Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help regarding family Christmas things .. need thoughts!

265 replies

Notoldeeally · 06/12/2023 19:27

So we have an issue about christmas!
last year we had a stressful time as we did not know when our adult dd s were leaving .. ( with partners) .. they ended up staying 10 days.

Now , i know they are our kids but its not the same when they bring partners .

We live in a modest 3 bed .

We are in our 60 s .. retired professionals with limited income . No state pension yet.

There are two issues

  1. lenght of stay .Dd is always reluctant to make firm plans . She likes to think this is still her home and as such can stay as long as she wants. At christmas last year she would not say how long she wanted to stay , just saying oh I might want the new year here too . we found 10 days just too long , especially as partner with her.How to limit the lenght of stay. I was thinking 6 nights not ten this year,but this would mean them not being here for new year.. and they always want to be here for that too. They live a 4 hour drive away.. so want to stay for duration . We live in a seaside town and alternative accommodation like a house nearby would be great but its v v expensive.
  2. activities ! When we are just watching tv or reading she says .. so what are we doing next .. i tell her oh we dont have to do anything, lets just chill .. but she seems to need structure .. so can we olay a game tonight , can we all watch a film.. ten nights of organised nights( as well as an organised thing like a walk for us all) exhausted us and we domt want to do it again. We repeatedly said games some nights but chill others , but she seems to have a fixation that we all need to be doing together!! Most if the time. She gets angry if we suggest otherwise.she seems to think us having a bit of soace is an insult to her , when it isnt .. she says things like well we should make the most of our time.how to tell her in a way she can hear???? Last Christmas was so exhausting and ended up with dh really really tense. we want to change it this year by being proactive and gently firm .. but we know dd will most likely be upset at this and also that there is a time limit as she thinks the oarental home is always open …and i get why she thinks that but we cant be that exhausted again. Any tips on how to say things much appreciated( I just know if we time limit she will say .. but if we only stay … so long.. what about new year.. i want to be here at new year too) I know we dont sound assertive but we dont want upset dd .. with our ds he takes time out goes for walks .. allows a bit of breathing soace.. with dd not so and its just how she is and has been since she was small .
OP posts:
Greenpolkadot · 07/12/2023 19:00

Youv received some good suggestions op.
Now it's time to formulate a plan.Dont be pinned down to buying all the drinks in the pub. Dds boyfriend sounds a right scrounging arsehole and bad mannered .
You could either say that he can come for s couple of days...as a couple they can stay until the 27th,,,
Make up an excuse to be going somewhere, and for goodness sake dont let your daughter bully you into constant activity

Sheepskinthrow · 07/12/2023 18:33

tralalass · 07/12/2023 07:28

I've read the full thread now and tbh it doesn't sound like you particularly like your daughter. How sad.

Don't ask her what day she's leaving - TELL her she can only stay until the 28th or whatever day suits. If she pushes back, be honest - tell her exactly how you feel - tell her, her BF takes liberties and that she needs to help out more.

This is the whole problem with not speaking up when things start to grate - you're now in a position where it's going to cause a massive kick-off, because you haven't managed the small things.

I think it’s a bit unfair to make the op feel bad for not liking her daughter, when frankly her daughter appears to be a bit of a bully!

It’s not sad to dislike a bully! It’s completely appropriate imho!

Sorry but some adult children do grow up to be bullies! It’s not always parents who are in the wrong! (Although to read Mumsnet, you’d think that most mothers were nearly always in the wrong!)

I know a 32 year old woman who demeans and bullies her 70 something mother horribly! I don’t think she realises she is doing it! And her mother is too nice to say anything as they only visit on high days and holidays.

Cone on, who gets cross with their mother when Christmas lunch is late? The appropriate response would be to pitch in if you weren’t doing so already. It’s cheeky, entitled and rude to complain.

Olika · 07/12/2023 17:15

I must say with every post of yours it just sounds worse and worse. I think you just have to upset her by telling how things are going to be this year. Take charge of your Xmas holidays now or it will never change.

guineverehadgreeneyes · 07/12/2023 16:43

FictionalCharacter · 07/12/2023 16:32

DD sounds immature. She has a partner and her own home, presumably a job? So she has an independent life. Yet she still expects to come “home” for as long as she wants, have mum cook for her, and be entertained. I don’t think you’re at all unreasonable to set some boundaries. It isn’t as if you’re telling her she’s unwelcome in your home. But she should be accepting that now she’s an adult with a home of her own, she and her partner are your guests. It’s the host who gets to invite them for a period of the host’s choosing, and the host doesn’t have to do everything the guests want.

