Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christmas as a Christian

92 replies

Bleakmidwinter1977 · 06/12/2023 18:33

Those of you who are celebrating Christmas, and consider yourself to be Christian...just wondering why you do, and what parts you opt out of/in to?

Asking as I'm interested, not because I have an opinion either way.

OP posts:
Ormally · 08/12/2023 14:07

Interesting questions and reactions to the use of a church for Christmas based activities. This can be for services and worship, which are a mixture of reflective and joyful, hopeful, in this season. However, there can be a lot more that is (for example) meeting need, that also goes on as it does in other seasons, such as food bank, drink or drug counselling, warm spaces, people in trouble or grief who need support. Not only does the winter often show these things to be really needed, perhaps more than the warmer months if anything, but the core of the Christmas story has all of this in there to ask that in your life you should aim to keep looking outward, be less hedonistic, careful of judgements, and show more love and hope, really. The general image of the festival is very family-centred and this can be great, but it can also be extra levels of painful for people who don't have that, or who have lost family.

The phrase: "wondering >why< you do (celebrate)" from the OP was interesting - made me think. I'm not always that joyful (that much might be obvious!) but I am hopeful and there are usually quite a lot of points through Advent when I am brought down to realise I (and the average person too) am/are vulnerable, and need hope, other people, less cynicism, etc. And also that I'm lucky. Even if there are years when I would rather rage at unfairness, or whatever. So it does get through to the heart.

Like others, the singing is what I would miss the most if I did not have that opportunity. I may not, always - as I get older my voice is not what it was, so even that might have to join the 'vulnerability and only human' reminder.

I've worked in some multicultural places and have had nice, though not OTT, staff lunches (perfect) where we just have a good time together. I really like hearing about how other colleagues following other faiths do things like carol singing or equivalent, and celebrations such as Ramadan and Eid and the things that I've found out from these. I love the different varieties of dates connected to Eid, that some colleagues didn't like so much! Definitely feel like a treat.

We have a Christmas tree, do other fun outings if we can, although the time for them is squeezed in favour of work, it's true.

LaChienneDesFromages · 08/12/2023 14:05

LaurieFairyCake · 06/12/2023 19:51

Really sorry to hear that OP 🙏

I will share one other thing we've done this year which is all about Jesus

We have put up a Refugee tent outside the Church, put two chairs in it and a fruit box manger with a baby in it - with the words 'Love is here'

Outside the tent are three HUGE signs:

'No crib for a bed'
'Christ was a Refugee'
And the Matthew verse: "When I was hungry you fed me... when I was sick you took care of me.. I was a stranger and you welcomed me"

We've gone ALL OUT this year in our church Grin

That’s such a powerful message. And a very timely reminder.

Butterflywings18 · 08/12/2023 14:04

FuzzyPuffling · 08/12/2023 13:42

I hear what you are saying, but if there wasn't a cohort of people who go all year, the church (building at least) wouldn't be there at Christmas. Would you rather be welcomed or ignored?

I don't see it as any different to say, the WI welcoming new members.

I've never heard people referred to as "strangers" - that does feel odd to me.

I made the point that the people who attend all year should be highly respected and the church couldn't exist without them. My thoughts are your not getting my point. Regulars inferring verbally or in writing visitors and non regulars are welcome promotes a sense of ownership. In reality people should feel free walk into a church without the necessity to make it a social occasion especially if all they want to do is sit quietly, reflect and pray. Of course regulars should recognise and say hello if a face is unknown. If that person walking in wants to take it further they will. At the end of the day everyone is a visitor to church and nobody should be made to feel they are walking into someone else's space.

FuzzyPuffling · 08/12/2023 13:59

We have an angel on the top of our tree, definitely not a fairy.
And a lovely plain wooden nativity set, to remind us of the humility of Jesus' birth.

Blueeyes13 · 08/12/2023 13:58

We have a Christmas tree, decorated with lights, baubles and a star. We don't use Father Christmas or fairies or elves in any of our decorations or wrapping paper/cards etc. We have a nativity scene stuck to our window and another one of figures inside. We are going to a carol service. The kids used to like pretending that Father Christmas was coming, but only because they wanted to do stuff their friends were doing, like leaving him a mince pie. We always told them he wasn't real. We read the Christmas story on Christmas morning before opening presents.

FuzzyPuffling · 08/12/2023 13:42

Butterflywings18 · 08/12/2023 12:02

On reflection, when I said I've posted on a thread from an atheist point of view, I should clarify I'm a firm believer. I was a member of church for many years & involved with most aspects. I moved house to a different area and haven't joined the local church, although I may one day. As previously mentioned its comments that give the impression of regular church attenders being a clique that makes non regular attenders 'feel welcome' that puts people off. A church should be a place where anyone can come and go as they please. They don't need to feel welcomed by regulars when they may just take the notion to go along. It's possible regulars may feel a sense of entitlement & ownership the more they contribute. This is a choice many people dont have for various reasons such as illness, social anxiety, work commitments, family commitments.etc. To turn this into those people are made to 'feel welcome' is simply wrong so my message to regulars remains. The church is not yours to welcome anyone. Please treat everyone the same as if the church is there for all who care to go once a week or once a year. Those who have the privilege of giving time and effort to contribute to church life should be respected. This doesn't give them the right to assume ownership.

I hear what you are saying, but if there wasn't a cohort of people who go all year, the church (building at least) wouldn't be there at Christmas. Would you rather be welcomed or ignored?

I don't see it as any different to say, the WI welcoming new members.

I've never heard people referred to as "strangers" - that does feel odd to me.

Lougle · 08/12/2023 13:39

@Butterflywings18 I think you need to pick your church, tbh. Different churches have different styles.

Butterflywings18 · 08/12/2023 13:34

Lougle · 08/12/2023 12:57

That's a really interesting perspective. In our church the person who leads the service always says something along the lines of 'It's great to see everyone. If you are here for the first time or are just visiting, please do come downstairs for tea and coffee after the service.' which I think is not a message to say 'you don't belong here' but a message to say 'you are welcome here'.

@Bleakmidwinter1977 I was listening to this song the other day and it reminded me how amazing the birth of Jesus was

It sounds like you need to find a balance in your house and your DH needs to be reminded that joy and happiness are an overflowing of the celebration of Jesus' birth.

This sounds like a respectful way to say it although I still dont feel there is any requirement to differentiate 'visitors' or 'first timers'
I'd prefer to hear something along the lines of its great to see everyone and please all join us for tea & coffee😊

On the subject and without wanting to appear picky, I also don't like the way some churches have people at the church door before a service to welcome me in as if I'm entering their space. I want to walk in quietly and leave quietly with the opportunity to attend teas & coffees if desired.

While I'm here I will add another perspective on noise before the service. This with the exception of children should be a time for peace & reflection. Many people treat it like a big catch up and the noise is akin to attending the theatre before the show starts. If you wish to have a good chat Please leave the hubbub until teas & coffees are served. 😊

Lougle · 08/12/2023 12:57

Butterflywings18 · 08/12/2023 12:02

On reflection, when I said I've posted on a thread from an atheist point of view, I should clarify I'm a firm believer. I was a member of church for many years & involved with most aspects. I moved house to a different area and haven't joined the local church, although I may one day. As previously mentioned its comments that give the impression of regular church attenders being a clique that makes non regular attenders 'feel welcome' that puts people off. A church should be a place where anyone can come and go as they please. They don't need to feel welcomed by regulars when they may just take the notion to go along. It's possible regulars may feel a sense of entitlement & ownership the more they contribute. This is a choice many people dont have for various reasons such as illness, social anxiety, work commitments, family commitments.etc. To turn this into those people are made to 'feel welcome' is simply wrong so my message to regulars remains. The church is not yours to welcome anyone. Please treat everyone the same as if the church is there for all who care to go once a week or once a year. Those who have the privilege of giving time and effort to contribute to church life should be respected. This doesn't give them the right to assume ownership.

That's a really interesting perspective. In our church the person who leads the service always says something along the lines of 'It's great to see everyone. If you are here for the first time or are just visiting, please do come downstairs for tea and coffee after the service.' which I think is not a message to say 'you don't belong here' but a message to say 'you are welcome here'.

@Bleakmidwinter1977 I was listening to this song the other day and it reminded me how amazing the birth of Jesus was

It sounds like you need to find a balance in your house and your DH needs to be reminded that joy and happiness are an overflowing of the celebration of Jesus' birth.

Pentatonix - Mary, Did You Know? (Official Video)

‘THE GREATEST CHRISTMAS HITS’ AVAILABLE NOWhttps://ptx.lnk.to/greatestchristmashits PENTATONIX THE MOST WONDERFUL TOUR OF THE YEAR TICKETS AND VIP PACKAGES O...

https://youtu.be/ifCWN5pJGIE?si=nLBlrYnsOworoAcs

IHS · 08/12/2023 12:35

I'm Eastern Orthodox and we have a 40 Advent fast in the lead up to Christmas Day so we definitely appreciate the food and wine when we can eat normally again 😄

As a family, we sing in the choir, so have extra services to attend and we get to sing carols and the church is decorated. The children receive a Christmas bag with some treats in.

We don't go overboard with presents and there's no focus on consumerism. We visit friends and have meals, treats and coffee etc.

Our main religious event is Easter, so Christmas is a bit more low key, but it's always a nice time of year as we celebrate The Saviour's birth 🤗🙏🏻☦️🕊️

Butterflywings18 · 08/12/2023 12:02

Butterflywings18 · 08/12/2023 09:48

A lovely post. Having made a few comments on a thread from an atheist point of view it lead me to this one. The reason I'm highlighting this post is to ask how others feel when regular church attenders use phrases like 'We are always glad to see people in church, even if Christmas is the only time they come'
I don't like hearing this. It reminds me of a time in church when someone speaking at a church gathering said 'may I extend a warm welcome to the strangers among us' I believe comments like this only add to the feeling of we own this space you are only a guest. People who attend church once year belong there as much as regular attenders. I understand regular attenders are involved with fund raising and all that goes along with membership. I still don't think it gives them the right to suggest non regulars are different. They have a right to feel it's their space too.They should never be made to feel like I'm entering into someone else's house. I also think this is the attitude that puts people off going to church to the extent they feel like intruders. Although I have great respect for regular attenders and those who contribute to church life, perhaps this is something that should be considered before saying things like WE always make people feel welcome even if they only attend once a year. Food for thought.

On reflection, when I said I've posted on a thread from an atheist point of view, I should clarify I'm a firm believer. I was a member of church for many years & involved with most aspects. I moved house to a different area and haven't joined the local church, although I may one day. As previously mentioned its comments that give the impression of regular church attenders being a clique that makes non regular attenders 'feel welcome' that puts people off. A church should be a place where anyone can come and go as they please. They don't need to feel welcomed by regulars when they may just take the notion to go along. It's possible regulars may feel a sense of entitlement & ownership the more they contribute. This is a choice many people dont have for various reasons such as illness, social anxiety, work commitments, family commitments.etc. To turn this into those people are made to 'feel welcome' is simply wrong so my message to regulars remains. The church is not yours to welcome anyone. Please treat everyone the same as if the church is there for all who care to go once a week or once a year. Those who have the privilege of giving time and effort to contribute to church life should be respected. This doesn't give them the right to assume ownership.

