Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not wanting to spend this much on sons GF

333 replies

BeforeNew · 06/12/2023 19:17

DS2 is 21, he has been with his girlfriend a little over a year. We like to keep Christmas budget pretty strict, we could spend more I just hate how consumerist it has become.
My budgets are set in stone really varying between £25 and £200 depending who it is.
Usually for the partners of our kids (we have 5) who aren't with us on Christmas Day we spend between £50 and £100.
I asked DS what I should get for his GF and he sent a link for a perfume costing more than £200.
I'm gobsmacked, we aren't struggling and I do have the money to buy the perfume comfortably but we don't ever spend that much at Christmas.
I called him and said WTF basically and he told me that he'd transfer the difference but she probably wouldn't want anything else!?!

He also told me that for her and her 5 closest friends they are spending around £200 on each person?!!

She's from a very wealthy family (dad is managing partner of a Swiss private bank type wealthy), but this is insane right?!!
AIBU saying I won't spend this much even if my son transfers the difference?!

OP posts:
Pinkpinkpink15 · 07/12/2023 00:38

@BeforeNew

Tell DS that it's not going to happen. Tell him buying very expensive perfume for a AC's girlfriend is just weird.

tell him
unless he comes up with some within budget by the weekend then you'll wing it.

not to mention how it would look to your other DC.

Does Freddie need some new outfits or accessories maybe with a little suitcase?

thebestinterest · 07/12/2023 00:23

That’s an insane amount of money for a perfume. But I think fragrances are gross anyways, so…

DS can buy it. Perfume is intimate. My in-laws give us a card and a bag of weathers caramel candy (which I’ve asked them to stop doing). I don’t get anyone gifts… I’m usually broke around that time of year anyways, but regardless - I hate the expectations! With my own DD we plan to buy 1 gift. That’s it.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 07/12/2023 00:22

Do a smaller version of the perfume that is within your budget. Tell your son he needs to get a little more creative and find out what she likes. During the rare time (from your description) you are with her try to find out what her interests are.

elliejjtiny · 07/12/2023 00:03

That's ridiculous. My in-laws are more than generous at Christmas and they don't spend that much on me. And I've been with dh over 20 years.

takeyourmeds · 07/12/2023 00:01

I guess its all relative if she is rich but just stick to your budget and buy her something nice within that limit.

Benibidibici · 06/12/2023 23:56

Tennis fan:

Wimbledon beach towel!!

Benibidibici · 06/12/2023 23:54

What fragrance is it? Id buy a smaller bottle of the scent she likes, in an eau de toilette, which will be cheaper.

Or buy complementing things like the showel gel, which is usually cheaper.

Diaria · 06/12/2023 23:47

I think your budget sounds reasonable.

I would be inclined to just get the perfume and have son pay the difference if he is massively in love with her.

If she is from this sort of background then that amount may be typical and doing other wise might put a spanner in the works of your son’s relationship.

If you only have to shell out at her birthday and Christmas, and she stays with DS and they make a go of it… it’s a small price to pay for his happiness, and indeed his security and enjoyment of life.

Runnerduck34 · 06/12/2023 23:41

£200 is a lot, personally I wouldn't spend it on a child's partner.
However in the context of coming from a wealthy family £200 may well be the equivalent of £25 for people who are less well off/ on minimum wage.
So I guess it's all proportionate to your income/ wealth.

MyCupOfTea32 · 06/12/2023 23:41

sprigatito · 06/12/2023 19:29

Good grief, my dc's partner of 2 years is getting a dragon hatpin (D&D obsessive) a packet of Stroopwaffel and a festive bow tie (they wear bow ties)

Worried I've been mean now!

Off topic, but this sounds like an INCREDIBLE present haul… excellent work

sadsack78 · 06/12/2023 23:34

YANBU

It's bad manners to ask for something that expensive from people you haven't known long, wealthy or not. I've been with my husband for a good 11+ years and wouldn't ask my inlaws for a £200 perfume!

Spend what you're comfortable spending and leave it at that. Twelve months is not a long relationship, and it sounds like your son is already feeling a bit insecure and out of step.

It sucks but he will learn eventually that buying stuff won't make you more compatible with someone from a wealthier background in the long run. Easy for me to say as an old bag, not so much when you're 21 and don't have that life experience under your belt.

determinedtomakethiswork · 06/12/2023 23:12

Moonshine5 · 06/12/2023 20:03

Why don't you just put in 50 and he can top up the 150, everyone's satisfied (to a degree)

Because then she thinks his parents have spent £200 on her and so next time it's Christmas or her birthday she will expect the same.

andyourpointiswhat · 06/12/2023 23:11

My son’s wife is from a very wealthy (and lovely) family. My usual budget for her Christmas present is $100 (so £50), DS gets more expensive presents from her family and overseas holidays, we all buy according to our means and nobody gets upset. I would be concerned at your son feeling the need to “keep up”.

MsRosley · 06/12/2023 23:11

I'd just send him a laughing emoji and leave it at that.

Lamelie · 06/12/2023 23:10

Ohtobetwentytwo · 06/12/2023 19:47

If he transfers the difference what does it matter? Why not?

It matters because it’s affirming what sounds like a pretty uneven relationship. She’s not visited OP’s house of course you don’t spend £200 on a relative stranger

Fightarealfire · 06/12/2023 23:08

@BeforeNew out of interest, what is your objection to splitting the cost of the perfume with your son? Ie, you spend your budget and he pays the difference? At least that way she will definitely use and enjoy it.

Saying that, my mum buys my wife a graphic novel every Christmas and birthday, and my wife buys her flowers- so I think your budget is generous.

Yetanothernewname101 · 06/12/2023 22:52

My in-laws asked for my favourite perfume name last year. It's a pretty cheap one, you can get a 50ml bottle for about £20 when it's on offer. Mil decided that wasn't expensive enough and bought a very expensive perfume instead that cost about £100. I was horrified that she'd spent so much. And that is after 15 years & married.
I think £200 is a ridiculous amount especially for a gf of about 1 year standing.

LuluBlakey1 · 06/12/2023 22:52

Surely they do a matching 'thing' like a body spray, scented candle in those scents that is cheaper.

ChaniceKobolowski · 06/12/2023 22:49

BobDylansMasterpiece · 06/12/2023 19:30

I dont spend that much on my DH - not going to happen on a GF

I was about to say the same!

frazzled22 · 06/12/2023 22:44

Is there a body lotion or shower gel to match the perfume you could get instead?
No way would I spend that amount on perfume for anyone let alone my son's girlfriend!

TwilightBee · 06/12/2023 22:39

A different perspective - your son may know that his partner’s parents are spending a lot on him. A good partner would know it’s not about what they spend, so he shouldn’t feel he has to make it up to her by expecting you to spend more and him transfer you the difference. Maybe he feels insecure that his partner is from a vastly wealthy background and worries she may leave him if he can’t provide the same. That’s not your problem though.

I know I feel really bad that my parents only spend max £20 on my partner only for Christmas, nothing for birthdays. His parents spend £50-£100 on me for both Christmas and birthdays. He understands my parents are just not as generous, even though present themselves as wealthier than my partners parents (I doubt they actually are).

Papillon23 · 06/12/2023 22:38

I was bought cashmere socks one Christmas which I absolutely love.

I'd definitely consider an outfit or two for the bear, maybe in addition if you can squeeze it out the budget?

User1789 · 06/12/2023 22:35

I'm going to agree that you need to pull your son up on this. You asked for ideas, and he came up with a single, overpriced, inappropriate gift. He has to suggest something else, not necessarily an item, but an idea or theme for you to work with, or you just use your own imagination.

She sounds like a nice girl, with an appreciation for the cosy and sentimental and an interest in food and travel. I think that should be enough to go on tbh.

The smaller bottle of perfume as people have suggested would be a nice touch but so would a nice hamper (Betty's? Is there a particular type of food she likes? You have eaten with her a few times and have access to her Insta), personalised travel stuff (Not on the High Street or Etsy) or fluffy socks and lounge wear. Surely everybody would appreciate a book token?

I think you need to be careful to set a precedent here. You are happy to get her a nice, thoughtful gift that isn't 'tat' in line with your own values, but aren't willing to contribute to performative extravagance. And tell your son that!

cariaaad · 06/12/2023 22:33

You have 5 kids. If you spent that much on all the partners that would be a grand on people you're not even related to. Ridiculous