Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that God doesn't exist and is a manmade concept

569 replies

Perimama · 07/12/2023 01:42

As it is taboo to talk religion politics with people socially, I often wonder whether many people think like me. As a species we have dismissed all the other "Gods" ie Greek gods etc. What makes the Christian God any different? I wasn't born into a religious household although I was baptized Christian. The whole concept seems so unbelievable to me.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
ErrolTheDragon · 08/12/2023 09:18

You do not get something from nothing.

Is that a fact? I think there are physicists who will disagree. There's also a huge problem with that argument about eternality - it doesn't seem to consider the fact that the evidence of Big Bang is the point at which time itself began. This is of course a difficult concept to understand but I don't think an 'eternal' supernatural power solves anything whatsoever in that argument - that would be the biggest 'something out of nothing' possible!

Bad science and bad logic.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 08/12/2023 09:17

Oldsu · 07/12/2023 02:05

As Thomas Aquinas once said 'To one who has faith, no explanation is necessary. To one without faith, no explanation is possible.

Edited

That's just a get out clause for blind faith though.

Anisette · 08/12/2023 09:14

TheBeautifulMoors · 08/12/2023 08:40

Are a third of state schools only available to christians? How did I not know this? None of those schools exists near me then because I’ve never heard of them.

I know of C of E schools with the majority of places going to children whose family attend CofE churches, with a small portion to other christians, then people of other faith.

Were you including catholic schools in these stats? The Catholic schools I know give majority of their available spaces to Catholics, and other christians have the same priority as everyone else.

The Bishops from cofE don’t represent all Christians. They are many varying views. In terms of the House of Lords seats, what about the over 90 inherited peers? They’re from a specific pool after all.

I was very interested to read about the christian privileges so disappointed to see these as the privileges you were talking about.

There are state funded schools for other religions too, with less inclusive admissions criteria. It is not a christian-only privilege.

There should not be state-funded schools for any religion.

@CurlewKate clearly didn't say that faith schools are only available to Christians. What she said, which is entirely correct, is that your choice of potential schools is wider if you profess to be Christian because, obviously, it is so much easier to get into a faith school. Yes, most of them do offer some places to members of other faiths and non-Christians, but they come way down the order of priority in an awful lot of faith schools, so much so that with the popular ones your chances of getting in are close to zero if you can't produce that certificate from the vicar or priest.

Even when a faith school accepts a larger proportion of non-Christians, that is expressly on the basis that they have to accept the church ethos of the school. If you don't want to inflict that on your child that reduces choice also.

MassageForLife · 08/12/2023 09:11

crikeymikeydoyoulikey · 08/12/2023 09:08

Earlier in the thread people were talking about whether the Romans had recorded a census, so thought it would be interesting to explore just what we could dig up referencing biblical events.

Ah, that makes sense.

crikeymikeydoyoulikey · 08/12/2023 09:09

The experiences that really interest me are those who have been lifelong atheists and then became believers.

MassageForLife · 08/12/2023 09:09

User135644 · 08/12/2023 08:59

Millions and millions die and keep dying in the name of religion, Israel and Palestine the obvious one at the moment.

Who knows, if there was no religion maybe these people who commit atrocities in the name of gods would be even worse?

If religion didn't exist, nether would Israel. And the vast majority of the people would have been very unlikely to move there. And so the space would not be so crowded and wouldn't result in the divisions of land that currently exist.

So while there might still be some fighting among people there, it would be unlikely to be nearly as significant.

crikeymikeydoyoulikey · 08/12/2023 09:08

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 09:07

Just in case anyone missed it- GotQuestions that @crikeymikeydoyoulikey linked to is a Christian site.

Oh yes, it's a Christian site! I suppose I should have said that!

crikeymikeydoyoulikey · 08/12/2023 09:08

MassageForLife · 08/12/2023 09:05

Is this an attempt at proving the Bible is factual?

In that case, can I introduce you to a genre called 'historical fiction'?

Earlier in the thread people were talking about whether the Romans had recorded a census, so thought it would be interesting to explore just what we could dig up referencing biblical events.

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 09:07

Just in case anyone missed it- GotQuestions that @crikeymikeydoyoulikey linked to is a Christian site.

MassageForLife · 08/12/2023 09:05

crikeymikeydoyoulikey · 08/12/2023 08:37

53 People in the Bible Confirmed Archaeologically - Biblical Archaeology Society

53 People in the Bible Confirmed Archaeologically

Biblical archaeology is an interesting subject too.

Is this an attempt at proving the Bible is factual?

In that case, can I introduce you to a genre called 'historical fiction'?

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 09:04

@TheBeautifulMoors And I do see a tendency among people of faith to say "Privilege? We don't have privilege! Oh, that! I thought you meant real privilege, not that old thing...."

Moonmelodies · 08/12/2023 09:04

crikeymikeydoyoulikey · 08/12/2023 08:45

It is a fascinating thought. Here's an excerpt from GotQuestions which I find a helpful site when my mind is wrangling with these thoughts:

Next comes the big question: does God exist? Atheists and naturalists (who do not accept anything beyond this physical world and universe) say “no.” While volumes have been written and debates have raged throughout history on this question, it is actually not difficult to answer. To give it proper attention, you must first ask this question: Why do we have something rather than nothing at all? In other words, how did you and everything around you get here? The argument for God can be presented very simply:

Something exists.
You do not get something from nothing.
Therefore, a necessary and eternal Being exists.

You cannot deny you exist because you have to exist in order to deny your own existence (which is self-defeating), so the first premise above is true. No one has ever demonstrated that something can come from nothing unless they redefine what ‘nothing’ is, so the second premise rings true. Therefore, the conclusion naturally follows—an eternal Being is responsible for everything that exists.

This is a position no thinking atheist denies; they just claim that the universe is that eternal being. However, the problem with that stance is that all scientific evidence points to the fact that the universe had a beginning (the ‘big bang’). And everything that has a beginning must have a cause; therefore, the universe had a cause and is not eternal. Because the only two sources of eternality are an eternal universe (denied by all current empirical evidence) or an eternal Creator, the only logical conclusion is that God exists. Answering the question of God’s existence in the affirmative rules out atheism as a valid belief system.

gotquestions bible - Search (bing.com)

"you must first ask this question" says who?
A lot of presumptions in that text.
Many atheist would simply answer that they don't know how everything came to exist - only that they don't accept the 'god did it' explanation.

crikeymikeydoyoulikey · 08/12/2023 09:03

User135644 · 08/12/2023 08:59

Millions and millions die and keep dying in the name of religion, Israel and Palestine the obvious one at the moment.

Who knows, if there was no religion maybe these people who commit atrocities in the name of gods would be even worse?

Yes, under Communism religion is banned and many millions have died under those regimes. I posted a link about that some pages back.

User135644 · 08/12/2023 08:59

Millions and millions die and keep dying in the name of religion, Israel and Palestine the obvious one at the moment.

Who knows, if there was no religion maybe these people who commit atrocities in the name of gods would be even worse?

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 08:58

@TheBeautifulMoors Of course I'm including Catholics as Christians-don't you?

To be honest, if you don't regard the fact that a third of state funded schools offer priority to people of faith as a privilege, then maybe we have a different understanding of the word. And this is not even mentioning that all schools in the UK have, by law, to have daily "broadly Christian" collective worship. Obviously, many do not- but they are breaking their statutory duty if they don't.

And I object very strongly to any unelected legislators. We are though currently talking specifically there for religious reasons.

NotEvenThought · 08/12/2023 08:55

I think the reason the idea of god exists is that it answers questions, gives comfort and structure and often allows people to be managed and exploited by other people.
People think the human brain is more developed than it is. I literally can't imagine space. I know it's there, I can sort of see it when I look up at night but the thought of it being so huge and old makes my brain struggle even though I know it's there. My brains cpu isn't powerful enough.

crikeymikeydoyoulikey · 08/12/2023 08:45

PianPianPiano · 07/12/2023 10:14

I think humans like to have explanations for things. Historically, things would happen that seemed inexplicable and so humans came up with the idea of gods as the explanation for why those things happen. It's reassuring.

I don't believe in god. However, I was reading a book with my son recently about space and the universe and I was reminded just how terrifying I find the concept of the universe. What was there before? How could there have been nothing? There surely had to be something in order for the universe to create/expand from it - so what was that?. And how can the universe be infinite, that just seems impossible. Yet equally, if it isn't, what is at the end of it? Again, there can't just be nothing...

These things hurt my brain, and I think it would be simpler to believe that it has all been created by some higher being instead. And perhaps our universe is actually just in a fish tank in his castle...

It is a fascinating thought. Here's an excerpt from GotQuestions which I find a helpful site when my mind is wrangling with these thoughts:

Next comes the big question: does God exist? Atheists and naturalists (who do not accept anything beyond this physical world and universe) say “no.” While volumes have been written and debates have raged throughout history on this question, it is actually not difficult to answer. To give it proper attention, you must first ask this question: Why do we have something rather than nothing at all? In other words, how did you and everything around you get here? The argument for God can be presented very simply:

Something exists.
You do not get something from nothing.
Therefore, a necessary and eternal Being exists.

You cannot deny you exist because you have to exist in order to deny your own existence (which is self-defeating), so the first premise above is true. No one has ever demonstrated that something can come from nothing unless they redefine what ‘nothing’ is, so the second premise rings true. Therefore, the conclusion naturally follows—an eternal Being is responsible for everything that exists.

This is a position no thinking atheist denies; they just claim that the universe is that eternal being. However, the problem with that stance is that all scientific evidence points to the fact that the universe had a beginning (the ‘big bang’). And everything that has a beginning must have a cause; therefore, the universe had a cause and is not eternal. Because the only two sources of eternality are an eternal universe (denied by all current empirical evidence) or an eternal Creator, the only logical conclusion is that God exists. Answering the question of God’s existence in the affirmative rules out atheism as a valid belief system.

gotquestions bible - Search (bing.com)

gotquestions bible - Bing

Intelligent search from Bing makes it easier to quickly find what you’re looking for and rewards you.

https://www.bing.com/search?pglt=2209&q=gotquestions+bible&cvid=f9d9738092064447a3b9874652e5e6bd&gs_lcrp=EgZjaHJvbWUqBggCEAAYQDIGCAAQABhAMgYIARBFGDkyBggCEAAYQDIGCAMQABhAMgYIBBAAGEAyBggFEAAYQDIGCAYQABhAMgYIBxAAGEAyBggIEAAYQNIBCDM0OTdqMGoxqAIAsAIA&FORM=ANNTA1&PC=HCTS

CampsieGlamper · 08/12/2023 08:40

I misread"manmade" as "marmalade". Now that's something to believe in.

TheBeautifulMoors · 08/12/2023 08:40

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 07:53

@TheBeautifulMoors "what special privileges do christians get in the UK?"

The choice of a third more tax payer funded state schools. An unelected block of 25 in the House of Lords all likely to vote in similar ways on many issues including end of life care and women's reproductive health.

Are a third of state schools only available to christians? How did I not know this? None of those schools exists near me then because I’ve never heard of them.

I know of C of E schools with the majority of places going to children whose family attend CofE churches, with a small portion to other christians, then people of other faith.

Were you including catholic schools in these stats? The Catholic schools I know give majority of their available spaces to Catholics, and other christians have the same priority as everyone else.

The Bishops from cofE don’t represent all Christians. They are many varying views. In terms of the House of Lords seats, what about the over 90 inherited peers? They’re from a specific pool after all.

I was very interested to read about the christian privileges so disappointed to see these as the privileges you were talking about.

There are state funded schools for other religions too, with less inclusive admissions criteria. It is not a christian-only privilege.

QuizzlyBear · 08/12/2023 08:34

100%! I honestly can't understand how people still have unwavering belief (which they are willing to die and kill for!) in THEIR God, when the other 4000 worshipped in human history are obviously bollocks.

Critical thinking is obviously not a human trait!

crikeymikeydoyoulikey · 08/12/2023 08:30

Perimama · 07/12/2023 01:42

As it is taboo to talk religion politics with people socially, I often wonder whether many people think like me. As a species we have dismissed all the other "Gods" ie Greek gods etc. What makes the Christian God any different? I wasn't born into a religious household although I was baptized Christian. The whole concept seems so unbelievable to me.

You may find this site helpful and interesting.

crikeymikeydoyoulikey · 08/12/2023 08:29

yoteyak · 07/12/2023 10:59

If you want a list of old-style gods, H. L. Mencken is a good starting place. See for example Funeral March: "Where is the graveyard of dead gods? ..."

"... Huitzilopochtli, like many other gods, had no human father; his mother was a virtuous widow; he was born of an apparently innocent flirtation that she carried on with the sun. When he frowned, his father, the sun, stood still. When he roared with rage, earthquakes engulfed whole cities. When he thirsted he was watered with 10,000 gallons of human blood. ...

"... Speaking of Huitzilopochtli recalls his brother, Tezcatilpoca. Tezcatilpoca was almost as powerful: He consumed 25,000 virgins a year. Lead me to his tomb: I would weep, and hang a couronne des perles. But who knows where it is? Or where the grave of Quitzalcontl is? Or Tialoc? Or Chalchihuitlicue? Or Xiehtecutli? Or Centeotl, that sweet one? Or Tlazolteotl, the goddess of love? Or Mictlan? Or Ixtlilton? Or Omacatl? Or Yacatecutli? Or Mixcoatl? Or Xipe? Or all the host of Tzitzimitles? Where are their bones? Where is the willow on which they hung their harps? In what forlorn and unheard of hell do they await the resurrection morn? Who enjoys their residuary estates? Or that of Dis, whom Caesar found to be the chief god of the Celts? Or that of Tarves, the bull? Or that of Moccos, the pig? Or that of Epona, the mare? Or that of Mullo, the celestial jack-ass? There was a time when the Irish revered all these gods ..."

A few more? ...

"Dagda
Robigus
Pluto
Ops
Meditrina
Vesta
Tilmun
Ogyrvan
Dea Dia
Ceros
Vaticanus
Edulia
Adeona
Iuno Lucina
Saturn
Furrina
Vediovis
Consus
Cronos
Enki
Engurra
Belus
Dimmer
Mu-ul-lil
Ubargisi
Ubilulu
Gasan lil
U-dimmer-an-kia
Enurestu
U-sab-sib"

... And so on. And so on.

Often people say, regarding their children, something along the lines of, "I don't want to tell them what to believe; I think they should be taught about different religions and then left to make their own minds up."

Similar thoughts are often expressed about R. E. in schools.

I'm still waiting for someone to mention Huitzilopochtli or any of the others in this regard.

I told my children the truth. Religions (plural) are nonsense - all of them. (Sometimes interesting nonsense, to be sure, but nonsense all the same.) We'd all be better off without them. My children grew up to be happy, successful, and - I dare assert - decent moral people who smile at the superstitious beliefs of theists (of all stripes).

This is fascinating and I will follow those up - I love reading this kind of thing.

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 07:53

@TheBeautifulMoors "what special privileges do christians get in the UK?"

The choice of a third more tax payer funded state schools. An unelected block of 25 in the House of Lords all likely to vote in similar ways on many issues including end of life care and women's reproductive health.

HRTQueen · 08/12/2023 07:28

*Christian days