Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP and Christmas, AIBU?

215 replies

Christingle94 · 06/12/2023 21:43

We've been together 6.5 years and have children, he also has DC from a previous relationship. We have split finances for numerous reasons, largely due to me being alot "better" with money than he is. He struggles with his ADHD and money management. He does have redeeming qualities, before anybody asks.

I deal with all of the bills, he just transfers me his portion of the money when he gets paid.

He has form for dithering when Christmas is coming up and doesn't start buying until it's too late, IE in December and all out of one pay check.

I've been buying since September and have all of my buying done. He on the other hand has bought one small thing for DC and nothing that is on any of their lists. He hasn't bought anything for me yet, his DM etc.

The whole reason I start buying in September is because I know he does this and if I didn't sort Christmas myself, it would be pretty shit for the kids and me when he spends all of his money at the last minute rushing to get things or they don't end up with things they really want.

I've spent alot of money including on him. He wanted the new xbox which I've got him, he doesn't know yet.

The kids (ours) have got plenty of really nice stuff (some second hand but fab condition) and will be really happy come Christmas day.

I no longer buy for DSC and leave that all to him after years of hurtful reactions to gifts, they don't want or need this, that's crap etc. MN suggested I stop troubling myself with it so that is what I did but I've been telling him since September to make a start on their Xmas presents..

So to my point.

Come his pay day which is next Friday he's going to go out and spend more than we can afford in one month, trying to play catch up. That will have repercussions for me as I'll then be carrying him through the rest of the month. His DC are going to moan if they don't get everything they wanted which includes multiple brand new games which cost 50-60 pounds each.

So on top of everything I've spent already which completely absolved him of any requirement to contribute to our DC Christmas, he is now going to cost me even more money when he powers through his last wage of the year and runs out within the week because he has to buy loads for his older DC and will want to buy me some nice things too.

His heart is in the right place and he has already said he feels like a failure because I've 'finished' Christmas buying already and have got everything they need, but good intentions won't cushion the blow when I've got to worry about his financial contribution to the household this month.

Do you think I'm being unreasonable?

OP posts:
Christingle94 · 07/12/2023 10:38

monsteramunch · 07/12/2023 09:58

Where I buy second hand for my own DC, DSC would never want something second hand and their dad would never buy second hand for fear of his ex giving him grief about it.

My children have been raised to be appreciative of whatever they get, whether it's a shiny new toy or a second hand jigsaw from grandma with bits missing. They love charity shops and trawling vinted with me.

All this for you and the kids but in a cost of living crisis where you don't have loads of money to throw around, your DH gets a brand new xbox?

That money was from my savings and is a one off expense that will last 10+ years and will also benefit all of the children who will be able to use it too. It had nothing to do with the monthly budget.

OP posts:
OneLollipop · 07/12/2023 10:18

So on top of everything I've spent already which completely absolved him of any requirement to contribute to our DC Christmas, he is now going to cost me even more money when he powers through his last wage of the year and runs out within the week because he has to buy loads for his older DC and will want to buy me some nice things too.

Or you could tell him how much he owes you for his share of your joint DC's gifts. Don't be a doormat, OP, people will wipe their muddy feet all over you if you let them.

His heart is in the right place and he has already said he feels like a failure because I've 'finished' Christmas buying already and have got everything they need, but good intentions won't cushion the blow when I've got to worry about his financial contribution to the household this month.

One joint account into which you each have a transfer set up for the day after payday. To cover rent, bills, groceries, petrol, regular weekly and monthly expenses etc. Why on earth have you been putting groceries on your own personal card!?

One joint savings account into which you each have a transfer set up for the day after payday. To cover anything that's less regular like birthdays, holidays, Christmas, dentist, MOT etc.

One individual account each (that you each get paid into) with your "leftover" money for personal spending. Arguably this is where his maintenance payment should come from, I'm not sure you should be paying towards that. Yes it means he'll have less money than you, but you're paying more towards bills using your larger salary anyway.

AnneLovesGilbert · 07/12/2023 10:06

He should be paying more than half of the households costs as he has additional children who aren’t your responsibility. You’re bending over backwards to make allowances for his ADHD and treating him like a child. I also agree he doesn’t need a big showy gift as thanks for basic parenting while you were recovering.

It’s awful you’re buying everything for your shared kids while he’s only buying for his older kids.

monsteramunch · 07/12/2023 09:58

Where I buy second hand for my own DC, DSC would never want something second hand and their dad would never buy second hand for fear of his ex giving him grief about it.

My children have been raised to be appreciative of whatever they get, whether it's a shiny new toy or a second hand jigsaw from grandma with bits missing. They love charity shops and trawling vinted with me.

All this for you and the kids but in a cost of living crisis where you don't have loads of money to throw around, your DH gets a brand new xbox?

MrsElsa · 07/12/2023 09:57
  1. You are both spending too much on Xmas full stop.
  1. Get a joint acct, all wages and bills go in and come out of that.
  1. Monthly "personal spending money" is a standing order of e.g. £100 each into individual accounts.
  1. Monthly "joint savings money" likewise standing order into a joint savings acct.

You are treating him like a wayward child not an adult, pack it in

monsteramunch · 07/12/2023 09:53

Oh and in the mid 00s when I was 21 I paid £400 to my parents living at home on a £17k salary.

Because I was an adult working full time so was quite rightly expected to contribute to the household.

It's embarrassing for him that he's contributing less than that in 2023 as a parent and partner.

monsteramunch · 07/12/2023 09:50

He sounds like a selfish prick tbh OP.

If you don't return the x box then you're mad! That money is needed to make up the shortfall he has caused as regards your family's household finances.

Frankly it's money that could be going towards the children's wellbeing (whether household bills / uniform / Christmas etc) instead of a bizarre reward for him when he's been selfish and thoughtless.

Prioritise them, not him.

LadyBird1973 · 07/12/2023 09:32

The other thing you have to think about is how your joint children will feel in later years, knowing dad blows all his money on his older kids and makes no contribution to them.

Looking after you when sick, is a basic expectation when in a relationship - he doesn't need an Xbox as a thank you. He's not a child but everything you are doing is allowing him to behave like one. Nothing is going to kill attraction quicker than having to parent your partner!

I think you're going to have a shock when you make a list of true expenditure and realise just how much you've been subsidising him!

Christingle94 · 07/12/2023 09:28

RoachFish · 07/12/2023 09:13

You have made Christmas all about consumerism. You spend 4 months of the year buying and talking about buying Christmas presents and then you spend more money on them than you have. This is all so bonkers and I think you need to scale it down a few notches. The fact that the kids will complain if they don't get everything on their lists is very telling. You have taught them that they are entitled to absolutely everything they want and that's how they know they are loved and important.

I strongly disagree with this.

The reason I start buying in September is to spread the cost. Alot of what I buy is actually second hand, albeit great condition. They haven't got hundreds of presents.

The xbox, whilst a splurge, is a one off gift. I have never spent so much on a present for anybody. The money for that came from my savings it hasn't eaten into any budget or left me short of anything, at all. I'm very smart with my money which is why I never run out, unlike him.

The DSC being ungrateful is nothing to do with me whatsoever. They have been that way since they were young, they're in secondary now.

Where I buy second hand for my own DC, DSC would never want something second hand and their dad would never buy second hand for fear of his ex giving him grief about it.

My children have been raised to be appreciative of whatever they get, whether it's a shiny new toy or a second hand jigsaw from grandma with bits missing. They love charity shops and trawling vinted with me.

The fact my own DC are complete opposites shows me that it's not a me problem at all.

OP posts:
Batgin · 07/12/2023 09:21

Shinyandnew1 · 06/12/2023 21:48

Don’t carry him then. Return the expensive present you got him and use that to pay the bills in December

Edited

100% this!

RoachFish · 07/12/2023 09:13

You have made Christmas all about consumerism. You spend 4 months of the year buying and talking about buying Christmas presents and then you spend more money on them than you have. This is all so bonkers and I think you need to scale it down a few notches. The fact that the kids will complain if they don't get everything on their lists is very telling. You have taught them that they are entitled to absolutely everything they want and that's how they know they are loved and important.

Anotherrname · 07/12/2023 09:07

@Christingle94 you only earn £300 more than him. That's not a lot. He should be paying HALF for EVERYTHING household and child related. That means rent, utility bills, Internet, children's clothes, children's clubs etc. He's taking advantage of you and knows he's having an easy ride.

SunRainStorm · 07/12/2023 08:59

@Christingle94

If DSC are always underwhelmed then all the more reason not to stretch himself financially on their presents.

I'm also not sure why you're subsidising his child maintenance costs but that's another issue.

Christingle94 · 07/12/2023 08:37

I wasn't expecting so many replies, thank you all. There's a lot to think about and some great advice.

Executive dysfunction is definitely a problem with ADHD and his manifests as poor money management, time blindness, disorganisation etc.

I'm going to sit down with him this evening and make a list of all expenditures including a budget for presents and suggest he buys on amazon so he can see exactly how much the basket total is before he buys it.

I have between 300 and 400 more than him coming in per month hence my contribution being higher. He also has maintenance to pay so I take that into consideration.

Regarding opening another bank account, yes that's an option and a good idea.

Somebody said his older DC seem ungrateful. Yes they are. I was talking about this on the step parenting board some time ago. I've come to really dread the present exchange with them as they're always underwhelmed and make that very clear. It has ruined a few Christmases for me so I leave all gift buying for them to him now, so when they're predictably disappointed it's not my circus not my monkeys, so to speak.

OP posts:
Santaiswashinghissleigh · 07/12/2023 08:28

My dh has inattentive adhd.. Resentment will come op.
Ime. Being the only adult is draining..

RightOnTheEdge · 07/12/2023 08:07

OP I think you should write down all your expenses for the month including kids clubs and shoes/uniform. Then sit down together and make sure you are both paying a fair amount.

Is he not contributing anything towards your kids Christmas? Not planning, paying or even thinking about them just his kids from his first marriage? Because that's really awful if so.

I think you buying him an expensive Xbox for looking after you and the kids when you are ill is also mad. It's just a basic thing that partners and parents do! Would you have expected a big gift as a thank you if it had been the other way round, or would it just have been expected because you're a wife and mother?

The bar for men is so low its a tavern in Hades 🙄

Morechocmorechoc · 07/12/2023 07:31

Yabu for letting him get away with it!!! Stop carrying him.

cheddercherry · 07/12/2023 07:29

As gently as possible, you reduced his responsibility and gave him what you thought was a fair chance and he blew it. Take more off him this month to prevent all the things you listed you’ll be lumped with so that his irresponsibility doesn’t then mean your kids miss out.

I will say I’d struggle to have to take money this way, you’re not his mum and AHDH doesn’t exempt you from considering your kids (I have it, I get it, you have to find work arounds for things you KNOW are issues you can’t simple coast with excuses your whole life).

What exactly is he trying? Has he worked out his weekly budget? Most banking apps now have pots to separate your funds and make budgeting much easier. On the most basic level if he can’t even tell you what his outgoings should be and that he understands he’ll be short this month, then let’s be real, he hasn’t been actually trying to manage this at all. I think you’ve all the best intentions but sometimes people won’t change because they know they don’t need to.

StartupRepair · 07/12/2023 07:29

Why doesn't he pay 50% of living expenses? Why do you have to shoulder everything? Your problem is not Christmas, it is that he doesn't pay his way.

ElfontheShelfIsWATCHINGYOUTOO · 07/12/2023 07:16

Op we are married and each pay what we can afford into a specially set up different bank to our usual banks for Xmas.

I pay marginally less than dh. When we had no money this was a few pounds a month. Now it's a few hundred.
So why not ask him for x amount each month on top of what he already gives this January and put it into special seperate joint Xmas saving?

disappearingfish · 07/12/2023 07:06

He should give you his share of the total cost of bills and shopping etc. plus a tiny bit extra for annual expenses. Put some aside for emergency savings.

He's shown zero responsibility and you've ended up paying the price.

And yeah, return the Xbox.

SeatonCarew · 07/12/2023 06:50

In January set up a monthly savings account with a good interest rate for Christmas, to which you both contribute. You can give him his share at the end of November.

As others have said, he is extracting the urine with the amount of money he is giving you. Insist in 50% of all regular expenses, plus a small contingency, every month going forward. It's time for a change, and hopefully less stress for you.

Iloveacurry · 07/12/2023 06:42

If he’s only giving you £300 towards the bills, what has he got left?

I assume he works full time! It’s a very small amount he’s giving you.

Ivegotthepowerr · 07/12/2023 06:25

@Glowygoose lols I completely agree with you it is nuts that I wrap up a couple of gifts I've bought myself so I have a few things to open on Christmas day!! I've done it for years so I'm used to it now. I've just come to accept that while my husband is great at providing financially for our family he is rubbish at shopping for anything, he barely does any shopping at all and that includes for himself, and I have full financial control of the household. So I buy what I need and want throughout the year and on xmas day I have a couple of things to 'open'.

SapphOhNo · 07/12/2023 05:38

You're totally infantilising him and enabling his incompetence. Does it not give you the massive ick that you have to treat him like this and he's constantly letting you down?

Absolute manbaby.

Swipe left for the next trending thread