Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this sounds like a rubbish Christmas Day?

356 replies

Tengreenbottles2 · 07/12/2023 00:14

We have a 4 year old and a baby. This year we are spending Christmas with the in-laws (they live in a different EU country). DH’s bro and sis will be there, with their kids (both aged 6). The massive fly in the ointment this year is, my SIL couldn’t come on the 24th due to work, so she she’s travelling up on the 25th with her partner and child, arriving at MIL’s around 4pm. It has therefore been decided that we won’t open presents until DSIL and co arrive, at around 4pm. We’ll then have our proper full Christmas Dinner on the 26th.

Am I being a consumeristic spoilt drama queen who is raising my children to be consumeristic spoilt drama queens, or does that sound like a really shit plan when you’ve got little kids?

It had apparently been proposed that we could potentially lie to the children and tell them it’s Christmas Eve on the 25th, and act as though it’s Christmas Day on the 26th, but that idea was rejected for some reason (I wasn’t involved in the conversations so I’m not sure why - it sounds like the ideal solution to me).

Another idea I have thought of would be to let the children open a couple of presents when they wake up and then open the rest when SIL and co arrive.

I can just hear the tantrums now, when our DC wake up on the 25th to be told “yes, Father Christmas has been, but don’t you dare touch those presents!”. I am struggling to think of a way of selling it to her. (There’s also the fact that I think it sounds a bit rubbish for the adults too… Just doing nothing all day until 4pm, and the kids won’t even be distracted with their new toys…)

AIBU to insist and say the proposed plan doesn’t work for us and we want to either do Christmas on the 26th, or let the children open a few presents on Christmas morning? Or am I being materialistic and selfish and we should just go with the flow?

OP posts:
Alighttouchonthetiller · 07/12/2023 07:12

AnotherDanceClass · 07/12/2023 00:27

They can’t tell you what to do. My kids would be opening their presents on Xmas morning, everyone else could do whatever they wanted. You’re an adult, a parent, you get to choose what your children do.

Ah, yes. The modern spirit of compromise. A lovely way to foster good relationships and to model the intricacies of social give and take to the next generation.🙄

Sugarfree23 · 07/12/2023 07:12

Op your DH basically has no Santa traditions. This really does smack of Grandparents trying to get the GC together because they missed out on the magic of Christmas when their own kids were little.
Do Santa the way YOU want to do it. TBH all families do it differently anyway.

Some Santa brings everything no acknowledgement to anyone other than Santa.

Some Santa only brings Stockings. But the definition of stocking even on MN varies from an actual stock to a sack or pillowcase. I'm not sure how magical that is, when kids have seen big things like bikes next to the tree before going to bed.

I grew up with Santa as a magic courier, he delivers everything. Gifts just appeared under the tree. Pure magic going to bed and everything just appears.

But whatever way you do it. It would be a heck of a long day for kids looking at gifts and not being able to open them.

I feel for SILs kid too what a rubbish way to spend Christmas day on a train. Do trains even run on Christmas Day?
18 sleeps to get a sensible plan worked out.

Really you only get a few years of kids truly believing before doubt sets in. Enjoy those magical years.

Globules · 07/12/2023 07:11

Tengreenbottles2 · 07/12/2023 06:48

Yes, this is how I see it too. I suppose there is potential for jealousy when the other cousin arrives and sees his cousins playing with their new toys when he hasn’t had any yet, but I’m thinking that jealousy would last all of 20 minutes before he gets to open his presents too.

I'm now remembering my children at their grandparents one Christmas day. Aged 5 & 7. Opened presents in the morning. Later in the day more family arrived, including step great grandparents and their biological grandchildren.

These 10&8 yr old grandchildren received full to the brim sacks nearly as tall as them from step great grandparents. Console games, expensive clothing, branded toys. These children had no consideration for what was in the presents, just ripped off the paper and dug into the sack for the next one. It was disgusting to watch the entitlement.

My children received nothing from step great grandparents. They didn't care. They weren't watching the show either, even though step great grandparents insisted they were in the room as it was "family". They had their noses in the thoughtfully chosen books from me they'd opened themselves earlier in the day. Couldn't put them down. Great grandparents were cross with my children that they weren't watching the present opening and kept encouraging them to put down their books 🤷

Grandparents were disgusted with great grandparents. I took my cue from my children. If they weren't bothered, why should I be?

And I'm glad they opened their presents earlier in the day. They had far fewer presents, and far more enjoyment in them because of it. I'd have felt awful if they opened their 3 presents, then had to watch the indulgence of the other two.

Tengreenbottles2 · 07/12/2023 07:10

Brefugee · 07/12/2023 06:49

have only read OP.
Your children are too young to understand that there is One True Christmas Day and therefore everything should happen on 25th. I would push everything one day back.

Because otherwise your insistence that one small child have the christmas YOU want, a whole family of adults have to have their idea shot down in flames.

As the parent or son/daughter in that family (your in-laws) i wouldn't be amused at all and not indulging you. A small present, if you really mus, for the 4 year old would be ok on Christmas day. Otherwise YABVU

Thank you for your comment, it’s good to hear other points of view because I think I’m starting to realise this might just be one massive culture clash… hinging on the question of whose enjoyment is most important at Christmas, the children’s or the adults’?

I was raised with the former… children’s enjoyment is at the very heart of Christmas and I feel like I would be willing to put up with a lot of inconvenience to make the children’s day a good one. But I think in DH’s culture it feels like Christmas might be primarily “for” the adults, and the children are expected to slot in around the adults’ plans for eating and drinking and opening presents together. There’s nothing wrong with either, but it makes it tricky to manoeuvre when you’re alternating from one culture to the other, doing one thing one year and another thing the next, and everyone is operating on unspoken assumptions that they haven’t discussed because they take it for granted everyone else knows.

For example, I would never in a million years have dreamed that some adults might feel their Christmas had been “shot down in flames” just because a young child opened a few of their presents a few hours earlier than everyone else (possibly in their own room).

OP posts:
Maray1967 · 07/12/2023 07:05

SantaBarbaraMonica · 07/12/2023 00:19

Ps. I GUARANTEE you that the two 6 yr olds will have opened Santa gifts that morning, no matter what the plan is.

Yes. I would be putting my foot down and saying my DC will be opening presents in the morning as per tradition. Adults can save theirs for later. Tell your DH to make this clear or do it yourself.

FeetupTvon · 07/12/2023 07:02

We open a present each first thing.
The rest are opened after dinner. It’s great, works really well for us. The excitement seems to last longer

startquitting · 07/12/2023 07:02

Zombiezee · 07/12/2023 00:21

When I was little, our stocking was from Father Christmas, and could be opened when we woke up. Big presents were under the tree, and we knew they were from parents/ relatives etc. and we waited until an appropriate point to open them. It was still magical and worked really well.

This is what everyone does here. But we’re not in the UK.

hettie · 07/12/2023 07:00

Well, Sil created this problem by her choice to come lete. The consequences of her choice are hers to manage not everyone else's to fix

Globules · 07/12/2023 06:58

Tengreenbottles2 · 07/12/2023 06:48

Yes, this is how I see it too. I suppose there is potential for jealousy when the other cousin arrives and sees his cousins playing with their new toys when he hasn’t had any yet, but I’m thinking that jealousy would last all of 20 minutes before he gets to open his presents too.

Your SIL is really not going to let her DC open any presents before a long drive in the car? I don't believe it for a second.

ItAintGonnaGoDownEasyIfItAintCheezy · 07/12/2023 06:58

Arrive boxing day morning.

Or, if thats not an option, and mil won't budge, let mil deal with the tantrums. Direct the child to her every time they ask or whine or moan. She made the rule, she can deal with the fallout.

madeinmanc · 07/12/2023 06:57

I don't think lying and deception is a good strategy.

ALunchbox · 07/12/2023 06:56

I agree with you - I would postpone the whole thing (or move it forward). We are doing ours on December 16th as we will be away the rest of the holidays and can't be bothered taking gifts with us. We are not religious though so the date is meaningless to us. We also celebrated Christmas in January in the past when it clashed with our plans.

NigelHarmansNewWife · 07/12/2023 06:53

I don't see why those of you already there can't open presents and then SIL and her family open theirs when they get there. Also, why can't Christmas dinner be the evening meal on Christmas Day? If SIL and co are arriving around 4 you can eat at 5 or later. Sitting round the table is the perfect way to all catch up. And whilst I'm at it, given that Christmas Day is a Monday why can't they travel over the weekend instead? I'm willing to bet any long train journey on Christmas Day is likely to be jollied up by the train company and it's staff so they'll probably have a high old time whilst you're being told to pretend it's just another day! Bonkers imho.

Tallerandtall · 07/12/2023 06:53

@Tengreenbottles2

its simple.
you go to some one else’s for Xmas you sign up to dance their tune.
want to do it your way stay at yours.

they is no issue at all waiting to open presents.

if your kids have a tantrum I would think about how you brought them up

and figure they need to be more polite and kind . As that is what it is to wait.

jeez.

CornishGem1975 · 07/12/2023 06:52

Yes @OhRightyThen that's exactly what we do and it's bliss. No dramas, everyone is perfectly chilled.

OhRightyThen · 07/12/2023 06:50

What @CornishGem1975. I gave up about three years ago trying to play the game of Christmas. I have three kids 6, nearly 4 and 1. We shut the door now for Christmas day, boxing day, new year eve and new year's day. Anything else can be booked in with family. Best decision we ever made. Kids want to sit in pyjamas, done. Kids want chocolate pancakes at 5am, done. Turkey not cooked by 2pm, who cares. No judgement (MIL), no drama, no schedules...bliss.

Brefugee · 07/12/2023 06:49

have only read OP.
Your children are too young to understand that there is One True Christmas Day and therefore everything should happen on 25th. I would push everything one day back.

Because otherwise your insistence that one small child have the christmas YOU want, a whole family of adults have to have their idea shot down in flames.

As the parent or son/daughter in that family (your in-laws) i wouldn't be amused at all and not indulging you. A small present, if you really mus, for the 4 year old would be ok on Christmas day. Otherwise YABVU

Tengreenbottles2 · 07/12/2023 06:48

Globules · 07/12/2023 06:31

Can I turn it around and look at it from the children's perspective?

Your DC and their cousin don't care if their other cousin is with them or not when they open their presents.

Their other cousin arriving later won't care if their cousins are opening presents when they are or not. They'll be enjoying their own new toys too much.

This is ALL about the grandparents wanting to watch all their grandchildren open presents at the same time.

You, BIL and SIL probably don't give a fig about all the cousins opening together. You parents just want happy children enjoying the presents they're given.

Get DH to tell the grandparents that if they want to hold back the presents from them until SIL arrives, of course they can. If they want to see all the children opening presents at the same time, of course you don't want to deny them that. But you're going to be letting your 4 year old enjoy the magic of Christmas, letting him enjoy his childlike wonder while he still has it and you've told BIL that's what you're doing.

Yes, this is how I see it too. I suppose there is potential for jealousy when the other cousin arrives and sees his cousins playing with their new toys when he hasn’t had any yet, but I’m thinking that jealousy would last all of 20 minutes before he gets to open his presents too.

OP posts:
Zonder · 07/12/2023 06:45

I wouldn't lie. I would just say we will do our presents on boxing day.

I'd do a stocking for Christmas morning tho from Santa. You don't have to do it how they say about what Santa brings. I bet it's not their entire country who say Santa brings everything.

Tengreenbottles2 · 07/12/2023 06:42

MrMucker · 07/12/2023 06:29

I honestly don't get this thread.

Help! What should I do! My kids have loads of presents which we bought from hard earned money, and I do not know how to say to them "wait a bit so we can all open them together because doing special stuff together is great for everyone"! O this is killing me, my poor kids, the trauma!

What are we raising?!

TBQH It’s more like “I’ve bought presents for my own kids with my own hard-earned cash and I don’t WANT to have to make them wait all day, because I want to recreate the magic I felt as a child of waking up Christmas morning and truly believing Father Christmas had been in my room and left me presents, and making the children wait until nearly tea time would not be enjoyable for me or them, and we will still be able to open some presents all together anyway”.

OP posts:
CornishGem1975 · 07/12/2023 06:39

I agree that sounds crap. I'd be staying home and doing Christmas the way I want to. We decided that years ago, Christmas is for us and the kids.

WillowTit · 07/12/2023 06:35

i bet sil will have her own dc open presents before they travel

Globules · 07/12/2023 06:31

Can I turn it around and look at it from the children's perspective?

Your DC and their cousin don't care if their other cousin is with them or not when they open their presents.

Their other cousin arriving later won't care if their cousins are opening presents when they are or not. They'll be enjoying their own new toys too much.

This is ALL about the grandparents wanting to watch all their grandchildren open presents at the same time.

You, BIL and SIL probably don't give a fig about all the cousins opening together. You parents just want happy children enjoying the presents they're given.

Get DH to tell the grandparents that if they want to hold back the presents from them until SIL arrives, of course they can. If they want to see all the children opening presents at the same time, of course you don't want to deny them that. But you're going to be letting your 4 year old enjoy the magic of Christmas, letting him enjoy his childlike wonder while he still has it and you've told BIL that's what you're doing.

MrMucker · 07/12/2023 06:29

I honestly don't get this thread.

Help! What should I do! My kids have loads of presents which we bought from hard earned money, and I do not know how to say to them "wait a bit so we can all open them together because doing special stuff together is great for everyone"! O this is killing me, my poor kids, the trauma!

What are we raising?!

Tengreenbottles2 · 07/12/2023 06:27

We don’t normally do stockings (santa brings the big presents, as that’s how we did it when I was growing up). But that’s another idea to suggest, which could work too.

DH just agreed to everything last night as he hadn’t had time to think it through, and it was only when he got off the phone and I started asking questions that it started dawning on him what a terrible idea it is. So he has resolved to talk to them again. But I was second guessing myself as MIL and BIL obviously thought the idea was fine, so I was wondering if I was being a bit of a prima donna for thinking the kids’ presents should be prioritised. But I’m glad to see I’m not alone in thinking it would be an issue.

I think partly MIL doesn’t get it as apparently they never tried to tell their kids santa was real, they just told them he was just a story people told, so DH never actually properly believed. (She is more than happy to go along with it for her grandkids (and used to go along with it for her nieces and nephews when they were little) but I think she just doesn’t understand that it actually feels like real magic and when children truly believe, and so she doesn’t understand that it has to be done a certain way to maintain the magic).

OP posts: