Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP and Christmas, AIBU?

215 replies

Christingle94 · 06/12/2023 21:43

We've been together 6.5 years and have children, he also has DC from a previous relationship. We have split finances for numerous reasons, largely due to me being alot "better" with money than he is. He struggles with his ADHD and money management. He does have redeeming qualities, before anybody asks.

I deal with all of the bills, he just transfers me his portion of the money when he gets paid.

He has form for dithering when Christmas is coming up and doesn't start buying until it's too late, IE in December and all out of one pay check.

I've been buying since September and have all of my buying done. He on the other hand has bought one small thing for DC and nothing that is on any of their lists. He hasn't bought anything for me yet, his DM etc.

The whole reason I start buying in September is because I know he does this and if I didn't sort Christmas myself, it would be pretty shit for the kids and me when he spends all of his money at the last minute rushing to get things or they don't end up with things they really want.

I've spent alot of money including on him. He wanted the new xbox which I've got him, he doesn't know yet.

The kids (ours) have got plenty of really nice stuff (some second hand but fab condition) and will be really happy come Christmas day.

I no longer buy for DSC and leave that all to him after years of hurtful reactions to gifts, they don't want or need this, that's crap etc. MN suggested I stop troubling myself with it so that is what I did but I've been telling him since September to make a start on their Xmas presents..

So to my point.

Come his pay day which is next Friday he's going to go out and spend more than we can afford in one month, trying to play catch up. That will have repercussions for me as I'll then be carrying him through the rest of the month. His DC are going to moan if they don't get everything they wanted which includes multiple brand new games which cost 50-60 pounds each.

So on top of everything I've spent already which completely absolved him of any requirement to contribute to our DC Christmas, he is now going to cost me even more money when he powers through his last wage of the year and runs out within the week because he has to buy loads for his older DC and will want to buy me some nice things too.

His heart is in the right place and he has already said he feels like a failure because I've 'finished' Christmas buying already and have got everything they need, but good intentions won't cushion the blow when I've got to worry about his financial contribution to the household this month.

Do you think I'm being unreasonable?

OP posts:
Milkand2sugarsplease · 08/12/2023 23:40

You'd be better off havjng a bills account that you both pay your respective share of the bills money into (however you calculate it based on your earnings) and the you both have the rest of your wages for everything else and when he runs out he runs out. That way, you're not micro managing because you're both putting your bills money aside on payday, he's left with some money to "learn to manage" for the month and you have your leftover cash to spend or save as you see fit.
At the minute you're treating him like a child getting him to transfer money to you, reducing the amount to see if he can manage - it all has undertones of babying him.

And he's taking you for a ride with it - you've funded Xmas for him and now you're going to fund December for him while he spends over the odds playing catch up

Takenoprisoner · 08/12/2023 23:22

Luxell934 · 07/12/2023 10:47

So he pays £300 to you for his share of rent and council tax (how is this so cheap?!)

So gas, electric, water, insurance bills, Food shopping, and all child related costs are paid by you?

Makes absolutely no sense. you're robbing from your shared dc and buying second hand gifts, whilst he and his dc get lavish gifts with expenses spared. There is nothing wrong with second hand, but your dc will grow up feeling like second class citizens in their own home.

Therealjudgejudy · 08/12/2023 23:12

Weaponised incompetence 100%. He is taking the piss out of you and your shared children.

OhYeahOhYeah · 08/12/2023 21:46

Luxell934 · 07/12/2023 10:47

So he pays £300 to you for his share of rent and council tax (how is this so cheap?!)

So gas, electric, water, insurance bills, Food shopping, and all child related costs are paid by you?

Wondering the same as our household bills including our mortgage come to about £3000 each month!

GrumpyPanda · 08/12/2023 19:38

I have between 300 and 400 more than him coming in per month hence my contribution being higher. He also has maintenance to pay so I take that into consideration.

So effectively you're subsidizing the step kids out of your income. No good OP. His share of expenses should be calculated out of his income before maintenance is taken out.

adorablecat · 08/12/2023 19:09

If your partner is expecting you to take on the entire financial management for your household, insist on doing it on your terms: all monies to be paid into an account which you control, you pay the outgoings and set aside monies for annual expenses including a Christmas fund, you transfer personal spending money into a separate account for your partner. You should not have to do this, but if he can't be an adult around money, somebody has to.

Gettingbysomehow · 08/12/2023 18:53

This is one of the reasons I've been divorced three times. I literally cannot stand this bullshit time and time again.

AmazingSnakeHead · 08/12/2023 18:50

MrsTerryPratchett · 06/12/2023 21:50

What is he buying the rest of the tear instead of saving up? I have ADHD, I buy in December, I probably spend too much. But I have the money because I make sure I do. The rest of the year.

Was going to say this exact thing! I have ADHD too and have so far bought one single thing for DC, and nothing for anyone else. I probably pay more for Christmas than someone who has it together enough to buy tech on black friday, for example, but I can afford it because I save throughout the year. OP, your DP is taking the piss.

5128gap · 08/12/2023 18:40

If his condition means he can't manage money, then he's not going to suddenly become capable because its Christmas. If you're happy to accept financial responsibility because he can't, then you could extend this to cover Christmas. So work out what it will cost to bail him out this year plus an amount for his share of next year then add it to his monthly payments.

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 08/12/2023 18:39

What would your partner do if he didn't have your income to fall back on? Tell him to do that.

bonzaitree · 08/12/2023 18:32

I put aside £50 each month and then have £600 towards Xmas every year. Completely automated- ADHD-proof. What’s to stop your partner doing that?

Snowdogsmitten · 08/12/2023 18:22

Shocked he pays £300 towards living expenses. He’s like a kept child. I paid more than that when I moved home. 😬

JLB198 · 08/12/2023 18:14

You're in a committed long term relationship, have you considered a different way to manage finances? My partner and I have had a joint account since we moved in together and our wages go in to that for all household expenses, joint purchases etc. We then have a direct debit for the same amount each to our personal accounts for spending on ourselves. This way he would be contributing to your children's gifts as they would be bought from the joint account.

lesdeluges · 08/12/2023 18:11

I think I'd sit down and show him exactly the monthly costs of running your household. Work out a FAIR division. I presume he is paying maintenance for his kids? Factor that in although it should not impact on your lifestyle either. His responsibility and he has kids with you also.

As for Christmas and his apparent lack of organisation and money management, would you consider adding up the entire years projected expenditure BY HIM on his family and yours for birthdays and Christmas, divide the approximate figure by 12 and get him to transfer that to you to manage. Maybe you could open a Revolut account just for this type of expenditure. Then the funds are spread and you will (hopefully) not have to sub him to the extent you are now. It is causing you anxiety, so come up with a plan to overcome it.

Phoenixfire1988 · 08/12/2023 18:09

Jack1987 · 08/12/2023 12:40

As a person with ADHD, I feel for you BOTH so much! I’m going to go ahead and assume you’re neurotypical in my response. Many people with ADHD get “time-blind” and they can’t math the pay days in response to the event if that makes sense? I’m an accountant and I’m fab with money NOW but I never used to be! Nothing much can be done for this year but whilst your partner is in this mode of feeling like a failure because yet again he did the ADHD thing and couldn’t plan… set up a savings account with a standing order from his bank account for £50 or more if you can afford it, each month starting January so next year when Xmas comes for the most part it’s taken care of! Please don’t punish him, trust me he is already feeling crap because he’s not been able to do the thing we’re expected to be able to do. I’ve been saying to my husband for years “please don’t punish me for not being able to do the same things you can - our brains don’t work the same and I am already trying my best!”

Bottom line - please bail him out this time as long as he promises to commit to the standing order so next year you are not in the same situation. I refer to it as being my future best friend! Xx

She's been bailing him out for YEARS!! He contributes £300 a month to the house and absolutely nothing for their shared dc at Christmas and she has to cover 90% of the bills alone he's taking the absolute piss out of her no other way of looking at it and him having adhd is a cop out for him being a shitty husband and father

Victoria3010 · 08/12/2023 18:02

Would it work having some joint savings that go towards Christmas spending, treats or holidays - if it was joint, he could have a card but you'd also have an eye on it and that way it wouldn't be "he spends too much on the SC" it would be both of you in November looking at what was in the joint savings and agreeing budgets and who was responsible for buying for who. You could both agree a sensible amount to pay in every month....
We do a joint account for all bills and food, petrol, kids clothes. Then we have joint savings for holidays and Christmas, or big expenses like boilers or a car. Then we have small individual accounts for personal spend. That way we both manage all the bills, all the presents etc, and nobody has to be in charge (and neither of us can fritter it away without the other noticing!)

MsRosley · 08/12/2023 18:01

Aquamarine1029 · 06/12/2023 21:52

ABSOLUTELY THIS.

1000% this.

Phoenixfire1988 · 08/12/2023 17:53

Christingle94 · 06/12/2023 22:11

I hadn't planned to get him an xbox initially.

I asked him what he wanted for Christmas and that was the only thing he came back with, followed with "..but I know its too expensive"

I paid for it out of my savings as I wanted to do something nice for him. I had a big op in October and he was so good to me in the lead up and afterwards, he had 2 weeks off work and did everything for me and DC so I didn't need to lift a finger. I wanted to show my gratitude for that and knew the xbox would make him happy.

I'm very good with money in general and don't make a habit of expensive splurges on consoles or whatever else.

Dear me do you hear yourself ???? You had an operation he wasn't being good to you he was doing what a bloody husband and father should be doing for Christ's sakes

MolkosTeenageAngst · 08/12/2023 17:50

I’d return the X Box and exchange it for something much cheaper, using the money you get back to make up for the fact he’s not contributing his fair share.

Dmsatdawn · 08/12/2023 17:45

@WhereIsBebèsChambre “weaponised incompetence”. This has to be the most succinct and meaningful phrase I have ever heard. And I cannot wait to use it at every opportunity.

Nicparke · 08/12/2023 17:41

I find some of these comments rather harsh. I have ADHD too - not a severe case. But I feel I can relate with him. Organisation, structure and planning, I struggle with a lot. I always plan to start early, October time. But then time just goes and in my head I'm organised, but technically I'm not. I find Christmas incredibly overwhelming. Maybe next year you could suggest to shop together for the children, in September when you start. Make a day date of it. I find it so much less overwhelming if I go with my husband.

Then when November / December hits, he would only have you to buy for.

Baffledandalarmed · 08/12/2023 17:39

I had a big op in October and he was so good to me in the lead up and afterwards, he had 2 weeks off work and did everything for me and DC so I didn't need to lift a finger. I wanted to show my gratitude for that and knew the xbox would make him happy.

He should do that because he’s your husband. It should be expected not rewarded ffs.

Take the gifts back and make him get a grip.

Neiiighbour234 · 08/12/2023 17:37

Christingle94 · 06/12/2023 22:23

Because a few months ago we agreed he would reduce the amount he sends me directly and instead learns to budget his money better.

So for example - he has more in his own account (to cover expenses, shopping etc) but has to be sensible with it.

The reason I'm worried about this month is because I know he's going to want to buy loads of presents all in one go, so he'll be skint in no time.

I have voiced all of this to him this evening and he said he will send me more this month, so we will see.

I have ADHD and I think him "learning to budget his money better" is just not going to happen - completely. If he is impulsive and disorganised generally as well with money, that isn't going to change. You may have to accept that there are certain things that he will never manage and other things he can.

It's not that he's being irresponsible, I bet he had great intentions and then time slipped by and he forgot until the deadline crops up and then it's all last minute. He would love not to be like this I bet, but it's the way his brain works. If it isn't urgent or very interesting to him he will find it hugely difficult to focus on it - especially if it is a difficult task with emotional baggage attached, as this seems to be. It's very hard to understand if you are NT, but literally it's almost impossible.

I see the "weaponised incompetence" accusations and I would agree - if he were neurotypical, but the fact is he is neurodivergent, not lazy. He is clearly trying to be better at it, but his brain just won't let him. And even if he managed it, it would take so much effort and energy, something else would probably fall by the wayside.

I suggest he play to his strengths (whatever they are - I bet he has some though) and you play to yours. I know you don't want to do all the budgeting and financials, but frankly if he has no interest in it, he will find it extremely hard to do it effectively which I would suggest means even more stress for you down the line than if you had just done it yourself. Try to think about what tasks he is good at/interested in that you can offload onto him that will give you the time to do the stuff he can't.

Phoenixfire1988 · 08/12/2023 17:25

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 06/12/2023 21:48

His heart is in the right place and he has already said he feels like a failure because I've 'finished' Christmas buying already and have got everything they need, but good intentions won't cushion the blow when I've got to worry about his financial contribution to the household this month.
Weaponised incompetence!

Exactly this !!! Christmas is the same date every year its not a surprise I'm glad he feels shit , he should ! Why should tleveryone else suffer because he's bloody useless I'd be telling him to still pay his portion of bills and get his kids less and he can explain to them why they didn't get what they asked for .
Why would he shop earlier when he has a wife that will cover bills and see him through the month no skin off his nose he has no money is it

Isthisit22 · 08/12/2023 16:59

I voted YABU because you’re being a martyr. I can understand you begrudgingly buying all the presents for DC as they shouldn’t suffer for his incompetence but buying him an expensive games console then complaining about how short of money you’re going to get is just total martyrdom

Swipe left for the next trending thread