Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help regarding family Christmas things .. need thoughts!

265 replies

Notoldeeally · 06/12/2023 19:27

So we have an issue about christmas!
last year we had a stressful time as we did not know when our adult dd s were leaving .. ( with partners) .. they ended up staying 10 days.

Now , i know they are our kids but its not the same when they bring partners .

We live in a modest 3 bed .

We are in our 60 s .. retired professionals with limited income . No state pension yet.

There are two issues

  1. lenght of stay .Dd is always reluctant to make firm plans . She likes to think this is still her home and as such can stay as long as she wants. At christmas last year she would not say how long she wanted to stay , just saying oh I might want the new year here too . we found 10 days just too long , especially as partner with her.How to limit the lenght of stay. I was thinking 6 nights not ten this year,but this would mean them not being here for new year.. and they always want to be here for that too. They live a 4 hour drive away.. so want to stay for duration . We live in a seaside town and alternative accommodation like a house nearby would be great but its v v expensive.
  2. activities ! When we are just watching tv or reading she says .. so what are we doing next .. i tell her oh we dont have to do anything, lets just chill .. but she seems to need structure .. so can we olay a game tonight , can we all watch a film.. ten nights of organised nights( as well as an organised thing like a walk for us all) exhausted us and we domt want to do it again. We repeatedly said games some nights but chill others , but she seems to have a fixation that we all need to be doing together!! Most if the time. She gets angry if we suggest otherwise.she seems to think us having a bit of soace is an insult to her , when it isnt .. she says things like well we should make the most of our time.how to tell her in a way she can hear???? Last Christmas was so exhausting and ended up with dh really really tense. we want to change it this year by being proactive and gently firm .. but we know dd will most likely be upset at this and also that there is a time limit as she thinks the oarental home is always open …and i get why she thinks that but we cant be that exhausted again. Any tips on how to say things much appreciated( I just know if we time limit she will say .. but if we only stay … so long.. what about new year.. i want to be here at new year too) I know we dont sound assertive but we dont want upset dd .. with our ds he takes time out goes for walks .. allows a bit of breathing soace.. with dd not so and its just how she is and has been since she was small .
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Sheepskinthrow · 01/01/2024 10:27

That’s great op! Brilliant update! Sometimes people appreciate a bit of firm guidance and some young folk take a while to grow up and see things from other people’s perspectives! Happy New Year!

Catsfrontbum · 01/01/2024 10:12

That’s a good update. Well done.

Cherrysoup · 31/12/2023 23:51

Notoldeeally · 30/12/2023 14:55

update!
well , it worked .
!!
we rested when we needed to .
we said we cooked you clear
we insisted on other s cooking
we set a leaving date
they said they had a great time and it was more chilled than normal!
so maybe they picked up on vibes and this really helped .

Superb! I was thinking about you yesterday and hoping it went well.

BritneyBookClubPresident · 31/12/2023 23:31

Great update!

HalebiHabibti · 30/12/2023 18:17

Lovely news!

Olika · 30/12/2023 17:06

So glad to hear you had a good Xmas!

GabriellaMontez · 30/12/2023 15:22

Maybe she read the thread!

That's great! I hope you have a much better relationship in future.

ThinWomansBrain · 30/12/2023 15:01

Glad it went well
hopefully setting a new pattern for visits

Notoldeeally · 30/12/2023 14:55

update!
well , it worked .
!!
we rested when we needed to .
we said we cooked you clear
we insisted on other s cooking
we set a leaving date
they said they had a great time and it was more chilled than normal!
so maybe they picked up on vibes and this really helped .

OP posts:
Notoldeeally · 17/12/2023 19:41

Ive spoken to her . Seems fine with it over the phone . Will have to see how works in person .
thankyou .

OP posts:
SquishyGloopyBum · 17/12/2023 12:19

How are you getting on @Notoldeeally? Have you had the chat with your DD?

steppemum · 11/12/2023 16:56

Or
You have your own home darling, and you know very well that in your own home you have to cook, shop clean and pay the bills, so, if you want it to be yours, then step up!

Newestname002 · 11/12/2023 15:31

Sheepskinthrow · 11/12/2023 11:18

And if she says “I am your child not a visitor” you can say “well you do rather behave like a guest darling when you and <bf> expect to be waited on hand and foot and when you don’t contribute to costs or do any chores”

Edited

Excellent response suggestion. 🌹

Sheepskinthrow · 11/12/2023 11:18

And if she says “I am your child not a visitor” you can say “well you do rather behave like a guest darling when you and <bf> expect to be waited on hand and foot and when you don’t contribute to costs or do any chores”

Sheepskinthrow · 11/12/2023 11:15

In other words, ignore the manipulation and kick back tactics, and keep circling back to clear “I” statements. Be firm.

Sheepskinthrow · 11/12/2023 11:13

In answer to the “I thought this was my home” question op:

Do not answer it directly! It’s a trap! if you say “yes it is” without qualifying then she has you on the ropes. And a direct “no it isn’t” is even worse as she can pretend she is justified in feeling hard done by”!

Best to say “of course <in a crisis> but it’s a home where your father and I live, and we find having visitors tiring and expensive nowadays which is why we are asking you to respect our limits please”

Notoldeeally · 11/12/2023 11:02

Notoldeeally thanks!
i think the food habit comes from when my dc were at uni .. i would alway send them back with a care package of food , treats etc .. like a few fresh bits for meals so that they didnnt have to shop after a long journey back . It felt that i was sending live with them .
So i think this sort of thing has stuck in their minds as a oattern .. and I still want to treat dc . However, I think its now sort of a pattern and also that bf is prehaos opportunistic. Its hard as 8 dont want to stop being kind and generous.

dh is most definitely on board!

You are right we need to practice.
Biggest anxiety is dd saying
we dont feel welcome i thought this was my home.. so i need to prepare for this .. and practice .. and find words to say its not actually her home but if she ever needed a roof over her head then our door is ooen . Its like I have to guard myself and its not natural .. but needs must and there is great advice on here.

OP posts:
Newestname002 · 11/12/2023 07:39

@Notoldeeally

You've made a start OP, but the habit of your daughter and her partner is engrained in their minds - see their intention this time of staying for 12 days instead of their usual 10 days, all without a thought of whether you want or can afford this, before you whittled the days back down to 7 - which is still very generous.

They are so comfortable they think nothing of helping themselves, without permission, to food they haven't paid for to take back to their home. The habit is strong with you too - you obviously love your daughter and want to spend some time with her - it's just become heavily weighted in her favour.

What does your husband think of the situation - can he support you by presenting a united front with both of you setting and maintaining the same boundaries where their thoughtless expectations are concerned? He can also bring up their taking over the family bathroom together.

I think the idea role playing is a good one and will get you (and your husband) into the habit of having an answer ready when needed or to preempt any falling back I to bad habits. Good luck - I'm sure it will get easier with practise and you can use this Christmas as a template for other holiday behaviours. 🌹

Notoldeeally · 10/12/2023 16:24

CateringPanic none !

OP posts:
CateringPanic · 10/12/2023 16:21

Have you got any other relatives who live nearby who can take them for an evening? My in laws have relatives staying for a whole week and have palmed them off on us to host one evening so they have have a bit of space

uncomfortablydumb53 · 10/12/2023 15:39

Well done OP!
As you're concerned she would gradually extend their stay, I would follow up with an email stating the dates of arrival and departure( sounds direct but you need to be)
Also, suggest they bring something( wine, cheese etc) to reinforce the message they need to contribute
Lastly, don't tiptoe around her.. she is an adult now and it's your home

Greenpolkadot · 10/12/2023 15:35

I hope that they take notice of you ,I feel angry on your behalf.
But i get the feeling that your dd is a bully and that you seem to be afraid of her,
Can your dh back you up in a strong manner?
If the idea of 'rounds' in the pub is ignored and they sit waiting for you to buy the next round, get your coat on and come home.

Sheepskinthrow · 10/12/2023 15:21

Notoldeeally · 10/12/2023 14:25

RhiWrites
ues practice is good ! As its new to us !
need to also practice motivating to go the day before .. like will you be leaving just aft lunch or shall i make you food for journey .. etc

👏👏👏 brilliant op! And role play it, however mad that sounds!

Cherrysoup · 10/12/2023 15:18

Notoldeeally · 10/12/2023 14:25

RhiWrites
ues practice is good ! As its new to us !
need to also practice motivating to go the day before .. like will you be leaving just aft lunch or shall i make you food for journey .. etc

Stop it! ‘Are you stopping en route home for lunch? There’s a lovely pub just off the A38.’ I say this nicely, @Notoldeeally but stop being such a doormat! Their lack of contribution/overstaying would drive me nuts! And don’t let cheeky fucker partner take food! If he tries, tell him that is for your dinner!

Cherrysoup · 10/12/2023 15:16

I remember your thread from last year and it’s time for you to put your foot down. If she gets angry, tell her she is hosting next year but you’ll only stay 2 nights. If she wants to extend, you tell her, reiterate that you said these dates and you meant it. ‘We need a break from hosting, plus we simply don’t have the money’. Is she aware of how little you have compared to her? She sounds hugely inconsiderate. It isn’t her childhood home, it’s not like she has a sentimental attachment. If you don’t want her there when you aren’t, tell her!

If you’re in the pub, you say ‘Rounds’ before you go so there’s no expectation that you pay for all the drinks.

Re the having sex in the bath, be brave and tell her it’s your house, not hers and it frankly makes you uncomfortable, could they please not do that. It’s a small 3 bed house, it’s pretty obvious and demonstrates a massive lack of consideration. Can’t they restrain themselves?!

Definitely mention col and how you only have limited funds (compared to them). Tell them the cost of last year and say you’re having a romantic UK break next year and you can’t afford to fund 4 others for 7 days. I think it’s disgusting, actually, that they’re not bringing/buying at least half of the food/booze/shopping. Ideally, discuss everything before she comes. Save up and be away next year and no, they can’t stay while you’re away!

I’m angry on your behalf, given the sheer cf of her and her partner, but I think she has attachment issues (I’m no psychologist , but saying what she was like as a child is telling). Is/was she the eldest/only child for a while?

Swipe left for the next trending thread