LaurieFairyCake · 08/12/2023 11:03

Our church has Father Christmas giving out presents in our Christmas Eve Carol service - proper presents as we live in a really diverse community and some children may not get much in the way of gifts

It's an important part of our giving to the community and costs us about £500 a year

FortheBeautyoftheEarth · 08/12/2023 10:57

I am working my way through an advent bible reading plan and hope to make it to church over christmas. Missed last year due to having flu and year before ended up on xmas eve going for meal with DH and DSD instead. I really hoped we could but I had already mentioned and didn't want to push the subject. They aren't believers so it always feels a little awkward, I hope to make it this year as I've missed last 2 years and I miss going to church over christmas as for me that's really central and makes me feel properly christmassy! I will go with mum and dad or on my own but don't expect them to come with.

ManateeFair · 08/12/2023 10:48

KrisAkabusi · 06/12/2023 20:22

he is becoming fixated on all the aspects of Christmas that are not necessarily related to Christianity, e.g. Christmas tree, santa, etc, and removing all the joy from the season.

What's wrong with these things? Why is there no joy in Santa? In your other thread you've been given loads of reasons why Christmas is a good thing for non-Christians. Why are you so negative about positive things?

Edited

I think you've misunderstood. @KrisAkabusi - the OP's husband is fixated on his own disapproval of Christmas trees, Santa etc because he considers them to be pagan. The OP thinks his disapproval is sucking the joy out of the season. The OP isn't saying Christmas trees are bad!

OP, it sounds like your husband is becoming increasingly fundamentalist in his approach to Christianity. I once had the very odd experience of looking around an English cathedral (C of E) a few days before Christmas while an American mother and her kids were also looking around. The mother was obviously genuinely interested in the history and architecture but was also keen to explain to her children why people who have Christmas trees and worship in elaborately decorated churches are not real Christians and have been seduced by the evils of paganism and idolatry.

I think my answer to your husband would be that of course Christmas trees are not in themselves Christian, but that doesn't mean you can't have them alongside Christian worship and belief. Christians are allowed to take part in secular traditions; saying you can't decorate your house at Christmas because decorations have nothing to do with Christianity is just odd. Lots of the nice things you have in your life aren't anything to with Christianity but I assume he doesn't bar you from, eg, enjoying secular leisure activities.

Butterflywings18 · 08/12/2023 09:48

FuzzyPuffling · 06/12/2023 19:00

C of E here.

I do lots more singing. I'm in the church choir and band and Christmas singing is the most glorious of all. I love the friendship and community feel of church, especially at this time, and the welcome extended to everyone. We're always glad to see people in church, even if it's the only time they come!

I always do some specific charitable giving.

We also have a full appreciation of Advent - the season of preparation for Christmas. That build up makes it all the more special.

Carols from Kings on the TV on Christmas Eve.

What do I not do? No Santa (I don't have children that sort of age), no excessive consumption, no Christmas Eve box etc. But definitely not Puritan and still a LOT of fun. It's more about old traditions than new ones.

And a lot of family time.

Edited

A lovely post. Having made a few comments on a thread from an atheist point of view it lead me to this one. The reason I'm highlighting this post is to ask how others feel when regular church attenders use phrases like 'We are always glad to see people in church, even if Christmas is the only time they come'
I don't like hearing this. It reminds me of a time in church when someone speaking at a church gathering said 'may I extend a warm welcome to the strangers among us' I believe comments like this only add to the feeling of we own this space you are only a guest. People who attend church once year belong there as much as regular attenders. I understand regular attenders are involved with fund raising and all that goes along with membership. I still don't think it gives them the right to suggest non regulars are different. They have a right to feel it's their space too.They should never be made to feel like I'm entering into someone else's house. I also think this is the attitude that puts people off going to church to the extent they feel like intruders. Although I have great respect for regular attenders and those who contribute to church life, perhaps this is something that should be considered before saying things like WE always make people feel welcome even if they only attend once a year. Food for thought.

