Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Found out DS taken out insurance in my name, and defaulting on payment

231 replies

Snowyscapes · 06/12/2023 11:12

DS aged 21, doesn't live at home. He has debt issues through over spending. I paid off significant credit card debt for him earlier this year on the basis he was living back home, earning good wage, and would pay back lump sum each month. He instead moved out, has taken on a high rent flat, and paid nothing back. He has written off 2 cars this year and I presume on his latest car (which he took out on finance in oct) he has been unable to get insurance or it was very high. Anyway, over last week I have had letters from insurance company addressed to me saying I have defaulted on payment. Thought it was their error at first as didn't recognise number plate, but then dawned on me it is his car. I absolutely cannot believe he has done this. Which I presume is fraud. DS appears to be currently going no contact with me, I cannot get hold of him last few weeks. His phone contract is cut as I was paying his bill for 3 years and he wasn't paying me back (he was on good wage no living costs), so I can't phone him. I don't know his new address. Whatsapp messages are being delivered, but unread. Whatsapp calls, some declined or unanswered. I have really good credit rating which I need to maintain. Me knowing he is fraudulently using my name and doing nothing about it could have professional repercussions for me. I wanted to give it a week and tell him unless he cancels the policy immediately that I will phone them myself and tell them. But I can't tell him this if he is not reading messages and just had another default letter through.

If I contact the insurance co and say it is not me, firstly he could be done for fraud, and he could become uninsurable, which would mean no way getting to work and could lose his job. I worry about if this happens him taking his life, which he has never stated to me, or shown indications of, but its something I always worry about as sadly I see it far too regularly through my work.

So if I contact insurer and tell them I know nothing of policy and its not mine
AIBU?

OP posts:
Goldbar · 06/12/2023 12:50

I am so sorry you are going through this with your son. It must be breaking your heart. Mine goes out to you. We have such a strong urge to protect our children, to make sure that they don't face irreversible consequences in their lives until they are mature enough to understand the course that they are taking.

But your son is out of control. If he has written off 2 cars and potentially a third, he is a danger to himself and those around you. It is hopefully unlikely that he will commit suicide - at this point, I would be more worried about him killing himself or someone else around him, potentially a child, through his reckless driving. The priority needs to be to get him off the road, and you can worry about his mental health and employment prospects later. And yes, that might unfortunately involve him facing some unpalatable consequences from the way he is behaving but at least no one has been killed or seriously injured so far.

Ebee19 · 06/12/2023 12:50

He is really acting cruelly. You cleared his debts which was really generous - and I know many parents do this. You gave him a roof over his head to save up money to sort himself out and pay you back. He chose not to live at home - even though at his age many do. He has chosen to rent high cost and to keep having cars. Up to this point, I think you have done what many parents do to help their child and try to help them correct their mistakes. From experience, someone I know did lent a lot of money to their son and then their son moved out and never paid off the debt. However, a few years later the mum was using a food bank and the son then paid it back a small loan (about 10% of what she had given him over the years). However, he actually could have afforded to give it all back - and has been very lucky his mum hasn't kept record so didn't ask for earlier debts as her memory is going. So I don't think what he did to that point was right but I think sadly it is common. But what he has done now is not ok in any sense of the word. I know you want to protect him - very natural. But your son is not protecting you and showing you no love. He is doing a criminal thing here, he didn't phone and ask you for help. He didn't tell you this was an issue. He is causing you damage with no care. If he couldn't be insured, he could have got a taxi or a bus or a bike. What he has done is commit fraud and wreck your credit rating and threaten your job, without a care. If you don't stop this now, this will get worse. Is this a behaviour you want to teach him is ok. I would try again to contact him and ask friends/work place. But he knows he has done wrong or he would be talking to you. I think contacting the insurers and saying it isn't you (you don't have to say you know who it is), is the next thing to do if you can't contact him. You want to protect your son, you want to believe the best in him, but your son is acting really horribly here - this is basically financial abuse and you don't want him to think this is ok as if he can do this to you then goodness knows what he will do next.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/12/2023 12:49

There's also any driving offences he's committed and parking fines during the time - they'll all be sent to you, especially if he has also registered the car in your name (or hasn't registered it at all, as the existence of a policy in your name means you're expected to be the driver).

Hereforaglance · 06/12/2023 12:48

Bit it ok if ur son takes someone elses life droves woth out insurance commits fraud amongst othervthings long ss he is alive lol

Spellcheck · 06/12/2023 12:48

I helped my son out on plenty of occasions with his car insurance after his many crashes. More fool me. Eventually he wrote the car off drink-driving and had to wait 3 years before he could buy and insure another (without any input from me). My fault as much as his for enabling his stupidity and not making him take more responsibility. He's 23 now and a lot wiser, having learned the hard way.

I know it's hard but you're going to be affected by this too, and your DS doesn't seem to appreciate how much it will affect you. Or maybe he does and that's why he's gone NC. So I'd ring the insurance company. I know he's 21, but there's no other way he will face up to the consequences of his actions. He won't allow you to contact him even to help him, so sadly I don't think you have any other option.

Jessbow · 06/12/2023 12:46

Just ring the insurance company, tell them there is an error occured- you havent taken out insurance. Ask them, if they'll tell you, the name/number on the bank card-that will prob be yours as well. Who has someone of a different name paying their insurance? the insured name, and the name on the bank card should surely be the same?

Let them deal with the fall out/cancel the policy/whatever.

if sonny Jim gets in touch over it, tell him just that- you hadn't and never dreamed he'd do such a thing, so assumed it was an error

WowOK · 06/12/2023 12:46

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 06/12/2023 12:41

If your son is old enough to drive a car, rent a flat and have a job, he is old enough to take responsibility for his own actions. I suggest that you

  1. ring the insurers and explain that you did not take out the policy
  2. follow up with a letter to the insurers
  3. write to your son (assuming that he has given you a correct address) explaining what you have done and why
  4. send the letter to his home by recorded delivery
  5. check your own credit records, even if you have to pay for the checks.

I agree with this.

LaDoIceVita · 06/12/2023 12:42

Snowyscapes · 06/12/2023 12:28

Definitely no drink drugs issues, the first incident was driving too fast, no one else involved. Breathalysed etc at scene. Second was a 5am wet road, I don't know ins and outs of it but another car involved

Oh well, that makes it all perfectly acceptable. If he skids on an icy road tomorrow and kills someone, it won't matter that he's uninsured, will it? At least he isn't driving under the influence.

Your son is commiting a criminal offence with your knowledge. This makes you an accessory. Unless you do anything except contact the insurers and the police immediately, you are no better than he is.

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 06/12/2023 12:41

If your son is old enough to drive a car, rent a flat and have a job, he is old enough to take responsibility for his own actions. I suggest that you

  1. ring the insurers and explain that you did not take out the policy
  2. follow up with a letter to the insurers
  3. write to your son (assuming that he has given you a correct address) explaining what you have done and why
  4. send the letter to his home by recorded delivery
  5. check your own credit records, even if you have to pay for the checks.
museumum · 06/12/2023 12:41

I'd tell the insurance that it's not your insurance and not your car, but without dobbing him in. Are you sure it is his car? Have you checked the reg? Even if you are sure I wouldn't volunteer that info to the insurers.
Of course, that opens the door for him to be charged with insurance fraud. But I can't see the alternative. I mean, you could pay the insurance for him but that's still fraud as you're not the main driver so as far as I can see, either he goes down or you both go down. By saving yourself, at least you keep your solvency and job and can be a safety net for him (if you choose to or he lets you).

OneMorePlant · 06/12/2023 12:40

Snowyscapes · 06/12/2023 12:26

I tried phoning his work. He's on leave this week. I think he's probably on holiday with his gf...........

I am extremely worried about him. He was spending on his very expensive hobby which he has now stopped

I sent a message on whatsapp re insurance. It will remain unread but at least if he sees the headline of it the first word is insurance so he will know what it is about

OP sometimes love means doing something that will get your loved one into trouble and give them stress. The earlier you do this the better so he learns a much needed lesson and he will grow up and live a responsible life. The sooner the better before he makes even bigger mistakes that will completely ruin his life because it's obviously escalating.

The situation is awful and I feel for you. But you have coddled your son for way to long and it's time to make him understand that there are consequences for his insane actions. Because make no mistake, this is not normal behaviour.

It's time to protect yourself. Call the insurance company. And if you really love your son it's time to cause him some trouble.

Snowyscapes · 06/12/2023 12:39

Thanks all for advice. I'm giving it til 4pm today then phoning. It really breaks my heart. I know I would have given someone else in my position the same advice as you have given me, but it literally breaks my heart and I'm sat here trying to work but crying my eyes out. I really fear for his future. A young person I had worked with earlier this year took their life last week, so I'm particularly raw and anxious

OP posts:
WowOK · 06/12/2023 12:39

Livingonaprayer101 · 06/12/2023 11:43

Have you checked your credit file to see if he’s taken any other credit out in your name?

Edited

This is my first thought. You could have a string of debts in your name.

Flopsythebunny · 06/12/2023 12:39

Pugdays · 06/12/2023 11:49

He's only 21 though,these comments seem very harsh to me
Is there no middle ground of him talking responsibility with out getting in to trouble.

He's an adult who needs to learn that there are consequences to his actions

Hereforaglance · 06/12/2023 12:38

Are you going to tell the judge he didnt mean any harm when he either kills someone or gets done for driving without insurance
Are u gonna tell ypur employers ur sons a good kid n didnt mean any harm when they r handing u a p45
You are enabling and exvusing tjis behaviour with o he is my son
He is young
He doesnt mean it
He doesn't deserve to face the consequences of his actions
Sure no hsrm done

MrsWombat · 06/12/2023 12:37

You need to put the oxygen mask on yourself first. You can't help him long-term (food and shelter not debts) if you don't have a job.

ManchesterLu · 06/12/2023 12:35

I know it's such a difficult situation, but as others have said, honesty is the only policy here.

He needs to learn that he can't just do whatever he wants and get away with it.

TrashedSofa · 06/12/2023 12:35

I'd do everything I could to keep him out of trouble, without getting myself in to trouble.

How? Be specific, and bear in mind the professional obligations OP has mentioned.

pikkumyy77 · 06/12/2023 12:32

Look: you really have no choice. You have to remove yourself from the fraud. Whatever happens to him has to happen. But if you don’t act decisively you will be dragged down to. He dies have more growing to do, more maturing, but he won’t if he is never faced with consequences. Cutting off contact with you was deliberate, not inadvertent. He did it to avoid being held accountable. You can’t bury your head in the sand. Stop trying to alert him and act!

Libertyy · 06/12/2023 12:32

Snowyscapes · 06/12/2023 12:22

He is barely responding to his Dad (we are not together) and doesn't respond to any other family members or read their messages. He's never done anything like this before.

I tried checking my file, can't see anything on it, doesn't even show that they ran a check when he took out the insurance as he's done it on a pay monthly so they must have run checks

He was previously insured in his name

OP I’m 21, there’s no bloody way I would do this to anyone, definitely not my own mum! There’s no excuse at all, I’m sorry to say this but you need to protect yourself. Call up, tell them this wasn’t you and you have nothing to do with it. Don’t feel bad about it, he didn’t feel bad when he was committing identity fraud against you and defaulting on payments that would adversely affect you and your career.

LakeTiticaca · 06/12/2023 12:30

Pugdays · 06/12/2023 11:49

He's only 21 though,these comments seem very harsh to me
Is there no middle ground of him talking responsibility with out getting in to trouble.

Reading the post about children having no resilience nowadays, comments like this are part of the issue. He's 21 ffs not 12. Once upon a time at 21 yoi would be considered a grown up person, with responsibilities.
Now what we have is a generation of "kidults" who have been so mollycoddled by their parents that they never learn from their mistakes.
I honestly fear for the future the way this country is heading

user1497207191 · 06/12/2023 12:29

Snowyscapes · 06/12/2023 12:28

Definitely no drink drugs issues, the first incident was driving too fast, no one else involved. Breathalysed etc at scene. Second was a 5am wet road, I don't know ins and outs of it but another car involved

Most people don't write off even one car in their entire lifetime, your son has written off 2 in a single year. He's a dangerous driver and probably shouldn't be on the road.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 06/12/2023 12:29

She has no means of contacting him

But the OP says this;

Whatsapp messages are being delivered, but unread. Whatsapp calls, some declined or unanswered.

If he doesn't want to see her messages that's up to him but at least she knows that she warned him.

SoreAndTired1 · 06/12/2023 12:29

I am surprised no one has recommended you see a solicitor. I think you should do so just to find out what your legal options are and cover yourself. This is extremely serious, more than what posters recognise. You could go to court and be done for fraud.

FrostyFlo · 06/12/2023 12:29

You tell the truth Let them know you have helped him financially in the past by paying his debts. He has now gone no contact and you have received their correspondence. Tell them you suspect he has done this and would like to see the paperwork that is connected to this.
Ask them where you stand and if it will have an impact on your own credit rating.

Swipe left for the next trending thread