Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP and Christmas, AIBU?

215 replies

Christingle94 · 06/12/2023 21:43

We've been together 6.5 years and have children, he also has DC from a previous relationship. We have split finances for numerous reasons, largely due to me being alot "better" with money than he is. He struggles with his ADHD and money management. He does have redeeming qualities, before anybody asks.

I deal with all of the bills, he just transfers me his portion of the money when he gets paid.

He has form for dithering when Christmas is coming up and doesn't start buying until it's too late, IE in December and all out of one pay check.

I've been buying since September and have all of my buying done. He on the other hand has bought one small thing for DC and nothing that is on any of their lists. He hasn't bought anything for me yet, his DM etc.

The whole reason I start buying in September is because I know he does this and if I didn't sort Christmas myself, it would be pretty shit for the kids and me when he spends all of his money at the last minute rushing to get things or they don't end up with things they really want.

I've spent alot of money including on him. He wanted the new xbox which I've got him, he doesn't know yet.

The kids (ours) have got plenty of really nice stuff (some second hand but fab condition) and will be really happy come Christmas day.

I no longer buy for DSC and leave that all to him after years of hurtful reactions to gifts, they don't want or need this, that's crap etc. MN suggested I stop troubling myself with it so that is what I did but I've been telling him since September to make a start on their Xmas presents..

So to my point.

Come his pay day which is next Friday he's going to go out and spend more than we can afford in one month, trying to play catch up. That will have repercussions for me as I'll then be carrying him through the rest of the month. His DC are going to moan if they don't get everything they wanted which includes multiple brand new games which cost 50-60 pounds each.

So on top of everything I've spent already which completely absolved him of any requirement to contribute to our DC Christmas, he is now going to cost me even more money when he powers through his last wage of the year and runs out within the week because he has to buy loads for his older DC and will want to buy me some nice things too.

His heart is in the right place and he has already said he feels like a failure because I've 'finished' Christmas buying already and have got everything they need, but good intentions won't cushion the blow when I've got to worry about his financial contribution to the household this month.

Do you think I'm being unreasonable?

OP posts:
Wallywobbles · 07/12/2023 04:24

What are your total household monthly outgoings? Including food, fuel etc?

Greenpolkadot · 07/12/2023 04:06

Your dsc sound pretty ungrateful

Sconehenge · 07/12/2023 03:59

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 07/12/2023 03:49

Then he is able to us “his card” for household expenses, from this joint account. You on the other hand will be able to keep an eye on it… because it’s a joint account.
And if he empties that account and bills are due?

I guess this is a risk but I’m operating on the assumption that her DP is disorganised and time blind rather than reckless. So presumably they would have a discussion about what specific expenses can be put on the joint card (eg food shopping) and what expenses he’ll need to use his own fun money card for (eg impulse buys or treats).

Geppili · 07/12/2023 03:54

Please stop pandering to this cocklodging manchild! At least return the effing XBox and get him a £50 xbox vouchers. He sounds about 15. How can you bear it?

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 07/12/2023 03:49

Then he is able to us “his card” for household expenses, from this joint account. You on the other hand will be able to keep an eye on it… because it’s a joint account.
And if he empties that account and bills are due?

Lalagahgah · 07/12/2023 03:48

Another one with a DH with ADHD. Completely agree with @InattentiveADHD and some of the comments are really ableist.

ADHD is not an excuse but it is a reason. Of course it's on him to come up with strategies to help himself but part of being a couple is supporting your partner. OP can of course decide this is too much and leave but if she chooses to stay she needs to help him (or accept living with this type of mess). I'm autistic and believe me DH helps me as much as I help him.

It sounds like he is trying - he's already agreed he'll transfer her the 600 this month all, and it sounds like it's OP that suggested he had 300 more to pay more of the expenses directly.

OP, I agree with everyone - 600 doesn't sound like it is likely to come close to 50% of actual expenses. You need to work out how much the household costs a month together (including an agreed amount for family trips etc) and have that in a joint account each month. Then the rest of his money is his to choose how he spends. If he doesn't have enough money to buy his kids what they want, that's his problem. You can then slowly work on him taking responsibility for paying specific joint bills from the joint account, if that's what you want.

For what it's worth, in our house all Christmas present shopping is done except that absolutely nothing has been bought for DH's family. I made it very clear 15+ years ago this was not my problem. In the early days they often didn't get presents. He has managed to work through it himself. He also knows there will be he'll to play if he doesn't get me anything and I always get something, albeit sometimes last minute and fairly random!

FictionalCharacter · 07/12/2023 03:23

Shinyandnew1 · 06/12/2023 21:48

Don’t carry him then. Return the expensive present you got him and use that to pay the bills in December

Edited

Yep. No way would I be buying this man an Xbox.

Firsttimemum623 · 07/12/2023 03:17

A longer term solution; perhaps you get a separate bank account for joint bills (in just your name if he really can't be trusted not to dip in). You both set up a standing order for the day after you get paid to put enough into this account for ALL household bills, including enough to save for Christmas for the year. Any excess you keep in your individual accounts to spend as you wish, but it means you'll be able to pay for food shopping etc out of the 'joint' account rather than your personal money & you'll have money to buy JOINT presents for your DC next year. Your portion could always be slightly more if you feel you should contribute more due to higher earnings.

Short term, he could get a credit card to pay for this Christmas & then he'd have to pay that off using his 'excess' next year. Granted that may be a risky solution for someone with poor impulse control, but you could cut it up as soon as the month is up to limit the damage & it's ultimately up to him to then pay for it, rather than falling to you.

Bournetilly · 07/12/2023 03:14

He hasn’t got better at budgeting he’s just got more money to spend so it lasts longer.

£600 is nothing for him to contribute nevermind £300. You need to take half of ALL the bills, your food shops and your kids activities. Or a % depending how much more you earn but him contributing £300 is unfair to you.

I agree get him to contribute £600 this month. It’s fine to start shopping at the last min if he wants but he should have saved up some money. Also next year I’d be asking for half for your DC Christmas presents.

Sconehenge · 07/12/2023 03:12

I think people here are posting from a lack of understanding of ADHD. It’s not fair to vilify him and doesn’t serve any purpose.

OP, I understand that you both wanted to have some of the things like shopping etc paid for on his card rather than yours all the time, but wouldn’t a better idea be to set up a JOINT account for all your household expenses, and you both have a card for this same account?

Budget effectively so you calculate all the daily expenses of living and child raising, then both put in the appropriate % into this account.

Then he is able to us “his card” for household expenses, from this joint account. You on the other hand will be able to keep an eye on it… because it’s a joint account.

You should also set up a savings account with a DD from his account so that he is saving some of the remaining money. You could pre-empt Christmas by setting up a Christmas pot in this way for him (maybe using something like a Monzo card which has easy savings pots). Ideally you can also monitor this so he doesn’t end up in a state where he is dipping into it each month and it never grows.

The rest of the money is clearly marked as his “fun” money and he can do what he likes with this without guilt.

I think you have to be realistic that you’re married to this man and have kids together and as you say he is great in lots of other ways, so you need to find a way to make his money management automatic and overseen by you, whilst still giving him his own card and also helping him develop good habits - not by having free range to do what he likes, but by living with good habits as you have a structure in place that’s basically automatic.

We have so many great financial tools and apps etc these days so it’s easy to set this stuff up in an hour or so.

As an aside, I don’t do any Christmas shopping in September! As long as you have the funds, late November seems like an ok time to start Xmas shopping. I will finish mine off next week.

InattentiveADHD · 07/12/2023 03:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What an ableist comment. ADHD is not an excuse, it's a reason. And I would hope that in any marriage, spouses would be looking to support each other rather than it being every man for themselves. Not much of a marriage imo. Which is why I suggested playing to their strengths, rather than saying that the OP needed to do everything which is what you seem to have read.

And unfortunately ADHD can't be managed away just by trying harder. Strategies weren't a cure. I have loads of strategies in place. But they go wrong all the time. I missed going to an event I was really looking for were to only the other day because I put the event along with the many reminders I have to set myself before any appointment or event, in the calendar on the wrong fucking day. Thankfully my DH is a bit more understanding than you. I beat myself up enough for my failings. I don't need other people adding to it. People with ADHD commonly have co-morbid depression and anxiety. This is because of trying to manage everything they need to manage when their brain is working against them. It's also because people like you tell them how useless and stupid and lazy they are their entire lives. People with ADHD spend their lives beating themselves up because they can't manage "normal" life, because they don't fit in. They don't make excuses, diagnosis gives them an explanation for why they find everything that others just seem to do with minimal effort do difficult.

So please do fuck off with your "ADHD excuses". Im sure I'm way more fed up of the ignorance of people like you.

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 07/12/2023 02:49

Agree @LaurieStrode if its as bad as those having a go at op say and it's on her to 'manage' and be the big responsible one, his entire salary needs to go to an account he doesn't get access to, and he gets personal spends to another, and its on him to buy gifts etc out.of that.

LaurieStrode · 07/12/2023 02:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Namechange4234 · 07/12/2023 02:11

Christingle94 · 06/12/2023 22:44

Reading these replies and they're making me think I've been taken for a fool 😔

Yup. You have. He's played you like a fiddle. Smart guy.

Codlingmoths · 07/12/2023 02:09

Take 600 this month. And if he hasn’t enough for his kids then you can offer to return his Christmas present and give him that.
has he improved AT ALL with only giving you $300 and coming up with the rest if it himself? He needs two bank accounts. One he gets paid into and transfers from it to you and from it transfers weekly into the other. The other is the one he gets money from.

PaminaMozart · 07/12/2023 02:01

He needs to pay half of all the bills, including rent, utilities, food, insurances, holidays, repairs and maintenance, and all irregular or yearly expenses - everything.

Since he is clearly incapable of managing money and you are determined to stay with him, he needs to transfer you this money each month. Include an allowance for birthdays and Christmas which you'll then give him as and when.

Yes, it's a bit like treating him like a child, but it's better than being taken advantage of as you are now.

And obviously return the X-box, so you won't be completely skint this Christmas.

tortoiseshellcats · 07/12/2023 01:43

I think it is probably related to his ADHD - seems very typical. Leaving things to the last minute is common - it probably doesn't feel "real" until December. It's great that you can be organised enough to buy presents in advance, but I don't know anyone with ADHD (male or female) who can plan this sort of thing months ahead. There are services like Klarna and I think PayPal? that can spread the cost over a few months, and then he can take those installments straight out of his salary at the same time as household costs.

The best way I have found to "ration" money was to have two separate accounts, my salary went into one and then I transferred a set amount each month/week to the other by standing order. I only used my card for the second account so I couldn't overspend on everyday things. Could you sit down together and plan something like this for next year? So that there is always money kept back that isn't as easy for him to access. Or transfer a set amount each month into a savings account that gets left until December? I think you need some kind of system to stop this happening again and he will likely need help to set it up but then it would be automated so he wouldn't need to think about it as much.

I absolutely agree that he needs to be contributing a lot more towards the household though, it sounds like the amount that gets transferred over needs to be hugely increased.

Anotherrname · 07/12/2023 01:23

@Christingle94 The bills will be paid (rent and council tax) and I've already paid for the Internet but within a week everything else will fall to me. The food shops, gas top ups, anything I want to do with the kids, the kids hobby clubs are due for term renewal so there's those to pay, more school uniform is needed due to growth spurts, more shoes for DS as he goes through them like nobodies business. Daily expenses. The £300 doesn't go very far at all.

He needs to pay half for everything - rent, council tax, gas top ups, Internet etc. Also calculate how much a typical weekly food shop is as well as the school uniforms and kids clubs and get him to transfer you half (on the day he is paid). £300 is a piss take. He'd pay more if he lived alone and had to pay you child maintenance.

He's taking advantage of you OP.

Nonplusultra · 07/12/2023 01:18

why not ask for £600 up front for this month?

You both know he’s going to struggle to juggle his budget. He’s trying to manage to be responsible which is good, but December is going to push him beyond his capacity to cope.

It’s a very reasonable adjustment to make. Come January, when the pressure is off, you can go back to the £300 arrangement again.

I’d also consider returning the x-box, buying something half that price for him and something lovely for yourself with the other half, if you think you’re going to be disappointed on Christmas Day. It’s not perfect but it’s better than being resentful about something that isn’t fixable right now.

telestrations · 07/12/2023 01:16

I have friends (thankfully not a partner) with ADHD and they are terrible with money and all the self loathing that follows. Also now you've had kids with him you've made your bed and need to figure out how to lie in it more comfortably

You have to take charge of his finances totally. Seperate accounts but you have the cards and pins, not him.

From this you ensure he pays his half of ALL household and child expenses, whatever he gives for his older DC, and put aside what's needed for birthdays, Christmas, new school clothes and so on. And the remainder he gets as pocket money to a separate account.

Either that or just work and pay for everything inc. whatever debt he gets himself into.

InattentiveADHD · 07/12/2023 01:12

"We find it far easier that all money paid into one account to pay for everything with x amount paying into personal accounts not related to family responsibilities or bills."

Yes this makes much more sense. You then know he is paying his way and that there is enough money for the essentials. Then whatever he does with his personal spends is up to him, you don't need to worry about it (as long as debt is not an issue?).

And on the managing money issue bring all on you. I get that it's a responsibility but in a couple you need to play to your strengths. I have ADHD and my DH is NT but I manage all the money. This is because I am better at it. I have inattentive type so am not really impulsive so don't have those issues with money and I really love a spreadsheet (interest), plus my mum passed on huge anxiety about money so that stress helps with focus (probably not get healthy but it works!).

He on the other hand is patient and loves routine, whereas I can't do routine at all and get bored extremely quickly. So he does boring (in my mind) routine jobs that I can't keep up with consistently. He's good at this and doesn't mind as he doesn't find them boring.

You need to play to your strengths. If he is terrible at finances, you do that. Poorly managed finances causes so many issues and a lot of stress and arguments. It's not worth it. He can do other jobs that he is either better at, as good at, or which have fewer negative consequences if he fucks them up.

Domino20 · 07/12/2023 01:11

Christingle94 · 06/12/2023 22:23

Because a few months ago we agreed he would reduce the amount he sends me directly and instead learns to budget his money better.

So for example - he has more in his own account (to cover expenses, shopping etc) but has to be sensible with it.

The reason I'm worried about this month is because I know he's going to want to buy loads of presents all in one go, so he'll be skint in no time.

I have voiced all of this to him this evening and he said he will send me more this month, so we will see.

Get him to buy the presents online and pay using Klarna then he can spread the cost over 3 months, it comes out of his own bank account plus he won't be completely broke for the rest of December.

SunRainStorm · 07/12/2023 01:05

I'd work out what half the joint bills and costs are and get in the joint account prior to him starting his shopping. Hes absolutely taking the piss with this £300 set up.

He can look at what he has left over, and then divide it up into a budget for Christmas expenses.

If he can't afford to get video games for DSC then they don't get them. That's life- lots of children are happy with far less.

He can put everything an Amazon basket - and then check out all at once- so he can see the total spend for all his Christmas shopping. Buying one gift at a time will make it harder to keep track and to not get carried away.

I have a lot of sympathy for people with ADHD. The people I know with ADHD work hard to manage it and have a million strategies to help them cope without burdening others. but time and time again I read on here about men whose only coping strategy is to rely on a woman to cover for them and pick up their slack. It's not on.

InattentiveADHD · 07/12/2023 01:00

I love all the posters who are trying to say this is not his ADHD. This is very typical ADHD!

This jumped out at me OP:

"He just doesn't consider these things and thinks because he gets paid in December he'll be able to catch up then and it'll all be fine. He doesn't look past the first week of being paid."

This again is very typical. People with ADHD find it extremely difficult to look forward. And consider consequences and problems in the future. It's part of the executive dysfunction and why they recommend immediate consequences for children with ADHD. A consequence 4 weeks away for example doesn't register.

People with ADHD also struggle to get their brains to work without novelty, interest or a deadline. The deadline has to be pretty immediate.

All of this means he will struggle to get going and plan adequately for Christmas. Fighting him on this is probably pointless.

I would suggest you either take over, or just let him get on with the way he does it. You say he's given you the money he has to give you (which seems a bit low tbh but that's a separate issue). If he runs out of his personal money then that's up to him to deal with.

If you want to understand ADHD a bit better then I would highly recommend taking the time (it's a long one!) watching this video. It's by one of the world's leading experts on ADHD Russel Barkley and he explains many of the issues that are relevant to the difficulties your DH is having with Christmas planning.

There's also a video or article somewhere about a woman with ADHD who couldn't get Christmas together at all to the point she would be driving her kids around Christmas Day trying to get food for dinner! ADHD is not a made up thing and it's certainly not "weaponised incompetence". Its makes it difficult or impossible to get yourself together! And everything that comes with that. Challenging and frustrating for both the person and their spouses!

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 06/12/2023 23:44

Increase his contribution so he pays what he needs to for the whole month. Have it out into a different bank account and out your money in there too.

If you run out of money from that account before the end of the month then you both need to increase the contribution the following month.

If he wants to do the food shopping he can do it from that account then. If he spends too much money on the food shop then you run out and have to eat cheap food for the rest of the month, and you need to make it clear that is because he didn't spend the food money wisely.

He doesn't feel the consequences of his actions at the moment because you keep bailing him out. You need to stop!