Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that God doesn't exist and is a manmade concept

569 replies

Perimama · 07/12/2023 01:42

As it is taboo to talk religion politics with people socially, I often wonder whether many people think like me. As a species we have dismissed all the other "Gods" ie Greek gods etc. What makes the Christian God any different? I wasn't born into a religious household although I was baptized Christian. The whole concept seems so unbelievable to me.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
IMustDoMoreExercise · 08/12/2023 11:39

eardefender · 08/12/2023 11:21

Ancient people were not uneducated at all. For example, their maritime knowledge was exceptional and advanced. Ancient people also had deep faith as we can see from the monuments they left behind. I think that religious and spiritual connection and experience is innate to us as human beings and its part of our shared subconcious.

A few people were educated but not the masses.

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 11:39

@Achildbelongstoitsmother

Am I somehow missing a joke? I don't understand your post.

eardefender · 08/12/2023 11:36

Achildbelongstoitsmother · 08/12/2023 11:29

Not enough, Kate, not enough.

And the few that have, haven't progressed past the conspiracy theory theory.

People need a God. Kate, and I'm sure you can encourage them to realise it. You must stop our secular society going to hell in a handcart.

You have made a very interesting point. There is an idea that we should all be upholding our religious communities churches etc even if we are atheist because we have nothing else and that atheism does not offer anything to those without faith in terms of life markers like baptism and funerals, marriages etc. No structure to the week, no moral code, no marking the seasons. No centre of a community to uphold values and help people. The idea being that until secular society creates a viable alternative to replace faith based practice then we need to continue with the old.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/12/2023 11:32

You must stop our secular society going to hell in a handcart

Oh for goodness sake.

Go look at every extinct, defunct, dead, non-existent historic civilisation. Every single one of them was non-secular, so evidently, belief in the divine does absolutely nothing to prevent "society going to hell in a handcart".

You could even look at Mayans, for example, where evidence suggests that utter devotion to their system of worship was, in fact, a significant factor in their terminal decline.

eardefender · 08/12/2023 11:31

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 11:20

@eardefender
"natural selection is a theory which many feel has not applied to humans at least as a species. I think there is some weight to the counter argument."

Oils you say some more about this?

Off topic for this thread but some feel that it is illogical to say that the fittest survived, they clearly didn't, natural disasters killed so many. The first wave of humans to come to the British isles suffered an ice age and may have all perished. There is so much we don't know about our history. Natural selection may make some sense to a degree but history and evolution is more messy and complex than that. Its an oversimplification to say that the best always survive and get to breed. In the case of humans it was status not health or genetics that meant who could breed or not. It still is, we don't have natural selection now. There are many things people simply cannot survive no matter how strong they are. If a group of animals lived in a stable population in a stable location for long enough then natural selection may flourish but Humans i am not so sure about as we haven't had those conditions and our way of relating to each other and the world is very complex.

Achildbelongstoitsmother · 08/12/2023 11:29

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 11:21

@Achildbelongstoitsmother "I wish they would turn their powerful intellects to ponder the question why mankind felt the need to invent God."

Surely lots of people on this thread alone have covered this point?

Not enough, Kate, not enough.

And the few that have, haven't progressed past the conspiracy theory theory.

People need a God. Kate, and I'm sure you can encourage them to realise it. You must stop our secular society going to hell in a handcart.

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 11:21

@Achildbelongstoitsmother "I wish they would turn their powerful intellects to ponder the question why mankind felt the need to invent God."

Surely lots of people on this thread alone have covered this point?

eardefender · 08/12/2023 11:21

IMustDoMoreExercise · 08/12/2023 11:17

Religion was just a way to control the masses.

It was necessary before most people were educated.

Ancient people were not uneducated at all. For example, their maritime knowledge was exceptional and advanced. Ancient people also had deep faith as we can see from the monuments they left behind. I think that religious and spiritual connection and experience is innate to us as human beings and its part of our shared subconcious.

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 11:20

@eardefender
"natural selection is a theory which many feel has not applied to humans at least as a species. I think there is some weight to the counter argument."

Oils you say some more about this?

Achildbelongstoitsmother · 08/12/2023 11:19

It was very wise of man to create God.

Quite a number of people proudly declare that God does not exist. I wish they would turn their powerful intellects to ponder the question why mankind felt the need to invent God.

eardefender · 08/12/2023 11:17

jonesysy · 07/12/2023 02:21

Possibly the most important point in history was 1859 when our species realised where we had come from via evolution by natural selction. At that point we should have cast off all religions declaring an Adam and Eve or a creator that put animals here for our benefit

natural selection is a theory which many feel has not applied to humans at least as a species. I think there is some weight to the counter argument.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 08/12/2023 11:17

Religion was just a way to control the masses.

It was necessary before most people were educated.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/12/2023 11:12

Moonmelodies · 08/12/2023 10:54

Even if it could be proven that a god created the universe, there is still no evidence that a god currently exists, so the atheist viewpoint would remain valid.

Edited

Hmm. Ok, this is semantic, but I'm not sure you could really credibly continue to use the term "atheist" in this scenario, given that atheism is the denial of the existence of the divine.

In a scenario where the divine have been proven to exist, even if they/it no longer do, then I would certainly concede that atheism is proven false, although I would have no issue whatsoever accepting the fact that the divine no longer exists.

I think this comes down to personal convictions and definitions of atheism though, but for me at least, atheism would no longer be a valid position because the fundamental definition no longer fits, and I'd be inclined toward the position that if the divine existed at one point, then it would surely follow that the could exist again at some point in the future. I mean, most species of dinosaur no longer exist, but I'm not a dino-denier, and it is possible that science could develop the technology to revive species from DNA, or that in the distant future the planet evolves once again to a state where it could support dinosaur species and they evolve naturally. Unlikely, but not entirely impossible. If dinos could make a comeback, then I'd concede that divine beings likely could as well.

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 10:58

@crikeymikeydoyoulikey " just thought it was interesting. We all seem to be having a general discussion about religion"

Oh, I see. You seemed to be expecting it to be a surprise to us that the Bible references historical characters.

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 10:56

"You can't get something from nothing"

"If people evolved from apes why are there still apes?"

Some people seem to have failed to notice that these conundrums have been solved.....

Moonmelodies · 08/12/2023 10:54

Even if it could be proven that a god created the universe, there is still no evidence that a god currently exists, so the atheist viewpoint would remain valid.

crikeymikeydoyoulikey · 08/12/2023 10:16

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 10:04

@crikeymikeydoyoulikey I don't understand why, in the context of this thread, it's relevant that there are historically real people mentioned in the Bible. Could you explain,please?

How are you getting on with your search for atheists who converted to Christianity? I understand they are pretty rare....

I know of some already (including myself). I will dig them up and post them here, if that's okay with everyone. I should be working, after having lost all day to a powercut yesterday, but I'll be back...

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/12/2023 10:16

ErrolTheDragon · 08/12/2023 09:18

You do not get something from nothing.

Is that a fact? I think there are physicists who will disagree. There's also a huge problem with that argument about eternality - it doesn't seem to consider the fact that the evidence of Big Bang is the point at which time itself began. This is of course a difficult concept to understand but I don't think an 'eternal' supernatural power solves anything whatsoever in that argument - that would be the biggest 'something out of nothing' possible!

Bad science and bad logic.

Yip.

I wish creationists would give it a rest with this "you can't get something from nothing" line that they frequently use in their arguments, because they are misunderstanding the principle, and misapplying in an irrelevant setting.

Atheists do not claim the origin of the universe involved "creating something from nothing" in the first place, so claiming that can not be done as a means to disprove and discredit Atheistic position is a total nonsense.

crikeymikeydoyoulikey · 08/12/2023 10:15

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 10:04

@crikeymikeydoyoulikey I don't understand why, in the context of this thread, it's relevant that there are historically real people mentioned in the Bible. Could you explain,please?

