Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed at being used as a secretary for my DH by my MIL?

111 replies

IdealisticCynic · 06/12/2023 09:55

First - I really, really, like my MIL: this is not a post to have a go at her. I just want to vent a little and see if this happens to other women.

Basically, my MIL often messages or calls me to pass messages on to my DH or send on invitations about family events - even ones I am not invited to. She always says she does it because my DH is so very busy with work etc.

The thing is - I also work full time! If anything, I do longer hours. My job is more pressured than DH’s and while earning a lot less than him, I am reasonably successful, some of which is in public so she knows about that - and often tells me she is proud of me because she is lovely.

So why oh why am I the person who receives calls and messages - during working hours - with info to pass on? Are there just some people who can’t contemplate that a woman’s job is as difficult or important as a man’s?

But also - is it just her? Or do other women have to deal with this??

(I am aware of the irony of me posting this during working hours btw, I’m just waiting for the kettle to boil!)

OP posts:
Bearbookagainandagain · 06/12/2023 11:04

She shouldn't go through you to pass in messages if you are not involved, but it's likely she does this purely because you are reliable and he is not.
I'm not sure if it's about gender here, if I'm trying to get a response on something from my family, I will reach out to my siblings first but will often forward to their partners if I know they won't respond or respond late, unrelated to their gender.

crumblingschools · 06/12/2023 10:54

I would go down the WhatsApp group route.

We live miles away from MIL so no family organising going on, but she sends both DH and I the same message separately if she wants to tell us news, keep meaning to tell her we will set up a family WhatsApp group, and if she wants to tell just one of us something she can message us separately

LoobyDop · 06/12/2023 10:53

Don’t reply to messages sent while you’re working. Reply several hours later with “sorry, I was working, did you manage to sort it out with him?” If she replies no, reply again with “try him now, he’s not working”. It’ll sink in eventually.

TheSuggestedAmendment · 06/12/2023 10:48

Aw - that you mention ‘lonely’ does change things a bit.

I was all coming on to suggest you get really blunt with MIL, but maybe this is all part of her wanting to feel ‘networked in’ to events. She wants to include you in plans to make things feel bigger.

Rudolphtherednoseddog · 06/12/2023 10:48

I get this, but it’s because in her world women do all the emotional labour and family management. She’s also not even my husband’s biological mother, she’s his step mother. She has taken on what I see as actually my father in law’s job of doing the work to maintain a relationship with his now adult children. So she thinks I ought to operate the same way.

If she wants to know how the children are or what to buy them for Christmas or can they pop in next Saturday she calls me. She finds it perplexing that I don’t sort out gifts on my husband’s side of the family, that I don’t keep in touch with all his relatives, that I have no idea when his cousin’s birthday is etc. I think it’s utterly bizarre that the two men in the family actually related to each other can’t just sort it out themselves but for the sake of family harmony I just go along with it. She’s utterly lovely, she just has a very different set of expectations of marriage, men and family roles.

Woahtherehoney · 06/12/2023 10:47

My DP never answers messages so his family just reach out to me. I did it all at first to be polite but now it is annoying as I do feel like his PA! So you’re not alone in this I promise.

Fraaahnces · 06/12/2023 10:46

Honestly, this drives me bonkers. I would pick up and tell her that you were far too busy at work to chat or think about plans. If she wants to organize something with DH, then she needs to call him.

Marie2023 · 06/12/2023 10:46

I’ve got the opposite problem. MIL will only communicate with DH, even though it’s me who looks after the diaries, kids, etc.

DH is also extremely busy and very forgetful, so I rarely get these messages.

We have missed out on spending Christmas with them because of it.

NoSquirrels · 06/12/2023 10:44

Is she telling him first, or at the same time? Or just telling you?

NoCloudsAllowed · 06/12/2023 10:44

'thanks MIL. Would you mind sending this direct to dh instead of to me to pass on to him? Thanks!'

Do not pass on messages. If dh is too shit to reply or get organized, that's on him. This only happens if you let it.

spitefulandbadgrammar · 06/12/2023 10:42

Are they the kind of texts where you can reply “Think you meant to send this to DH :)” or is she phrasing it like “Can you let DH know he’s invited to miniature golf a week on Saturday”? If the former I’d repeatedly reply with the generic “Whoops, another one you meant to send to DH :)” until it clicks that you’re not going to pass things on and she can contact him directly. If the latter and she’s specifically asking you to be a go-between, it depends on your relationship and whether she’ll respond better to a straightforward, “Look, Sheila, I work FT as well as DH – you’re asking me to be his PA when it’s much easier for you to talk to him directly!” or a gentler (some would say passagg, I would say it just takes longer to work) strategic incompetence: forget to reply for days, never ever pass the message on and claim you forgot (even if it’s eating away at you and you want it off your to-do list), pass it on vaguely and incorrectly so DH has to call to clarify anyway, until eventually it becomes easier for her to just contact him as she should have been doing in the first place.

Ginge246 · 06/12/2023 10:41

The whatsapp group is a good idea!

Ginge246 · 06/12/2023 10:40

I absolutely get this but from my own mother. She will message me asking me to tell DH something or ask him about something for her. Being my own mother I can probably be a little more direct and blunt than if it was MIL but I either say, 'ye, when I see him later tonight' which then makes her message him herself as she doesn't want to wait hours for a response or if I have no patience that day I just say 'ask him yourself' 😂.

But I do think in terms of family events and social calanders it's because generally women are more organised (don't come for me!) and social expectations have built us to be able to mentally arrange/look after several different things at once. It's not right and it is frustrating but you are definitely not alone!

MrsSkylerWhite · 06/12/2023 10:37

Really don’t understand this kind of post. Just politely ask her to stop, problem solved.

BrimfulOfMash · 06/12/2023 10:36

I think it is a lack of scrutiny of the old tradition in which the family network is largely held together woman to woman.

She probably sees it as viewing you as an equal family member alongside your DH.

And in our patriarchal old reality, many men ARE lax on the whole ‘family arrangement’ stuff. Agonising about Xmas hosting, buying presents for extended family, sending cards (birthday / christening/ sympathy), we see it daily on MN.

During work hours I would not take calls or open or reply to messages. Tell her later you were working. Send a v quick message ‘soz, can’t reply, meeting, DH will know’.

And if she leaves a message, get DH to contact her, don’t do it yourself.

Is your DH pro active in family arrangements?

Gradually her expectation and perspective will change.

seven201 · 06/12/2023 10:35

At the start of our relationship my MIL used the try this. I just used to respond with "you need to tell DP that, I hate doing my own life admin, I'm not doing his too". She once tried to tell me when all the extended family birthdays were so I could send cards. Erm, nope! You need to push back.

toastofthetown · 06/12/2023 10:30

Would having a WhatsApp group between the three of you help, where your DH responds to his mother’s invitations and you can mute the group? This is what we do. I like being in the loop, but I also don’t have the onus to be the social secretary.

IdealisticCynic · 06/12/2023 10:30

To address some of the points:

I no longer answer the phone if she calls when I am working.

My DH is very family oriented so it’s not a matter of me having to force his own family relationships on him. He also sees his mother once a week, minimum, usually when I am working late in the office.

DH is very forgetful - so maybe it is because of this that she directs things through me. It’s the comments she makes about him being too busy that I find (mildly) irritating. I AM BUSY TOO!

I don’t want to confront her about it, or make her feel bad. As I say, she’s lovely. She’s also a little lonely.

I think I just wanted to know I’m not the only person dealing with this - and it seems I’m not. I wonder if it’s a bit of an old fashioned thing - I certainly can’t imagine doing it to any future DIL!

OP posts:
EmmaEmerald · 06/12/2023 10:27

Tell her you are not his secretary.

HippeePrincess · 06/12/2023 10:27

Ignore her during work hours and explain you are also busy with work. My ex and my exMIL still expect me to be his secretary when it comes to the children’s school events despite me multiple times encouraging and reminding him to be on the letters home list and to download and access the school apps. He hasn’t. I sometimes invite ex in laws to events I think they like, or if the kids want to invite them when I can’t make it and exMIL always responds with. Have you asked/does Ex know. And I respond the same way, he should do if he’s sorted the apps out. She says oh best remind him. And I say no, I’ve essentially nagged him to get the apps, no one reminds me, so he clearly doesn’t care or want to attend anything and I’m not his PA. He’s had the same opportunity I have to know what’s going on and he hasn’t taken it but I don’t want the grandparents and kids missing out because of him. I repeat this every time, and have done for 5 years. He’s still not downloaded any apps. She still asks in the same way, but I’m ever hopeful she’ll get the message eventually.

mondaytosunday · 06/12/2023 10:25

Nice try @plumtreebroke.
I think in most couples I know, even when both work full time, it's still the woman who organises the social diary. Sure it may be because she sees his job as more important, but it could just be he's useless at passing messages on to you about stuff so she's short circuiting it. If you dislike it say you can't deal with it she needs to call him direct.

wishingiwas20something · 06/12/2023 10:22

The first year I was married, my MIL started sending ME texts to remind me of H’s family birthdays, i.e can you source a card and present. I spoke to H and said they are your family first and foremost, I don’t want to take over your life admin, and I’m not expecting you to do mine. H does his side of family and I do mine, 50:50. It works well for us.

Mummypete · 06/12/2023 10:20

This is so annoying. DH has divorced parents so I get this from both sides so twice as many messages! He has a job where he can’t have his phone on him and works 10-12 hour days so often doesn’t get back to people for several days so I have become their go to person for making plans.
It’s hard because his family are all lovely and I have a great relationship with them but my mental load is already overwhelming at times without all these extra messages as well. The other thing is when they message asking me about something we don’t want to do. DH just says “tell them no” but then I look like the bad person!

cheddercherry · 06/12/2023 10:18

My MIL also did this… till I realised husband rarely answered during the day hence it was bouncing to me. A few days and a polite message of “sorry I’ve got a lot on a work so can’t respond to messages” soon sorted it.

MilkChocolateCookie · 06/12/2023 10:16

It's so annoying OP. Last time MIL was staying with us DH and I were both working from home. She didn't go and ask him things because she "didn't want to disturb him" but was fine about coming to chat to me! Arghhh