Coffeesnob11 · 06/12/2023 22:47

We go to church every week. I volunteer in the kids groups. We loved the christingle service. We will donate more to the food bank, we have enough kitch Christmas decorations to keep anyone happy but also a nativity scene.
I have 2 Hindu colleagues who put up a tree and they like the look of it and want to be part of traditions in the UK (immigrated here a few years ago).
We celebrate Father Christmas and sing Happy birthday to Jesus. Its not an all or nothing. We should bring joy to others all year.

Decafflatteplease · 06/12/2023 22:06

salamirose · 06/12/2023 19:55

God loads

I like that. I read it as God (Loads of)

Me too! Which way did you mean @LaurieFairyCake ? I like it as in loads of God!

Girasoli · 06/12/2023 22:00

We happily do both the religious bits and the secular bits. Cocolate advent calenders for the DC, a tree and Santa, as well as an advent candle, nativity scene, carol services and church every Sunday.

DS1 has decided that Santa is St. Nicholas who now lives forever at the North Pole.

We dont do elf on the shelf though or too many expensive days out.

Not sure if we'll go to the Crib service or midnight mass this year, I used to love midnight Mass as a DC but I can't remember how old I was when I first started going (my eldest is 7.5).

Fightarealfire · 06/12/2023 21:59

Bleakmidwinter1977 · 06/12/2023 20:52

Thanks for your comment.
I don't believe there is anything wrong with these things. My husband however, is another matter.
I'm just interested in the motivations of individuals/people who celebrate Christmas, whether they are Christian or not.
Perhaps I was hoping for some ammunition to argue "for" Christmas, as we seem to be heading towards not celebrating and taking on a puritanical view of Christmas.

You don’t need to argue ‘for’ Christmas, you just celebrate the way you want. If you want a tree- buy a tree and put it up.

Mumofmarauders · 06/12/2023 21:28

I also have a lovely book using R S Thomas's poems as an advent devotional, and I read that each day (just one poem and a page or two of exposition), though I'm already behind this year!

Mumofmarauders · 06/12/2023 21:26

We're heavy into advent here which is weird when the rest of the country is celebrating Christmas!! We make a Jesse tree with ornaments symbolising the Old Testament prophecies and stories which foreshadow/lead up to Jesus's birth, and there are lots of saints days we celebrate during advent (we celebrated St Nicholas's day today with little chocolate Santas in the kids' shoes, singing special songs and watching a mini film about st Nicholas on YouTube (called the boy who became Santa, it was quite nice!). We usually try to do some secret act of kindness in the spirit of St Nicholas too but we didn't get to that this year even though that's probably the most important bit 🤦🏽‍♀️It's St Lucy's day next week where my little girl has a candle crown and we do a little light procession and make saffron buns. And all the gorgeous advent hymns!!!
Advent is so full for us that Christmas itself always takes us a bit by surprise 😂😂 My friends do reverse advent calendars where their kids donate something each day of advent which is lovely.

CraftyGin · 06/12/2023 21:25

We don't do Santa, Elf, etc. Never have done.

We put our tree up a few days before Christmas, and take it down on twelfth night.

We are fairly minimalist on presents, but with five children plus their spouses, the heap under the tree is still obscene

I'm a churchwarden and find Advent/Christmas absolutely exhausting with all the church events plus external concerts.

Topiography · 06/12/2023 21:19

@Bleakmidwinter1977

Great user name ! Please listen to BBC Radio 4 Nine Lessons and Carols, Christmas Eve 2023 at 15.00, or you could watch on BBC television, not sure if it's broadcast at the same time. Even if you have not been brought up in the Christian tradition, hoping you will feel the warmth of the message.
Would you consider attending a local church on Christmas Eve or Christmas Day? Hoping you will find a lovely atmosphere. Happy Christmas !

tinytemper66 · 06/12/2023 21:16

I also have a Nativity scene in my house.

tinytemper66 · 06/12/2023 21:15

I go to Mass weekly so I will be at Mass on Christmas Day. I give money to charity. I will also partake in our school Advent Carol Service this week.