How are you getting on with your search for atheists who converted to Christianity? I understand they are pretty rare....

I just thought it was interesting. We all seem to be having a general discussion about religion now, as OP has long since disappeared after making only two posts.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/12/2023 10:07

Moonmelodies · 08/12/2023 09:04

"you must first ask this question" says who?
A lot of presumptions in that text.
Many atheist would simply answer that they don't know how everything came to exist - only that they don't accept the 'god did it' explanation.

Indeed.

It's actually reasonably sane and cogent, by the typical standard of creationist argument, but at this point it completely loses the plot and becomes nonsensical drivel -

This is a position no thinking atheist denies; they just claim that the universe is that eternal being. However, the problem with that stance is that all scientific evidence points to the fact that the universe had a beginning (the ‘big bang’). And everything that has a beginning must have a cause; therefore, the universe had a cause and is not eternal. Because the only two sources of eternality are an eternal universe (denied by all current empirical evidence) or an eternal Creator, the only logical conclusion is that God exists. Answering the question of God’s existence in the affirmative rules out atheism as a valid belief system

Atheists do not invariably claim that this universe is eternal, or an eternal being. It also posits only one possible definition of "eternal" with regard to the universe, oddly enough the one that suits the creationist argument, and makes no mention of the fact the "universe" can exist eternally via means the argument ignores entirely. It posits only two possible explanations for the origin and nature of universe, attributes one to Atheists irrespective of the fact it is not the only or default Atheistic position, discounts it, and then concludes the other must be true, a creator being, because its the only one left standing.

Utter tripe.

CurlewKate · 08/12/2023 10:04

@crikeymikeydoyoulikey I don't understand why, in the context of this thread, it's relevant that there are historically real people mentioned in the Bible. Could you explain,please?

How are you getting on with your search for atheists who converted to Christianity? I understand they are pretty rare....

ButterCupPie · 08/12/2023 09:41

Cailleachian · 07/12/2023 04:08

I was brought up christian (sunday school, occasional church, prayers at school etc) and as a child I never questioned God. When I was about 14 I went rabidly atheist for about 6 months, then gradually faded back to soft belief as I became an adult.

Over the decade or so, first prompted by climate change I've come to a fairly firm belief in an entity that I think is what Abrahamic traditions would recognise as God. While I wouldn't say I am actually "religious", God is important to me.

I was the same, and now I am often drawn to the Sea of Faith movement. Does anyone remember Fr Jude Bullock? Pilloried in the press as 'the priest who doesn't believe in God'. Had to leave the Catholic church but found a welcome in the C of E where he is vicar of St Anne's, Chingford. He has given talks to local faith groups including a Reform synagogue. The S of F position is roughly that God is a human creation, but a very valuable one. The Quakers are very open to some of their ideas.

EyeInTheSky23 · 08/12/2023 09:41

Something exists.
You do not get something from nothing.
Therefore, a necessary and eternal Being exists.

Why would it have to be a being?

Why do you jump to a being?

Because you can't imagine anything else?

Because you don't have the capacity to imagine anything else?

EyeInTheSky23 · 08/12/2023 09:39

Millions and millions die and keep dying in the name of religion, Israel and Palestine the obvious one at the moment.

Most of the time it's nothing to do with religion though. There will be a label/identity for the warring factions .... But it's about "resources*.

ErrolTheDragon · 08/12/2023 09:31

On faith schools... I live in an area where there's a massive oversupply of faith schools - all CofE or RC - vs the proportion of the population likely to be Christian. Some are good, some aren't. So if you can't or won't fulfil their 'faith' criteria (baptism, church attendance) then your child is likely to be excluded from the better schools yet still end up having to go to a 'Christian' school! Does anyone think it's remotely moral for kids to be discriminated against because of their parents' beliefs or circumstances don't enable them to attend church regularly?
Thats an issue for another thread or two though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread