Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Found out DS taken out insurance in my name, and defaulting on payment

231 replies

Snowyscapes · 06/12/2023 11:12

DS aged 21, doesn't live at home. He has debt issues through over spending. I paid off significant credit card debt for him earlier this year on the basis he was living back home, earning good wage, and would pay back lump sum each month. He instead moved out, has taken on a high rent flat, and paid nothing back. He has written off 2 cars this year and I presume on his latest car (which he took out on finance in oct) he has been unable to get insurance or it was very high. Anyway, over last week I have had letters from insurance company addressed to me saying I have defaulted on payment. Thought it was their error at first as didn't recognise number plate, but then dawned on me it is his car. I absolutely cannot believe he has done this. Which I presume is fraud. DS appears to be currently going no contact with me, I cannot get hold of him last few weeks. His phone contract is cut as I was paying his bill for 3 years and he wasn't paying me back (he was on good wage no living costs), so I can't phone him. I don't know his new address. Whatsapp messages are being delivered, but unread. Whatsapp calls, some declined or unanswered. I have really good credit rating which I need to maintain. Me knowing he is fraudulently using my name and doing nothing about it could have professional repercussions for me. I wanted to give it a week and tell him unless he cancels the policy immediately that I will phone them myself and tell them. But I can't tell him this if he is not reading messages and just had another default letter through.

If I contact the insurance co and say it is not me, firstly he could be done for fraud, and he could become uninsurable, which would mean no way getting to work and could lose his job. I worry about if this happens him taking his life, which he has never stated to me, or shown indications of, but its something I always worry about as sadly I see it far too regularly through my work.

So if I contact insurer and tell them I know nothing of policy and its not mine
AIBU?

OP posts:
pontipinemum · 06/12/2023 14:23

I can see why this is breaking your heart 😢

I would send him a lot of 1 liner whatsapp messages, he is probably dragging down to read them or has the blue ticks turned off.

You have my sympathy though in this crappy situation x

LAMPS1 · 06/12/2023 14:21

In order to be there for him later down the line when he realises he has to actually face the consequences, you need to protect yourself now.

You have to make sure your career and professionalism can’t ever be compromised, make sure your earning ability remains viable, make sure you keep your credit rating, make sure your health isn't damaged and make sure your conscience remains clear.

This is a terrible dilemma for you OP, but hard as it is, you can not condone what he is doing so you must do the right thing.
You have tried every which way to get hold of him to no avail. There is no avenue left open to you to reach him.

Phone the insurance company today to protect yourself down the line so that you are there when he comes to you for help.
Then send a WhatsApp message saying
‘your car is not insured, do not drive, call me’

Good luck.

Cyclebabble · 06/12/2023 14:19

Hi OP I am a Senior Manager in an insurance business. At 21 with 2 right-offs behind him few insurance companies would cover him. If he did get cover the premium would be extremely high. What he is engaged in is I am afraid fraud.

If he has a further accident now the insurer will pursue you and given it has sent letters to your home address may look to hold you as culpable for the fraud. This is serious.

Get him to cancel the policy now and settle with the insurer. If he does not contact them yourself. I cannot stress how serious this might become and please think about the people he might hurt when driving effectively uninsired.

user1497207191 · 06/12/2023 14:17

My nephew is an immature man-child - he's made his mother's life a misery, and he's in his early 30's now!

A string of written off cars, motoring offences with short periods of being banned, a string of broken relationships, a few children he's left behind to be looked after by their mothers, convictions for low level crime, a string of jobs where he's been sacked and a wrecked credit rating, not to mention unable to rent a home in his own name because he can't get a "good" reference from any of his past landlords (due to unpaid rent, damage and being evicted legally a few times).

His latest wheeze is to change his name to his mother's maiden name and "steal" his dead grand-father's identity by taking out loans, credit cards and car insurance using his grandmother's address (who is in her 80s with dementia). His initials are the same as his grandfathers, so it's been very upsetting for the grandmother to start getting letters, default notices, etc in her dead husband's name! He never even goes near their house to pick up "his" mail, so clearly has no intention of paying his debts!

Between living with numerous girlfriends (he has to move in with them as he can't get a home of his own so only "targets" women with their own home, either rented or bought), he comes back to his mother, tail between his legs, promising to change his ways, etc., just to get a roof over his head, and then a few weeks later, he's found a new "victim" to move in with and the cycle repeats itself until new girlfriend gets fed up of his freeloading, abuse, etc - if she's lucky, she won't have got pregnant by him, but he has 4 kids and counting, none of whom he sees nor pays maintenance for.

As for jobs, it's just a succession of dead end jobs, usually "off the books", as he can't show references as he always gets sacked, but it's never his fault!!

OP needs to be very careful. My sister started down that road of being used and abused by the "he's only 21" type of thinking and all it's done is facilitate his reckless and selfish lifestyle.

Headband · 06/12/2023 14:13

Its best to let the shit hit the fan now while he's young and has enough life left to improve his behaviour rather than letting this go and find yourself with a 40 year old son who still can't sort his finances out .

Laffydaffy · 06/12/2023 14:11

OP, my brother committed fraud against my parents and lots of other people for many, many years. My parents never went to the police about it and I do wonder now if it would have been better for him had they done it. DB is now mid-40s, unable to budget, permanent pt-time job and still asks for money from mum and dad. There is also definitely significant (undiagnosed) MH issues that my parents never bothered about and now it is really too late.

My contribution - doing what you are planning to do is most likely the best decision. Please let us know how it goes with your DS.

Edited - spelling errors

WinterParakeets · 06/12/2023 14:07

Pugdays · 06/12/2023 11:45

If it was my son .at 21 doing this ,
I'd think 21 is still very young in the great scheme of things ,and I'd try hard to make sure I didn't cause him more stress.
I doubt he is doing this to deliberately cause the op stress ,he just is clearly struggling with money ,and making mistakes as young people do
I'd do everything I could to keep him out of trouble, without getting myself in to trouble.
I'd be trying to find him ,there must be a way,a friend of a friend must know where he is

I know someone who did this. The problems just escalated. The parent who 'helped' almost lost their house.

Far better for him to face the consequences right now while he is young enough to put them behind him.

Coconutter24 · 06/12/2023 13:59

You need to contact the insurance company. Sounds like he needs to learn his lesson, you’ve offered him help and this is how he repays you.

whynotwhatknot · 06/12/2023 13:49

its fraud plain and simple and if you dont report it youre complicit so in turn you wont gt insurance or worse go to court

Nicole1111 · 06/12/2023 13:49

His actions have consequences and he’s unlikely to learn from his mistakes until he feels the full force of them. You’re doing the right thing, however difficult I am sure it is for you.

AdoraBell · 06/12/2023 13:48

YANBU. Contact the insurance company and tell them you did not take out the insurance.

I understand your fears but if you let this go he will continue doing things like this because it seems in his head -Mum will sort it for me.

Katbum · 06/12/2023 13:47

He has to face what he has done, and go through the consequences of being an entitled idiot. If you don't report him, he will learn nothing and continue this behaviour. If he is on a path to self destruction, this will not make him take his own life, but may prevent him from something more terrible down the line.

Lazydomestic · 06/12/2023 13:47

Have you checked the letter isn’t a scam ?? Have had emails like this which have ignored as clearly are.
DO NOT call the telephone number on the letter - make sure you get the insurers number from their website.

Shrammed · 06/12/2023 13:43

Snowyscapes · 06/12/2023 12:39

Thanks all for advice. I'm giving it til 4pm today then phoning. It really breaks my heart. I know I would have given someone else in my position the same advice as you have given me, but it literally breaks my heart and I'm sat here trying to work but crying my eyes out. I really fear for his future. A young person I had worked with earlier this year took their life last week, so I'm particularly raw and anxious

I think your worry is understandably in overdrive - this could be the kick up arse he needs to sort his spending out.

I do think you have no choice but to ring insurance company - but I would check on-line that number on letter it legit and then do TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment five points plan.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 06/12/2023 13:43

I genuinely don't understand the "he's only 21" posts. And yes I have been the parent of a 21 year old. There's a vast difference between immaturity due to age and illegal, immoral decisions and actions.

Neither do I. I get that 21 is young and that some guidance from adults is still essential but at that age you should know that if you screw up, you have to take the consequences and not expect mummy and daddy to bail you out (and it sounds like the OP's S has screwed up a hell of a lot without ever having to take the consequences!).

Riva5784 · 06/12/2023 13:43

However difficult it is to accept, he has put you in this position and doesn’t care how this could affect your life. Ignoring your calls and leaving you to deal with the fall out is unforgivable.

His behaviour shows that he doesn't give a shit about you. You need to protect yourself. Sorry OP it must be heartbreaking.

Uricon2 · 06/12/2023 13:42

If you misguidedly try to protect him from his actions this time OP, what will it be next?

ButterCrackers · 06/12/2023 13:40

Report this to the insurance and the police. He’s an adult and therefore responsible for his own choices. Don’t get your reputation ruined by his illegal actions.

Motnight · 06/12/2023 13:37

I genuinely don't understand the "he's only 21" posts. And yes I have been the parent of a 21 year old. There's a vast difference between immaturity due to age and illegal, immoral decisions and actions.

betterangels · 06/12/2023 13:32

Motnight · 06/12/2023 13:30

He is a danger to himself and others. He is a liar. He is refusing even to speak to the Op. There's no middle ground here.

And he committed fraud, so he's already in trouble. That ship has sailed.

ilikemethewayiam · 06/12/2023 13:31

Pugdays · 06/12/2023 11:49

He's only 21 though,these comments seem very harsh to me
Is there no middle ground of him talking responsibility with out getting in to trouble.

ONLY 21! F*ck me! At what age do people grow up these days? At 21 I had a good job, was in a stable relationship, put my first deposit on a house and was financially planning for my best future. OP’s son is a fully grown adult by any stretch of the imagination.

I agree with PP’s, OP is now aware of the potential fraud and could be implicated.

OP you need to do whatever’s necessary to extricate yourself from this to save your reputation, job, etc. However difficult it is to accept, he has put you in this position and doesn’t care how this could affect your life. Ignoring your calls and leaving you to deal with the fall out is unforgivable. I couldn’t imagine a world in which I would have done this to my parents. Time for tough love!

Motnight · 06/12/2023 13:30

Pugdays · 06/12/2023 11:49

He's only 21 though,these comments seem very harsh to me
Is there no middle ground of him talking responsibility with out getting in to trouble.

He is a danger to himself and others. He is a liar. He is refusing even to speak to the Op. There's no middle ground here.

Bumcake · 06/12/2023 13:26

I really feel for you, and don’t know why some other posters are being so arsy with you. It’s a horrible situation but there’s nothing you can do except drop him in it. What a fool he’s being.

Pipsquiggle · 06/12/2023 13:25

OP - could you contact his GF?

hsapposhit · 06/12/2023 13:20

I would notify the insurance company immediately. There's nothing else you can do.
Your DS has shown he can't be trusted so no amount of tracking him down and trying to persuade him to do the right thing will work.
Of course there will be consequences for him when the insurance company find out he committed fraud but he has to face those consequences.
Also, he's already written off two cars so it's only a matter of time before that happens again or even worse, he kills someone. The best thing is for him not to be allowed to drive because he's dangerous.