Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help regarding family Christmas things .. need thoughts!

265 replies

Notoldeeally · 06/12/2023 19:27

So we have an issue about christmas!
last year we had a stressful time as we did not know when our adult dd s were leaving .. ( with partners) .. they ended up staying 10 days.

Now , i know they are our kids but its not the same when they bring partners .

We live in a modest 3 bed .

We are in our 60 s .. retired professionals with limited income . No state pension yet.

There are two issues

  1. lenght of stay .Dd is always reluctant to make firm plans . She likes to think this is still her home and as such can stay as long as she wants. At christmas last year she would not say how long she wanted to stay , just saying oh I might want the new year here too . we found 10 days just too long , especially as partner with her.How to limit the lenght of stay. I was thinking 6 nights not ten this year,but this would mean them not being here for new year.. and they always want to be here for that too. They live a 4 hour drive away.. so want to stay for duration . We live in a seaside town and alternative accommodation like a house nearby would be great but its v v expensive.
  2. activities ! When we are just watching tv or reading she says .. so what are we doing next .. i tell her oh we dont have to do anything, lets just chill .. but she seems to need structure .. so can we olay a game tonight , can we all watch a film.. ten nights of organised nights( as well as an organised thing like a walk for us all) exhausted us and we domt want to do it again. We repeatedly said games some nights but chill others , but she seems to have a fixation that we all need to be doing together!! Most if the time. She gets angry if we suggest otherwise.she seems to think us having a bit of soace is an insult to her , when it isnt .. she says things like well we should make the most of our time.how to tell her in a way she can hear???? Last Christmas was so exhausting and ended up with dh really really tense. we want to change it this year by being proactive and gently firm .. but we know dd will most likely be upset at this and also that there is a time limit as she thinks the oarental home is always open …and i get why she thinks that but we cant be that exhausted again. Any tips on how to say things much appreciated( I just know if we time limit she will say .. but if we only stay … so long.. what about new year.. i want to be here at new year too) I know we dont sound assertive but we dont want upset dd .. with our ds he takes time out goes for walks .. allows a bit of breathing soace.. with dd not so and its just how she is and has been since she was small .
OP posts:
steppemum · 09/12/2023 15:40

dont you want me to be here.. ( angry voice ) - NO not for 10 days, no I don't. I find it too much. 4 days is perfect and then we can really enjoy each others company!

fam important - YES and at the heart of the family is respect. Please respect our choices and decisions.

steppemum · 09/12/2023 15:38

She is behaving like a child, and yet she is an adult.
She can throw a strop, have a tantrum all she likes, you need to find that place in yourself where YOUR well being is more important than her tantrum.

You said you were ND, it seems to me that she is too. She is not getting any social cues at all from you. It is time to sit her down and have an adult conversation. No hints or suggestions, be BLUNT. Darling, no, you cannot stay for 10 days.

I would use phrases like
Darling, we love you, and you know that we love celebrating Christmas with you. But you are an adult now, and you have your own home.
This house is not your main home any more and it is not your partners home.
This is our home, and we are getting older and now that you and ds have left home dad and I would like you to start respecting it as our home.

But before you do that, I would start with the contributions.
I said in a post further up, that my mum changed christmas when I was a similar age, she took the bull by the horns and said to people - what are you bringing? But she give them options like - 6 bottles of wine or 3 desserts? So that each person pulled their weight.
Add in the - so we are sharing the cooking, I will do Christmas day and boxing day, ds you do christmas eve and dd you are cooking on 27th.

I think you will find that if you insist on sharing costs, bringing their share of food, and helping with cooking and chores, that the issue of staying 10 days will disappear.

stomachameleon · 09/12/2023 15:21

@Notoldeeally have you addressed the contributing? Cooking? Housework? Yet.

I am also puzzled as to why feel you can't stand up to your own child? What do you think will happen? Will she squeam and squeam until she is sick?

This is your chance to get this right for all the holidays to come. Or this will continue to be your existence.

Come on you got this....

Imobsessedwithsuccesion · 09/12/2023 14:41

I'm not getting why a grown adult has to be tiptoed round, so what if she's angry. 'It suits us to have you til the 28th then we have plans/want to relax' The end. You matter too!

Notoldeeally · 09/12/2023 14:34

Imobsessedwithsuccesion when we have said tou can head off on so and so a date because we are busy with friends.. reply has been oh dont worry we will fit round them ie still stay
that we are going away / to a show .. same
ie they seem to consider our house a place they can stay ( and call it a base) wether we are here or not . We would haveto say we want you to go and we do not want you to stay in the house.
would find that v hard .)
then they would say .. why not ..? I have no words for that , especially as It is a pretend thing .
The only way I could do ut is pretend someone else is coming or a house swap .
I think she would be realky really angry or upset if i said they could not stay if we were ‘ away’ .

OP posts:
Notoldeeally · 09/12/2023 14:26

Imobsessedwithsuccesion
because she says things like “ dont you want me to be here.. ( angry voice ) fam important/ its ok we will stay and you can still do yr thing/ in the past they have stayed in out house when we away and they wd see it as odd that thyley cant stay when we are away if we siad we were going away …
I did say why dont you host this year you have several bedrooms. But they said they want to come here . Next year id love a change but only if ds can come to hers also.I gave example of when I was small it was takennin turns.

OP posts:
Imobsessedwithsuccesion · 09/12/2023 13:46

OP tough! I want to be a size 8 and still eat loads of chocolate but it's not happening. Why does it all have to suit her? Tell her she needs to head home to let you do pretend thing. The end. Why are you so scared of her?

guineverehadgreeneyes · 09/12/2023 13:12

I hate to say this OP, but you seem very reluctant to do or say anything you think might upset your daughter even though the current holiday arrangements and her expectations are untenable.

In order for this situation to change, she is going to have to accept some degree of discomfort and you are going to have to stand up to her.

StoodySmithereens · 09/12/2023 13:12

Tell them you’ll be taking turns in future, not open for discussion. If there’s 3 of you that’s a day of hosting each, with Christmas Eve, Christmas Day, & Boxing Day. Your daughter has dictated to you for far too long. No more 10 day freeloading.

Notoldeeally · 09/12/2023 12:41

Imobsessedwithsuccesion because they would want stay in house ! I really cant say you cant stay in oaretalnhome when we away .

OP posts:
Imobsessedwithsuccesion · 09/12/2023 12:25

Why can't you just say, 'It will be great to have you DD, we're seeing friends/going to X city/going to a show on the 28th so you can head home then' to her as though that's a fact and not up for discussion OP, I don't get it?

Honeychickpea · 08/12/2023 17:50

Hobnobswantshernameback · 08/12/2023 16:18

Nobody is this much of a wet lettuce

Actually, on mumsnet it seems to be the norm to tiptoe around adult offspring's demands - reasonable or not.

Spaghettieis · 08/12/2023 16:21

Poor DD, she must have barely moved out and clearly misses you and wants to make the most of the time you get together. Can you blame her? Your lack of energy which has presumably gone drastically downhill in the few years since she saw you every day probably makes her worry that your health/longevity isn’t good, you chose to move away and you didn’t cut the apron strings when you brought her up.

How often do you see her during the year? Could you do shorter but more frequent visits instead? And get her therapy

Hobnobswantshernameback · 08/12/2023 16:18

Nobody is this much of a wet lettuce

stomachameleon · 08/12/2023 16:08

@Notoldeeally I wouldn't necessarily tackle that In a discussion about Xmas and expectations.

It all depends how you want the chat to go?

A list of 'you did xyz' isn't going to work. It will get her back up.

An email suggesting
Christmas Eve - dinner provided by you and bf
Christmas Day- we do a course each.
Boxing Day- games day. Son will be bringing nibbles.

Is more constructive.
What do you want Xmas to look like?

guineverehadgreeneyes · 08/12/2023 16:04

"You don't work so how tired can you actually get, you'll have the rest of the year to catch up on sleep."

I'm afraid the OP's DD and her BF because of her clinginess and their unwillingness to pitch in with cooking and chores sound very tiring to be around, irrespective of what age you are or whether you are retired or not.

violetcuriosity · 08/12/2023 15:48

I think you're being a bit precious here. It's Christmas and you're so, so lucky that she wants to spend time with you. You don't work so how tired can you actually get, you'll have the rest of the year to catch up on sleep.

It sounds like she wants lots of structure so play her at her own game and structure in breaks for you guys/nights where you don't cook or host them.

Monday- walk and pub in the afternoon- chill time in the evening with you and Dad cooking
Tuesday- puzzle and mulled wine in the afternoon- DD/partner cooking and cleaning up that evening
Wednesday- free time to clean and chill/read- DD and partner to sort out own dinner

Etc etc

Make the effort to plan some nice things from your part but also make the expectation clear that DD needs to play ball too.

ThinWomansBrain · 08/12/2023 15:20

she seems angry at me very quickly but wants to be with us a lot .

Even though you will have a leaving date arranged, the first time that she has a hissy fit, say "you're clearly unhappy here, please leave"

Sheepskinthrow · 08/12/2023 15:13

Notoldeeally · 08/12/2023 14:58

About the shared bath .. what do i say ?!

This thread is getting odd.

Sorry op if you are genuine. You have had lots of good advice. Time to put it in to practice and just have a chat with your daughter. If you feel uncomfortable on your own have a group chat on WhatsApp, invite your dh, and your ds and his partner to join (brief them in advance) and set out your terms. Ask them to set the tone by volunteering to bring some cheese and wine and offering to cook some meals. Your dd and her bf can’t get away with so much cheekiness if everyone knows what’s what and what’s expected.

ThinWomansBrain · 08/12/2023 15:08

tell them you're going away, make their own plans!

Have a conversation with them - just say ten days is too much, you found last year way too stressful -and expensive, and set a limit on how long they can stay.
And sod organising activities - if they regard it as 'home' they shouldn't require to be hosted in the same way as if they're guests.
If "D"D wants an activity, tell her what meal she is preparing for supper. (or to launder the bed linen before she leaves)

Tooshytoshine · 08/12/2023 15:03

Notoldeeally · 08/12/2023 14:58

About the shared bath .. what do i say ?!

Do you mind not having a bath together in our house as it makes us very uncomfortable?

If you don't want to say anything, you could just say you and your DH were going to go and enjoy a luxurious, long bath together. Then see how they react 🤣

Notoldeeally · 08/12/2023 14:58

About the shared bath .. what do i say ?!

OP posts:
Tooshytoshine · 08/12/2023 14:12

Anything more than three nights is too much. Six nights is a very generous level of hospitality. Ten nights is sheer lunacy.

You are preparing and paying for a very lovely Xmas for them if course they won't want it to change. That they don't treat you to a lovely meal or bring a hamper of treats at the very least is really shameful.

When I was 24, I cooked Xmas dinner for my family and we started to rotate it each year as I had my own home and partner. It shocked me how much it cost and how much effort it took. I didn't want my mum and dad to have to do that. My parents also enjoyed having a few days to themselves.

Your daughter doesn't get to tell you how long they are staying, they do not have baths together in your house (how uncomfortable for you!) and they take responsibility for at least one meal from the three nights they stay even if it is just buying a takeaway. They are taking the piss and are not good house guests.

Your son is a separate issue. He doesn't want as much and is a decent house guest. Three nights over Xmas all together and then they can go and enjoy their own home and make their own traditions. Save the money for a lovely holiday!

MimiGC · 08/12/2023 14:02

Nothing will change unless you change it. Your selfish daughter and her downright rude boyfriend are taking liberties. You have to let them know that you are not ok with it, otherwise you'll have many more years of it ahead of you.
And personally I wouldn't worry about treating both your children the same. If she complains that she can only stay for 6 days (even that's excessive in my books), but her brother can stay for 10, then explain that's because he pulls his weight and contributes and she doesn't.

Oh and knock that taking a bath together nonsense right on the head. They can do that in their own house, not yours.

Does your son bring a partner too? How do they behave?

steppemum · 08/12/2023 13:49

ManateeFair · 08/12/2023 13:43

Just reading through your follow-up posts.

I'll be blunt: your daughter and her partner sound like a pair of absolute horrors. Everything you've said about your daughter suggests that she is selfish, spoilt, rude, aggressive and clingy and doesn't give a shit about anyone but herself. Her boyfriend is tighter than a duck's arsehole and also doesn't have any social skills.

You and your DH are just enabling their bullshit but letting yourself be walked all over. Your daughter is a giant whining baby who needs to grow the fuck up.

don;t hold back there 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread