the world)

So either God doesn’t have the power to eliminate all evil, or doesn’t know when evil exists, or doesn’t have the desire to eliminate all evil.

That is, God doesn’t exist.

This argument is certainly valid (the conclusion follows from the premises).

Is it sound? (Given its validity, are the premises all true)? ... Well, perhaps God is not all three of (all powerful), (all knowing) and (morally perfect). Perhaps there's an ignorant creator, an impotent Demiurge, or a big baddie. But otherwise, yes this is a sound argument (pace Leibniz and that best-of-all-possible schtick). So its conclusion is true.

There is no god.

Very monotheist view though.

As far as I'm aware, most pagans don't think the gods are those three things. I certainly don't.

yoteyak · 07/12/2023 13:56

For those (and there are some) who think we have no proof either way, here is a sketch of a proof that God does not exist:

God, if existent, is omnipotent, omniscient, and morally perfect.

Omnipotent: God has the power to eliminate all evil.
Omniscient: God knows when evil exists.
Morally perfect: God has the desire to eliminate all evil.

Evil exists. (Earthquakes, war, famine, ... lots of bad things in the world)

So either God doesn’t have the power to eliminate all evil, or doesn’t know when evil exists, or doesn’t have the desire to eliminate all evil.

That is, God doesn’t exist.

This argument is certainly valid (the conclusion follows from the premises).

Is it sound? (Given its validity, are the premises all true)? ... Well, perhaps God is not all three of (all powerful), (all knowing) and (morally perfect). Perhaps there's an ignorant creator, an impotent Demiurge, or a big baddie. But otherwise, yes this is a sound argument (pace Leibniz and that best-of-all-possible schtick). So its conclusion is true.

There is no god.

BrainInAJar · 07/12/2023 13:50

I've been thinking about this stuff a lot recently.

So I made a list of reasons "why we have religion". I've copied and pasted a few that haven't already been mentioned.

Interested in anyone's thoughts.

........................................

It’s human/evolutionary to fear the finality of death so we make something up to comfort ourselves that we actually won’t die. This is why people get religious as they get older

We also want to believe that we will be reunited with our loved ones in heaven and that bad folk will be punished in hell.

We WISH someone else was in control – we are scared by war, disease, natural disasters, where humanity is going, it’s a child-like impulse to look for an adult. But just because we wish it were so, doesn’t mean it is.

It is evolutionary for people to follow their parents’ beliefs eg about religion as generally YES they do have more knowledge/experience than you.

It is evolutionary to assume there’s a person behind something rather than it’s random chance, like you see a face in a pattern.

Evolution may explain why all tribes/people have tended to have a religion – it may be that it’s beneficial for people to have this sort of shared belief as it encourages the tribe to stick together and be able to identify outsiders. Some feel the same these days at a football match or a pop concert.

In the olden days, it was essentially social security – the church would look after widows

Homophobic people can use it to justify their position.

We want people to think we are moral.

We feel superior because we know “the truth”.

We feel superior because we are “God’s chosen people” and “special”. No-one wants to think they are just the same as everyone else, 1 of 6 billion people.

We enjoy the music, rituals and “quiet time”. Connects us to our childhood/deceased relatives like our Christmas traditions.

We are overly impressed by the architecture, stained glass, art, music, Biblical scholars etc. Seems strange that it would all be based on nonsense.

Religion is essentially a hobby like any other. Something to be part of, learn about, ascend the hierarchy of in one’s local church. In the old days, it was possibly the only book you had and was your main source of social interaction (apart from the pub?) You would have really stood out if you hadn’t participated.

Swipe left for the next trending thread