OP has said that the DD and her boyfriend work in professional jobs and the boyfriend is on a higher salary than OP and her husband were on before they retired.

FictionalCharacter · 07/12/2023 16:32

DD sounds immature. She has a partner and her own home, presumably a job? So she has an independent life. Yet she still expects to come “home” for as long as she wants, have mum cook for her, and be entertained. I don’t think you’re at all unreasonable to set some boundaries. It isn’t as if you’re telling her she’s unwelcome in your home. But she should be accepting that now she’s an adult with a home of her own, she and her partner are your guests. It’s the host who gets to invite them for a period of the host’s choosing, and the host doesn’t have to do everything the guests want.

Honeychickpea · 07/12/2023 16:12

hattie43 · 07/12/2023 06:25

Absolutely what I was thinking .

If you hadn't said you were 60's I'd think the post was written by someone in their 80's.
Be happy your DC want to spend time with you .

I would not be one bit happy that the rude, freeloading boyfriend was part of the package.

Gymnopedie · 07/12/2023 13:48

OP with your every post she (and he) sound worse. I think you're going to have to upset her - easier said than done, I know. But it doesn't sound like she's coming because she loves to see her parents. It's more she wants a (long) free holiday, with food, entertainment and all expenses paid thrown in.

The line which tipped me over the edge was when you said she got cross when you were late serving Christmas dinner. Who - in the real world - ever gets the dinner on the table exactly on time. And if she's done three fifths of five eighths of sod all towards it she can go whistle.

She clearly doesn't give two hoots about what anyone else wants, it all has to be done to suit her. To put it bluntly, she's selfish and feels entitled. Time to tell her that there are other people in the world besides her and that they have just as much right to have their needs and wants considered as she does. And if (when) she gets huffy calmly tell her that's how it's going to be this year. Give her examples of how you expect her to behave and what you expect her/them to do or contribute. If she takes it badly, so be it. She doesn't get to spend your money, eat your food (and a lot of it), demand your time and then spend the time complaining. Christmas shouldn't put this much stress on you.

Newestname002 · 07/12/2023 12:21

@Notoldeeally

Your daughter and her boyfriend are both adults. Each of them bring in a wage they have to work for. Both, when they're not with you, have to pay their own way including buying their own food. They know life is not free - except, apparently, when it's with you. They're also not toddlers who need entertaining all day and should be able to give you some peace whilst you and your husband take things calmer and in your own time.

They should not need any of this pointing out because they are adults but yes, you will need to spell all this out to them clearly, however kindly, because it's making you uncomfortable and is costing you more financially than you can afford. Tell them, in an email, quickly as the days are racing towards the Christmas break. Set those boundaries as mentioned above and be very clear about their arrival and departure dates whilst you're about it. Yes they may well be upset but that's a consequence of their entitled behaviour and lack of sensitivity around you. Its also something adults need to learn how to cope with in life. I hope you have a peaceful and enjoyable Christmas OP. 🌹

LunaBlueSkies · 07/12/2023 11:54

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

avenue1 · 07/12/2023 10:40

Group Christmas WhatsApp needed!
While you're setting the expectations for length of stay, set all the expectations.
Go on the positive front foot, suggesting sharing cooking once or twice per 'family', evening activities or games every other night.
Request that each couple brings items to contribute to Christmas. Wine/beer, chocolate, snacks, deserts etc! Don't be shy, this is how families actually operate- they share the load, willingly, cheerfully. It's not a hotel service you put on. Meal prep and clear up should also be shared, then you have time to get to know future SiL etc in a more meaningful way than a coffee out. Tell your dd, it's so you can truly be family.

Blueberrycreampie · 07/12/2023 10:34

And just keep saying you are having a much more frugal Christmas as you found last year's very expensive and you've had to cut back during the year to make up for it and don't want to overspend this year. Stress that they are free to do what ever they want on their own eg pub visits, days out, fish and chips but you won't be participating!

Blueberrycreampie · 07/12/2023 10:30

Also if there are any trips out say to them the cost per person is £xxx is that ok do you want to pay that?

guineverehadgreeneyes · 07/12/2023 10:22

"But for context bf is on a higher wage than us as ex professionals were when we left ."

But he won't pay for a round of drinks!

They are imposing on you. At their age, they could be volunteering to help the homeless - not being waited on hand and foot by mum and dad for 10 days, not chipping in with expenses and expecting to be entertained all day.

GabriellaMontez · 07/12/2023 09:59

It's not mean to expect them to contribute financially and practically to the cost of hosting Christmas for 10 days.

The cost of petrol to travel probably equates to 1 meal with wine.

