Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not wanting to spend this much on sons GF

333 replies

BeforeNew · 06/12/2023 19:17

DS2 is 21, he has been with his girlfriend a little over a year. We like to keep Christmas budget pretty strict, we could spend more I just hate how consumerist it has become.
My budgets are set in stone really varying between £25 and £200 depending who it is.
Usually for the partners of our kids (we have 5) who aren't with us on Christmas Day we spend between £50 and £100.
I asked DS what I should get for his GF and he sent a link for a perfume costing more than £200.
I'm gobsmacked, we aren't struggling and I do have the money to buy the perfume comfortably but we don't ever spend that much at Christmas.
I called him and said WTF basically and he told me that he'd transfer the difference but she probably wouldn't want anything else!?!

He also told me that for her and her 5 closest friends they are spending around £200 on each person?!!

She's from a very wealthy family (dad is managing partner of a Swiss private bank type wealthy), but this is insane right?!!
AIBU saying I won't spend this much even if my son transfers the difference?!

OP posts:
Pbjammy · 09/12/2023 20:23

Cheeky little sods. I'd do one of those donation to charity gifts.

autienotnaughty · 09/12/2023 20:14

Yeah we do £40 on partners I'd do a joint gift with son but I'd want it to be clear it was a joint gift.

SLeanne · 09/12/2023 18:31

I would not spend more than £20. Maybe a scented candle and some nice chocolates. Any gift should be gratefully received imo. We even specified on our wedding invitations NO GIFTS as I don't agree with asking for specific things.

BIossomtoes · 09/12/2023 18:13

Mrschickenn · 09/12/2023 15:15

I bet there are dupes of it you can find. There usually are with expensive perfumes. Or do they do a body lotion or something in gift set with the scent? If not, a fragrance shop voucher towards it

If someone wants a very niche £200 perfume they won’t be fobbed off with a dupe. Body lotion or hair mist is a good call.

Mrschickenn · 09/12/2023 15:15

I bet there are dupes of it you can find. There usually are with expensive perfumes. Or do they do a body lotion or something in gift set with the scent? If not, a fragrance shop voucher towards it

Diaria · 09/12/2023 01:36

alohaa · 09/12/2023 01:16

What's with all the random tips for champagne on a beer budget??? 1) If OP is going to hunt high and low or scrimp and save for luxury on a bargain, I'm sure she'd rather do that for her actual loved ones than this random gf, as much as she likes the girl 2) she'll also have to spend that much on her other kids' bfs/gfs in the name of fairness so just multiply £100 by a few

@alohaa OP stated her budget was £50-100 per child’s partner, I pointed out that the eau de toilette for one of the perfumes is around the £100 mark, as is the scented candle and others have shown that other products such as hair mist, body lotion are less than £100.

For the kilian perfume that is more expensive, you can get one of them for about £150, and the other in a travel set for between £120-150. Both of which would be possible if she allowed DS to top up the difference if this is what she’d prefer.

My parents and I sometimes do a joint gift for DH, not a big deal.

And it’s relatively straightforward to do a google search or use voucher codes/cashback sites. Personally I would rather that than be ripped off!! Not hunting high and low, but being a smart shopper. There’s no need to be spending in excess of £200 on any of these products.

If OP is happier with an individual present in the £50-70 range, the body lotion or similar or a voucher for a premium store would be ideal.

alohaa · 09/12/2023 01:16

What's with all the random tips for champagne on a beer budget??? 1) If OP is going to hunt high and low or scrimp and save for luxury on a bargain, I'm sure she'd rather do that for her actual loved ones than this random gf, as much as she likes the girl 2) she'll also have to spend that much on her other kids' bfs/gfs in the name of fairness so just multiply £100 by a few

NChance · 09/12/2023 00:41

Love don't be shy is £44 for 7.5ml so it's tiny

This is £70 for the hair mist or they do a body oil for £85 if that helps at all?
Personally if I wanted a really £££ perfume either of those would be a great alternative (I'm a perfume addict!)

https://www.harrods.com/en-gb/shopping/a-la-rose-scented-hair-mist-70ml-21287323?gadsource=1&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIv-O9uI6BgwMVtpRQBh0xnwOXEAQYDiABEgLjMPDD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds

T1Dmama · 09/12/2023 00:00

I would buy her build a bear a Christmas outfit…
or simply yell your son that you don’t spend anywhere near that much on the other partners and it’s just ridiculous to suggest it!
he should get her the perfume!

TowerRaven7 · 08/12/2023 20:35

Yanbu, that’s a lot of money. But don’t take it out on gf as your Son said she probably wouldn’t want anything else - not her - and she might be horrified he told you that as gospel truth. Give her the benefit of the doubt. As for how much they spend on others that has nothing to do with you, and if you’ve shown a good example as it seems like you would that’s his own mistake (or not depending on the person).

kaboomy · 08/12/2023 20:28

toomuchfaff · 08/12/2023 15:17

Buy her a gift within your price range - even if its not something she "wants" or indeed likes... Stuff the £200 perfume. She would be getting a Sanctuary gift set from boots for £25

If you do the perfume and he sends you the difference; you're enabling, and you're also creating an issue for next year and the following.. what happens when he doesn't send the difference and she expects a £300 present "as usual"? nope

Edited

Huh? Buy something she doesn't like? What a fantastic waste of money. Also shows no thought. Who buys some random shite with no care if the recipient likes it or not. You've missed the whole point of gift buying. You are supposed to put some thought into it. And that doesn't have to cost a fortune

windmill26 · 08/12/2023 18:48

As your budget can stretch to £100 you could also get the MFK A' la Rose scented Hair Mist or the Hair and Body cleansing gel which are £70 or the Body lotion for £85. I wouldn't get a random gift as suggested by others like products from the Sanctuary etc. Buy a product from the line that she actually likes and she would use, or a Gift Card (in your budget)from a retailer that stocks her perfume. I like what I like and often it comes with an expensive price tag but I don't expect it as a gift from others (and I am sure she doesn't either). On the other hand though I'd rather get a gift card/chocolate/handmade biscuits than something random that I don't like and would not use.

bananamangoes · 08/12/2023 17:54

Definitely not

how about a luxury body wash? Everyone washes and one for around £30 is a nice treat!

windmill26 · 08/12/2023 17:32

I would buy a gift card from Harrods or Selfridges for the amount you are willing to spend and she can put it towards the perfume or something else .

Madamum18 · 08/12/2023 17:32

Presumably she eats at expensive restaurants with your son? How about a joint present of a voucher for a 1 Michelin star restaurant ...you can have a tasting menu in some that would be covered by £200 ..for both of them, depending on where they live.

Wouldyouguess · 08/12/2023 17:29

BeforeNew · 06/12/2023 20:01

He sent 3 different perfumes but all around the same price

  • Kilian Intoxicated
  • Kilian Love don't be shy
  • MFK A la Rose (think this was a little cheaper but not loads)

I haven't heard of any of them or the brands tbh

These are very well known niche brands- I would maybe go for something with a similar vein like this one
https://www.fragrantica.com/perfume/Reminiscence/Guimauve-22324.html

TheGoogleMum · 08/12/2023 17:07

Woah that's a cheeky ask. My MIL doesn't even get me anything half the time.

BestBadger · 08/12/2023 17:06

I'd agree, if she agrees to get her Dad to tell you were they've hidden their Nazi gold.

Minimooncat · 08/12/2023 16:46

No way that's an obscene amount for a perfume! I spend £200 on my kids including all stocking stuff etc but no one else. My parents spend about £30 on me and my husband each. I would never expect anyone to spend that much.

StarlightLime · 08/12/2023 16:44

I don't think it's unreasonable for a very rich person to only have certain kinds of v expensive perfume
Nobody had suggested this is unreasonable 😂

WonderingAboutThus · 08/12/2023 16:38

I don't think it's unreasonable for a very rich person to only have certain kinds of v expensive perfume.

Stick to your budget but get a different gift. Like €60 very expensive nice chocolates kind of things, very expensive nice showee gel, whatever.

She is allowed to pick her standards, you are allowed to pick your budget.

user1492757084 · 08/12/2023 16:22

Stick to your budget.
It is fair that all partners get the same.

I suggest a meal out at a local restaurant close to you; your DS and his girlfriend could meet at your place first.
Your DS can be pretentious but you should be yourself, welcoming and honest and fair.

Museum10662 · 08/12/2023 16:19

"She's from a very wealthy family (dad is managing partner of a Swiss private bank type wealthy), but this is insane right?!!" @BeforeNew

Id guess not, from those circles especially if your quite wealthy, that said to the average person then its unusual, but it depends on your circle of friends and their income etc.

tachycardigan · 08/12/2023 16:16

Is DS also buying you and DH presents to the tune of £200?! Because I doubt it!

Don’t let him try to look flash at your expense, buy her a nice Oodie the same colour as her Build a Bear!

RubyBon · 08/12/2023 16:06

In this situation it’s not the gf’s fault

I wouldn’t buy gifts with a £200 price tag tbh even if he was putting the difference towards it.

just because that wouldn’t be a gift from me really

just be honest, tell him no

ask him to select something else she’d like in budget and if he can’t/wont then buy a voucher to somewhere that sells said gift and she can put the money too herself or buy something else in that store