Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP and Christmas, AIBU?

215 replies

Christingle94 · 06/12/2023 21:43

We've been together 6.5 years and have children, he also has DC from a previous relationship. We have split finances for numerous reasons, largely due to me being alot "better" with money than he is. He struggles with his ADHD and money management. He does have redeeming qualities, before anybody asks.

I deal with all of the bills, he just transfers me his portion of the money when he gets paid.

He has form for dithering when Christmas is coming up and doesn't start buying until it's too late, IE in December and all out of one pay check.

I've been buying since September and have all of my buying done. He on the other hand has bought one small thing for DC and nothing that is on any of their lists. He hasn't bought anything for me yet, his DM etc.

The whole reason I start buying in September is because I know he does this and if I didn't sort Christmas myself, it would be pretty shit for the kids and me when he spends all of his money at the last minute rushing to get things or they don't end up with things they really want.

I've spent alot of money including on him. He wanted the new xbox which I've got him, he doesn't know yet.

The kids (ours) have got plenty of really nice stuff (some second hand but fab condition) and will be really happy come Christmas day.

I no longer buy for DSC and leave that all to him after years of hurtful reactions to gifts, they don't want or need this, that's crap etc. MN suggested I stop troubling myself with it so that is what I did but I've been telling him since September to make a start on their Xmas presents..

So to my point.

Come his pay day which is next Friday he's going to go out and spend more than we can afford in one month, trying to play catch up. That will have repercussions for me as I'll then be carrying him through the rest of the month. His DC are going to moan if they don't get everything they wanted which includes multiple brand new games which cost 50-60 pounds each.

So on top of everything I've spent already which completely absolved him of any requirement to contribute to our DC Christmas, he is now going to cost me even more money when he powers through his last wage of the year and runs out within the week because he has to buy loads for his older DC and will want to buy me some nice things too.

His heart is in the right place and he has already said he feels like a failure because I've 'finished' Christmas buying already and have got everything they need, but good intentions won't cushion the blow when I've got to worry about his financial contribution to the household this month.

Do you think I'm being unreasonable?

OP posts:
PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 08/12/2023 16:56

Haydenn · 06/12/2023 21:45

Can’t you get his contributions for the month early and hold a bit back for him?

i mean I’d hate to manage someone in this way but you seem to have reconciled yourself to it

This. Household contributions are transferred to our shared account immediately after we get paid / the end of every month.

That would be the best solution in OP´s situation (imo).

Edit: You could return (or re-sell) his Christmas gift if he doesn´t manage to cover his share, I suppose...

StartupRepair · 08/12/2023 16:54

He is not earning enough for his lifestyle. Why do you have to make up the shortfall?

C152 · 08/12/2023 14:24

OP, clearly this a bigger issue than just Christmas, but if you're going to continue to carry him, make life easier and set an amount at the start of the year for things like Christmas and ask him to give you an extra £20 per month which you transfer into a separate account that's just for Christmas. Then you won't have this particular issue next year.

WrongSwanson · 08/12/2023 13:35

SunRainStorm · 06/12/2023 21:59

Tell him he will still need to pay the day to day expenses and to cut his cloth accordingly.

If you're leaving pay check to pay check then why are you buying such expensive Christmas presents?

Why do people make Christmas so stressful for themselves?

Your DH doesn't need an Xbox more than your bills need paying. Your DSC don't need multiple video games. They just don't.

Agreed.

I know your DH needs to get control but also it sounds like you are hugely overspending, just in a "spread out" way

AgnesX · 08/12/2023 13:30

You know he's got ADHD and that he's hopeless at managing money. Why do you think this year is any different from any other.

Make sure you get money from him on payday so you're covered for January, and after that it's up to you whether you let him sink.....

LadyDanburysHat · 08/12/2023 13:19

Also, he seems to be completely absolved of buying your joint DC gifts. Again a budget should probably be decided in advance. If you are going to do the buying that is fine, but he should be making his contribution.

LadyDanburysHat · 08/12/2023 13:16

Luxell934 · 07/12/2023 10:47

So he pays £300 to you for his share of rent and council tax (how is this so cheap?!)

So gas, electric, water, insurance bills, Food shopping, and all child related costs are paid by you?

This was my question too. Even if you take out his CM, then do your income as a percentage, is he really earning so much less that it is all he should be paying?

Who pays all of the other bills, like those listed above?

PanettonePuff · 08/12/2023 13:14

@Frazzled83

😁
Perhaps it’s just passed me by then, I just thought it was a kids, tweens, teens, young adult thing🤷‍♀️ But then it didn’t exist when I was young, so that’s why I’m surprised that it’s an adult pastime.
If I presented DP with an Xbox, I doubt either of us would know which way up it went!😂

OhIlovetosew · 08/12/2023 13:11

He needs to give you an amount extra every month to allow him to not pay household bills in December, ie he gets December off but he’s given you a bit towards December in the previous 11 payments which you save ‘for him’.

if he won’t do that then I’d up his monthly amount secretly until you have it.

really OP it’s not on at all

Frazzled83 · 08/12/2023 13:09

PanettonePuff · 08/12/2023 13:07

I know I’m probably gonna get shot down in flames, but…

Do grown men, adults, Dads, actually play X box?

It would be a massive ick for me.

Believe it or not so do some grown women and moms - the controls thankfully aren’t operated by genitals 😂

Frazzled83 · 08/12/2023 13:08

You haven’t been taken for a fool - it’s just most people really don’t get how disabling adhd can be and how much shame people with it have. I’d sit down with him and problem solve it. I have to outsource most of my executive function otherwise I still get into bother. Plum account auto saving. Different pockets set up for different things that the money goes directly to. All of these things are possible because I have an understand and compassionate partner who helps me solve problems when I fuck up rather than making me feel like a naughty child. It goes a long way.

PanettonePuff · 08/12/2023 13:07

I know I’m probably gonna get shot down in flames, but…

Do grown men, adults, Dads, actually play X box?

It would be a massive ick for me.

theuntameableshrew · 08/12/2023 13:07

Buying him an xbox as a big gesture of gratitude because he did what any decent person would do when you needed support around the time of an operation is not warranted in my opinion, particularly given the financial circumstances you have described.

I’d return it and stop facilitating him not taking responsibility by bailing him out.

It all sounds horribly stressful and I feel for you. Out of sheer exhaustion and necessity, I have had to limit how much I sacrifice to compensate for these sorts of issues in my family (ADHD/ASD). Natural consequences now here if I’ve done all I reasonably can to ensure I’ve supported my family’s struggles the best way I know how, without shouldering all the responsibility for everything.

I hope you get to feel cherished and appreciated at Christmas OP 💐

Rjahdhdvd · 08/12/2023 13:03

I think me and you have the same life. I get DH to give me money every month to save towards Christmas and I match it so that he’s contributing equally and then I organise buying the gifts. I’ve tried leaving it to him but what you described happens and I’ve accepted things the way they are.

Hickry · 08/12/2023 12:59

ADHD is a reason to struggle but it's not an excuse. I have ADHD.

Difference is I don't have a safety net person like your dh does. You need to stop bailing him out.

Also you've spent a LOT there on a grown adult! 😱 Is that usual? Does he spend the same on you? Can you afford that?

I like you sometimes buy toys second hand for my kids. That aspect of your life seems at odds with buying your manbaby a fancy new console?!

Do NOT let him off with bills money. Do not bail him out.

Suggest he sets up a standing order into a savings account starting with his January pay slip, paying a set amount each month into it to pay for his Xmas spending.

Stop spoiling him like he's an incompetent child.

Ladyluck22 · 08/12/2023 12:51

Could you not take a bit extra off him each month then give it to him in December or save to help you towards the bills when he spends to much?

Jack1987 · 08/12/2023 12:40

As a person with ADHD, I feel for you BOTH so much! I’m going to go ahead and assume you’re neurotypical in my response. Many people with ADHD get “time-blind” and they can’t math the pay days in response to the event if that makes sense? I’m an accountant and I’m fab with money NOW but I never used to be! Nothing much can be done for this year but whilst your partner is in this mode of feeling like a failure because yet again he did the ADHD thing and couldn’t plan… set up a savings account with a standing order from his bank account for £50 or more if you can afford it, each month starting January so next year when Xmas comes for the most part it’s taken care of! Please don’t punish him, trust me he is already feeling crap because he’s not been able to do the thing we’re expected to be able to do. I’ve been saying to my husband for years “please don’t punish me for not being able to do the same things you can - our brains don’t work the same and I am already trying my best!”

Bottom line - please bail him out this time as long as he promises to commit to the standing order so next year you are not in the same situation. I refer to it as being my future best friend! Xx

LadyBird1973 · 07/12/2023 22:29

And it won't improve when they get older - they'll be just as ungrateful and demanding but on a larger scale. Are you going to let your own kids have less indefinitely, while he continues to buy his everything they demand ? And use your money (because make no mistake, he can only do it because you are paying his bills) to subsidise it?

amiold · 07/12/2023 21:19

So you pay more of the bills than him. You take his maintenance into consideration.. why? They're his kids to pay for and in essence you're paying for them because he doesn't contribute to his bills to pay the maintenance. Also, he leaves all present buying to you for the kids he has with you and buys presents for his other kids only. Money he can't afford.. but in reality you're paying because you allow him not to contribute to your kids presents but I bet they're from "mum and dad".

You're subsidising kids that aren't yours and you and your own kids lose out. He's taking the piss out of you.

ManateeFair · 07/12/2023 17:07

His DC are going to moan if they don't get everything they wanted which includes multiple brand new games which cost 50-60 pounds each

Let them moan, then. It's not your problem. If he can't afford to buy everything they want, he can't afford it. You need to make it clear to him that you aren't covering it.

If you keep covering for him, he's never going to learn from his mistakes.

StripeyDeckchair · 07/12/2023 16:24

Return the PlayStation you bought for him & use the money for your DCs Christmas

Hes watched you prepare for Christmas for 3 months & chosen to do nothing so this is the consequence of his choice

SequentialAnalyst · 07/12/2023 15:02

Again I say: Work out what your expenses are. Forecast next year's based on that. Without this data, any strategy is surely bound to fail.

Then work out a joint strategy, together. Think it through. Talk through what next year will be like, month by month.

Make a plan as to how to manage the flow of money into and out of the household, and you as individuals. As PP have said, share your strengths with each other - and remember, you are both after the same goal.

Keep trying methods for coping with his ADHD behaviour, and utilising any ADHD advantages, again as PP have said.

PaminaMozart · 07/12/2023 11:19

All the money you are spending on him and his ungrateful children is money that ought to benefit your children. It's incredible that you can't see this. You ought to be a team, but instead you seem to be carrying and funding them, while he bumbles along in his own world. Neurodiversity is no excuse for selfishness.

LaurieStrode · 07/12/2023 10:59

MrsElsa · 07/12/2023 09:57

  1. You are both spending too much on Xmas full stop.
  1. Get a joint acct, all wages and bills go in and come out of that.
  1. Monthly "personal spending money" is a standing order of e.g. £100 each into individual accounts.
  1. Monthly "joint savings money" likewise standing order into a joint savings acct.

You are treating him like a wayward child not an adult, pack it in

Agree with @MrsElsa

I'd return the xbox.

Luxell934 · 07/12/2023 10:47

So he pays £300 to you for his share of rent and council tax (how is this so cheap?!)

So gas, electric, water, insurance bills, Food shopping, and all child related costs are paid by you?