BTW anyone who voted yabu didn't read your updates about their behaviour. They are outrageous.

You'd be doing her a favour to have a frank, open chat about it. She's certainly not shy about telling you what she wants.

Notoldeeally · 07/12/2023 09:45

lilsupersparks that sounds a perfect plan .. but they would jot do it as id be directing them and they would say but wht dont you want to come too.
the plan you made has really helped tho as it’s clearly balanced and that is really helpful.

Alao the poster that said this is the year that we need to save for a holiday was amazing ! Because its true , we would like a holiday . Paying entirely for Christmas was the cost of a city break in england and i think they would understand the desire for a holiday .. so that is an exellent point . I really domt want to be mean as they do travel to come. But for context bf is on a higher wage than us as ex professionals were when we left .

OP posts:
WickedSerious · 07/12/2023 09:43

howdoesyourgardengrowinmay · 07/12/2023 08:23

Move to a 1 bed flat

This is what my uncle did as soon as his DC left home.

guineverehadgreeneyes · 07/12/2023 09:31

"...The way I’d personally do it is set up an activity jar in advance with activities written on paper inside. Each time your daughter ‘has’ to do an activity one gets picked out. But put ones in there that are quiet and relaxing activities like a walk, watching a film together, a board game or cards, a pamper evening that sort of thing. And it’s only one activity per day."

I might do this for a child - but not for a 24 year old who holds down a professional job.

To me, it would be pandering to her apparent need to always have someone's company and to not entertain herself. She has her boyfriend with her - what does he do all day apart from eat? Does she bring no hobbies of her own?

guineverehadgreeneyes · 07/12/2023 08:47

"I think that’s a bit harsh. They are YOUNG. They have time to improve with guidance and more assertive communication from op."

They are both at least 24.

They hold down professional jobs. They can afford holidays. They are not teenagers. But they are behaving like teenagers. And please, I don't want someone to trot out that the "brain isn't fully developed at 24".

If they were staying in their rented accommodation for the holiday period they would need to buy food. It doesn't matter whether the OP is in her 60s or her 80s. Having people or family staying for that length of time in a very small house when one of them is demanding and neither of them chips in with costs and food prep is tiring and cheeky.

Member984815 · 07/12/2023 08:45

In your shoes I'd tell her come Christmas eve leave 28th and then you go to hers for new years . All the cooking the extra people in the house is stressful you need a break in between. They also should be sharing the cooking the cost of shopping and trips out. My daughter is almost your daughters age although still lives at home but I'm 20 years younger than you and add a partner and another couple I'd be fed up and it just causes tension and you wouldn't enjoy your time together.

howdoesyourgardengrowinmay · 07/12/2023 08:23

Move to a 1 bed flat

Catsfrontbum · 07/12/2023 07:44

Write down what you wnat to TELL your Dd. You’re telling her and not asking her.

be honest.

SquishyGloopyBum · 07/12/2023 07:33

They sound incredibly entitled.

You say they don't even buy drinks and would never pay for a meal out, nor would you ask. Why on earth not?

Id make clear that they are expected to contribute to food and cooking meals and that there won't be 24/7 activities planned.

You might find that they are so tight, once they realise their all inclusive free holiday has ended, they'll decide not to come for as long. Win win.

You do need to have an honest conversation with her about not being able to afford all this stuff though. You sound almost scared of her.

rookiemere · 07/12/2023 07:32

Just read the post where the BF wouldn't buy you a drink in the pub Xmas Confused. I would honestly have got up and left at that point after him enjoying your hospitality for so long.

I had kind of skimmed the thread and until that point thought he was treating you like substitute DPs, which is a bit clueless but understandable.

However now I think he is a CF. I would definitely message her something about cost of living and not being able to treat them because you have no money. Be very up front about it, they're taking the absolute mickey.

tralalass · 07/12/2023 07:28

I've read the full thread now and tbh it doesn't sound like you particularly like your daughter. How sad.

Don't ask her what day she's leaving - TELL her she can only stay until the 28th or whatever day suits. If she pushes back, be honest - tell her exactly how you feel - tell her, her BF takes liberties and that she needs to help out more.

This is the whole problem with not speaking up when things start to grate - you're now in a position where it's going to cause a massive kick-off, because you haven't managed the small things.

HalebiHabibti · 07/12/2023 07:23

If the OP is tired then she is tired - why are people telling her she is not allowed to be tired at 60 :/

Also, the scolding for not wanting to have her DD laminated to her side for 10 days straight. Surely anyone, no matter how much of a parent-saint they are, would have had enough of that by Day 3?

And I haven't even got to the financial cheekiness...

Swipe left for the next trending thread